loading
Back to Search
$327,010
Est. $2,089/mo savings
5 Beds1 Bath1,365 Sqft

11 Coffey Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553

Overview

This Single Family Residence is located at 11 Coffey Ave, New Windsor, NY and was last sold on 02/12/2020 for 53,000.00. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 327,010, approximately $239.57 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1870. 11 Coffey Ave is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including New Windsor School, South Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

See Less
Take advantage of your home equity.Learn More
Local Experts
Buying a home is a big decision
You don't have to do it alone.
Schedule a Home Estimate
11 Coffey Ave
May8
May9
May10
May11
May12
May13
May14
May15
May16
May17
May18
May19
May20
May21
May22
May23
May24
May25
May26
May27
May28
Compare Similar Homes
Currently Viewing This Home
Est: $327,010
$239/Sqft
5 Bedrooms
1 Bathrooms
1365 Sqft
3990 Acre(s)
Built 1870
$390,000
$178/Sqft
5 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
2186 Sqft
Lot Size not available
Built 1952
$368,328
$133/Sqft
5 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
2767 Sqft
0.18 Acre(s)
Built 1900
$315,300
$240/Sqft
5 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
1313 Sqft
Lot Size not available
Year Built not available
Contact a lender to learn more about your financing options.
Recently Sold In New Windsor, NY

    01/03/2021
    $315,056
    4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,660 Sqft
    53 Continental Dr, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 53 Continental Dr, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 315,056, approximately $189.79 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1964. 53 Continental Dr is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Heritage Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/23/2020
    $222,544
    3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,152 Sqft
    227 Franklin St, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 227 Franklin St, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 222,544, approximately $193.18 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1953. 227 Franklin St is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Temple Hill School, Heritage Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/22/2020
    $379,552
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,350 Sqft
    102 Creamery Dr, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 102 Creamery Dr, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 379,552, approximately $281.15 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1989. 102 Creamery Dr is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Cornwall Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/21/2020
    $203,965
    4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,584 Sqft
    14 Old Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 14 Old Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 203,965, approximately $128.77 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1940. 14 Old Riley Rd is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Temple Hill School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/20/2020
    $394,875
    4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,680 Sqft
    15 Clarkview Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 15 Clarkview Rd, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 394,875, approximately $235.04 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1957. 15 Clarkview Rd is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Temple Hill School, Temple Hill School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/17/2020
    $279,870
    2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,065 Sqft
    7 Willow Ln, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 7 Willow Ln, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 279,870, approximately $262.79 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1954. 7 Willow Ln is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Heritage Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/16/2020
    $311,112
    3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,296 Sqft
    8 Rocky Ln, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 8 Rocky Ln, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 311,112, approximately $240.06 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1954. 8 Rocky Ln is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Cornwall Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/16/2020
    $302,610
    3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,216 Sqft
    3 Elizabeth Ln, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 3 Elizabeth Ln, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 302,610, approximately $248.86 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1953. 3 Elizabeth Ln is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Little Britain Elementary School, Temple Hill School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/15/2020
    $553,518
    -- Beds | -- Baths | -- Sqft
    9 Knights Ct, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Lot is located at 9 Knights Ct, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 553,518. 9 Knights Ct is within the school district Washingtonville Central School District with nearby schools including Little Britain Elementary School, Temple Hill School, and Washingtonville Senior High School.

    12/13/2020
    $294,292
    3 Beds | 1 Bath | 960 Sqft
    27 Harth Dr, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 27 Harth Dr, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 294,292, approximately $306.55 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1961. 27 Harth Dr is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Heritage Middle School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/13/2020
    $671,872
    4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,248 Sqft
    1 Green Valley Ct, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 1 Green Valley Ct, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 671,872, approximately $206.86 per square foot. This property was originally built in 2005. 1 Green Valley Ct is within the school district Cornwall Central School District with nearby schools including Willow Avenue Elementary School, Cornwall Middle School, and Cornwall Central High School.

    12/10/2020
    $539,434
    4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,196 Sqft
    2046 Independence Dr, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 2046 Independence Dr, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 539,434, approximately $168.78 per square foot. This property was originally built in 2005. 2046 Independence Dr is within the school district Cornwall Central School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Temple Hill School, and Cornwall Central High School.

    12/08/2020
    $176,088
    -- Beds | -- Baths | -- Sqft
    21 Pin Oak Dr, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 21 Pin Oak Dr, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 176,088. 21 Pin Oak Dr is within the school district Cornwall Central School District with nearby schools including Little Britain Elementary School, Temple Hill School, and Cornwall Central High School.

    12/08/2020
    $98,600
    3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,430 Sqft
    115 Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 115 Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 98,600, approximately $68.95 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1946. 115 Riley Rd is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Temple Hill School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

    12/07/2020
    $423,864
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,800 Sqft
    271 Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Off Market

    This Single Family Residence is located at 271 Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY. The estimated value of this home is currently priced at 423,864, approximately $235.48 per square foot. This property was originally built in 1987. 271 Riley Rd is within the school district Newburgh City School District with nearby schools including Vails Gate Steam Academy, Temple Hill School, and Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus.

View Similar Homes for Sale
    $390,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,186 Sqft
    241 Spruce Street, New Windsor, NY 12553
    House For Sale

    Walk through the front Dutch barn door into this beautiful and inviting 5 bedroom colonial located on a quiet cul-de-sac. Large living room with fireplace, recessed lighting and large windows over looking the backyard which includes an in-ground pool. Spacious eat-in kitchen includes stainless steel appliances, plenty of cabinet space, new double sink and cut out through to the living room. Formal dining room. Huge 1st floor bedroom with built-in shelving and gorgeous hardwood floors. Classic subway tile in first floor full bathroom and recently replaced tub. Three seasons room lined with windows. Additional four large bedrooms upstairs. Additional storage in attic. Lovely, flat back yard with lots of potential for entertainment. Did I mention the in-ground pool has a new liner? Buderus boiler. New windows installed 2012. New siding installed 2012. New roof 2016. Additional storage in garage attic. Quiet neighborhood. Nothing to do but move-in!

    $60,000
    $368,328Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,767 Sqft
    27 Cullen Avenue, New Windsor, NY 12553
    Multi Family For Sale

    ALMOST A 10 Cap on a Totally Turn key money making property!! Newly done from top to bottom, new roofs, windows, floors, all new appliances and systems. Super convenient location, and stable tenancy. Tenants pay ALL utilities resulting in great noi. Laundry on site. Get your money in the market without the months of renovation. Make money from day 1. This is all done!

    $60,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,467 Sqft
    New Windsor, NY 12553
    House For Sale

    1467 sq ft. Pre-Foreclosure Single Family Home features 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. Pre-foreclosures can offer opportunities to purchase properties at attractive prices.

    $315,300Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,313 Sqft
    New Windsor, NY 12553
    House For Sale

    1313 sq ft. Pre-Foreclosure Single Family Home features 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. Pre-foreclosures can offer opportunities to purchase properties at attractive prices.

    New
    $319,900Est. Payment
    6 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,496 Sqft
    74-76 Valley Avenue 76, Walden, NY 12586
    Multi Family For Sale

    Welcome to 74-76 Valley Avenue. The long time owners of this well maintained and updated duplex is the perfect owner occupied on one side and rent out the other. Also a great investor opportunity. Updates are as follows: roof is 11 yrs old with 25-30 year shingles, thermal windows, vinyl siding, all new plumbing and electric, including new services to both units as well as both baths have been totally re-done. The left side also has new insulation and sheetrock, kitchen with gas stove, pantry, flooring and pull down attic stairs. The right side has new main level flooring, new kitchen with gas stove, pantry and attic storage. Basements can be used for storage. Very quiet, one way street. Don't miss out on this rare find at a great price!

    New
    $379,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,279 Sqft
    17 Grand Street, Marlboro, NY 12542
    Multi Family For Sale

    Well maintained village 4 family with the same owner for the past 17+ years. Ideally located just outside the quaint village of Marlboro where you will fine may restaurants and shopping. Centrally located to both Poughkeepsie and Newburgh/Beacon and Rt. 84 for easy commute. Tenants pay all electric heat and hot water, internet/cable. This home is comprised of three 1 bedroom units and one 2 bedroom unit. Owner recently had all new Thermopane windows installed and exterior painting. In addition, there is a full front covered porch and large backyard for you use.

    New
    $349,900Est. Payment
    6 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,400 Sqft
    50 Wells Road, Newburgh, NY 12550
    Multi Family For Sale

    3 bedroom 1 1/2 bath side by side duplex is waiting for you. Rent one side and live in other or keep it as a rental property. Both units currently have tenants. This great investment property offers privacy yet is conveniently located to many amenities such shops, major malls, schools, both fine and casual dining, wineries, breweries, hiking, skiing and more. This one is close to NYS Thruway, route 84 and just over an hour from the GW.

    New
    $339,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,520 Sqft
    4 Kings Hill Rd, Walden, NY 12586
    Multi Family For Sale

    Located in the town of Newburgh, Wallkill School District, with a Walden mailing address this duplex house has side by side units. Each unit has access to a basement area, and the left unit has access to the basement and garage. The left unit was renovated in 2006 with a new kitchen, appliances, flooring and bath. Do not disturb tenants, must have 24 hours notice to show. Broker is related to owner and is disclosing interest. Owner pays heat and partial electric. Call for more information.

    $338,900Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 6 Baths | 1,300 Sqft
    7 Shire Ridge Court, Walden, NY 12586
    Multi Family For Sale

    Very lovely and spacious 2 & 3 bedroom, 2 bath side by side duplex in the Town of Newburgh with Wallkill schools! This great investment is nestled on the end of a dead end road with off street parking, nice level yard and private deck. Live in one & rent the other, rent both or bring the extended family to the country. Private setting yet conveniently located to many amenities such as shops, schools, restaurants both casual & fine dining, wineries, breweries, hiking, transportation just minutes from Route 84 and NYS Thruway and much more.

    $327,000Est. Payment
    6 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,904 Sqft
    132 Chambers Street, Newburgh, NY 12550
    Multi Family For Sale

    Recently renovated 2-unit townhome, with off street parking and large back yard! Each apartment spans over two levels; the property has four renovated levels of living space in total. Excellent tenants paying market rate rents make this a great investment, or enjoy passive income while planning to be an owner occupant in the future. A smart contemporary renovation has preserved the historical character of this building, making it a "best of both worlds" choice!

How To Finance

As a homebuyer, there are quite a few financing options to consider. Our interactive guide can help find which is right for you, and guide you through the paperwork.

Get Started

Home Values in New Windsor, NY

There are currently 8 properties with a median home value on Coffey Ave of $153,700, $173,310 less than this home. The median list price per square foot on Coffey Ave is $148, $115 more than this home. Of the total homes on Coffey Ave, 93% are For Sale, 7% are For Rent, and 69% are Single Family Homes. Coffey Ave represents Infinity% of home addresses in New Windsor, NY. Interested in knowing how much your home on Coffey Ave is worth? The Homes.com Automated Valuation Model (AVM) provides an estimate of the home value of every on and off market property in the US.

$327,010

5 Beds1 Bath1,365 Sqft

11 Coffey Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553

Call to ask about this home today!

(845) 219-5143
version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >