107 Houses For Sale in Old Lyme, CT

Sort by:
$350,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,909 Sqft

2 Joyce Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Large 2003 Cape Cod situated on 1 acre very private lot close to Rogers Lake area where you can boat, swim, fish and more! This home has tons of living space with wide open rooms with hardwood floors, walkout dry basement with natural light, huge upper level deck that is partially covered and two car garage under. The first floor features massive great room with half bath and entry area. This room is very open to the dining room and kitchen. The first floor has a full bath and two bedrooms. The second floor needs some finishing but has three bedrooms, a laundry room, a full bath that needs a bit more tile work in the shower/tub area. There is a huge master bedroom with a walk in closet and space for a large private master bathroom and dressing room that needs to be completed. You can make it your own. The second floor also has a spacious family room! There is over 2900 square feet of living space and another few hundred square feet that could be finished in the walkout basement. In need of some finishing and updates, this home can quickly become your dream home! Call for your private showing today.

$289,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,390 Sqft

23 Town Woods Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

This beautiful single level home will blend everyday living with the tranquility with lakeside living. Walk to the shore of the lake and relax your days without being too far from the restaurants and stores. Don't miss this freshly painted three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, bright open living room, dining room and hardwood floors throughout. Galley kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a whole house generator.

$820,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 4,342 Sqft

20 Meetinghouse Lane, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

"Tree Tops" is a captivating contemporary Colonial, surrounded by mature trees, professionally landscaped and lighted, and sited on one of the highest points in Old Lyme with absolutely stunning views of the Connecticut River and Valley, and long views of Long Island Sound. Close to the Village of Old Lyme, this remarkable home is privately located at the end of a cul-de-sac in a sought-after neighborhood, adjacent to conservation land with designated walking and hiking trails...all within walking or biking distance to the beautiful Old Lyme Country Club, featuring gourmet dining, golf, tennis, paddle tennis, and an Olympic-sized pool complex. Architecturally designed and custom built with great attention to detail, the open floor plan is filled with natural light from walls of glass, all focused on the magnificent views. The main level is designed for family or formal entertaining with a Great Room warmed by a beautiful stone fireplace, and is adjacent to the casual dining area and Chef's kitchen. A formal dining room easily accommodates large gatherings, and additionally there is a cozy den and full bath. The second level is highlighted by a dramatic Master suite with vaulted ceilings and fireplace, full marble spa bath and commodious closet...an intimate oasis. Two additional bedrooms and a spacious bonus room complete this level. The full walkout lower level is finished and ready for expansion into a media room, office or additional family room. Simply stunning!

$199,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 672 Sqft

11-1 Hefflon Farm Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Cute 1937 bungalow on .53 level acres in Hefflon Farm a beautiful neighborhood of $400K+ homes near the Black Hall River. Enjoy nearby kayaking beautiful White Sand Beach restaurants and a local farm stand as well as all the amenities the town of Old Lyme has to offer. A little TLC can make this home yours and many updates have already been done: replacement oil tank water pump main floor thermopane windows; new furnace in 2000 roof deck and gutters in 2006 circuit breaker box 2008 fence 2009 hot water heater 2014 septic tank 2015. The interior was just freshly painted. Make this cozy antique home your own or build new on the beautiful private lot approx. 150' x 150'. Home is currently not in the Hefflon Farm Homeowners Association but a future homeowner may join. The driveway is a deeded right of way over 13-1 Hefflon Farm Rd. Inspections for buyers' information only.

$1,850,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | -- Baths | 4,281 Sqft

86-3 Joshuatown Rd, Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

This impeccable Nantucket style home radiates New England Charm! Surrounded by the Lyme Nature Conservancy, Hamburg Cove and Waterfront estates, the popular design expertly blends traditional construction and modern amenities. The classic architecture and welcoming veranda lead you through a beautiful arched doorway to open and bright spaces! With Hamburg Cove beyond the glass, the graceful 2 story curved staircase sits center stage to the foyer. The handsome stone fireplace is the heart of the gathering spaces featuring maple floors, spacious kitchen, large windows, sun room with walls of glass, and a large dining area with a walk in bay backdrop. Wow.. the Master Suite.. Spacious with fireplace, large walk in closets, a beautiful en-suite as well as a resting porch and a sun deck. The supplemental bedrooms include 3 bedrooms and a gathering space that can be closed off by a pocket door. Lower level is home to a fun media room, billiards area, bedroom or home office and full bath. The list of amenities is long, but included among them are a full mud room with laundry, automated lawn irrigation system with separate well, 360' of water-frontage on Hamburg Cove, dock, mooring, and a 50 amp 220 volt port in the garage that can be used to charge any electric or hybrid vehicle. Custom lighting, custom vanities and sinks, refined mill work and raised paneling, exterior landscape lighting, beautiful stone walls, all coming together gorgeously to create this stunning home!

$399,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 1,735 Sqft

5-1 Huntley Aka 412 Neck Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

This sweet hideaway set on 3.92 rolling acres is the former "Windmill Hill" guest cottage. This home needs some renovations, but the period bones look good and provide a solid canvas to create a dream retreat. Set at the highest point of the land, you'll find Connecticut River views to Saybrook and Essex. There are 3 BRs, 2 FBs, front to back living room, dining room, sun porch and kitchen area with original porcelain sink. You'll find vintage 50s bathrooms-one first floor, one second floor, hardwood floors and a charming fireplace. Fantastic location close to the village, paddling/water access at Pilgrim's Landing and Old Lyme Marina are a stone's throw away. The home has it's own NEW private drive. Use 5-1 Huntley Road as the GPS address See sign at foot of drive.) This property can also be purchased together with the main house "Windmill Hill" (41 Neck Road listed separately as MLS 170279572 for a total 7.5 AC riverview property.) *** Taxes on this property reflect hose on main home (significantly higher) and do not reflect an assessor adjustment TBD. Home currently shares well water with main home and will need a will of it's own. Home being sold "as is." Chance to own the location of a lifetime.

$469,900Est. Payment
5 Beds | -- Baths | 3,079 Sqft

3 Deer Ridge, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Stately home at end of cul-de-sac on private road. Formal living and dining rooms flank the center staircase of the two story foyer as you enter the front door. Renovated kitchen with granite counters and center island, new stainless steel appliances, eating area with bay window for maximum sunlight and views of the backyard that borders a nature preserve with walking trails which can't be built on, ensuring you total privacy. Step down from the kitchen into the fireplaced family room with sliders to an expansive deck area for outside enjoyment! There is also a half bath off the kitchen with separate laundry area. The master suite is located on the second floor, offers a sitting/study area,walk-in closet and magnificent bathroom with beautiful glass walled shower, jacquzzi tub and double sinks. Three additional bedrooms plus the guest, in-law, au-pair suite with full bath, private deck, large closet and sitting area complete the second floor. New carpet in bedrooms, 2 zone pet fence. Amazing home in lovely community!

$459,900Est. Payment
4 Beds | -- Baths | 2,545 Sqft

19 Wood Ridge Hills Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Welcome to this immaculate and perfectly cared for home! The 3 acre backdrop to this neighborhood home is serene with stone walls, tree-lined borders, and plenty of yard for fun! The main level features a bright and neutral decor, living room with fireplace, den, large kitchen with eating spaces, formal dining, laundry room and sunroom - all of which have definition and doors to open up the floor plan or allow private spaces. The second level is home to 4 generous bedrooms and 2 full baths. You will love the master suite!

$995,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 2,972 Sqft

62 Grassy Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Direct waterfront on Rogers Lake with desirable western views & glorious sunsets! Fully updated, featuring an open floor plan & flooded with light. A first floor bedroom and full bath. This home is perfect for entertaining with the generous deck just off of the kitchen/great room. The great room is the heart of the home with the very well-appointed kitchen, big center island, fireplace, dining room, & family room all overlooking the waterfront with fantastic views. 2nd Master bedroom suite up with balcony/deck that opens to the view. Additional bedroom & office complete the upper level. Lots of outdoor space for waterfront dining & outdoor activity. Canoe, paddle board, swim, fish, boat, waterski,...right from your own backyard or just sit relax & watch the ever changing view & sunset. This is a vey special home that is the perfect family retreat. Don't wait, buy your dream home today!

$1,795,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | -- Baths | 4,712 Sqft

433 Joshuatown Road, Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Grey Rocks is a historic 18th century Georgian colonial with an incredible sense of place. Located in the heart of bucolic Lyme, CT on the most beautiful, peaceful country road. This much admired, one-of-a-kind property is perfectly sited on 8.67 acres. A tranquil retreat with a picture-perfect post card setting of rolling hills, stone lined pastures filled with galloping horses & grazing sheep, glorious sunsets. Built circa 1796, this spacious light-filled home features high ceilings throughout, 5 bedrooms, 6 baths, a glorious eat-in chef's kitchen, original stone wood burning fireplaces, chestnut beams, antique wide-board wood floors, plaster walls, incredible trim work, gorgeous windows, warm & inviting light filled family room, a gracious dining room, spacious mater suite with dressing room & lovely bath. This timeless home has been beautifully renovated from top to bottom using the finest materials, period reproduction lighting, state of the art infrastructure, and modern amenities while preserving fine period details and antique charm throughout. A rich history including the underground railroad & presidential stays. The first level is ideal for entertaining with exposed chestnut beamed ceilings, massive stone fireplace, wine cellar, and bath. A 3-car carriage, an at home office, painting/art gallery, yoga studio, lots of storage space & is architecturally rich with arched windows, filed stone foundation & timber framing. Lyme, CT is a very special place to live!

$890,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 3,366 Sqft

183-3 Joshuatown Road, Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Beautiful reproduction saltbox on 12.97 private acres features a centered stone chimney with 3 fireplaces. The architect and builder were specialists in the restoration of 18th century dwellings. They achieved the ambience of the past and combined it with the conveniences and efficiencies of today. The massive stone family room fireplace includes an old brick beehive oven and antique crane. Adjoining the family room is the traditional borning room which makes an ideal study or guest room. The kitchen with center island, is enhanced by a vaulted beamed ceiling. A sunroom with French doors, and radiant heat under a fieldstone floor. The upper level, reached by rear and front stairways, has 3 bedrooms, 2 with en-suite bathrooms. The lower level includes an exercise/TV room, in-home office, full bath and laundry room. Re-cycled materials were used throughout: beams from an old barn in Litchfield, weathered barn board siding, chestnut hand rails, old interior doors, etc. Skim coated plaster walls, hand planed wide board paneling, handmade reproduction sconces and lighting fixtures add to the historic ambience. Outside, is a 2 story Post and Beam barn with attached potting shed. Property features stone walls, woods and meadows. Abuts a Land Trust Preserve which adjoins more conservation land with hiking trails through five connecting preserves. Over 1,000 acres for outdoor enjoyment! The twenty acres between the house and Joshuatown Rd are also protected by the Lyme Land Trust.

$925,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | -- Baths | 6,500 Sqft

4 Brockway Ferry Road, Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Sited overlooking Lower Pond, this 6 acre retreat is a naturalist's delight. Lofted ceilings and open spaces accent this Nantucket shingle residence. A gracious entry hall with balcony welcomes you to through to the living and dining rooms and onto the spectacular center island kitchen and great room. A well appointed kitchen will be the center of your gatherings. All of the public rooms open to the deck with delightful, ever changing pond views, offering a great platform for viewing the natural surroundings. You'll find a first floor master suite with staircase to a superb private office. Another bedroom and full bath is located on the first floor. (Possible second office.) In addition, there are two second floor bedrooms with ensuite baths and a private bonus room accessed off the rear staircase for a private in law or au pair quarters. So much flexibility - and all spaces enhanced with stunning hardwood floors and classic finishes. Top notch mechanicals lean toward greener living with low impact and efficient GEOTHERMAL heating and propane hot water. A whole house on demand generator offers peace of mind! These mechanicals are housed in an exceptional, unfinished, walk out basement. There is a three car garage/and adjacent workshop space and additional one car garage off the first floor. Just minutes from civilization but a world apart. See the virtual tour for a walk through! Exceptional.

$450,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 2,632 Sqft

2 Riverdale Landing, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Rare Opportunity to Own an Impressive Colonial In Riverdale Landing with Beach Rights. This Freshly painted Home features New carpeting and ready to move in! Open Kitchen with granite counters, stainless steel appliances, island, leading to dining area and den with fireplace. Hardwood Floors throughout lower level. Upstairs includes 3 bedroooms including a Master suite with walk in closet, double sink vanity and whirlpool tub. First floor laundry room. 4 Baths. First floor office with new carpet could be used as forth bedroom. Deck for outdoor entertaining and 2 car attached garage. Located in private association w/deeded beach rights to Oakridge Beach Association

$409,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | -- Baths | 2,459 Sqft

4 Homestead Circle, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Perfect Pandemic Paradise!!! Come see this fabulous, renovated Farmhouse with versatile living space, in-law apartment, close proximity to the beach, large level yard, and views of the water and Old Saybrook lighthouse! Recently updated, this move-in ready home is adaptable to today's complex living needs. With a wonderful, covered, front porch that affords privacy thanks to mature landscaping, this space invites relaxation or additional work space. Flexibility allows the new homeowners to designate this home with up to 5 bedrooms or to create usable office or in-law space. A huge side yard creates the potential for a possible subdivision or just room for outdoor activities. With the town beach just moments away and access to water sports almost next door, this home is positioned to take advantage of all Old Lyme has to offer. The first floor in-law apartment has its own bedroom, bathroom and kitchen and can have its own living space if desired. The garage, with new garage doors, offers plenty of storage, potential space for a small boat and a workshop. Wonderful property!

$1,995,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 2,900 Sqft

40 Neck Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Direct Waterfront, this historic waterfront has been tastefully updated with lovely terraces from which to enjoy breathtaking, magical sunsets overlooking the CT River. Panoramic water views and everchanging reflections from the water highlight a light, airy, open interior where antique beams, built-ins and three fireplaces accentuate walls of glass and a sophisticated kitchen with cathedral ceiling in this stunning home. Hundreds of acres of river views are yours with a fully-permitted, 40 ft deep water dock assuring easy access to the CT River or L.I. Sound. The property and dock are protected from waves and boat wakes by Calves Island.This historically significant Residence, "Ker Guen" (White House in Dutch), was the home and the artistic inspiration for famed American Impressionist Painter, Clark Voorhees, a prominent artist of the Florence Griswold House and Lyme Art Association from 1903-1933. Located near the Old Lyme Marina, this property is zoned as light industrial allowing for multiple uses but as a residence, it is uniquely beautiful. It is minutes from I-95, Amtrak, shopping, art galleries and restaurants. Conveniently located 2 hours from both New York and Boston. Watching the river activity with its parade of boats, wildlife and infinite views, in the privacy of this magnificent home is always relaxing while magnificent sunsets crown almost every evening.

$829,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 2,966 Sqft

248 Hamburg Road, Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

Rare offering in Lyme of a Commercial building in the heart of Hamburg featuring highly stylized design and superb construction. Current use has been set up as a private oral surgery practice with reception area, two surgical suites, office, staff lounge and consultation room. The layout allows for very flexible usage with many spaces opening onto a 20 X 18 deck overlooking Cove Landing Marina, inner Hamburg Cove and the surrounding hills. A truly unique space that would also make a very handsome 3 bedroom residence with it's dual zoning and history of previous owners having done so. Other features include a full basement with utilities and storage, 2 new air conditioning units and 2 Buderus boilers. Be sure to take the virtual tour and enjoy!

$1,995,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | -- Baths | 3,818 Sqft

66-7 Ely Ferry Road, Lyme, CT 06371

House For Sale

PEACE, QUIET & SERENITY, this glorious secluded waterfront property has it all! Featuring a spectacular home that is flooded with light from walls of windows, a well-appointed guest house, a swimming pool, a first-floor master suite,... all with spectacular ever-changing water views. Perfectly sited on 8.00 private acres overlooking Lord's Cove in the CT River Estuary, the ideal spot to watch sunrise, sunsets, & bird life including bald eagles. This property is truly one-of-a-kind & has never been offered before! The main house is perched on a promontory with spectacular views over the cove to the CT River beyond. The family room is the heart of the home with floor ceiling windows & the warmth of a large stone fireplace. The kitchen with spacious dining area opens to an inviting covered stone patio to the water. Two en-suite bedrooms up also with stunning views. A handsome guest house has an open floor plan & equally beautiful views of the water & is perfectly site just above the waterfront pool. This is a rare offering providing the glory of the Lower CT River & the true privacy away from life's hustle & bustle, all just 10 minutes from town center. This property has it all, a true family retreat. There would be no reason to ever leave with hundreds of acres of conservation land with hiking & horseback riding trails just a short walk down the lane.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >