- 121 Results

Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, NY

to
Relevance
Preferred
Newest
Low to High
High to Low

14 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 6
  • Sqft: 1,894
  • Lot Size: 0.92 acres
  • Year Built: 2014
$739,000
Price per Sqft: $390

Just Listed
25 Photo
  • Beds: 6
  • Baths: 6 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 15
  • Sqft: 9,230
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$7,950,000
Increased $650,000 (09/22/16)
Price per Sqft: $861

Pool
25 Photo
  • Beds: 2
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 40
  • Sqft: 1,450
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$1,649,000
Reduced $46,000 (09/23/16)
Price per Sqft: $1,137

Just Listed
13 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 11
  • Sqft: 2,187
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$925,000
Price per Sqft: $423

Pool
25 Photo
  • Beds: 6
  • Baths: 4 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 39
  • Sqft: 6,494
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$3,500,000
Price per Sqft: $539

25 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 39
  • Sqft: 1,346
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$639,000
Price per Sqft: $475

Pool
25 Photo
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 2 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 39
  • Sqft: 3,084
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$1,350,000
Price per Sqft: $438

Video
25 Photo
  • Beds: 6
  • Baths: 6 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 40
  • Sqft: 8,000
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$11,995,000
Price per Sqft: $1,499

Video
24 Photo
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 4 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 40
  • Sqft: 2,710
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$4,500,000
Price per Sqft: $1,661

Pool
24 Photo
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 3 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 40
  • Sqft: 2,388
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$2,175,000
Price per Sqft: $911

Just Listed
20 Photo
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 3 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 29
  • Sqft: 2,800
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$4,250,000
Price per Sqft: $1,518

Just Listed
15 Photo
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 26
  • Sqft: 1,385
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$1,895,000
Price per Sqft: $1,368

Pool
15 Photo
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 3 full & 1 half
  • Days on Homes.com: 40
  • Sqft: 2,554
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$999,000
Reduced $36,000 (09/12/16)
Price per Sqft: $391

Just Listed
15 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 17
  • Sqft: 1,340
  • Lot Size: --
  • Year Built: --
Offered By:
EE Shelter Island
$769,000
Price per Sqft: $574

Just Listed
13 Photo
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 3 full
  • Days on Homes.com: 23
  • Sqft: 2,138
  • Lot Size: 0.7 acres
  • Year Built: 1971
Offered By:
Sag Harbor Brokerage
$2,495,000
Price per Sqft: $1,167
1 - 15 of 121 Results
Save this search & be the first to know when new listings hit the market!