25 Homes For Sale in Milford, NY

Sort by:
$249,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,300 Sqft
1556 County Highway 35, Milford, NY 12116
House For Sale

Currently a working DAIRY FARM FOR SALE! Newer 2014: 3 bedroom 2 bath RANCH home on 14 acres is available as a turnkey dairy farm (animals and equipment are available for an additional cost) or bring your own animals and continue farming! Approxmiately 8 acres of pasture. The 2014 doublewide RANCH sits above overlooking the farm and the beautiful views of the valley with spectacular sunrises and sunsets viewed of your front porch or back deck with hot tub! The one level living has the master bedroom and bath on one side and the other 2 bedrooms and full bath on the other. The kitchen with center island and open dining room- leads out to the back deck with views of the hills. The entire house has natural lighting and livingroom has views of the valley! Property consist of: Dairy Barn with Milk house 30 x 60 quonset hut currently used for housing the heifers 18 x 20 Canvas Shed 24 x 96 Machine shop with 18 x 96 lean to 12 x 21 with 10 ft ceiling - Additional building that can be finished for a studio apartment for additional living quarters. Outdoor wood burning furnance.

$165,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,892 Sqft
3672 State Highway 28, Milford, NY 13807
Multi Family For Sale

Great opportunity to own a well maintained 3 family home in the village of Milford. This home sits nicely back from the road with mountain views from the back yard. Apartments have been tastefully updated. Apt 1 is a two bedroom with two nice sized bedrooms, updated kitchen and bath. Laundry in unit as well. Apt 2 is a one bedroom with large living room and fire place. This apartment also has a spacious updated eat-in kitchen and bath. Living room is open to the kitchen with a fireplace and private laundry in the apt. Apt 3 is a large 1 bedroom with an open floor plan and spacious living room with a fireplace. This also has a nice kitchen with dining area. There is plenty of off street parking, a two car detached garage and large back yard. This home would be a great owner occupied home or buy as an investment property. Minutes to Cooperstown and Interstate 88 for commuting.

$899,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,800 Sqft
2727 State Highway 28, Milford, NY 13834
House For Sale

MAGNIFICENT LUXURY RANCH HOME HAS THE PRIVATE SETTING YOU HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR. Over 93 ACRES of open and wooded land. Custom built in 2007 the Sprawling first floor offers ONE FLOOR LIVING with an OPEN CONCEPT DESIGN . Beautiful Cherry floors, Living Room and Dining Room open to a Master Chef Kitchen . Top of the Line Stainless Steel appliances, WOLF STOVE , Two Refrigerators (drawer refrigerator & freezer also) GRANITE Countertops, Custom Cherry cabinets and Breakfast Bar. RADIANT Heat with multi zones. Enjoy the MOUNTAIN VIEWS and VIEWS of GoodYear Lake while sitting by the front Fieldstone patio. Vaulted Ceiling L/R, DR. Gorgeous Custom made Fireplace with a sunken area that gives you the ambience for those winter nights relaxing by the fire. Generous Primary Suite with Private Side covered Porch, En-suite bath with double sinks, Tiled walk-in shower, separate large walk in closet. Two more bedrooms with En-suite baths. Family Room with French Doors, Large office with custom built-in bookcases, 1/2 bath off the main living room. Another charming sun filled room could be a second office, artist's studio, or fourth bedroom. Off the main living area, there is another Covered Back Deck with built in ceiling speakers. The speakers are also on the side porch and through out the house with separate controls. Two CENTRAL AIR units and a FULL HOUSE GENERATOR also included. Full Basement doubles the size of the house if you need a mancave or just extra space. Privacy abounds with the 900 ft. driveway, Garage space for 6 CARS .

$329,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,206 Sqft
126 Vito Molinari Road, Milford, NY 13807
House For Sale

Lake Front home! This lake house has water frontage on Goodyear Lake with 0.85 acres. There is a spacious front porch with BEAUTIFUL LAKE VIEWS. There are views from almost every room in the house! Living room has a cobblestone FIRE PLACE, WOOD FLOORS and a VAULTED CEILING. The dining room has room for large gatherings, directly off the kitchen but open to the living room. There are three bedrooms with a BALCONY overlooking the huge living room. Sit on the front PORCH and enjoy the view of the lake or sit by the camp fire. This home also has CENTRAL AIR for those those hot summer nights. Furnace is newer. Large yard and shed. Access to the lake has balcony, DECK LAKESIDE and a dock with a shed to store all your lake toys. This home could also be a weekly baseball rental with a RENTAL PERMIT in place. 15 Minutes to Oneonta, Cooperstown All Star Village and Cooperstown Dreams Park. This home was fully rented weekly in 2019.

$79,500Est. Payment
47.18 Acres
0 Upper Dutch Hill Rd, Milford, NY 13820
Lots Land For Sale

Looking for that perfect property close to Cooperstown? 47 acre parcel that has EVERYTHING you're looking for- beautiful views, open meadow and woods. The property has frontage on Upper and Lower Dutch Hill Rd a nice quiet, tree-lined country road, with easy access to Cooperstown culture, recreation and services- including the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Glimmerglass Opera, Cooperstown Dreams Park baseball camp, Bassett Hospital, Leatherstocking Golf Course and Otsego Lake and Oneonta with its shopping, colleges and services. The land features gentle slopes, the perfect mix of open land and woods for hiking and hunting. Great for building your dream home, establishing a farm, recreational use or investment. Recent survey.

$18,000Est. Payment
0.12 Acres
0 Lake Shore Dr N, Milford, NY 12116
Lots Land For Sale

Goodyear Lake building lot for sale! Your chance to own in a Lake Community, build when you're ready. Call today to reserve your piece of paradise. Lake Rights!

$150,000Est. Payment
26.47 Acres
4237 State Highway 28, Milford, NY 13807
Lots Land For Sale

This may be the perfect piece of land for you. Located on Rt 28 in the Town of Hartwick, near Clintonville Road, just 1.5 miles from Dreams Park, this property is 26.45 acres of mostly wooded land, slightly sloped, 317' road frontage, Easterly views, includes a 0.92 acre building lot, Milford Schools. Convenient to Cooperstown, Oneonta, I-88. Offered Exclusively by ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY

$239,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,400 Sqft
2888 State Highway 28, Milford, NY 13834
House For Sale

River front home with business opportunities! This would be a great spot for a year round home, weekly rental or open up a full service store for all activities on the river and Goodyear lake. This well maintained home has a great rustic feel with some knotty pine, some original interior log siding and vaulted ceilings with an open floor plan. There are three bedrooms and a large bathroom with laundry on the first floor. Kitchen and living room are open to the dining room with French doors leading to a wrap around deck overlooking the docks and river with beautiful mountain views. Utilize the Basement to its full potential! You can access the basement from inside or riverside. Live upstairs and open a business serving the many boaters, kayakers and fisherman who frequent the Susquehanna river and Goodyear lake. This was the only place to gas up your boat and the only bait shop on the river offering live bait to many fisherman. The gas tank is gone now, but the concrete platform is still there with its own electric. The plumbing and heating for the bait tanks that were in the basement are still there. There are also 2 spots to set up campers with electric and water. The docks are in place for your private use and plenty of spots for boats to pull up if you were looking to start a business. This home is located near a Kayak & Canoe rental shop bringing lots of recreation to the river and lake. Goodyear Lake is busy with all sorts of water craft and fisherman. What a great opportunity to live and work on the water! 15 minutes to Cooperstown and Oneonta.

$219,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,500 Sqft
55 S Main Street, Milford, NY 13807
Multi Family For Sale

BRAND NEW ROOF plus exterior upgrades! GRAND VICTORIAN VILLAGE HOME offering PREMIER LOCATION and SOLID HISTORY as a PRIME THREE UNIT, SIX BEDROOM YEAR ROUND RENTAL AND PROVEN HISTORY AS SUMMER BASEBALL RENTAL property. SOLID GOLD RENTAL HISTORY includes off-season rentals to mid May, and then 13 weeks of baseball family rents. This is ONE OF THREE owner properties: buy one, PACKAGE WITH NEXT DOOR, or buy all three! RARE HOTEL/MOTEL CERTIFICATION means owner has complied with all Department of Health and County Regulations for OCCUPANCY LEVEL OF 15 PERSONS. This is a lovely home with EXCELLENT CURB APPEAL, a massive, HANDSOME FRONT PORCH, a 40'x50' PARKING LOT, on-premises, attached COIN OP LAUNDRYy, and a two story, TWO CAR BARN with concrete floor for storage. This home is FULLY FURNISHED and is TURN-KEY READY to go as a SOLID MONEY MAKER.

$149,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,222 Sqft
2872 State Highway 28, Milford, NY 13834
Multi Family For Sale

Price Reduced! Waterfront! This INVESTMENT property is on the Susquehanna River for enjoying kayaking, canoeing, relaxing and a Great Location in between both Cooperstown Dreams Park and Cooperstown All Star Village. Also a good investment for renting all year long or keeping an apartment for yourself. Let the rental income pay your mortgage. Four separate one bedroom apartments, Four baths. All separate utilities. The upstairs apartment is much larger and has a den/office area. Very large Living Room, updated bathroom. Newer Roof (6 yrs) Septic pumped every two years. Tenants pay utilities. There is an old barn on property, condition unknown. Waterfront property owned by the same Seller since 1978. Now is your opportunity to have an investment property.

$149,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,479 Sqft
158 Main St N, Milford, NY 13807
House For Sale

3 Bedroom 2 Bath home with 1479 sq.ft. Village water. Newer Roof. Central Air. Just 3 miles south of the Cooperstown Baseball Dream Park. Being sold Furnished. This property being used as a Dream Park rental. Being only 3 miles south of the park, was a great location. It rented 10-12 weeks every summer. Last rented for $1400 per week.

$180,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 6 Baths | 3,664 Sqft
59 S Main Street, Milford, NY 13807
Multi Family For Sale

Lovely two story VILLAGE VICTORIAN home has both YEAR ROUND RENTAL HISTORY AND SOLID BASEBALL/FAMILY RENTAL HISTORY plus OFF-SEASON RENTS as well. NEW EXTERIOR PAINT! UNIQUE GROUP STYLE MAIN APARTMENT features 1st and 2nd floors with FOUR BEDROOMS with EN SUITE FULL BATHS OFF EACH BEDROOM (Two up/two down). Common area first floor features EXTRA LARGE FAMILY STYLE KITCHEN flowing to OVERSIZED DINING ROOM, gameroom/FAMILY ROOM, and GENEROUS LIVING ROOM. Common LAUNDRY ROOM ON FIRST FLOORfloor also includes handy 1/2 bath for owners/contractor use. Rear separate SECOND FLOOR APARTMENT features CATHEDRAL CEILING in living room/kitchen, LARGE BEDROOM with closet, and full bath. This home adjoins 2nd of three of owner's PRIME VILLAGE BASEBALL FAMILY RENTALS, all with SOLID RENTAL HISTORY, all just EIGHT MINUTES TO BASEBALL PARK. BUY ONE, BOTH, or PACKAGE all three. This property has a UNIQUE 24'X49' BUILDING IN REAR that was EARLY CENTURY SHOPS/BARN/STORAGE, with a long-standing but JUST EXPIRED PERMIT for a spacious two story, ONE BEDROOM APARTMENT... let your imagination go. SIDE YARD is USED IN COMMON during baseball season WITH ADJONING HOME belonging to SAME OWNER (and ALSO FOR SALE). The BACK LOT includes width for TWO PARKING SPACES at southwest corner of lot off unimproved rear building. (Split rail fence of driveway and rear parking lot are not included- with exception of space for two cars in lot). Balance of lot and parking belong to 55 South Main Street. PURCHASED AS PACKAGE, the use of BOTH DRIVEWAYS and COMMON LAWN AREAS is advantageous. All properties have RARE COMPLIANCE AS HOTEL/MOTEL DESIGNATION standing on their own- meaning New York State Dept of Health and OTSEGO COUNTY CODES have been met/maintained to QUALIFY FOR FIFTEEN PERSON OCCUPANCY per building). This home is FULLY FURNISHED and is TURN-KEY READY! Excellent opportunity!

$74,900Est. Payment
30.43 Acres
618 Konchar Road, Milford, NY 13807
Lots Land For Sale

What has 30.43 acres, 2000' of road frontage on Konchar Road, a hemlock forest and an adorable 12x26 Little House On The Prarie two room off the grid cabin? ... your new hunting camp, that's what! Located in Historic Milford NY, this property has so much character it could be the star of it's own realty show! With strategically placed tree stands, logging trails (respectively and lightly timbered in 2018) + hiking and ATV trails, you can entertain yourself on this property for days on end. The camp is wired for electricity or generator + the cabin is already prepped for a wood fired stove. This is the perfect inexpensive get-a-way retreat. Not just for hunting, considering the Boy Scout Lake is one mile south of this property where you can enjoy fishing, canoeing and kayaking. How about quietly pontificating or starting to write that book you've been living in your imagination? There are many attractions to explore in Milford NY and the surrounding areas. Ommegang and Old Slugger Breweries, Bear Pond Winery, Charlotte Valley Rail Road (which is a heritage railway offering rides between Milford and Cooperstown from June to September), Crumhorn Lake, Crumhorn Mountain, Crumhorn Mountain Wildlife Management Area, Good Year Lake and Saddlebag Lake to name a few. Come for the beauty of the land, it's good to be the King and Master of your own Domain, own the land of which they ain't making anymore! And stay for the welcoming Town of Milford, maybe one day you will decide to build a permanent residence on this lovely parcel of paradise. Whatever your decision, Milford Welcomes You.

$185,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,106 Sqft
88 W Main Street, Milford, NY 13807
Multi Family For Sale

Excellent opportunity to own this CLASSIC VILLAGE HOME with YEAR ROUND RENTAL HISTORY AND SOLID BASEBALL with off-season RENTAL HISTORY! This home is ONE OF THREE village BASEBALL FAMILY RENTAL HOMES just FIVE MINUTES FROM BASEBALL PARK / camp. BRAND NEW CARPET throughout all BEDROOMS except one! Buy one, two, or PACKAGE all THREE TOGETHER. All 3 properties have earned the designation of HOTEL/MOTEL STATUS from Department of Health and Otsego County Code office, which ALLOWS occupancy level of FIFTEEN PERSONS. Home offers HANDSOME FRONT PORCH, SPACIOUS BACKYARD for recreation/play, and a COIN OPERATED LAUNDRY. This home is FULLY FURNISHED and is TURN KEY READY!

$125,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,538 Sqft
5993 State Highway 7, Milford, NY 13820
House For Sale

Nice home sitting on just over 1 acre with deck, front porch, fireplace and fenced in yard. First floor has a nice size bedroom, laundry room with eat in kitchen, dining room/bar area and bright living room with fireplace. Upstairs there are three bedrooms with family room. The master bedroom has 1/2 bath with balcony over looking the back yard with sliding glass doors. Plenty of room for everyone! From the top of the property are beautiful views, great place for star gazing and camp fire. Located on a bus route, close to shopping, restaurants and easy access to Interstate 88. Give a call today for your private showing.

$549,000Est. Payment
-- Beds | 3 Baths | 2,144 Sqft
335 Jumps Road, Milford, NY 13820
House For Sale

Erected in the mid 1800s and returned to glory in 2008, this totally renovated farmhouse on 151 Acres will take your breath away! From the exposed custom milled beams in the spacious kitchen dining room combo to the Cleft Stone Hearth of the living room fireplace, this dwelling comes alive with quality and charm. There are so many amazing aspects to this home that you must see it to appreciate it. Stainless appliances with custom track lighting adorn the kitchen. Beautiful tumble stoned tile in the first-floor bath with jacuzzi tub + walk in shower and mountain views is the ultimate in relaxation. The list of features goes on like a ticker tape! The floor plan leads you through the house as if you are floating on a cloud. The floors are hardwood throughout + the second floor has gorgeous original wide plank flooring in remembrance of this homes humble beginnings. High hat lighting throughout creates an ambient lighting experience worthy of the Broadway Stage. The natural light from Mother Nature is brought into every room through top of the line replacement windows allowing enjoyment of the property from inside your new home at every turn. And isnt that what we all come to the country for? Five bedrooms + 2.5 baths is enough space for family, friends and hospitable adventures. Heres a thought, when the Baseball Hall of Fame returns, how about renting it out for the season when venturing on vacation yourself? So close to Cooperstown with so much to explore! This property has it all from location to renovation perfection. The electric, plumbing, heating system & windows have all been replaced. You could refer to this house as The New Old House! Radiant heat on the first floor and basement + a Unico System on the second floor with the opportunity to use dual fuel! There is an outdoor woodburning furnace for either a back-up or primary heating source, your choice. Talk about economic efficiency. Insulated 6 walls with energy shield wrapped around

$395,000Est. Payment
10 Acres
114 N Main Street, Milford, NY 13807
Lots Land For Sale

Attention developers and investors! Featuring more than 10 acres of flat, developable land, this is the ideal property for you! Leverage the visibility that this parcel will offer. Positioned nicely between the bustling settlements of Oneonta and Cooperstown on a major state highway, your business will see more than 7,000 cars per day. Located just a short drive from Central New York's bustling baseball venues, scenic lakes, and craft breweries, this property is flanked with businesses that attract travelers year-round. Offering a commercial building with more than 13,000 climate-controlled square feet, bathrooms, office space, an RV dump station, three silos, as well as village water and a private well, you will experience maximum flexibility. Currently used as a heated storage facility, possibilities abound. It would be easy to expand the storage capacity in the current structure, or perhaps go in an entirely different direction. Perhaps an RV park? Baseball fields? Hotel? The possibilities are endless!

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >