Buying a home in Shelter Island, New York does not have to be difficult - Homes.com makes home buying a breeze. With 126 homes for sale in Shelter Island, New York, you can search by price, bedrooms, neighborhood, and even by property type. Search Shelter Island homes for sale, foreclosures, MLS listings, and more. Make an informed decision with Shelter Island school data, neighborhood information, find Shelter Island real estate agents, and research home values in Shelter Island, NY. Homes.com has everything you need but the house keys.