108 Homes For Sale in Cincinnatus, NY

Sort by:
Updated 4-Bedroom Farm In Cincinnnatus
$338,800Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | -- Sqft
5837 Mcfarlane Rd, Cincinnnatus, NY 13040
Farm For Sale

FARM FOR SALE with NEWLY UPDATED HOUSE and GREAT CELL SERVICE!! Sitting on 55 gorgeous acres with terrific views, this1890 home and farm have been well cared for and are ready for your new adventure. It was an operating dairy not too long ago and the land is CERTIFIED ORGANIC. Everything you need to get your farm up and running is already here. A solid house to make your own, while growing your herd or choosing next years crop. The house has four good size bedrooms, with one located on the first floor. The kitchen looks out onto the fields and features STAINLESS APPLIANCES. The living room/dining room combo has plenty of windows and a place for a wood stove if you'd like. The rear of the home offers an open pavilion for use as CANNING KITCHEN or HE/SHE-SHED area. It also has large SHELVED PANTRY for whatever you want to squirrel away. Out in the DAIRY BARN you'll find a LARGE WORKSHOP for all your tools and hardware storage. The barn has room for about 30-40 cows and has an EQUIPPED MILKHOUSE. The sale will include the following barn equipment; pipeline, pump, vats, milking units, fan, gutter grates, walkway covers, mats, bulk tank, water heater, water buckets and fencer. Above you'll find a LARGE HAYLOFT with room for about 4000 square bales or whatever need it suits. The barn has higher than usual ceilings and could be converted for horses. Additionally two good size lean-to livestock shelters are located behind the barn. The land is gently sloping, with good drainage and offers a SOUTH-WEST EXPOSURE. There are 32 tillable acres, 15 acres in pasture and the balance natural. The land affords nearly 300ft frontage on Brackel Creek. Also available for sale separately is a solid selection of farm machinery. List available upon request. So everything you need to get going, Oh and I did mention REALLY GOOD CELL SERVICE. Map to 5836 McFarlane Rd. 5837 is not yet mappable.

1344 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$127,800Est. Payment
4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,344 Sqft
3695 Suarez Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

WELCOME HOME TO PEACE AND QUIET AT AN AFFORDABLE PRICE. CHECK OUT THIS COUNTRY HOME ON JUST OVER A 1/2 ACRE 0.632. INSIDE IS AN OPEN FLOOR PLAN WITH LIVING ROOM/ DINING AREA MAKING UP A NICE GREAT ROOM FOR FAMILY GATHERINGS OR GET TOGETHERS WITH FRINDS. THERE ARE 4 BDRMS, 1 CURRENTLY BEING USED FOR THE LAUNDRY ROOM, COULD EASILY BE CONVERTED BACK.. MASTER BEDROOM WITH WALK IN CLOSET AND A GENEROUS SIZE ROOM. THE FULL LOWER LEVEL HAS A WALK OUT TO YARD, NOT FINISHED BUT COULD BE!!! UPSTAIRS INTERIOR RECENTLY PAINTED, LOTS OF NEW FLOORING, NEW IGHTING FIXTURES, SOME NEW TRIM AND BASEBOARDS, NEW SLIDING GLASS DOOR WITH BLINDS, FRONT AND BACK DECKS LOTS HAS BEEN REPLACED, UPATED INSULATION IN THE LOWER LEVEL, NEW DISHWASHER AND REFRIGERATOR, NEW TOILET AND VANITY. WITH ALL THIS WORK DONE FOR YOU JUST MOVE IN AND ENJOY YOUR NEW HOME AND THE FRESH COUNTRY AIR. THE 20 X 40 COVERED PAVILION W/CEMENT FLOOR IS GREAT SHELTER FROM THE SUN OR A RAINY DAY GATHERING. CALL FOR PRIVATE SHOWING BEFORE IT'S GONE....

2670 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$338,800Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,170 Sqft
5837 Mcfarlane Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

FARM FOR SALE with NEWLY UPDATED HOUSE and GREAT CELL SERVICE!! Sitting on 55 gorgeous acres with terrific views, this1890 home and farm have been well cared for and are ready for your new adventure. It was an operating dairy not too long ago and the land is CERTIFIED ORGANIC. Everything you need to get your farm up and running is already here. A solid house to make your own, while growing your herd or choosing next years crop.The house has four good size bedrooms, with one located on the first floor. The kitchen looks out onto the fields and features STAINLESS APPLIANCES. The living room/dining room combo has plenty of windows and a place for a wood stove if you'd like. The rear of the home offers an open pavilion for use as CANNING KITCHEN or HE/SHE-SHED area. It also has large SHELVED PANTRY for whatever you want to squirrel away.Out in the DAIRY BARN you'll find a LARGE WORKSHOP for all your tools and hardware storage. The barn has room for about 30-40 cows and has an EQUIPPED MILKHOUSE. The sale will include the following barn equipment; pipeline, pump, vats, milking units, fan, gutter grates, walkway covers, mats, bulk tank, water heater, water buckets and fencer. Above you'll find a LARGE HAYLOFT with room for about 4000 square bales or whatever need it suits. The barn has higher than usual ceilings and could be converted for horses. Additionally two good size lean-to livestock shelters are located behind the barn.The land is gently sloping, with good drainage and offers a SOUTH-WEST EXPOSURE. There are 32 tillable acres, 15 acres in pasture and the balance natural. The land affords nearly 300ft frontage on Brackel Creek. Also available for sale separately is a solid selection of farm machinery. List available upon request. So everything you need to get going, Oh and I did mention REALLY GOOD CELL SERVICE. Map to 5836 McFarlane Rd. 5837 is not yet mappable.

Lot In Cincinnatus
$41,900Est. Payment
6.11 Acres
6089 Mcfarlane Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

Allow yourself this alluring property to take you away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Enjoy the options you have with owning this 6.11 parcel.The property is surrounded by private property while the state land is up the road. Not only is the land graceful and comforting, it has a newly built (in 2020) 12' x 20' building with a 6' x 6' bay and a 12' x 20' pavilion and a 8' x 8' shed. As you can see from the pictures, this part of paradise won't last long.

$350,000
Farm In Cincinnatus
$850,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | -- Sqft
5935 Staley Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Farm For Sale

230+/- acre grass base Dairy Farm in Cortland County, town of Cincinnatus on a quiet country road. Endless possibilities and a nice amount of road frontage comes with this farm that has just been recently operated and in working condition along with a well kept, 4 bedroom, 2 bath home a full walkout basement. The 300 cow free stall is equipped with double 8 rapid exit milking parlor, with high pressure flush system, a 5,000 gallon and a 1,000 gallon bulk milk tanks. The outbuildings include dry cow and calf barn, special needs barn, a 5 bay dry feed storage barn, equipment storage/work shop, and a large bunk for crop storage. The 50 +/- acres crop land has a very gentle roll, with 130 +/- of woodland along with 55+/- acres of pasture with some high tinsel fencing. This listing includes 3 parcels to total the 260 acres. There may be additional crop land in area for rent or purchase as well. 260 acre Dairy Farm in Cortland County, Town of Cincinnatus.

Lot In Cincinnatus
$44,900Est. Payment
24 Acres
Hubbards Hill, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

This property has 24 acres of gorgeous potential! Quiet, secluded partially wooded land surrounded with lovely views in every season. Here is your potential to build a seasonal camp, your own private residence, develop as a solar farm... the possibilities are endless! Located close to large tracks of state land.

1500 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$132,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,500 Sqft
4350 Potter Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

This private get-a-way year round home might be just what you need! Use to be home to Froggy Bottom Raceway with parts of the track still existing. Not only does the 28 acres offer the track but also has trails and if that isn't enough is nestled and surrounded by State land. The acreage is a perk to this quaint 2 bedroom one bath home with first floor bath, bedroom and laundry. Open floor plan concept makes this a great option for many needs. Check this out.. One thing they don't make more of is land.. so this won't last long.

Lot In Cincinnatus
$44,900Est. Payment
24 Acres
3497 Hubbards Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

This property has 24 acres of gorgeous potential! Quiet, secluded partially wooded land surrounded with lovely views in every season. Here is your potential to build a seasonal camp, your own private residence, develop as a solar farm... the possibilities are endless! Located close to large tracks of state land.

Lot In Cincinnatus
$349,900Est. Payment
101.45 Acres
2401 Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

Set on the top of a hill, with outstanding views of the valley below, the beautiful multi-use active farm offers the new owner two well maintained, timber framed barns built in 1906, ~31 acres fenced pastures and ~30 acres of active agricultural fields currently planted to hay and a nice woodlot. With a well and electric already in place, there are so many options for how this property could be utilized: any number of different crop and livestock farming, converted for horses, or a workshop / business, vacation get-away or convert the timber frame barn to a year round home. The highly desirable barns have been very well maintained, and currently are being used as a beef cattle operation with wooden decorative fencing along the roadside and high tensile (3 strands) for the pastures behind the barns. The main barn has a new 200 amp service and well pump recently replaced. The smaller barn was rebuilt by the Amish five years ago and some general repairs to the main barn were made by them at the same time. The entire road frontage offers ample electric, providing multiple options for building a new home or cabin. In addition the Town of Cincinnatus has municipal water along the road frontage which could be tapped into as well, rather than drilling another well for a new home or cabin. Also, there is a fire hydrant in front of the main barn which is very favorable with insurance companies as far as getting coverage in a country location. There is a potential building site north of the barns where a perc test was performed by the County, which passed with flying colors. And most uniquely, there is a spring house on the property which covers an 400' deep artesian well, originally drilled to supply Lower Cincinnatus with fresh water in the 1920's, and now continues to provide a constant, year round steady flow of fresh water, which the new owner could pipe to a storage tank and provide gravity fed spring water to a new house, camp or agricultural related venture.The fields

Lot In Cincinnatus
$49,900Est. Payment
-- Acres
6077 Melody Lake Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

BUILDING LOT ON MELODY LAKE IN CORTLAND COUNTY! Welcome to Melody Lake, also knows as Ellis Lake where the fish bite and she sun shines! This lot has UNOBSTRUCTED VIEWS OF the lake. This is a nice flat parcel with full sun, a new well and drainage. Brinhg your building plans, your manufactured home, or your camper and start enjoying the fresh air and sun of Upstate New York. Association dues of $100/yr help maintain the access points for cottages with deeded lake rights. This is a no motor lake- so bring your kayaks, canoes or trolling motors and enjoy the peace and quiet. This lot is 50x160 which gives added space in the back for sheds,garage,etc.

864 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$59,900Est. Payment
1 Bed | -- Baths | 864 Sqft
2762 East Freetown Texas Valley Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

If you want privacy, and love to hunt, this 2 acre parcel is for you. It includes a 24' x 36' ranch style metal building, fully insulated, and on a slab. Just the building will be sold, with a hand pump in the mud room area that is fully functional and brings (gravity fed) water from the drilled well up the hill. The exterior boasts a horse shed, a shed/garage for tools, and there will be a finished (by closing), a wood framed barn, 20' x 24' with a metal roof. Up the road less than 1/4 mile is state land, the possibilities are endless. An easy rehab loan can used to make this a functional house.

$6,000
1664 SqFt Farm In Cincinnatus
$79,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,664 Sqft
5773 Post Office Street, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Farm For Sale

Large home on a desirable dead end street in the town of Cincinnatus. Walking distance to school, park, and other local amenities. Home offers large yard, no traffic, awesome historic outbuilding and garage, and a new septic. Inside the home offers character and charm with built ins, large rooms, and first floor bathroom. A little attention and some updates could easily restore a structurally sound home into the your beauty.

1485 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$98,750Est. Payment
4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,485 Sqft
5007 Gee Brook Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

20 beautiful acres with great views. A four bedroom house with a potential apartment or in-law suite. Tie stall barn, perfect for a small dairy, hobby, or horse farm. The property is located centrally between Marathon and Cincinnatus. Sold as is.

$2,600
1832 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$179,900Est. Payment
5 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,832 Sqft
2879 East View Terrace, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Enjoy this solidly built colonial style home nestled on a dead end street. This lovely property has a beautiful exterior complete with a newly build brick outdoor fireplace, landscaped grounds, an above ground pool and a deck. Inside you will find a new spacious living room off the back of the house that overlooks the landscaped back yard. Inside has an open concept to a second living space and kitchen, (Corian countertops). A primary bedroom and a full bath with a walk in closet is on the main floor, there are 4 bedrooms on the second level, and a large bedroom in the attic space. The roof is newer, nicely sided, and there is a new on demand hot water tank. With just a little trim work needed and a few rooms painted this house would be priced higher. Make this your haven yours to enjoy, call today for a showing.

1422 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$74,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,422 Sqft
3970 Telephone Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

This home has been in one family since 1947. It has had several improvements; newer furnace, 200 amp-CB, vinyl windows, newer walk-in shower. replacement stairs to the second floor. Double LR, large dining room and eat-in kitchen. First floor bathroom with 3 BRs up. Enclosed front porch. Two garages, one near the house, the other in upper corner near the road. There are two electric meters; one for house an done on light pole in the yard. More photos to come!

930 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$120,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 930 Sqft
5112 Telephone Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Looking for move in ready? This 2 bed, 1 bath home is for you! Kitchen features new cabinets, countertops and flooring. Hardwood floors in living room and first floor bedroom with California closet. Second floor offers bedroom, wall to wall carpeting and loft space - great for office or playroom! Lots of natural light and extra storage in basement. Everything is new! A must see!

1817 SqFt House In Cincinnatus
$415,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,817 Sqft
3638 Taylor Valley Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Operating CERTIFIED ORGANIC DAIRY FARM with 127 beautiful acres. A big game hunters dream or a farmer's paradise that includes 50 acres of forest with abundant wildlife. 70 acres of fenced-in tillable land with spring fed water lines to all pastures. The barn is equipped with 45 comfort stalls, 2 heifer pens, ridged concrete floor, Patz barn cleaner, 18 x 50 silo with a Patz unloader, concrete barnyard, and round bale unroller. This farmhouse is a 4 or 5-bedroom, 1 bath with a newly renovated boot room and some interior updates including hard wood floors throughout the living area. Also included is a 3-year-old propane boiler and an outside wood furnace. Cows and a short line of equipment available upon request at additional cost.

1
234
...
7