- 119 Results

Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, NY

  • Any 
  • < $100,000 
  • $100,000 - $150,000 
  • $150,000 - $200,000 
  • $200,000 - $250,000 
  • $250,000 - $300,000 
  • $300,000 - $400,000 
  • $400,000 - $500,000 
  • $500,000 - $600,000 
  • $600,000+ 
  • to
  • Cities
  • ZIP Codes
  • Neighborhoods
  • Year Built
  • Any (119) 
  • < 1900 (5) 
  • 1900+ (48) 
  • 1950+ (45) 
  • 1975+ (34) 
  • 1995+ (21) 
  • 2005+ (10) 
  • to
  • Square Footage
  • Any (119) 
  • < 1,000 (11) 
  • 1,000+ (92) 
  • 1,500+ (77) 
  • 2,000+ (66) 
  • 3,000+ (34) 
  • 4,000+ (19) 
  • to
  • Lot Size
  • Any (119) 
  • < 1 (71) 
  • 1+ (24) 
  • 2+ (10) 
  • 4+ (5) 
  • 6+ (1) 
  • 10+ (1) 
  • to

16 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 1 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 1
  • Sqft: 1,496
  • Lot Size: 0.63 acres
  • Year Built: 1967
$825,000
Price per Sqft: $551

15 Photo
  • Beds: 2
  • Baths: 1 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 1
  • Sqft: 1,200
  • Lot Size: 1.9 acres
  • Year Built: 1965
$1,149,000
Price per Sqft: $958

14 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 1
  • Sqft: 1,894
  • Lot Size: 0.92 acres
  • Year Built: 2014
$759,000
Price per Sqft: $401

1 Photo
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 3 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 1
  • Sqft: --
  • Lot Size: 1 acres
  • Year Built: 2001

1 Photo
  • Beds: --
  • Baths: --
  • Days on Homes.com: 1
  • Sqft: --
  • Lot Size: 1.4 acres
  • Year Built: --

Just Listed
14 Photo
  • Beds: 6
  • Baths: 7 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 3
  • Sqft: 2,690
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$995,000
Price per Sqft: $370

7 Photo
  • Beds: 2
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 4
  • Sqft: 1,006
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: 1948
$500,000
Price per Sqft: $497

Just Listed
16 Photo
  • Beds: 2
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 6
  • Sqft: 1,300
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$650,000
Price per Sqft: $500

Just Listed
16 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 3 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 14
  • Sqft: 2,600
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$1,050,000
Price per Sqft: $404

Just Listed
13 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 14
  • Sqft: 2,187
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$925,000
Price per Sqft: $423

Just Listed
11 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 3 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 12
  • Sqft: 1,200
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE North Fork
$975,000
Price per Sqft: $813

Video
25 Photo
  • Beds: 6
  • Baths: 6 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 50
  • Sqft: 8,000
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$11,995,000
Price per Sqft: $1,499

Video
24 Photo
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 4 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 34
  • Sqft: 2,710
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$4,500,000
Price per Sqft: $1,661

17 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 34
  • Sqft: 1,670
  • Lot Size: 0.73 acres
  • Year Built: 1957
Offered By:
Bridgehampton Brokerage
$1,695,000
Reduced $200,000 (07/15/16)
Price per Sqft: $1,015

Just Listed
12 Photo
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 23
  • Sqft: 2,106
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$795,000
Price per Sqft: $377
1 - 15 of 119 Results
Save this search & be the first to know when new listings hit the market!