loading

15 Houses For Sale in Cattaraugus, NY

Sort by:
New
$299,900Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,132 Sqft
9875 Hill Road, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

NEW ON THE MARKET! THIS SPACIOUS 4+ BEDROOM, 2-1/2 BATH HOME IS SERVICED BY FREE NATURAL GAS. THE KITCHEN OFFERS A COUNTER BAR AND DINING AREA. THE LIVING ROOM FEATURES A GAS FIREPLACE. WORK FROM HOME AS THE HOUSE HAS AN OFFICE. THERE IS A FIRST FLOOR BEDROOM AND BATH FOR EITHER A MASTER SUITE OR IN-LAW BEDROOM. UPSTAIRS THERE ARE THREE MORE BEDROOMS AND ANOTHER ROOM, PLUS A SECOND BATHROOM. FROM THE GARAGE, YOU ENTER INTO A MUD ROOM AND A FIRST FLOOR LAUNDRY. THE SPACIOUS FULL BASEMENT IS HEATED AND COULD BE FINISHED FOR ADDITIONAL LIVING SPACE OR AN IN-HOME SCHOOL SPACE. THE BACK DECK LEADS TO THE ABOVE GROUND POOL. STROLL THE GROUNDS WHICH BOAST TWO PONDS, WOODS AND LAWN AREA. THE ACREAGE TO THE LEFT IS STATE LAND. THIS HOUSE SITS OFF THE ROAD AND HAS SCENIC COUNTRY VIEWS. PARK YOUR CARS IN THE ATTACHED GARAGE AND YOUR TOYS IN THE DETACHED POLE BARN.

New
$45,900Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,612 Sqft
158 South Main Street, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

Handyman Special! Listed as a single family home, the upstairs is a two bedroom apartment! Perfect for the in laws or as an income apartment. With a little polish, this can be a real gem. Huge yard on a double lot right in the historic Village of Cattaraugus; walking distance to shops, dining, and school. Being sold "As is", seller will make no repairs.

$199,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,600 Sqft
9421 New Albion Road, New Albion, NY 14719
House For Sale

This well built ranch home located just ouside the Village of Little Valley offers about 17 acres of land (an approximate 2-3 acre parcel is being split off of the parcel). Currently set up as a two bedroom home, it could easily be converted back to a three bedroom home, as one of the rooms is currently set up as a laundry room. With a kitchen and family room that are open to each other, you will love entertaining with the back deck that is accessible from the family room through a sliding glass door. You will notice a beautiful stone propane fireplace in the family room that is also a great source of heat. This home was well taken care of over the years, and just needs some updating to make it modernized. With a creek running through the back of the yard, kids would be thrilled to play in the water. There is a two car garage attached to the home, a 1.5 car garage attached to the barn, and you cant forget the massive barn that you would be able to store all of your belongings or create the ultimate workshop area. With a full basement, there is potential for more living space, the ceilings are high enough to consider adding a room in the basement.

$139,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,640 Sqft
23 South Franklin Street, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

This beautiful 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom Craftsman style home boasts updates GALORE!!! Over the past two years this home has received the ultimate transformation!!! The before and after photos are remarkable! Remodeled kitchen and bathrooms, refinished hardwood floors, all new interior paint with exterior to be completed this Spring, garage converted into family room, new hot water heater, blacktopped driveway, new appliances - the list is endless! Excellent location - walking distance to the school! Make this one your forever home!

$98,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,456 Sqft
22 North Franklin Street, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

This charming 3 Bedroom 1 Bathroom home is ready for its new family to grow up in. It boasts nice sized rooms with character and original woodwork craftsmanship. The beautiful woodwork greets you starting with the front door and follows you through the home. Put a little time and sweat equity into refinishing the hardwood floors, and youll have gorgeous floors that all your friends will envy. A large fenced in backyard gives your family plenty of space for outdoor games and activities. Youll love gathering outside on warm days and nights with an inviting concrete patio and covered porch. Plus enjoy the large 35 x 20ft newer detached garage, offering you plenty of room for parking a car and housing your toys. Kids will have an easy walk to school. All appliances are included in the sale. This wont last long, make this home yours.

$84,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,776 Sqft
130 North Main Street, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

Welcome to 130 North Main Street!! This is the ideal location for anyone looking to invest in scenery and land! Sitting beautifully on 3.10 acres of land and a few creeks that run along the property lines! Main home is a three bedroom fixer upper that does need renovations. There is a detached two floor garage, transform the upstairs loft into an apartment or extra space! Come take a look!

$277,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,240 Sqft
10675 Tug Hill Road, New Albion, NY 14719
House For Sale

Stunning Views from every direction & out every window! A long driveway leads to this custom built home on approx. 4 acres. Additional land is available. The deck wraps all the way around the house where you can see for miles and miles. Enter the front door into a hallway with a large closet that houses the Laundry. To the left is the open floor plan kitchen, dining & living room area. Travertine and hardwood floors, custom cabinets, granite countertops & a propane heater to make the area nice and cozy. To the right of the hallway is master bedroom with double closets and a 4 piece bath with a jetted tub, travertine tile, granite and linen closet. Upstairs is a large loft area with hardwood floor, two bedrooms with carpet, closets and a 3/4 bath. The basement has tile floor, plenty of room for additional living space, one car garage, all the utilities and tons of storage, A detached 24x30 garage with a concrete floor is a bonus for all the toys. Wildlife all around with privacy and seclusion makes this home a destination! Taxes and assessment is based on 41 acres, a new survey will be done and taxes will be adjusted.

$45,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 10 Baths | 1,596 Sqft
153 South Main Street, New Albion, NY 14719
House For Sale

A fixer-upper with so much potential. Wonderful natural woodwork throughout. First floor features a large mudroom/laundry room entry at back of house. Kitchen, formal dining room and large living room. There's a bedroom and full bath on first floor. Upstairs - an office area, two more bedrooms and full bath. Detached 2-car garage. Bring your TLC and vision!

$105,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,400 Sqft
183 South Main Street, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

Come see this well maintained, impeccably clean raised ranch in the charming Village of Cattaraugus. Carpets have all been cleaned, fresh paint on the walls, this three bedroom (with a possible fourth) is move in ready. The bathroom is newly remodeled (2018), exterior of the home painted same year.Plumbing is in place for a potential second bath on the lower level. Appliances included, huge bonus room, separate storage room/workshop, generous closets in every bedroom, laundry chute, attached garage, garden shed, covered patio.. this house has it all! Schedule your appointment today and start packing!

$79,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,102 Sqft
8180 Dake Hill Road, Otto, NY 14719
House For Sale

Looking for a peaceful quiet setting surrounded by fruit trees and hardwoods & a nice back yard, you will want to see this cared for home. Beautiful drive down to the house. Pond located at right side of the driveway. Covered entry takes you into the kitchen area w/ newer stove & refirgerator. Small "bar" between the dining area & kichen work area. Into the spacious living room w/ newer sliding glass door & soap stone wood stove. Off the living are 2 bedroooms, bathroom & good size laundry/stroage room w/ door to the back/side yard. A greenhouse & shed for Summer projects. A beautiful setting & easy to maintain. Detached garage has stairs to a nearly finished room that could be a guest bedroom or area for the kids to play. Be sure to put this well priced home on your "look at" list.

$110,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 2,462 Sqft
9147 Cattaraugus Otto Cty Rd 12 Road, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

Unique property! Remodeled school house.2462 Sq Ft with 2 Bedrooms, 1 Bath. Large rooms throughout. 2 car detached garage/workshop with abt. 10 x 32 lean-to on back of garage. Handicap ramp to front door enters the large family room with a balcony on 3 sides. Some hardwood floor needs finishing. Some rooms still have big wall blackboards. Wood storage on one side. Living/Dining remodeled with laminate floor, cathedral ceiling,woodstove. Door leads to rear deck overlooking Cattaraugus Creek.Updated Bath/laundry has tile floor and walk in tub with jets. Galley kitchen with loads of cupboards, microwave and dishwasher, recessed ceiling lights. Large bedroom with a whole wall of closets. Stairway to attic is off the kitchen. 10 yr old steel roof; old aluminum siding, portable generator wired in. Gazebo, storage shed, above ground pool (needs liner), deck and many flower beds. Access to Cattaraugus Creek which runs along he property. Many possibilities for this unusual property!

$3,000
$57,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,228 Sqft
17 Carter Street, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

This is a great home with an awesome location in the village of Cattaraugus. Close to school and center of the village. Hard wood floors throughout.

$10,000
$125,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,532 Sqft
9406 North Otto Road, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

Welcome Home! This is a property you have to see- over 2500 sq ft, 5 BDRM, 2 full Bath- two story home sitting on 4.6 acres in beautiful Cattaraugus County. Loads of storage with walk in closets, 1st floor laundry, bonus rooms, and a ton of living space. Updated metal roof and furnace (2016). Potential Studio Apartment is currently used as a 5th bedroom, can be converted back for extra income. Enjoy your morning coffee on the front porch or take in the picturesque views on the back deck. Two trails lead to your private firepit area where the nights of summer can linger into fall. Showings start immediately- Make your appointment today!

$29,900
$95,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 784 Sqft
10490 Mosher Hollow Road, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

This single wide has an oversized living room added on and includes a large hot tub / pool on the back deck. This property is perfect for the outdoor sports minded. It has 13 acres for hunting and fishing is accessible given New Albion Lake is located across the street. This property also comes with a mother in laws apartment that needs completing and 13 acres of timber. The timber includes Hemlock, Hickory, White Oak, Cherry, and Maple and hasn't been logged in 40 years.

$74,200Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,624 Sqft
Cattaraugus, NY 14719
House For Sale

1624 sq ft. Bank owned foreclosure Single Family Home features 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms. Bank-Owned Foreclosures can offer opportunities to purchase properties at attractive prices.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >