207 Homes For Sale in Monticello, NY

Sort by:
$200,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,122 Sqft
6 Thompson Place, Smallwood, NY 12701
House For Sale

Spacious and charming 2 bedroom cottage in Smallwood lake community is move in ready. Home offers an open plan living/dining room with original stone fireplace, vaulted ceilings, huge master with private 1/2 bath, adorable country kitchen, and a heated 4 season enclosed porch. Many recent upgrades include kitchen, baths, floors, deck, septic, hot water heater, and whole house generator. Originally a small 1940's cabin, this is now a modern rustic cottage with twice the space due to a 2014 addition. Petite finished loft space is great for additional storage or could be used for spillover sleeping quarters. Fireplace has efficient and new wood burning insert to cozy up those chilly winter nights. Interior has pine tongue and groove ceilings and engineered wood floors which add a warm and inviting feel. Washer/dryer on main level is a plus. Great outdoor entertainment spaces with wraparound deck and firepit. A large yard, shed for storage and plenty of parking are all huge bonuses. Smallwood amenities include beach, dock, clubhouse, sports courts and club with a heated pool for a nominal fee (pictured in listing photos).

$114,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 952 Sqft
151 Park Avenue, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

Village Ranch! This nice Ranch home features lovely hardwood floors throughout the home, a bright and sunny living room, eat-in kitchen with a pantry and mud room, three bedrooms and a full bath. There is a level, fenced back yard, paved driveway and seamless gutters. A good deal. Don't miss out, call today.

$399,000Est. Payment
1 Acre
79 State Route 17b, Monticello, NY 12701
Lots Land For Sale

This multi-use property is located on a prime corner with high traffic numbers and visibility on State Rt 17B now known as Woodstock Way and West Broadway in Monticello NY. One of the busiest intersections in Sullivan County with 250 feet of road frontage from Monticello Raceway and right off Exit 104, State Hwy 17 (future I-86)-main exit for the Bethel Woods Center for Performing Arts. The one acre property is zoned B1 for retail & commercial usage. Currently for sale with turn-key Automotive Repair Shop business and building. Solid building with 3 bays, office, parking for over 40 vehicles, storage, 20 ton truck lift, hydraulic press, tools and much more.

$429,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 4,644 Sqft
74 Leonard Road, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

Endless Opportunity! Artistically designed, this 5+ acre renovated property consists of a 1940 s 3BR/1/Bath farm house and a state-of-the-art recording sound studio, known as Yonderbarn. Reconstructed in 2012 by an Oscar, Grammy, and Golden Globe winner, used for music, film, broadcasting, photography, or art studio also consists of a BR, full bath, kitchen and maple floors throughout. The barn has its own septic, central ac/heat, and generator run by propane. The house hosts a rocking chair porch, sunroom, eat-in kitchen, HW floors, two heat pumps with oil/hot water baseboard back up with the property dotted with apple trees, stone walls and detached garage. Versatile usage for private living/workspace and great opportunity for rental/investment business. Just 90 miles to NYC! The best of two worlds!

$239,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,821 Sqft
47 Park Avenue, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

This home is located at 47 Park Avenue Monticello, NY 12701 US and has been listed on Homes.com since 2 February 2021 and is currently priced at $239,000, approximately $131 per square foot. This property was built in 1940. 47 Park Avenue is within the school district(s) Monticello Central School District with nearby schools including Kenneth L Rutherford Elementary School, Robert J Kaiser Middle School, and Monticello High School. Similar properties nearby are <a href="/property/47-park-ave-monticello-ny-12701/id-400022215027/">47 Park Ave</a>, <a href="/property/156-joyland-rd-monticello-ny-12701/id-400022212029/">156 Joyland Rd</a>, 10 Hamilton Ave, <a href="/property/monticello-ny-12701/id-400022212421/">25 Burton Ave</a>, 128 E Broadway, <a href="/property/24-sunset-dr-monticello-ny-12701/id-400022212133/">24 Sunset Dr</a>, <a href="/property/153-rose-valley-rd-monticello-ny-12701/id-400022205598/">153 Rose Valley Rd</a>, 430 Broadway, 368 E Broadway, and <a href="/property/58-lakeview-dr-kiamesha-lake-ny-12751/id-400022211689/">58 Lakeview Dr</a>.

$3,000,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 6 Baths | 16,476 Sqft
399 Gregory Road, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

This Amazing property on almost 20 acres can be a gem for the ones who love to live among nature and yet an easy trip to NYC. Come and Surround yourself in pure serenity with this once in a lifetime property!! This vast, spacious and well -designed HOME has 16,476 sf of space that can accommodate large party for entertainment, a compound, a beautiful oasis or anything your heart desires. This Fantastic Property consists of three sections; Main living quarters, Huge banquet room that can seat 200+ guests, an Olympic size salt water indoor pool, DJ Booth , Recreation room with a 2 lane Bowling Alley, Pool Table, Exercise Room and a Recording Studio. The main house has an open floor plan with a granite countertops kitchen, dining room, six bedrooms, & 6+ baths. The Lower Downstairs has two bedrooms, living room, bar and a full bath. You get it ALL 16,476 Square Feet Home on Beautiful 20+/- acres, Privacy, Serenity and a 5+ car garage. A Nature Lover Delight!! With beautiful mature trees, open level fields, wild flowers, chirping birds, and zillions of stars to gaze upon. The Main house was built 1989 featuring three bedrooms on first floor with two baths, an additional two bedrooms with full bath, a living area and its own bar. The Master suite with Master Bath is on the upper floor with walk in closets. The center of the house was built in 2003 with a very large banquet room that can seat 200+guests w/ its own bath and a commercial kitchen that includes a hand made and special designed brick pizza oven. There are two indoor pools. A smaller pool (currently off for the season) and a large heated salt water Olympic size pool with two full baths and a custom bar. The pool area has a filtration system and dehumidifier, a loft that can accommodate an additional 200+ guests. The recreation room has a pool table, ping pong table, exercise room and two lane bowling alley. The recording studio with a sound proof room is set to the side of the house. The outside deck can also accommodate more than 150 additional guests. The house has a build in surround sound and an intercom system. The private office has its own entry. There is also a 5 car garage and a separate garage (not shown) that can house an RV, boat or additional cars. There is a playhouse with a swing set and plenty of open area for the avid gardener. The whole property is fenced in with an alarm and security system. The back of the house is level and is large enough for few holes of golf, tennis court, or any type of outdoor recreation. The setting is very quiet with limited traffic and the close to the Swinging Bridge Lake for motorboating and other water activity. Trex Deck and railing-

$120,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,000 Sqft
12 Cedar Park 11, Monticello, NY 12701
Condominium For Sale

3 acre condo community is waiting for you to call it home! Close to town and all of the amenities, this property is a must see and will not last! This condo boasts of 2 spacious bedrooms with the master that has a screened in balcony overlooking a shared common area. A extra office nook and an open floor plan with oversized foyer. Laundry is on the main floor and there is an abundance of closet space. Close to Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, bus and shopping.

$188,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,034 Sqft
10 Varnell Road, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

2 bedrooms upstairs and 1, possibly 2, bedrooms on the first level. 1 full bathroom on each level. YOU WILL be amazed at the views! The double decker deck runs the full length of the house! Open concept with the kitchen, dining room, and living room one big open space. A huge family room is also a bonus on the first level. The pictures were taken before the current tenant moved in. This home can be seen on Sundays only at this time.

$115,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,680 Sqft
95 Cambrige Circle, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

Huge beautiful house in the middle of the Catskills. Short drive to Lakes , Akva Park, Casino, Shopping Malls. Completely renovated. All appliances stay includes TV & all furniture. Close to Monticello.

$1,500,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 6 Baths | 3,924 Sqft
935 Starlight Road, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

Gated, paved driveway takes you to a majestic executive home on 5.26 acres of seclusion and privacy overlooking two ponds and the nine mile Swinging Bridge motor boat Lake. No expense was spared while this home was crafted. Master craftsmanship woodwork throughout, tile and stone, gorgeous home with high-end appliances, full size sauna, 2 fireplaces are just some of the amenities. This lovely home is meticulously appointed and built with the finest materials. 3,230 sqft of above grade living space includes 5 bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms, a powder room, den, Chef kitchen, dining room and living room. The finished basement has 3068sqft which is finished with an Aupair suite with a private bath, summer kitchen, recreation room w/fireplace, an additional guest room with a bath and laundry room. Summertime entertain on the huge patio surrounding your inground pool, two ponds with great fishing and lake front. Very private outdoor space. A two car built in garage and a one detached garage for all the outdoor toys! Too much to list a must see property. You cannot build this home for what it's listed for A MUST SEE priced to sell, move in ready and furnished!

$280,000Est. Payment
8.76 Acres
0 Plank Road, Forestburgh, NY 12777
Lots Land For Sale

Large acreage building site located in one of the areas most desirable locations! The property backs up to Swinging Bridge Reservoir, with potential floating dock access to this beautiful lake. Enjoy fishing, boating, and recreation! The surrounding areas high-end homes and seclusion enhances this ideal getaway site.

$22,000Est. Payment
1.56 Acres
Sheldon Dr, Monticello, NY 12701
Lots Land For Sale

Lightly wooded one and a half acre lot at the end of a cul de sac in a small sub division just outside the village of Monticello. Many beautiful up scale homes in the area. Some building restrictions . This property will give you the privacy you are looking for but you will be close to the village, shopping, restaurants, Casino, Lakes and transportation.

$79,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 718 Sqft
23 Landfield Avenue, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

Conveniently located in Monticello village. Close to Broadway for shopping . Cozy two story 2 bedroom , 2 bath home, and very affordable. Nearby offices so there is a possibility it could be converted to a very affordable office with town approval. Also could make a nice little rental. Home in good condition and could use some updating. Not many in this price range so come take a look. Buyers agent to verify taxes.

$199,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,269 Sqft
498 Hamilton Road, Monticello, NY 12701
House For Sale

Come and explore this cozy ranch home on a generous 3+ acres of land, Renovated approx. in 2017 with 3 bedrooms and 1 bath with separate laundry room, remodeled kitchen with granite countertop, stainless steel refrigerator, and tiled floor, septic was pumped approx. in 2017, new floors, new siding, new windows, new water heater, new deck, and a fireplace in the living room, plus much more, come see yourself what this house has to offer.

$99,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 754 Sqft
29 Mohawk Trail, Smallwood, NY 12701
House For Sale

Location! Location! Smallwood seasonal home on large corner lot within walking distance to beach, Civic Park, waterfall, dog park and Forest Reserve. 3 bedrooms, 1 bath , fireplace, hardwood floors, enclosed porch, open floor plan, washer/dryer and spacious deck overlooking partially wooded lot. Build a garden, firepit, outdoor yoga space or rock garden. Create your dream paradise and live in the hamlet of Smallwood that is an outdoor oasis. Sandy beach. walking trails, tennis, basketball, children's play area, outdoor exercise equipment, non-motor boating and fishing. Nearby Bethel Woods, Farmers markets and lakefront dining. Call to take the tour.

$270,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,190 Sqft
25 E Kenoza Place, Smallwood, NY 12701
House For Sale

Welcome to your new home! This Smallwood beauty is ready for you to move right in. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home offers one level living with open living space. The main bedroom with en suite bath comes complete with walk in closet and access to the deck. Washer/ dryer hook-up. Steps from Gabriel Pond. Live in it all year long or use it as your second home. Smallwood offers swimming, boating, fishing on non-motor Mountain Lake, tennis courts, ball field and basketball courts for a nominal fee. It also offers nature trails, outdoor workout equipment and dog park. Close to Bethelwoods Performing Arts Center, lakeside dining, Resorts World Casino and Kartrite Indoor Water Park.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >