Are you looking for homes for sale in Pine Island, New York? View recently listed real estate properties throughout the Pine Island, New York area on Homes.com. We have hundreds of listings including condos, town homes, foreclosures, new homes and apartments for rent. Once you have located a listing of interest, simply complete the information request or search for Pine Island Real Estate Agents to help you find or purchase your new Pine Island home. We receive new listings everyday from local agents, brokers and the MLS, so check back regularly!

Listings

1 2

Displaying 1 - 9 of 16 Listings

---

• PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• Beaver Mt Log Home Spectacular Views!Private! 85 ft covered front porch with high... View Details

• $1,100,000
• 3 Bd, 2/1 Ba
• MLS# 471868

• 10 Eagle Wood Vista Lane, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• Beaver Mt Log Home Spectacular Views!Private! 85 ft covered front porch with high... View Details

• $1,100,000
• 3 Bd, 2 Ba
• 4200 sq.ft.
• MLS# 471868

• Mountainside Road, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• 4800 sqaure foot Colonial that offers covered porch, flowing floor plan, in-law... View Details

• $799,000
• 4 Bd, 4 Ba
• 4800 sq.ft.
• MLS# 456438

• Oil City Road, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• Gorgeous Colonnial Farmhouse on a beautiful wooded lot near wildlife refuge.This... View Details

• $679,000
• 4 Bd, 3/1 Ba
• 3500 sq.ft.
• MLS# 456442

• Oil City Road, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• View Details

• $679,000
• 4 Bd, 3/1 Ba
• 3500 sq.ft.
• MLS# 456472

• Oil Cty Road, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• Custom home to be built by exceptional local builder on this level, wooded lot... View Details

• $659,000
• 4 Bd, 2/1 Ba
• 3000 sq.ft.
• MLS# 456473

• 43 Glenwood Road, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• TRUELY ONE-OF-KIND OLD WORLD CHARM HOME. INCREDIBLE VIEWS FROM PORCH, WIDEPLANK... View Details

• $585,000
• 5 Bd, 3/1 Ba
• 4826 sq.ft.
• MLS# 474371

• 13 Little Brooklyn Road, PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• PRICE REDUCTION AGAIN. Charming TOTALLY RENOVATED Farmhouse. Low Taxes. Very... View Details

• $399,000
• 3 Bd, 2/1 Ba
• 2016 sq.ft.
• MLS# 471013

• PINE ISLAND, NY 10969
• Looking for the right home, in the right neighborhood ? Great home with 1.3 level... View Details

• $349,900
• 4 Bd, 2/1 Ba
• MLS# 467249

---

1 2

Browse Options

Signup for MyHomes

Local Resources