loading

27 Homes For Sale in Cincinnatus, NY

Sort by:
$239,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,508 Sqft

5726 Cheningo Solon Pond Road, Truxton, NY 13040

House For Sale

Tranquility Found! A quarter of a mile off the main road surrounded by 25 acres of privacy and an abundant cherry forest you will find this authentic Yankee Barn Constructed home built in 1980. Plus a separate guest house/studio and a quarter acre pond. The Main home offers post and beam construction with soaring ceilings, exposed beams, large windows to enjoy the natural sunlight and beautiful views. Open floor plan with hardwood and clay tile floors. Wood burning stove in the first floor bedroom/office/den. Radiant and hot water baseboard heat. Two stall attached garage with utility room. Guest house/studio has a full kitchen, full bath, living area, bedroom, front porch with a wood burning stove as well as electric heat. Custom constructed home surrounded by a beautiful forest and located in a private location.

$86,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,260 Sqft

515 State Hwy 23, Pitcher, NY 13040

House For Sale

Welcome to this cozy and private home located on over 11 acres! This 3 bedroom home has a very nice open floor plan with dining and living room combination and galley kitchen. Nice full bath and master bedroom on the 1st floor. Second floor includes two generously sized additional bedrooms. You'll love the large deck from the sliding glass doors off the living room. Serene streams that runs close to the deck will make you feel like you're in your own private retreat home. There are three outbuildings, a large two car garage, a one bay barn, and a smaller tool shed next to the home. This home is only minutes from Cincinnatus, and will serve as the perfect year-round home, weekend getaway, or hunting cabin.

$129,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | -- Baths | 2,088 Sqft

4676 Fox Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

House For Sale

This lovely country home was professionally constructed in 2012 by the owner's son who is an Amish home builder. (Three very nice buildings) An Amish living style home, using quality industry materials. This home does NOT have electric, its own well, a conventional heating system or bathroom, all could be added by the new owner if desired. (SELLING AS IS) There was a new concrete septic tank and leach field installed when the home was constructed. There is a new horse stable with tack area that could be converted to house most any farm animal, with an adjoining fenced pasture. A shop building used by the seller as a meat processing facility (all processing and storage equipment and track system will be removed) could be converted into a multi-use storage and or nice workshop. Adjoining the home parcel is a 12.5-acre (no survey) woodlot with a variety of hard and soft woods including mature maple and black cherry timber. There are obvious signs of deer, turkey and small game using this area, bordered by a pond and wetlands on one side. A small stream runs through the one end of the woods adding diversity and beauty as you walk up the trail into the woods. The 3.7-acre home parcel is newly surveyed in a private country setting with nice established gardens and a wide driveway offering plenty of room for multiple purposes. The house was part of a larger parcel and is now on its own lot...tax parcel number is not yet available. It is a very nicely constructed home, without modern appliances. The taxes are estimated.

$5,000
$149,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,444 Sqft

2723 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

House For Sale

Welcome to this charming ranch home nestled in the village of Cincinnatus. 3 bedroom, 2 full baths, laundry and all on one floor. This home has new flooring with some original hard wood, Rooms have been freshly painted, and the kitchen has been remodeled. Full basement, nice big back yard and a small garage out back for storage or work shop. Great place to retreat after a long day, and you can even unwind in the hot tub. This home is move in ready and waiting for it's new owner.

$59,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,280 Sqft

2597 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

House For Sale

You're going to love this privately located property situated high on 2.44 acres. Enter through the back door mudroom to leave your boots and coats. Spacious kitchen and dining room lead to French doors. Spend time entertaining or relaxing on the full front deck while soaking up the amazing views. Enjoy sitting around the approximately 5 year old rice coal stove and the foam insulation in the ceiling and floors help keep your costs down. 2 large bedrooms and the master has a toilet and laundry room. The metal roof is only 3 years old and the hot water heater is approximately 2 years old. Plenty of room in the full basement for a workshop or storage. Come check out this diamond in the rough and make it your own!

$259,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,560 Sqft

0 Allen Hill Rd, Taylor, NY 13040

House For Sale

Don't miss this beautiful log cabin on over 27 acres in Cortland County! This 1,560 Square Foot, 2 Bedroom, 1 Full Bathroom log cabin sits back from the year round maintained road at the end of an 800 ft. driveway! Featuring tongue and groove pine interior, hardwood floors, vaulted ceiling, large loft, and an open floor plan giving the feel of the great outdoors! The cabin is heated by both a wood stove and propane forced air furnace, propane fired hot water, has a private drilled well and septic system, and electricity. Sitting on piers with a crawl space with a full porch across the front for perfect viewing of over 27 acres of gently rolling fields and wooded terrain. Outside, there is a 40 x 38 foot pole barn with concrete floor and 12' overhead door for all your storage needs, including a separate space on the side for snowmobiles, an outdoor shower and a hydrant behind the cabin! There are so many possibilities. This amazing property could be yours! Give Nicholas Polce a call today to schedule your showing!

$27,500Est. Payment
10.27 Acres

0 Hollow Road, German, NY 13040

Lots Land For Sale

Great opportunity to purchase 10.27 acres that connects to stateland. 3 tax map parcels combined. All on a quiet maintained road.

$5,500
$489,500Est. Payment
180.23 Acres

3294 Haines Road, Taylor, NY 13040

Lots Land For Sale

Certified organic farm. 180 acres in Cortland County at the end of a peaceful country road. 30 year old 1500 SF raised ranch home in a well-maintained condition in an ideal setting for your farm or recreational property. 4 bedrooms, large open kitchen, multiple heating sources (fuel oil, outdoor wood boiler, Central A/C). Multiple barns- an old dairy barn, open barn, large equipment and hay storage barn with a heated shop, a 20'x30' horse barn with 3 box stalls rounds out the buildings. The land is exceptional with 115 tillable ares, 25 acres of pasture and 40 wooded acres which provides an abundance of area for livestock, riding trails, or hunting. A secluded fishing pond and meandering stream enhances this choice property. All mineral and timber rights transfer to the new owner.

$329,900Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,664 Sqft

4343 Potter Hill Road, Taylor, NY 13040

House For Sale

Lovely waterfront property located on Solon Pond in Taylor NY includes the pond along with both woodlands and some tillable acreage.4 bedroom, 2 bath farmhouse and a small barn.Hunt, fish, hike, ride -- this one has it all! Spacious downstairs with a dining room, large living room and bedroom on the first floor and a bathroom and three bedrooms upstairs. There is a large hallway between them as well. Land on both sides of Potter Hill Road with tillable acreage on one side and the bulk of the acreage, house and pond on the other. Take a look at the Solon Pond website: solonpond.com Convenient access from I-81 means you will use the property well. Come on up for a look at this acreage/waterfront.It will take your breath away.

$19,900Est. Payment
8.18 Acres

00 Cheningo Solon Pond Road, Taylor, NY 13040

Lots Land For Sale

Nice parcel for those who want to build a home, camp or just as a little hunting spot in Taylor NY. The property goes down from the road and has Pond Creek in the back. All wooded with apple and brush loaded with deer tracks. 8.18 acres of relaxation! While walking the land I saw plenty of deer tracks for those who are into hunting or for those who are into watching the wildlife. Have a look at the photos. Nice small parcel for you to buy and add whatever you would like!

$275,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,392 Sqft

3488 Hubbards Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

House For Sale

"The Cabin" is ready for your Buyer! Beautiful finishes and all the equipment your buyers will need to not rely on outside resources! Solar panels and generators, propane for heat and fire places, and a beautiful log home hideaway... Original log cabin on property is included in the transfer of title. This listing includes tax map # 114200-103-000-0003-004-000-0000.

$4,100
$244,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 672 Sqft

4816 Fox Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

House For Sale

113.76 FABulous acres in a gorgeous setting! 52 acres are surrounded by new five wire high tensile fence, at least two creeks and several ponds. You can fill your thermos with fresh spring water! There are two separate pastures that easily produce 250 round bales. The property is also loaded with shale. Brand new frost free water pump with electric is ready to be hooked up. All is new in the 2 BR Ranch style home with full basement including the well, septic, plumbing, electric, furnace, hot water tank and blown in insulation. Inside features laminate floors throughout, stackable washer and dryer off the kitchen and fresh paint. All appliances convey. Enjoy your time on the covered porch so you can enjoy the breathtaking views that upstate NY is so well known for.

$18,500
$279,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,440 Sqft

5147 Gee Brook Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

House For Sale

Lovely 2440 square foot custom ranch with hardwood, tile floors and many extras. Large master bedroom with soaking tub with private deck. Walkout basement with family room, craft room, music room, and lots of extra storage space. Also outside 24x14 storage shed. All this on 124 acres of land, consisting of both woods and fields. connected on back side to 700 acres of state forest. There is an additional well near back field. Property near shopping, fishing, golfing, and skiing. Town of Cincinnatus has several historic landmarks. 6 miles to Marathon and route 81. Owner is a licensed real estate agent.

$95,940Est. Payment
47.97 Acres

100 German Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

Lots Land For Sale

With its woods so lovely dark and deep you'll forget the promises you have to keep. Totaling 47.97 acres of flat to rolling land that offers a large private pond, streams and fields too. This property has everything and is loaded with deer and other small game. Build your home and still have the entire back 40+ acres to enjoy. Located in Cincinnatus, NY on a town maintained road with a desirable southern exposure, affording excellent building sites and agricultural acreage too. Perfect for homesteading, hemp farm, hunting, fishing, kayaking, hiking and horse back riding. Within easy proximity to large swaths of state forest as well, for further enjoyments of the outdoors. Take a stroll and get lost in the possibilities.

$95,940Est. Payment
47.97 Acres

0 German Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

Lots Land For Sale

With its woods so lovely dark and deep you'll forget the promises you have to keep. Totaling 47.97 acres of flat to rolling land that offers a large private pond, streams and fields too. This property has everything and is loaded with deer and other small game. Build your home and still have the entire back 40+ acres to enjoy. Located in Cincinnatus, NY on a town maintained road with a desirable southern exposure, affording excellent building sites and agricultural acreage too. Perfect for homesteading, hunting, fishing, kayaking, hiking and horse back riding. Within easy proximity to large swaths of state forest as well, for further enjoyments of the outdoors. Take a stroll and get lost in the possibilities.

$3,000
$69,900Est. Payment
44 Acres

00 Ny Route 41 Road, Freetown, NY 13040

Lots Land For Sale

44 acres mostly tillable land with some pasture, woods and views in Freetown NY, Cortland County. This lovely parcel has all the features crop growers and country home builders are looking for.A large level well-drained field of clover lies along the road.From there, the land slopes gently up into several hay fields bordered by hedgerows of apple trees and maples. Great views of the valley and south facing slope. The wood lot and brush or pasture area is large enough for firewood or to hold the deer and turkey that feed in the fields.Maple syrup hedge row. Concrete barn foundation approx. 34 x 60, building could be built on this existing foundation. Nearby state forests, rivers, trout streams, Finger Lakes, ski slopes provide additional outdoor recreation. More land available.

1
2
list-24px Created with Sketch. width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" version="1.2" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" overflow="visible" preserveAspectRatio="none" > version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >