loading

34 Houses For Sale in Cooperstown, NY

Sort by:
New
$1,395,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 4 Baths | 5,200 Sqft
13 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Beyond the wrought iron fence stands this prestigious home built in 1802. Enter into a grand foyer with a lovely sweeping curved staircase with wide pine treads, high ceiling and long hallway. Stunning 24' X 18' formal dining room boasts plaster moldings, interesting ornamental ceiling art, indoor shutters, stenciled pine flooring, 6/6 windows, fireplace with marble mantel and 12' high ceiling. Federal moldings, marble fireplace, indoor shutters, 10' high ceiling and pine floor showcase the formal living room. The cozy den/library with wall of built in shelving and a fireplace could also be used as a downstairs office. There is a marble top center island with sink, dishwasher and extra storage in the eat-in kitchen. Double ovens, 6 burner plus grill cook top, refrigerator, lots of cabinets and pantry. Computer desk area and lovely fireside seating. Adorable powder room is across from two hallway closets. Laundry room has a deep sink, more storage, washer, dryer and extra refrigerator. The 14' X 12' fantastic mudroom has multiple hooks, shelving, built-in bench and room for all kinds of sporting and outdoor equipment. Entertainment is made easier with the butler pantry/ bar, conveniently located between kitchen and dining room, off a side entryway. Laid stone and iron fence surround the flagstone patio which is great for outdoor entertaining. Patio leads to small room with built-ins perfect for books and board games. Upstairs (via front or back stairs) are five bedrooms (one is a walk through to another), office/den, and three full bathrooms. Master bedroom has double walk-in closets. Cedar lined and a hallway walk through closet are also included. Bonus is the newer two bedroom, full bath apartment above the three bay garage with history of rentals (not included in the square footage of the house). Pretty side yard has children's playground. This beautiful historic property, with green lawn, trees, iron fencing, and great parking is adjacent to Cooper Park. Just

New
$169,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,512 Sqft
302 Springfield Hill Rd, Middlefield Center, NY 13326
House For Sale

(8646) Look at the values in this updated 3BR/2BA Ranch offering on 16.50 acres. Many comforts, including dining room, cathedral ceilings and master suite with walk-in closet. Airy and bright floorplan, den, skylights. newer kitchen with oak cabinets, laundry room. Gas heat, newer furnace. Newer roof, storage shed. Seasonal Lake views from property. A very tempting buy! Cooperstown Schools.

$282,500Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,632 Sqft
21 Eagle Street, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

If you are looking for the perfect house to make your own, this is the home for you. Built in 1969, this 4-bedroom Cooperstown Village Colonial is located on a quiet street only blocks away from the schools, grocery store, and hospital. The current owners have lived here for nearly 40 years and it is evident they have cared for and loved the home during this time. New owners could choose to move in and make changes to the existing home, as the roof and other systems have been recently updated, or they can take advantage of the oversized yard and expand the home by adding an addition off the back. The beautiful 1/3 of an acre lot affords lots of possibilities for expansion while still leaving plenty of room for a great yard. Do not hesitate - houses on this street do not change hands often! This home is being sold AS-IS.

$2,700,000Est. Payment
8 Beds | 8 Baths | 6,904 Sqft
1 Lake Street, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Edgewater, Cooperstowns most important historic home. Built by Issac Cooper, brother of James Fenimore Cooper, between 1810 1812. Remodeled and Victoranized in the late nineteenth century the Edgewater of today is the work of Society architect Frank Whiting who was commissioned to return the house to its Federal style in the 1920s. This impressive home has played host to some of Americas most important citizens. Writers, artists, sports figures, statesmen and Presidents have been part of this homes history from the early nineteenth century until today. Situated on two acres in the center of Cooperstowns charming village the 7000 square foot main house and its guest cottage are set among specimen trees and lawns completely enclosed within a fence and hedgerow. There are also a large two bay garage building with additional storage, period ice house and green house.The drive is paved with curbing and lighting. The two story brick main house has large public rooms on the first floor, a dynamic double curved staircase, eight bedrooms several with en suite baths, eight fireplaces and a full basement. There is a commercial kitchen and large pantry, service stairs and a third floor once used for maids quarters. Period details abound with Federal era mantle pieces, woodwork and plaster moldings. The dining room if finished with a hand painted landscape mural, custom curtains remain in the dining drawing rooms as well as other rooms throughout the house.All systems are up to date including heating and central air conditioning. The three bedroom guest cottage, once a carriage house, has been completely updated within the past few years. All surfaces in the main house have been refinished with new paint and paper, both the main house and cottage are in excellent condition. This property is rarely available even once in a generation.

$699,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,275 Sqft
396 Huff Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Braeburn Farm A Cooperstown treasure. The builder of this house searched in vain for a country farmhouse close to Cooperstown Village. When he couldnt find what he wanted he had this incredible home built to exacting specifications. Set on almost 14 picturesque acres in the Pierstown district of Cooperstowm this home was truly a labor of love. The exterior profile says historic home while the interior is designed for todays lifestyle. There are none of the dark small rooms you encounter in historic homes, here there are bright spaces flooded with natural light. The main floor has an open concept Kitchen, Living and Dining room so saught after today.There are beautiful figured Cherry counters and custom shaker style cabinetry. Glowing reclaimed wide pine floors and refinished 19th century doors create the impression of a period home somehow designed for modern living. The central chimney has a Vermont Castings woodstove for cozy winter days. A spacious entry/mud room boasts a custom refrigerated bar, flower sink and large walk in pantry. With a full tiled bath, this space seperates the Kitchen/Living/Dining Room from a cozy study/media room easily reinterperted as a first floor bedroom.Upstairs are three spacious bedrooms each with ample closet space. A large hall has room for an Office and Lounge. These three bedrooms share another custom tiled bath. A large linen closet provides ample storage. The full basememt has radient heat as does the first floor. The second floor is heated with reclaimed and refinished cast iron raidators. There is also a laundry and darkroom in the basement. Outside is a large two story barn/garage, another historically accurate recreation. the first floor has parking for one or two cars and equipment storage, upstairs is a large three season rec. room. This is a charming family home in Cooperstowns most desireable residental area. No expense was spared in the construction of this house now just twenty years old. Braeburn Farm has had only two owners who used the property for summers only so it has seen very light use.

$104,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,202 Sqft
7634 State Hwy 80, Springfield, NY 13326
House For Sale

Escape to a simpler time at the BURNHAM COTTAGE dubbed after its earliest occupants of 1860, a farrier and his wife. From the moment you step into the enclosed front porch you may not be able to help yourself from feeling like you're stepping back in time, then take in the aroma of simmering pear butter and enjoy the visit. This rustic, post-beam colonial cottage offers 3 bedrooms, one of which is on the first floor, one bathroom (room available and plumbed for a half bath and laundry) and an authentic pantry. Thoughtfully renovated to its period colonial style, features include 12 over 8 windows (original and custom replacements), solid wood interior doors w/ Cherry Valley Latches, wide plank floor boards and beadboard staircase. The kitchen renovation revealed pine plank walls which are now complemented by Nutmeg Oak Cabinets and tile countertops. A room off the living room, currently used as a bedroom, could simply become an office with access to a deck overlooking the tree lined backyard. The decorative gas fireplace(not currently in use) adds charm to the renovated and reinsulated living room. If it's a unique home you've been searching for this just may be the one! This home's location is set in a well established seasonal rental community and was initially purchased with a rental cottage in mind. Just 10 miles from Cooperstown in The Town of Springfield offering Otsego Lake Privileges, stands this quaint cottage. Two Tax Parcels, IDs 41.06-1-45.00 and 41.06-1-46.00 create the .28 acres. This home is BEING SOLD AS IS

$299,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,140 Sqft
12 Susquehanna Avenue, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Looking to own a multi-family unit in Cooperstown? Well look no further than 12 Susquehanna Avenue. This grand Victorian home sits right in the heart of the Village and is currently set up as a family residence on the first floor, with the second floor having been set up for use as a Day Care Center. Endless opportunities exist with this home, from converting back to a charming single family to renting out the second floor for use as a business or income earning apartment. Updated kitchen on main level with concrete countertops, newer stainless appliances and new floor. Original hardwood, wide planked floors remain on most of first floor, as do original pocket doors and Butler's pantry. Original features include stunning bay windows overlooking the large front porch, skeleton key holed original doors and knobs, tin ceilings, an ornate fireplace, sunporch, and an upstairs balcony. New deck built for upstairs tenants, and a 3 Bay, 2 Story Carriage Barn on this large, surveyed lot. Storage galore. Short walk to Main St., Restaurants, Hospital, Schools and Sports Center. All for less than $300,000.00 - this is a can't miss opportunity!

$269,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,706 Sqft
42 Beaver Street, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Bright and sunny 4-bedroom 2-bathroom colonial home in the Village of Cooperstown. The 1st floor of this home features an eat-in kitchen with a large bay window overlooking the backyard. A good size formal dining room, large living room,3/4 bathroom, and an office with built-in bookshelves, this room would also make a great 1st-floor bedroom. Upstairs is a spacious full bathroom and 4 bedrooms, 2 of the large bedrooms have walk-in closets. The basement could be used as a family room; bonus to the basement is a wood-burning fireplace and a back patio off the back door. Easy walk to Main St., Bassett Medical Center, the Clark Sports Center, grocery store, and schools.

$349,900Est. Payment
6 Beds | 7 Baths | 3,694 Sqft
3179 County Highway 33, Middlefield, NY 13326
House For Sale

Endless Possibilities!! Currently Established as The Willow Tree Inn, this Booming B&B is just 7 miles from Cooperstown, and 7 miles from Glimmer Glass Opera. This Stately Center Hall Colonial with Covered Front Porches, Gorgeous Perennial Gardens, Pond and a Back Deck With Endless Countryside Views! Home offers 6 Bedrooms all with Private Baths. Spacious Dining Room, Library, Farm Style Kitchen, with Commercial Range and Refrigerator. Original Hard Wood Floors throughout! Additional Owners Quarters/Employee Apartment. Outside Excellent 2-Story Barn. Perfect for Wedding Venue, Entertaining, Storage and More... This Property Has So Much To Offer! Come View All of the Possibilities Today!

$369,000Est. Payment
10 Beds | 8 Baths | 8,900 Sqft
316 County Hwy 28, Otsego, NY 13326
House For Sale

ThistleBrook Farm-Unique Converted 1860's Barn minutes from the Village of Cooperstown. This stunning property offers options for a family retreat, B&B, or use as a high-end rental investment. The main section offers spacious great room, dining room, 2 kitchens. All five bedrooms have private baths. Owners Quarters features 3-4 bedrooms, kitchen with stunning views of the Hager Hop Farm, master suite, kitchen, dining and office area. Plus access to private back deck. Bonus: An additional one bedroom apartment with private side entrance. Outside this grand home offers, stone patio, pond, private decks all surrounds by landscaped grounds. This is a truly spectacular property! Come view all this property has to offer.

$259,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,122 Sqft
180 Allen Lake Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Otsego Lake-View Cape - This spacious Cape Cod, with bucolic views of Otsego Lake - the legendary Glimmerglass of James Fenimore Cooper's Leatherstocking Tales, is your opportunity to live in the privacy of a country home. This 2,100 SF home is sited on 3.51 acres of mature flower gardens, lawns, shade trees, and woodlands with brook. The main floor features Living Room with double closets, Dining Room with sliding door to deck and gardens, fully applianced eat-in Kitchen with oak cabinets, laundry, comfortable Den with lake-view, Full Bath, en suite Master Bedroom, and spacious second bedroom. Upstairs are two large Bedrooms with good closets, hallway with 20' of closets, and additional 125 SF for potential bathroom, or more storage. This floor is a work-in-progress waiting for your finishing touches. The full basement has potential for more living space, large utility rooms, and abundant storage. Detached two-car garage. Easy drive to Cooperstown, America's Most Perfect Village. Its finest include The National Baseball Hall of Fame, historic Doubleday Field, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, The Glimmerglass Festival, The Otesaga Resort Hotel and the legendary 18-hole championship Leatherstocking Golf Course, Clark Sports Center, Bassett Hospital, Brewery Ommegang, fine shops, restaurants. Springfield Lake Rights. Cherry Valley-Springfield Schools. 3-1/2 hours to New York City. Offered Exclusively by ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY

$599,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 3,080 Sqft
249 Co Hwy 28, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

In Pierstown - conveniently located on County Highway 28 just a couple miles from the village of Cooperstown, this c. 2000 Countryside Colonial provides 3080 square feet of outstanding living space. Situated on 11 acres with picturesque valley views, sweeping lawns, and pond. The first floor includes an open floor plan with formal living room, dining room, den, eat-in kitchen with center island, oak cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless-steel appliances; family room with gas fireplace, and a half bath. Upstairs are four bedrooms, including an en suite master, a second full bathroom, laundry area, and playroom or possible bedroom. The finished basement provides additional living area with possible bedroom, family room, gym/exercise room, large utility/storage room, and a workshop area. Additional features include hardwood flooring, wide mahogany decked front porch, large back deck leading to patio surrounding the inground heated saltwater pool with pool house, a huge backyard, attached two car garage, 50x30 three stall horse barn with oversized shop/storage, electric, water, and poured concrete floor. More land available. This property offers privacy and seclusion coupled with the opportunity to experience all that makes Cooperstown, "America's Most Perfect Village". Its finest include Otsego Lake - the legendary "Glimmerglass" of James Fenimore Cooper's Leatherstocking Tales, The Otesaga Resort Hotel and the legendary 18-hole championship Leatherstocking Golf Course, The National Baseball Hall of Fame, historic Doubleday Field, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, The Glimmerglass Festival, Clark Sports Center, Bassett Hospital, Brewery Ommegang, fine shops, restaurants. Cooperstown School District. 3-1/2 hours to NYC. Offered Exclusively by ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY

$599,000Est. Payment
7 Beds | 7 Baths | 3,472 Sqft
1270 County Highway 33, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

ELEGANT: pleasingly graceful and stylish in appearance or manner. The perfect adjective to describe this historic home. Extensive updating, a lovely 11.67 acre lot, and easy proximity to the amenities of Cooperstown render this property perfect in every way. The generous living room features a wooden bar, original to the home. The bar is a wonderful location to entertain family, and friends, and is a great conversation piece. The dining room is spacious enough to host a large dinner party, with a new gas stove for ambiance and warmth. The bright and spacious kitchen, a chefs dream, has been fully updated. If working from home, or an in home business is of interest, there is a lovely library/office on the first floor. It can be closed off for privacy. Also on the first floor is a grand master suite, with a large sitting room, bedroom, and full bathroom. The second floor boasts 3 roomy bedrooms, each with their own bathroom. Increasing the appeal of the property is the separate 2 bed room apartment. The first floor of the apartment offers an open kitchen, living room, bedroom, and full bath. On the second floor is a sweet bedroom, with sky lights, an office (or exercise room) and a tremendous amount of storage. The grounds surrounding the home are beautifully landscaped, and the 11.67 acres includes plenty of room for hiking, camping and all out door activities. The charm and grace of this property make it a wonderful place to call home. This property has a myriad of possibilities. Live in the main house, and rent the apartment, seasonal or year round. If you are looking for an investment opportunity in this area...this property has been run as a successful B&B and house rental for 6 years. The owner occupied the apartment. The property is fully furnished and furnishings are for sale. There are flat screen TVs, and window A/C units in every room. Call for a showing, prequalified buyers.

$449,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | -- Sqft
386 Springfield Hill Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Magical views! Three bedroom plus, raised rustic 2016 ranch with spectacular views on over 29 acres, with more space to build !! This is definitely a must see property. Plenty of storage on the lower level for outdoor sports equipment. Nature abounds! This property sits approximately nine miles from the historic village of Cooperstown, serene, private and outstanding views. Plenty of land to build another home or homes. Minutes to the Glimmerglass Opera Festival and State Park. Plenty of hiking, biking, boating, fishing and hunting. Commuters dream to the Route 20 corridor. East to Albany, west to Utica. Cooperstown Central Schools. Bus pick up a two minute drive!

$229,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,609 Sqft
106 Lower Toddsville Rd, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Upgraded Country Home - Just 3.8 miles from the Village of Cooperstown, this 1,609 square foot house sits on 0.86 acres surrounded by perennial gardens, mature shade trees, and sweeping lawn. This tastefully upgraded home has a large living room with propane stove, fireplace, built-in shelving; den or possible fourth bedroom, full bath, modern fully applianced eat-in kitchen with center island, large pantry closet, and mudroom. Upstairs are three spacious bedrooms with good closets, full bath with marble floor, and laundry. Oak, and Pine wood floors give "farmhouse" charm. Wide front porch for sitting, perfect for summer lounging. Great single-family home or rental opportunity. Detached two car garage sits to the back. Anderson replacement windows, newer roof, move-in ready. Cooperstown Schools. Spectrum Highspeed Internet. Convenient to Cooperstown, Oneonta, 3.5 hours to NYC. Offered Exclusively by ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY

$599,000Est. Payment
7 Beds | 7 Baths | 3,472 Sqft
1270 Rt 33, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

ELEGANT: Pleasingly graceful and stylish in appearance and manner. The perfect adjective to describe this Historic home. Extensive updating, a lovely 11.67 acre lot, and easy proximity to the amenities of Cooperstown render this property perfect in every way. The generous living room features a wooden bar, original to the home. The bar is a wonderful location to entertain family, and friends, and is a great conversation piece. The dining room is spacious enough to host a large dinner party, with a new gas stove for ambiance and warmth. The bright and spacious kitchen, a chefs dream, has been fully updated. If working from home, or an in home business is of interest, there is a lovely library/office on the first floor. Wonderful B & B potential offering 7 Bedrooms , 5+ Baths.

$429,900Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,833 Sqft
144 Pete Hendricks Rd, Cooperstown, NY 13326
House For Sale

Splendid 135-year-old Victorian Farm House that has been lovingly restored to its original splendor with all updated amenities. Plenty of room to entertain friends and family with 4 bedrooms/2 baths, dining room, family room, den, media room and more! Large kitchen features granite counters, breakfast bar, plenty of cabinet space and seamlessly blends into family room with fireplace. Spacious backyard offers a private patio with screened room and a shed. This incredible property is nestled in a wood clearing on 38 acres of wooded land just six short miles from Cooperstown's museums, Otsego Lake, Glimmerglass State Park & the Baseball Hall of Fame. This home has been well cared for and was previously used as a B&B. A must see!

1
2
version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >