Est. $798/mo
5 Beds2 Baths1,920 Sqft

500 York Street, Poultney, VT 05764

Listed by David Anderson
Rebuilt 5-Bedroom House In Poultney

TWO HOMES FOR ONE PRICE This home has been well taken care of by its present owner, and it is evident when you view this property. This home was built from the foundation up after a fire in the late 1980's. The rebuilt home has many desirable features including a standing seam roof, all new replacement windows, vinyl siding, and paved driveway & walkway. The house is currently being rented as a two family, but easily converts to a one family with five bedrooms and two baths, by removing the upstairs kitchen. During this COVID 19 Pandemic, this would make a terrific multigenerational living enviroment. The Seller has requested that all Buyers be preapproved by a financial institution prior to viewing. This property was withdrawn for sale this past winter season, so as to not to displace two long term tenants.

See Less
Interested in this home?
Schedule a Tour
500 York Street
Compare Similar Homes
Currently Viewing This Home
5 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
1920 Sqft
0.33 Acre(s)
Built 1990

Sorry, no matching properties were found.

Contact one of our agents for a more detailed home comparison!
Listing provided by
David AndersonListing Agent(802) 775-5565
Continue Your Search
    $549,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,317 Sqft
    4130 Vt Route 30, Poultney, VT 05764
    House For Sale

    Lake St. Catherine's "Sailing Winds" is available to make your lake living dreams come true. This property includes a single story cottage (year round) with two bedrooms that features a sunlit living room, dining room and kitchen all with views to the lake. The wrap around deck invites you to sit by the sparkling water with friends and family and offers the perfect place to enjoy Lake St Catherine's popular July 4th fireworks display. The seasonal guest cottage offers room for more visitors with it's open living room and eat in kitchen. The upstairs bedroom is spacious and comfy. The oversized two car garage has a large storage area above which could easily be your art studio, man cave, she shed and more. This property offers 1.2 acres and 274 feet of lake frontage. That's not all... there is also a 612 sq. ft. attached workshop to the main cottage which is presently used for storage and a recreation room. The possibilities are endless! Most furniture and other items are included. Close to hiking/biking trails, golfing, skiing and more. Number on main house is 4150 ( for 911 purposes)

    $499,000Est. Payment
    3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,448 Sqft
    552 Thrall Road, Poultney, VT 05764
    House For Sale

    Come Home to Quintessential Vermont. 1997 Farmhouse 3 Br, 3 Ba with some of the following Features: Some Hubbardton Forge Fixtures, Granite Waterfall Countertops in Kitchen, Maple Cabinets, Bamboo Floors on 1st level, Wolf 4 burner gas Stove with Convection Oven, and a Balcony off upstairs BR.The spacious living room offers a Wonder Fire Gas Vermont Castings Stove. In case of electric outage there is a generator HU. Outside features many stonewalls, 30X40 Garage/Barn with concrete floors, electric and heat plus a lean to. $60,000 solar panels on barn roof with 30 year guarantee, provides electricity for house, barn and sugaring operation. 20X30 Sugarhouse (Equipment is not included in this sale) List of equipment and cost will be provided to an interested buyer. List at LO. 2 stall Horsebarn, Shed, Poultry Coop, and Apple Trees. 1 Ac.16 foot deep Pond with large Deck to Relax or Dive off plus Sandy Beach area. Country Living at it's Best.

    $139,500Est. Payment
    -- Beds | -- Baths | 2,860 Sqft
    249 Beaman Road, Poultney, VT 05764
    Multi Family For Sale

    2 Unit Residential Home located in the Village of Poultney. Close to town amenities. Rare 3 bedroom 2 Bathroom units. This would make a great opportunity to own a investment property. You can rent both units or live in one unit while renting the other. Bottom line it's a must see property.

    $185,000Est. Payment
    2 Beds | 1 Bath | 720 Sqft
    237 Cone'S Point Road, Poultney, VT 05764
    House For Sale

    LAKE ST CATHERINE. Located on the channel ( 200 ft) going into Lake St. Catherine , this winterized cottage sits on a double lot (0.74 acre) with breathtaking mountain views. A great location on Cone's Point within walking distance to Otto's Mini golf, market, soft cream and snack bar. A 2 bedroom and 1 full bath single story ranch makes life easy navigating the open floor plan. A Very cheerful and charming interior with a water front deck. The large open yard has plenty of room for gardens, summer barbecues, pets, yard games and children's play. Make life long memories at the fire pit roasting marshmellows while overlooking the mountains and water front. A new drilled well was installed in 2016, a new roof 2018, a new propane wall furnace in 2017 and a new electrical box in 2017. The large garden shed is included in the sale. Don't miss out on lake living. Very close to the Lake St. Catherine Golf Course and state park. Manchester outlets only 30 minutes away. The new bike paths are located just down the road. Lots of hiking and berry picking in the area. Very private and peaceful. Looking to Kayak - a perfect spot!

    $350,000Est. Payment
    6 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,654 Sqft
    5491 Vermont Route 315, Rupert, VT 05764
    House For Sale

    Have you looked at homes and wondered if you could move a wall to make an open floor plan or create a bigger mudroom or master? Here is your chance! Due to a freeze up this winter this wonderful property is ready for you to let your imagination take flight! Just heading up to Rupert Mountain's Merck Forest, and merely two and a half miles from the Dorset green, with views of the Green Mountains and meadowlands, she is waiting for you to love and restore her. The five-bedroom main house and outbuildings include a one bedroom guest cottage, carriage barn, and workshop sited on five acres of land. Come make a special piece of Vermont your own!

    $174,900Est. Payment
    -- Beds | -- Baths | 1,996 Sqft
    230 Church Street, Poultney, VT 05764
    Multi Family For Sale

    MOVE IN READY!! The first floor unit is currently unoccupied and ready for owner occupancy! This could easily be converted back into a single family home with very little effort. The detached 2 car garage offers plenty of storage AND there is a 10x18 concrete pad in place for an additional storage shed if needed. Everything has been done to include new windows, wiring, 4-zone heating system with new state-of-the-art boiler! This lovely village home offers water and sewer as well as all the village amenities within walking distance. With Green Mountain College under new ownership Poultney is headed in a wonderful new direction - come be a part of this revitalization today!!

    $159,000Est. Payment
    -- Beds | -- Baths | 2,459 Sqft
    32 Main Street, Poultney, VT 05764
    Multi Family For Sale

    Solid 3 unit Multifamily located right in the middle of town. Easy walk to shopping, dining and small town charm. Well maintained apartments with some renovations over the years including: 3 newer hot water heaters, some newer appliances, house painted in 2015 and 12 inches of insulation in attic. Apartments consist of a (1) one bedroom, (1) Two bedroom (1) Three bedroom. Large 3 bay garage with workshop areas.

    $150,000Est. Payment
    4 Beds | 2 Baths | 3,146 Sqft
    291 Bentley Avenue, Poultney, VT 05764
    House For Sale

    The Bentley Home - C 1885 was built by Rufus Broughton - a Real Estate agent w/ 19th Century Architecture. A Queen Anne style home that is on the historic registry and has 2 apartments with 2 beds and 1 baths each . The apartments are in good shape but the outside needs updating. If your interested in Vintage homes this could be for you . 48 hr tenants right The property has been owned by the same family for nearly 100 years.

    $125,000Est. Payment
    3.7 Acres
    00 West Lake Road, Poultney, VT 05764
    Lots Land For Sale

    3.7 acre lot that is a portion of a larger parcel as far as the tax bill, but it has already been divided with it's own description. This lot will be sold with shared access to Lake St. Catherine over a lot currently owned by the same owner of this property. That lot is also for sale-23.63 acre lot of $225,000. See photos for map of the lot that the access to the lake will be over. ( The Span # the Deed book and page are for the larger parcel that this lot is part of) There is an opportunity to buy a larger parcel with the remaining portion of this property being available soon)

    $225,000Est. Payment
    23.63 Acres
    2495 West Lake Road, Poultney, VT 05774
    Lots Land For Sale

    Very unique 23.28 Acre parcel with road frontage on West Lake Road and it includes Lot #13 with 100 feet lake front on Lake St. Catherine. This lot is owned by the owner of the lot being sold and is included in this sale but there are 3 other owners who have a right of way to use this lot for access to Lake St. Catherine.

    $145,000Est. Payment
    5 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,652 Sqft
    1292 High Road, Poultney, VT 05764
    House For Sale

    Spacious five bedroom farmhouse in a quiet country location. The lower level has a very large kitchen, large living room, full bath and bedroom. Upstairs there are an additional four bedrooms. Other amenities include a screened in front porch and rear deck off the kitchen providing beautiful views. There is a large yard with plenty of room for gardening. Property is near Lake St. Catherine Park.

    $199,000Est. Payment
    1.1 Acres
    0 Kinni Kinnic Lane 12, Poultney, VT 05764
    Lots Land For Sale

    Lovely building lot in Kinni Kinnic!! Build your dream home on this lovely partially wooded lot with deeded access to Lake St. Catherine. Only a 7 minute drive to Poultney, 3 minutes to Lake St. Catherine Country Club, and practically next door to Lake St. Catherine State Park. This is a much desired community on the main body of the lake with a common area with over 180 feet of direct lake frontage.

How To Finance

As a homebuyer, there are quite a few financing options to consider. Our interactive guide can help find which is right for you, and guide you through the paperwork.

Get Started


5 Beds2 Baths1,920 Sqft

500 York Street, Poultney, VT 05764

Call to ask about this home today!

(833) 252-8033
version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >