Back to Search
Est. $2,810/mo
3 Beds2 Baths885 Sqft

142d Orchard Road, Shelter Island, NY 11971

Listed by Linda McCarthy
885 SqFt House In Shelter Island Heights

Adorable Craftsman style 3BR/1.5Ba Cottage centrally located. Access to Gardiner's Creek at the end of the private road for your kayak. LR w/FP & built-in book shelves opens to the formal DR. The first floor also hosts 2 BRs, Full BA, 3 season porch, Kitchen w/door to back yard & stairs up. The second floor has a large bedroom with half bath and lots of storage. Covered patio, shed for storage & spacious grounds all add to this Island charmer.

See Less
Interested in this home?
Local Experts
Buying a home is a big decision
You don't have to do it alone.
Schedule a Tour
142d Orchard Road
Compare Similar Homes
Currently Viewing This Home
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
885 Sqft
0.32 Acre(s)
Built 1930
4 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
1900 Sqft
0.34 Acre(s)
Built 1957
Price Per Sq. Ft not available
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Sq. Ft. not available
0.5 Acre(s)
Built 1928
Price Per Sq. Ft not available
4 Bedrooms
4 Bathrooms
Sq. Ft. not available
0.47 Acre(s)
Built 1926
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
1200 Sqft
0.5 Acre(s)
Built 1970
Contact one of our agents for a more detailed home comparison!
Listing provided by
Linda McCarthyListing Agent(631) 745-2626
Continue Your Search
    $565,000Est. Payment
    1.43 Acres
    1 Shorewood Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Lots Land For Sale

    Located in the Shorewood Farm area and a short distance to Wades beach. Surrounded by preserved land on 2 sides, this 1.4 acre lot has been cleared and has DEC permits in place and a site plan for a 5 bedroom home including a pool and pool cabana/garage is available. This property awaits your dream home! Exclusive $565,000. 631-905-4339, Louise Poleshuk, [email protected]

    $722,000Est. Payment
    2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,100 Sqft
    22 W Neck Road, Shelter Island H, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    Cozy 2 bedroom, 2 bath ranch style home with utopic back yard. Close proximity to golf course, restaurants, Sunset beach and Town.

    $1,286,300Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,608 Sqft
    5 Osprey Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    This unique property was part of the Artimus Ward Estate, Built in Circa 1895 and renovated in 1977, this Shepherds cottage and guest cottage offer an abundance of privacy set on .75 acres on Osprey Lane in coveted Shorewood Farm. The main house offers a kitchen, living room, den and half bath on the first floor. The second floor has a master suite with bath divided by stained glass with a oversized dressing room, 2 additional bedrooms and 1 bath. The cottage built in 2006 features a southern exposure with passive solar with winter water views of South Ferry. The cottage is 1390 square feet and has one bedroom , 2 baths, eat-in kitchenette, living room and a third floor mezzanine/office/art studio. This unique property is landscaped for complete privacy, Association tennis and beach available. 631-749-0800, Louise Poleshuk, [email protected]

    $5,975,000Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,800 Sqft
    62 Winthrop Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    Nantucket style traditional situated on 3.36 acres over looking the beautiful sunsets of Dering Harbor and Salt Pond. Recently renovated, gourmet eat in kitchen, 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, living room with wood burning fireplace, hardwood floors, wrap around deck and porch with gazebo, approx. 52' x 22' heated gunite swimming pool, mature landscaping, 125' deep water boat dock and beach. Possible room for 1000 sq ft expansion. Exclusive: $5.975M Dering Harbor Real Estate

    $995,000Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 3 Baths | -- Sqft
    32 South Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    Waterfront Shelter Island Beach House. Three levels of living space, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, chef's kitchen, and two fireplaces. Beautiful seaside brick patio, cedar siding, landscaped for privacy. Exclusive: $995K. Please call/text Angelo at: 631 456 0051 Dering Harbor Real Estate

    $1,745,000Est. Payment
    8 Beds | 5 Baths | 3,098 Sqft
    101 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    A true oasis in beautiful South Ferry Hills. This 8BR/4.5BA home feature breathtaking Cathedral ceilings, a gorgeous renovated kitchen w/high end appliances & indoor/outdoor speakers leading to a pool w/retractable cover & a hot tub for cool summer nights. In addition to this magnificent home, a private boat slip is included w/lovely views of the South Ferry from the beach. The newly paved driveway features a basketball hoop & the yard is spacious for varied lawn games. A truly remarkable home for entertaining w/numerous amenities.

    $449,000Est. Payment
    1 Bed | 1 Bath | -- Sqft
    13 Winthrop Road #24, Shelter Island, NY 11965
    House For Sale

    Situated on almost eight acres of prime Shelter Island waterfront this beautifully renovated coop has a new kitchen with; granite counter tops, appliances and wood floors. Plus, a newly renovated tile bath with high end finishes. Located on the first floor for easy access and a lovely terrace with water views. The COOP offers: tennis, heated 50' x 24' gunite swimming pool, gym, and marina. Important consideration, $1,187. monthly Maintenance fee is all inclusive and includes, with no extra charges or fees, all of the following: real estate taxes, heat, hot water, air conditioning, electric, water, septic, refuse pickup, high speed WiFi, cable television, telephone, gym membership, all year round grounds maintenance, parking, snow plowing, heated pool, kayak racks, storage, 24 hour on-site property manager and a heated and secure storage area. An on-site deep water dockage with power and water is available at a discounted rate for owners. Exclusive: $449K. Dering Harbor Real Estate

    $1,885,000Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,300 Sqft
    10 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    Sitting majestically in the Heart of the Heights on 3 levels with Water Views from practically all rooms this well designed and beautifully maintained home is now available for sale. Bordering a park and with all the amenities your heart could desire for year round living. Enter through the lovely sunroon adjoining the living room with large bay picture window and a wood burning stove which leads through to the eat in kitchen, completing the first floor are two guest bedrooms (one en suite with waterviews) and two bathrooms. The second floor has a very spacious master bedroom with both private deck and a French balcony from which to watch the ebb and flow of Dering Harbor or feel the summer breezes. Master Bathroom has whirlpool tub and large shower, great sized walk-in closet. There is an open mezzanine library/ den space that overlooks living area. The walk out lower level has an additional guest room, office, space for a gym, art/pottery studio, laundry room and garage. With fenced in freeform pool and patio surrounded by plethora of wonderful flowering bushes in raised beds. The home has multi-level outdoor entertainment areas and a large round deck is the focal point by the kitchen for you and your loved ones to begin your story in this wonderful home. Please call with any questions or to make an appointment to view.

    $4,995,000Est. Payment
    6 Beds | 7 Baths | 5,500 Sqft
    189a Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    Take in sweeping views of Gardiners Bay from this 6 bedroom, 7 bath custom built waterfront home located at the end of Shelter Island's coveted Ram Island Drive. The 1.3 acre property features a 20x45 gunite pool, manicured gardens, 123 feet of sandy bay beach and a separate legal guest suite above the detached 2 car garage complete with bedroom, kitchen and full bath. Constructed with unparalleled craftsmanship, the main house features 5500 square feet of both open concept living and multiple spaces for work, movies and privacy. Once in a lifetime opportunity to live, work and entertain on the singularly spectacular Ram Island.

    $3,250,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,802 Sqft
    18 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    New to market, excellent location, 5 beds/ 3 baths, large great room with soaring ceilings and full height ram island stone fireplace. Wrap around deck overlooking the harbor, stone bulkhead, 151ft of beachfront. Garage with studio above. Room for pool and expansion. Exclusively represented. Call for details Call M. Wein Realty, Inc. 631-749-0999, ask for Melina

    $2,995,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 3 Baths | 4,220 Sqft
    3 Bluff Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    This home is located at 3 Bluff Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964 US and has been listed on Homes.com since 11 January 2021 and is currently priced at $2,995,000, approximately $710 per square foot. This property was built in 1895. 3 Bluff Avenue is within the school district(s) Shelter Island Union Free School District with nearby schools including Shelter Island School. Similar properties nearby are <a href="/property/3-bluff-ave-shelter-island-ny-11964/id-400033223452/">3 Bluff Ave</a>, <a href="/property/24-s-midway-rd-shelter-island-ny-11964/id-400032794037/">24 S Midway Rd</a>, 90 Peconic Ave, <a href="/property/120-caiola-ct-greenport-ny-11944/id-1000027869648/">120 Caiola Ct</a>, <a href="/property/33-westmoreland-dr-shelter-island-ny-11964/id-400032770607/">33 Westmoreland Dr</a>, 47b S Ferry Rd, <a href="/property/67925-county-road-48-greenport-ny-11944/id-1000068486386/">67925 County Road 48</a>, <a href="/property/2055-albertson-ln-greenport-ny-11944/id-1000008235242/">2055 Albertson Ln</a>, <a href="/property/62675-county-road-48-greenport-ny-11944/id-400022191149/">62675 County Road 48</a>, and <a href="/property/751-laurel-ave-southold-ny-11971/id-1000038405249/">751 Laurel Ave</a>.

    $749,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,100 Sqft
    84 N Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    House For Sale

    Cozy country home viewing large pastoral setting featuring 3 bedrooms, 1 bath, fireplace, detached garage, just around the corner from Coecles harbor. A true nostalgic piece of Shelter Island.

    $2,390,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,544 Sqft
    87 N Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965
    House For Sale

    Incredible Business Opportunity on 1.62 Acres. This centrally located fully operational restaurant accommodates 56 seats, has a market, takeout counter, main dining room, covered porch, outside eating area and spacious commercial kitchen. A country farm stand provides a space for pop-up summer markets . The lager 2550 sqft. workshop creates plenty of options for any entrepreneurial spirit. The farmhouse with 3 bedrooms and 2 Baths makes for the ideal live and work lifestyle .

    $2,495,000Est. Payment
    3.77 Acres
    5 Pandion Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Lots Land For Sale

    As you enter Pandion this gracious 3.772 acre parcel which would allow up to a 11,000 sq. ft. house (subject to town approval), pool and garage. Pandion is a residential neighborhood of remarkable natural beauty comprised of 24.8 acres. With its sweeping views of Coecles Harbor, Ram Island, the protected lands of Mashomack Preserve and Gardiners Bay in the distance, Pandion is unique on Shelter Island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve the environmental and visual integrity of the land and seascape. Common parcels have been set aside to preserve open space corridors and accommodate shared amenities so as to reduce the number of structures near the water and lessen the environmental impact on pristine Coecles Harbor. There are five residential parcels and two Home Owners Association parcels with a waterfront boathouse, a 6 slip deep water dock, a boat barn and 1-2 tennis courts. This is a great opportunity for a savvy client to buy into a fabulous community with all the amenities listed above, with amazing water views at a terrific price.

How To Finance

As a homebuyer, there are quite a few financing options to consider. Our interactive guide can help find which is right for you, and guide you through the paperwork.

Get Started


3 Beds2 Baths885 Sqft

142d Orchard Road, Shelter Island, NY 11971

Call to ask about this home today!

(631) 765-7734
version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >