Back to Search
Est. $3,301/mo
2 Beds1 Bath1,360 Sqft

40 Nehantic Trail, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Listed by Dean Mitchell
1360 SqFt House In Saybrook Manor

Rare opportunity in Indian Town with beach rights to build or renovate two existing homes 40 & 36 Nehantic Trail. Indian town is an awesome beach community with private beaches, marina and activities. Both homes require extensive renovations and are being sold as is. Separate building lot available located at 3 Aquaterra MLS# 170340208, behind #36 Nehantic. Flexible options include: new construction, renovate and live in one and rent the other. 40 and 36 being sold as a package (see MLS# 170339354). Will not be sold separately.

See Less
Interested in this home?
Local Experts
Buying a home is a big decision
You don't have to do it alone.
Schedule a Tour
40 Nehantic Trail
Compare Similar Homes
Currently Viewing This Home
2 Bedrooms
1 Bathrooms
1360 Sqft
0.22 Acre(s)
Built 1959
4 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
2264 Sqft
Lot Size not available
Built 1947
2 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
1535 Sqft
Lot Size not available
Built 2018
3 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
3220 Sqft
1.16 Acre(s)
Built 1982
4 Bedrooms
4 Bathrooms
2397 Sqft
0.26 Acre(s)
Built 2018
Contact one of our agents for a more detailed home comparison!
Listing provided by
Dean MitchellListing Agent(203) 453-5546
Continue Your Search
    $799,900Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,264 Sqft

    44 Willard Avenue, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Spectacular views of South Cove, Fenwick and Long Island Sound from this very special home in Old Saybrook, Connecticut! Featuring 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this Cape style home boasts a very high-end kitchen renovation, a gunite heated pool, hot tub and an outside shower. Located on a lovely quiet street, walking distance to Main Street and Saybrook Point. Set your kayak in the water in your backyard and explore South Cove. This home has been meticulously maintained by its current owners for the last 31 years. Beautiful updates in 2015 include the kitchen renovation with Bulthaup cabinets and quartz countertops along with Gaggenau appliances and new hickory flooring, a fabulous mudroom and all 1st floor doors were replaced with solid hardwood doors. Geothermal heat was installed in 2011 along with a new hot water heater at that time. The Gunite heated pool was installed in 2009 and has an automatic retractable solar cover and a concrete surround. There is Ipe decking and a hot tub for beautiful nights any time of the year along with an outside shower with custom Ipe tile removable floor and custom Ipe seat! In 2000 a new roof, new windows and new siding were installed, which are in beautiful condition to last many more years to come. Most of the interior of the house was just painted prior to listing for a fresh start for the next owner. You won't want to miss this gem calling you home to the wonderful town of Old Saybrook and specifically sought-after South Cove!

    $449,000Est. Payment
    2 Beds | 4 Baths | 1,915 Sqft

    25 Sunset Road #18, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    Condominium For Sale

    Looking for a home that feels like vacation every day? Come see this townhouse in a beautiful complex, with a pool overlooking a private marina on the Oyster river. Boat slips and boat storage are available at no cost to owners. You can enjoy the peaceful privacy of your patio, or walk down to the pool and perhaps meet some neighbors. Or maybe you want to kayak on the river or join someone going out on their boat. After all, you don't have to do any yard work so just enjoy! This unit has been updated throughout with an eat-in kitchen with nice lighted cabinets and wood floor. The open living and dining room are welcoming, with sliders to the patio and yard. Upstairs each bedroom has it's own private bath. And the lower level is nicely finished with a family room, several closets, and a full bath with shower. There's also a workshop area with utility sink and storage shelving. The small 20-unit complex is in a great area for walking and biking, with a nearby town park offering tennis, basketball, and a playground. The beach is just down the street and a fun place to visit with a low tide sandbar. And you can even walk to the town center restaurants and shops. What's not to love? See why Oyster River Landing is called "Old Saybrook's best kept secret". This is an ideal year-round home or weekend getaway, priced to sell.

    $449,900Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,896 Sqft

    519 Main Street, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Lovely village home! Steps to everything from this well maintained 1870s Victorian home. Property includes a barn garage, beautiful front porch with views of North Cove, and a rear deck. The "newer addition" of a large family room with fireplace and an 2 picture windows that let in the afternoon sunlight. A total of 3 bedrooms plus a den and parlor. A wonderful walk up attic with potential for mor living space. Convenience to Saybrook Junction train station, Saybrook Point Marina, Fenwick Golf Course, North Cove public boat launch and town beaches. Home enjoys new roof in 2020, newer windows, and furnace. House has on natural gas line if needed. Low taxes of $4800. Professional photos to come shortly.

    $570,000Est. Payment
    2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,535 Sqft

    14 Essex Glen Drive #12, Essex, CT 06475

    Condominium For Sale

    Perfect Home For Easy Living. An exciting new planned unit development of 26 exceptional stand alone homes. Live the Essex lifestyle at the Essex Glen! community for today's living in Historic Essex "The Best Little Town in America". No age restrictions low low energy costs and low taxes. No snow plowing or lawn care. This Centerbrook plan offers a very large kitchen with a large island open space dining and living area a master bedroom with his and hers walk in closets a walk-in shower and a full sized 1st floor laundry area Relax in any weather condition with a natural gas fireplaces a shady front Porch and a large rear deck with plenty of space for summer sun an barbecuing.

    $350,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,776 Sqft

    254 School House Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Well-loved 3BR Colonial Home set on 1.26acres of park-like grounds. Enter the main level to a large Family Room with Fireplace (set up for Gas Insert) and sliders to a private deck for summer cookouts and relaxation. Private office/sitting room, Laundry Room, and Full bath on this same level with access to the garage. Head upstairs to Light and Bright LR/DR/Kitchen with stainless appliances and bay window. All hardwood floors on this upper level with 3 bedrooms and a full bath. Fantastic, large, landscaped yard with paver stone patio areas, two great outbuildings with metal roofs, and plenty of room to play. Seller will credit for downstairs slider to be replaced. Don't miss the 3D Virtual Tour attached. Agents check private remarks in MLS

    $640,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 3,220 Sqft

    236 Maple Avenue, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale


    $519,700Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,444 Sqft

    23 Park Avenue, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Here is your opportunity to purchase this diamond in the rough just a short walk to Fenwood Beach! The last of the homes on prestigious Park ready for a facelift! This home features a generous 2 story floor plan with a cathedral kitchen and dining area first floor bedrooms including a garage conversion adding a private bedroom family room or office area. The upper story includes a master bedroom and full bath with an open floor plan of living space great as an expansive bonus room. A private fenced yard garden area and lot's of possibilities in this area of much higher valued homes make this a rare find. Come put your special touch on this gem and be ready to enjoy warm summer days for a lifetime!

    $459,000Est. Payment
    2 Beds | 4 Baths | 1,865 Sqft

    25 Sunset Road #12, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    Condominium For Sale

    Rarely offered - Waterfront condo in a beautiful 20-unit complex close to town center and beaches. This unit overlooks the Oyster river, with western exposure, offering incredible sunsets and fabulous bird watching. The townhouse has been lisghtly used, being a second home for the owners. The kitchen is remodeled with a built-in desk area, and gets great morning sun. The entire first floor has hardwood floors, and features a wall of built-in cabinets and a fireplace. Sliders open to a new Trex deck with awning for outdoor dining and relaxing. Two generous-sized bedrooms on the upper level have private baths. Additional finished space in lower level offers an office, den, and bath with shower. The HOA fee covers exterior, interior and flood insurance. A unique bonus of Oyster River Landing Association is that all unit owners get a free boat slip and winter boat storage. An in-ground pool overlooks the newly-built marina and river. And its a nice walk or short bike ride to the beach or town center. This may be your perfect getaway or year-round home! Come see why Oster River Landing is called "Old Saybrook's best kept secret"

    $979,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,019 Sqft

    3 Mohican Trail, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    New Construction FEMA compliant building in Indian Town! Open floor plan! Turn key home offering the perfect ocean getaway. ELEVATOR in home accessing all three floors. STandby whole house generator. Closed cell insulation providing high efficiency heating and cooling. Direct vent propane fireplace. Recessed lighting throughout. Gorgeous master suite with walk in shower and rainhead. All bedroom closets with built ins. Indian Town offers two private beaches, private marina, clubhouse and so much more!

    $895,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 6 Baths | 3,290 Sqft

    325 Main Street, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Every home tells a story and The Deacon Timothy Pratt House c. 1746 is no exception. Whether you are looking for the perfect period home* or have always wanted to fulfill your dream of owning your own Bed & Breakfast** this well known & often admired Center Chimney Colonial is rich in both local history and architectural detail. Recently renovated & beautifully furnished by the current owners the house is brimming with charm & character. As you enter, a welcoming foyer leads to a formal LR and DR, each with their own fireplace, custom built-ins including an original corner cupboard, detailed paneling & gleaming hardwood floors. A lovely first floor bedroom with spacious bath offers convenient one floor living or may be easily converted back to the library. The well appointed kitchen w/fireplace & original beehive oven, gas cook top w/ granite counters & office completes the first level. The original staircase leads to a spacious master suite with study/sitting area & beautifully remodeled bath. There are two additional en-suite bedrooms and a back staircase leading to the first floor. A true highlight of the property is a finished bedroom on the third level fondly referred to as" The Treetop" featuring a dramatic cathedral ceiling, exposed beams, a charming sitting area, writing desk & private bath. Located just steps from Main Street, Library, Restaurants & The Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center the Deacon Timothy Pratt House is listed on the National Historic Register.

    $699,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,488 Sqft

    463 Main Street, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Welcome to this Main Street home that offers a stunning main level sunroom with sliders to the large deck overlooking the level back yard and amazing views. The views are like a changing painting with every season year round color with flowering plants and bushes such as lilies hydrangeas and rhododendrons. Owners enjoy the South Cove view complete with Osprey platform that is home to nesting pair and other coastal wildlife. Enjoy kayaking from town ramp in North Cove 2 minutes away. Biking and short walk to town in addition biking and walking to surrounding neighborhoods along Long Island Sound and the CT River. This home offers Master Bedroom with full bath. Two additional bedrooms on Main Level. Living room on Main level with fireplace.Lower level has large family room with laundry and bathroom new tile floor and gas fireplace. Walk out lower level to beautiful open yard property has native raspberry and blueberry patch. Open concept Kitchen completely redone all appliances included oven/range dishwasher and microwave. Dining room on main level Living room with fireplace. Updates to this home include Buderus Furnace AC Hot Water Heater interior painting front stonework Porch and walkway landscaping Kitchen and inside lighting and ceiling fans. A must see!

    $359,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,768 Sqft

    90 Bokum Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Beautiful Dutch Colonial located in costal town of Old Saybrook Ct best of both worlds with large private yard and minutes from the beach and Amtrak. Newer furnace and oil tank, 200 amp service, remodeled kitchen and more make this Dutch Colonial a contemporary home on a country road! Wood flooring throughout the home. Master includes it's own half bath, extra "closet" space, and walk in closet. Full bath on second floor with 2 more bedrooms. Front to back living room features a fireplace, sliders to large back deck and patio. Kitchen features black stainless appliances, there is a "pot filler" above the smooth top, double oven range, D/W, French door bottom freezer Refrigerator, and Large breakfast bar. This house is perfect for entertaining with open concept kitchen, dining room, and living room. Large private yard with one shed, a professionally landscaped yard that includes 500 white tulips ready to welcome the spring! Lower level is partially finished with an exercise room/office/play room. In the utilities room there is a work bench and laundry area.

    $799,900Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,397 Sqft

    99 Neptune Dr, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    2 YEAR OLD Oversized cape built in desirable Knollwood Beach community. Enjoy unobstructed views of South Cove while relaxing outside on your front porch. Offering many modern luxuries; motion-activated lights, smart locks, USB electrical ports, and so much more! Step inside to gleaming hardwood floors, center propane fireplace with built-in shelving, recessed lighting throughout. Entertainers dream kitchen featuring customizable mood lighting, Blue Ice Granite countertop, center island with seating for six, stainless steel appliances. The first floor master with views of South Cove features custom built-in granite desk ensuite bath and walk-in closet. Discover double sinks, jetted tub & glass enclosed tile shower. Sliders to large backyard deck and grill area additional tile and stone built-in firepit. The second floor presents an expansive landing with built-in storage space, reading/sitting area with additional views. Also upstairs 3 bedrooms with additional bonus/office space. Rare & unique in a beach community on the lower level, gain an additional 3 car garage spaces with a large workbench. Beyond the 3 car garage find a private entrance and exit to studio space featuring a full kitchenette & bath. Enjoy life at the beach within the golf cart community! Ride/walk to the tennis/basketball court & playground/clubhouse all within Knollwood beach association. Short distance to prestigious Fenwick Golf Course & Saybrook Point. Explore life on the shoreline today!

    $415,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,080 Sqft

    212 Old Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Residential or Commercial options with this recently updated Ranch home in a B3 zone. Can be a residence, Home Business, Professional, medical or dental office. The living room has a stone fireplace and hardwood floors. There is a large eat-in country kitchen with granite countertops. There are hardwood floors in all 3 bedrooms. Both full baths have been updated. There is a spacious finished lower level family room. approximately 640 SF, with the second stone fireplace in the home. The large 3-season sunroom, approximately 300 SF, sits behind the 2-car attached garage along with a covered patio and a walk-up attic. There were major renovations in 2017 including the heating system, central air, hot water heater, electrical, plumbing, kitchen granite & floors, and family room walls and floors. All this with a pleasant yard with a stone wall and a convenient location.

    $450,000Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,079 Sqft

    16 Half Penny Lane, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    House For Sale

    Welcome to this wonderful four bedroom colonial home which is located on a lovely 1.07 acres. Upon entering the front door, you are greeted by beautiful hardwood floors which flow from room to room throughout the house. The kitchen is expansive and has granite countertops, room for a kitchen island, and a view to the backyard. Off of the kitchen is a cozy family room with a wood burning fireplace, wide plank hardwood floors, and ceiling fan. The family room also provides easy access to a deck which overlooks the beautiful backyard complete with an in-ground pool with a new liner and fence--perfect for seamless entertaining! Completing the first floor are the formal dining room, half bath, and a formal living room which spans from the front of the house to the back with wood burning fireplace. The master bedroom with recently updated ensuite & three additional bedrooms are located on the second floor. Entertain your family & friends on the outdoor deck & enjoy your summers in the pool! Upgrades: pool liner and fence 2019, newer windows. Easy access to Route 9, I-95, Train Station, Town Beach, restaurants, shopping, marinas, & more! Property is an estate.

How To Finance

As a homebuyer, there are quite a few financing options to consider. Our interactive guide can help find which is right for you, and guide you through the paperwork.

Get Started


2 Beds1 Bath1,360 Sqft

40 Nehantic Trail, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Call to ask about this home today!

(860) 952-3031
version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >