27 Homes For Sale in Forestburgh, NY

Sort by:
$899,999Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,928 Sqft
4 Bradford Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

A private road leads to this property w/ lush gardens and water views. Custom home offers enough space for a large family or anyone looking to entertain. HW floors, original doors, windows, and spacious layout give a warm welcome. The light filled LR feat. wood stove shares the water views w/ the formal DR perfect for entertaining. Large kitchen is equipped w/ custom cabinetry, high-end stainless-steel appliances, Wolf stove, butcherblock island and wetbar. One of 2 master suites is on the 1st floor, complete w/ an en suite bathroom, large closet and built-in shelving. Upstairs, a large master BR w/ en suite bathroom, 2 addt'l BRs, a full bath and office. New generator protects against power outages and a basement and 2-car garage offer plenty of storage. Outside, a private pond is yours for fishing, kayaking or taking in the scenery from the bluestone patio. The natural beauty of this property sits adjacent to the Neversink Unique area--more than 7000 acres of nature preserve.

$997,500Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,076 Sqft
303 Tannery Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Escape total isolation at this private 127-acre retreat. A one of a kind opportunity to own a private natural 13-acre lake with a waterfall. The historic hunting lodge was built with family vacations in mind, with two massive stone fireplaces designed for entertaining large groups. Four spacious bedrooms include a ground-floor master suite. Each bedroom offers a unique view of the natural landscape. Other amenities include a screened billiard room with lake views, an attached two-car garage, and all furnishings are included in the sale. Will not last! Call today for a private tour.

$225,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,059 Sqft
7 Black Brook Drive, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Come home to this lovely 3 BR 2 bath Ranch home with new rocking chair porch. Check out the beautiful newly redone natural hardwood floors on main level. Curl up near the cozy wood stove in the living room and enjoy cooking in spacious kitchen with lots of nice oak cabinets and plenty of counter space. Sunny dining room with beautiful bay window overlooking deck and level back yard with new shed. Nice large room on lower level to create den, exercise room, library + workshop and laundry area on lower level. Endless possibility. House as many possibilities. Workshop was a 1 car garage at one time. Owner was in process of renovation and there are still some minor cosmetic things new owner can finish to make it their own. Sold as-is. Town has pool and summer recreation program.

$415,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,570 Sqft
273 Dill Road, Monticello, NY 12777
House For Sale

Elegant, stately and private describe this beautiful contemporary colonial. If you are looking for privacy, look no further this is your private sanctuary. Large airy rooms invite peace and tranquility in this fine country home. Love to cook and entertain, maybe thought about your own you tube cooking show this is the kitchen you have been dreaming about. Miles of counter space, stone & marble back splash, enough cabinets for all of your kitchen items and then some. The master suite is the cherry on top, it includes a huge bathroom and immense walk-in closet, There are three other bedrooms, & central bathrooms for family and friends. With the attached 2 car garage you never have to walk in the rain or snow. The basement has 9 ft ceiling and is partial finished. There is also an outside wood burning stove with 3 sheds 2 for wood and one is heated for all tools, The deck overlooks a well manicured back yard. The property is in close proximity to the motor club, Casino, Appoximately 15 min to the Performing Arts Center in Bethel.

$280,000Est. Payment
8.76 Acres
0 Plank Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
Lots Land For Sale

Large acreage building site located in one of the areas most desirable locations! The property backs up to Swinging Bridge Reservoir, with potential floating dock access to this beautiful lake. Enjoy fishing, boating, and recreation! The surrounding areas high-end homes and seclusion enhances this ideal getaway site.

$325,000Est. Payment
1 Bed | 1 Bath | 750 Sqft
124 Griffin Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

A stunning property on a rare find road in Forestburgh, NY. The bucolic road leading to Griffin House sets the ambience for the rest of your day or weekend. This one will not last!! Take a walk, all you hear are birds & see abundant wildlife meandering. The home offers a Scandinavian aesthetic with a warm, cozy comfortable feeling, comes completely furnished move in ready! High end appliances, laundry room, open kitchen, new Essleman septic, new oil tank, new water pump and filtration. Fantastic light coupled with woods...the most enchanted house of its kind on the current market. Love it as it is or live in it and build a new home and use it as your guest cottage. Just 90 mins from GWB. Two lots 0.34 ac & 2.35 ac = 2.69 acres. 10 minutes to the NJ Transit train station to NJ & NYC. Catskill Mountains offers Trout fishing on the Neversink river, hiking 6,500+ acres of state land in the Neversink Unique Area, Kayaking, rafting, mountain bike trails, golfing, Bethel Woods Performing Arts/Museum, Forestburgh Playhouse, Resort World Casino, Kartrite Resorts Waterpark, breweries, wineries, antique shops and great farmer markets.

Donna Geba

$45,000Est. Payment
5 Acres
Plank Road 5 Acres, Forestburgh, NY 12777
Lots Land For Sale

Located in Beautiful Forestburgh N.Y. close to Commuter Buses, Bethel Woods and the New Casino for entertainment This Lovely Lakefront Lot could be your Perfect dream Home Destination! Build the Home that you Personally Design with Custom Touches Throughout! Great Location with Privacy and Nature Abounding, Take Walks, Kayak, Canoe & Enjoy Great Fishing!

$339,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,392 Sqft
28 French Clearing Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Love knows no bounds. Every inch of this home has been improved with great attention to detail and you can feel it as soon as you enter. Brand New Roof, Storage shed, New upgraded electric and Panel, 4 Different Heating Zones, Totally renovated 3 season porch, Gorgeous refinished solid wood floors in living room. Generator for whole house. The list goes on. Come to the forest of Forestburgh! Walk across the stream that runs through your property on your little bridge, Hang out on your large back deck.

$304,900Est. Payment
5 Beds | 3 Baths | 3,323 Sqft
2847 State Route 42, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Escape the city to this large home on 1.03 acres. Boasting 5 bedrooms and 2 1/2 baths and a kitchen any chef would die for with oak cabinets, pantry, SS appliances, composite sinks, granite countertops with marble and glass backsplash with huge dining area, laundry room, office with butcher block desk and hot tub room. The primary suite offers privacy and is MASSIVE with sliders to private balcony and has it's own bathroom! All new life proof flooring on the first floor and most of second floor can stand up to kids and pets alike. House comes with a Austroflamm pellet stove. 2nd bedroom is enormous with french doors to separate entrance. 3 additional bedrooms to fill as well! Entertain on the 16x50 back deck or in the back yard around the fire pit after hanging in the above ground pool. Plenty of parking with a 2 car garage and driveway parking. Just a short drive to the train, 90 minutes to NYC.

$389,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,546 Sqft
111 Griffin Road, Forestburgh, NY 12729
House For Sale

Drive Up The Winding Road To This Incredible...Architectural Custom Design Home... Breath Taking Views From All Three Floors...Three Levels Of Living To Spread Out.. Plenty Of Rooms For Your Privacy..And Remote Office.. This Is What You Have Been Searching For...Soaring Ceiling In The Main Family Room...Open To The Kitchen.. Sliding Glass Doors Open From Every Living Space... Private Office On The First Floor With Stone Fireplace....Walk Up The Third Floor Staircase And Be Wowed!! A Magical Space With Skylights...And So Much Light!!! Perfect For Your Studio...GetAway...Or Playroom...Close To Port Jervis/Mattamoras/Otisville And Around The Corner From The Forestburgh Theater..Forestburgh General Store And Forage Pizza...

$275,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,169 Sqft
175 Dill Rd, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

If you have a secret longing to live in the country, come see this 2000+ square ft Raised ranch home which features 4 bedrooms, 2 full bath, Living room, dining rm, Full finished basement, Hardwood floors & carpet through out And 2 wood stoves. You will have comfort, privacy, and convenience, on 11+ acres. This home is centrally located direct and easy access to rte 17, Resort world casino, Water Park,Spa,And the performing Arts center in Bethel woods.

$209,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,256 Sqft
2335 State Route 42, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Renovated...Storybook Charm...Awaits You In Forestburgh... Refinished Hardwood Flooring..New Furnace...Electrical And Plumbing..This Home Is Move In Ready... Cozy Enclosed Front Porch...The Living Room Focal Point Is The Vintage Stone Fireplace With Insert...Restored Staircase.. A Floorplan With Plenty Of Room For Your Remote Office..Family And Getaway Areas... Two Brand New Bathrooms...Down The Road From The Forestburgh General Store and Forage Pizza...Plus Aournd The Corner From the Forestburgh Theater...And The Community Pool...

$850,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 4 Baths | 4,038 Sqft
1 Keg Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Turn key remodeled custom home equipped w/ HW beams, skylights & ambient lighting. LR w/ stone FP & kitchen complete w/ state of the art appliances complimented by maple cabinets, 6-burner stove, warming tray, wall ovens, 2 sinks, 2 dishwashers & built-in wine fridge. Full bar w/ built-in wine rack, formal DR, FR w/ wood stove, 2 home offices, laundry room, garage, finished basement, whole house generator, workshop, gun room w/ safe, central vac & A/C, alarm system, instant hot water heater & coat closet that goes from the basement to the 2nd level, can be converted to an elevator. Master BR w/ walk in closets & bath w/ spa shower, jacuzzi & sauna. There's an enclosed porch & large deck walking distance to a private beach. Located in Hartwood Club, a 6,800 acre private preserve w/ 4 lakes & trout stream, hiking trails, hunting land, clubhouse, tennis courts, shooting range & full crew & caretaker. All of this could be yours when you become a member of this nature lover's club.

$399,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,350 Sqft
20 Foster Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

Beautiful craftsmen-style cape cod home on 10 acres of land offering a gorgeous backyard with privacy. This home offers two bedrooms and one and half baths. The wrap around porch offers great entertaining space and views of the mature fruit trees on the property. The living room offers ample natural light from updated french doors and windows with warmth from the propane fireplace. The kitchen is fit with stainless steel appliances and views of the large backyard. The master bedroom is complete with a walk-in closet, jacuzzi tub, and new hardwood floors. Outdoor entertainment at its finest- complete with a hot tub, fire pit, cedar shed, gazebo and patio space! The three car garage has an additional finished bonus space! This is a must see private country homestead!

$459,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,195 Sqft
2773 State Route 42, Forestburgh, NY 12777
House For Sale

The unique details of this home are unmatched. Your own pond that you can walk outside and fish from whenever your heart desires. Newly upgraded kitchen and updated bath. Three car garage with lots of room, workshop, gym set up and lots of extra storage. This home has been cared for and upgraded while keeping its unique charm. Additional lot with active Air b n b also available for purchase.

$179,000Est. Payment
5.02 Acres
1261 Plank Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
Lots Land For Sale

Looking for a level wooded home site to place your new build? Look no further! Private 5 acre parcel situated on a beautiful scenic wooded homesite with lake rights, cabin and dock. Just 14 parcels surround this lake in the subdivision known as Wildwood Way. Currently being used as a seasonal fishing cabin. Already approved and electric service in place. Forestburgh is a fantastic location which yields rural privacy but still close enough to Monticello for all of your, shopping and area amenities. 15 minutes to Resorts World Catskills Casino & and Route 17 for your city commute. Don't let this one get away , one of the few waterfront lots left that has not been developed.

$689,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,888 Sqft
129 Griffin Road, Forestburgh, NY 12729
House For Sale

On a serene country road this tastefully renovated 1870 Farmhouse is surrounded by 12.65 acres of bucolic forest with river frontage on the Neversink River. The home has old world charm with original tin ceilings, hand hewn beams and wide plank floors. Upon entering the home, you will see it is bathed daily with natural light. 1st floor Kitchen, dining room, Living room, Den, office/bedroom with a sleeping loft, half bath and laundry room. 2nd floor tranquil Master bedroom with skylights, 3 additional good size bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Enclosed porch, large decks in ground pool and gardens makes this home perfect for year-round entertaining. Newly installed whole house water filtration system There is an original classic Black Smith barn, pool house, bird aviaries, 2 car garage, Iron gate and stockade fencing for privacy. Ancient trees, stone walls, rolling meadows makes this one of the perfect quintessential Farmhouses in the Town of Forestburgh with 100 Ft of River frontage on the Neversink River as per survey.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >