90 Homes For Sale in Montauk, NY

Sort by:
$409,999Est. Payment
1 Bed | 1 Bath | 448 Sqft
727 Old Montauk Hwy #401 401, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Lower level corner unit located high on the hilltop in the "Ocean East" Building offers a double exposure and beautiful views to the Atlantic Ocean and pool below. Spectacular ocean views and resort amenities are available on this five acre property. Walk to private ocean beach and Montauk Village. Highly successful on-site professional rental program. Fully renovated Studio "A" rated apartment, full bath, spacious 448 ft2 with kitchen. Rare opportunity! Dune-OBM

$4,900,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,000 Sqft
248 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

This beautifully renovated waterfront home has a rarely found, wide, sandy beach on Lake Montauk. Tucked off the road, the sprawling shy acre property has a fully renovated 3,000 sq ft home with chic living spaces throughout. The main living areas are open and airy with walls of glass overlooking the water. The kitchen has been updated with stainless steel appliances, breakfast area, center island, bar area with wine fridge, ice maker and storage, as well as formal dining area, all of which overlook the Lake. The living room has double height ceilings, stone fireplace, and folding glass doors that open to a gorgeous deck perfect for outdoor dining and lounging on the waterside. The south side of the homes interior features the luxe master suite with its own private bath, an office, walk-in closet, and access to the outdoor deck. Two guest bedrooms and a full bathroom are also found on this side of the home. Down the hall, there is a laundry closet, a full bathroom, and a private guest bedroom with it's own access outdoors. The 1,500 sq ft basement has been finished with a spacious living area and custom built bar. The exterior has been perfectly landscaped and features an outdoor shower, hot tub, and plenty of lounge areas.

$1,800,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,800 Sqft
51 Monroe Dr, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Located in Montauk's Hither Hills with deeded ocean beach rights, this upside down beach house has three bedrooms and two bathrooms set on a corner lot. The first floor features two guest bedrooms, a bathroom, and a laundry room. Upstairs you will find an airy kitchen with open living and dining room along with the master bed and bath complemented by a spacious deck perfect for entertaining.

$5,350,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,528 Sqft
272 Old Montauk Highway #Salt Sea 3 Salt Sea 3, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Enjoy ownership of an exclusive lifestyle on the most desirable 1,000' stretch of pristine, private beach coupled with the elegance and amenities of the Hamptons' only world-class, full-service, year-round resort. Salt Sea 3 is a spectacular three bedroom, three and one-half bath home with a total of 2,528+/- sq. ft. (1,780+/- indoors and 748+/- outdoors), presenting unobstructed ocean views from nearly all rooms. The airy, light-filled living areas feature vaulted ceilings and clerestory windows flooding the space with natural light. Glass doors open wide to an oceanfront terrace showcasing dramatic panoramas of sand, sea and sky. Ideal for entertaining, the living area with a gas fireplace and comfortable seating flows seamlessly to the well-equipped kitchen providing counter seating, and high end stainless steel appliances by Viking and Sub-Zero. Downstairs the spacious master suite has glass doors to a terrace with a hot tub and ocean views, and features a walk-in closet and luxurious bath with double vanity, frameless glass-enclosed shower with rain head and a freestanding soaking tub. A second beautifully appointed bedroom suite, also with glass doors to the terrace, an additional guest bedroom suite and laundry room complete this level. The home comes with private parking, a custom dedicated owners' beach cabana and access to all the amenities of the neighboring five-diamond Gurney's Resort, including a personal concierge and maintenance services. Additionally, the owner will have enjoy convenient access to Gurney's five unique dining and social venues, the Beach Club and world-famous luxury Seawater Spa.

$5,500,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 7 Baths | 5,472 Sqft
16 Fir Lane, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Rarely do properties like this masterfully built Montauk gem come on the market. The expansive six-bedroom home is sited on 1.6 elevated acres with sweeping ocean views from almost every room. Enter to a large foyer which opens to the dining room with stone fireplace and the Atlantic Ocean as a breathtaking backdrop. The eat-in gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream and features Dacor range with warming drawer, plus additional wall ovens. There are four Fisher& Paykel dishwasher drawers and a Sub-Zero refrigerator. The large living room is perfect for entertaining and features a second stone floor to ceiling fireplace. The first level is completed by an en-suite bedroom and bath, as well as a powder room. The second level boasts three en-suite bedrooms and two guest rooms which share a bath. The well-sized master bedroom suite enjoys a panoramic ocean view and a private balcony from which to enjoy it. There is also an upstairs laundry room. The finished lower level includes a full bath and additional living space for recreation or study. Your guests will swoon over the large, plush home theater with projector and stadium seating. The home's beautiful private property features extensive landscaping and gardens, a gunite pool and spa, and a pool house with full interior bath, kitchenette, and outdoor shower. There is also an outdoor kitchen. Gurney's Spa is just down the block making it easy to enjoy its many luxury amenities. This exceptional home in Montauk's sought-after Hither Woods area has been priced to sell and won't last long.

$5,400,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,600 Sqft
12 And 18 Tara Road, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Seize the opportunity to own two single and separate parcels in one of Montauk's most coveted locations, with beautiful views of the Atlantic from each. Privately tucked away atop a hill, this combined offering features a 1.1 acre vacant parcel on the south, with a very spacious building envelope, suitable for an approximately 5,000 sq ft residence with pool. With an elevation of roughly 100 feet above sea level, beautiful ocean views can be captured from the ground level. Just behind this lot, there is another 0.90 acre property featuring a four bedroom, three bath residence with deeded ocean access. The upside-down layout has an upper level with oceanviews throughout. The living room has vaulted, beamed ceilings, a fireplace, and oversized windows and sliders that open to a wraparound deck. The light and airy living room is open to the eat-in kitchen and dining area. On this level you will also find the master suite with full bathroom and deck access. The entry level of the home, has three guest bedrooms, two full baths, a sitting room with sliders to a wraparound deck, and an office space with seating area. A workspace and two-car carage provide the perfect place for storage. This property is complete with a freeform, vanishing edge, heated gunite pool, and a generator. This shy acre also has plenty of options. Use this home as-is, or start anew and build nearly 5,000 sq ft here as well. Included on this listing are renderings and plans for two new 5,000-/+ sq ft homes, providing a conceptual design for creating your dream compound in Montauk. There is also drone footage showing the vastness of the properties, and height footage to show the oceanviews from a proposed new buildout. If the properties were to be merged by the purchaser, a nearly 8,400 sq ft home with pool could be created as well.

$6,950,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,500 Sqft
18 & 22 Maple Street, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Seize the opportunity to own two adjacent parcels totaling nearly 2 acres with incredible, open ocean views in Montauk. Being offered together for sale, 18 Maple Street (Lot 1) features a gorgeously renovated modern ranch with four plus bedrooms, four full bathrooms, and sleek light-filled living areas throughout. This shy 1 acre property has plenty of room for a new 5,000 sq ft residence with pool. 22 Maple Street (Lot 2) is a vacant shy 1 acre parcel with a generous building envelope as well, allowing for an approximately 4,900 sq ft home with pool. Proposed renderings featured on this listing show a modern 5,000 sq ft beach house, with pool overlooking the water, extensive outdoor living areas, and garage on 18 Maple Street (Lot 1). There are also renderings for a proposed new home on 22 Maple Street (Lot 2) which has 3,900 sq ft of living space, pool, and garage Create a one-of-a-kind compound in this private, elevated location, situated among multi-million dollar homes.

$7,900,000Est. Payment
7 Beds | 6 Baths | 4,632 Sqft
36 And 40 Ditch Plains Road, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Two separate properties being sold together in Ditch Plains with close proximity to the ocean shore. Each of these properties has their own gated entry and are tucked back off the road, yet a short block to Ditch Plains Beach. The main house has been immaculately maintained by the current and only owners. The interior offers an open floorplan. The first floor features a kitchen with center island, stainless steel appliances, walk-in pantry/laundry room, dining area, spacious light-filled living room with wood burning fireplace, and an enclosed sunroom with built-in seating and fireplace that opens to the deck and pool area. The first level also hosts two bedrooms that share a full bathroom, and a powder room to service the main living areas. Upstairs, the master bedroom has soaring vaulted ceilings, a luxe spa-like bathroom with oversized shower, dual sinks, Jacuzzi tub, private deck with outdoor shower overlooking the pool and grounds, and plenty of closet space. This level also has two guest bedrooms that share a full bathroom as well as an extra room perfect for use as an office or gym area. The basement is unfinished, but offers plenty of room for storage and/or the potential to add extra finished spaces. The manicured grounds have plenty of outdoor decking to enjoy during the warmer months, along with a heated gunite pool with swimming current program, and a second outdoor shower. Just to the south of the main house, the picture-perfect cottage provides another great beachside retreat. Sitting on just under a half acre, this home has its own private gated entry as well. Colorful and chic, the two bedroom, two bathroom cottage has 1,200 sq ft of spacious open living areas with high ceilings, and a kitchen with custom built-in seating. There is also a loft space that is great for overflow or storage. Complete with its own laundry, outdoor shower, and solar panels. This is a very rare opportunity to own a a turn key compound in sought-after Ditch Plains moments to

$3,899,999Est. Payment
7 Beds | 8 Baths | 4,011 Sqft
80 Essex Street, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Montauk original Carl Fisher home has gone through a custom renovation to be completed by April 2021. Rare to the market, featuring 7 bedrooms with all en-suite bathrooms featuring marble baths, glass shower doors and custom hardware. Beautiful chef's kitchen with white Shaker style cabinets, quartz counters, and 36-inch farm sink. Stainless steel Thor professional grade appliances and gas range. All new electric complete with LED lighting throughout the house. Energy efficient geothermal heating/cooling system with 4 zones which can save up to 50% compared to traditional oil or electric systems.The living room features a large open space with wood beams in the ceiling and electric fireplace. Enjoy a sunroom for added space off the living area. The home features 4-inch white oak floors, Yale keyless entry on all doors for keyless entry and 2 Nest doorbells, all interior roofs have been spray foamed and exterior roof features Rfoam board. There is a 2-car garage, Architectural shingles with Cedar impression siding, Azek trim, bluestone pavers to be added, sod, bluestone driveway and 16x32 gunite pool and security cameras will be completed this spring. This beautiful home backs up to a nature preserve for added privacy. Located within 6 minutes to the village and 8 minutes to the Atlantic Ocean beach. Enjoy restaurants, shops and outdoor entertainment close to home.

$2,195,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,300 Sqft
133 Monroe Dr, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Coveted Hither Hills location just one block from the Atlantic Ocean with exclusive deeded beach rights. This bright and sunny 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath contemporary "upside down" beach retreat greets with soaring cathedral ceilings, skylights and generously appointed living spaces. There are 4 graciously sized bedrooms on the first floor, with high ceilings and updated bathrooms. The spacious ensuite master is complete with an adjoining sitting room with two rooms having sliding glass doors that reveal a lovely western-facing deck. The upper floor is the heart of the home and an entertainer's delight. The great room boasts soaring ceilings bedecked with skylights, endless windows and sliding glass doors which beckon onto an enormous full length deck with southern exposure. The wonderfully sun-filled open-concept kitchen, dining and living area is replete with a cozy wood-burning fireplace. The finished windowed lower level has a gym, office/den, full modern bathroom, laundry and utility area. Plenty of room and activities at your beck and call just outside the front door: play time on the front lawn, refresh time in the hot tub after a fun day at the beach, and chill time with cocktails or s'mores around the fire pit. Moments away from downtown Montauk and one of the most beautiful beaches in the world. Montauk Beach Property Owners Association member.

$1,995,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,500 Sqft
11 Reuter Place, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Newly listed immaculate three + bedroom, two bath beach house in ever popular Ditch Plains. Open living room, kitchen, and dining area. Two common areas, new decking and solar panels, located on a quiet cul-de-sac, and close to the ocean. Great rental potential.

$2,350,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 850 Sqft
15 Jackson Road, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

This home is located at 15 Jackson Road Montauk, NY 11954 US and has been listed on Homes.com since 17 February 2021 and is currently priced at $2,350,000, approximately $2765 per square foot. This property was built in 1967. 15 Jackson Road is within the school district(s) Montauk Union Free School District and East Hampton Union Free School District with nearby schools including Montauk School and East Hampton High School. Similar properties nearby are <a href="/property/15-jackson-rd-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021962919/">15 Jackson Rd</a>, <a href="/property/20-foxboro-rd-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021957834/">20 Foxboro Rd</a>, <a href="/property/34-foxboro-rd-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021957852/">34 Foxboro Rd</a>, <a href="/property/324-e-lake-dr-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021962848/">324 E Lake Dr</a>, <a href="/property/144-essex-st-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021959278/">144 Essex St</a>, <a href="/property/133-monroe-dr-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021960921/">133 Monroe Dr</a>, <a href="/property/16-second-house-rd-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021959044/">16 Second House Rd</a>, <a href="/property/33-grant-dr-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021962630/">33 Grant Dr</a>, <a href="/property/11-reuter-pl-montauk-ny-11954/id-400021959620/">11 Reuter Pl</a>, and <a href="/property/montauk-ny-11954/id-400021962756/">23 Mckinley Rd</a>.

$695,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | -- Sqft
100 Deforest Road Unit 404, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Your beach house awaits here at Montauk Shores! A gated waterfront community at Ditch Plains Beach with endless ocean views! Featuring 2 heated pools, a clubhouse, playground, and a basketball court. Enjoy the coastal views at any of the three community decks overlooking the ocean. Very low monthly common fee and taxes! Own this special place at one of the most desired surf spots on the east end!

$825,000Est. Payment
1 Bed | 1 Bath | 723 Sqft
20 Surfside Avenue #80b 80b, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

Fully renovated one bedroom, one bath with a new kitchen Oceanfront East-Ocean View Duplex Apartment on spacious oceanfront property with private sundeck. Highly successful professionally operated rental program. Dune/OBM

$689,999Est. Payment
1 Bed | 1 Bath | 500 Sqft
779 Old Montauk Highway #12 12, Montauk, NY 11954
House For Sale

This upper level unit located on the hillside offers beautiful views to the Atlantic Ocean. Spectacular ocean views and resort amenities are available on this multi acre property. Walk to private ocean beach and Montauk Village. Highly successful on-site professional rental program. Spacious Apartment with cathedral ceilings, split A/C-Heat, kitchen and sun deck. You will keep this unit in your family for generations to enjoy for years to come.

$3,000,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,500 Sqft
19 Gilbert Path, Amagansett, NY 11954
House For Sale

OVER A FULL ACRE OF LAND! The Is The Perfect Home For A Charming Getaway From The World. It Is Also Perfect To Build On, Or Build Out As An Investment Property Or Your Dream Home Vision.

$1,100,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 2 Baths | -- Sqft
407 W Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954
Multi Family For Sale

This two family home is perfect as an investment and is available for sale with tenants in place. Each apartment has 3 bedrooms with newly renovated baths and kitchens. Efficient oil hot water heat, convenient to harbor shops, restaurants, fishing and ferries. Reasonable taxes. Call to view.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >