141 Homes For Sale in Sag Harbor, NY

Sort by:
$8,250,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,428 Sqft
1 Bluff Point Lane, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

In a very special location overlooking Sag Harbor Cove, this 1.1+/- acre property with 447 ft. of water frontage is a rare offering in a quiet community, on a private, almost secret lane surprisingly close to the Village center. There is much literary history in Sag Harbor but little as storied or as beautiful as Bluff Point Lane. The west facing Point at the end of the private road shares a beach with the former John Steinbeck residence and studio. The three-bedroom cottage is set on a rise overlooking the water and enjoys delightful sea breezes all summer long. The west and north facing property includes two stationary docks, a boat ramp and boat house, a small private beach and stadium seating facing the water. The site can accommodate a 3,538+/- sq. ft. home. A variance and a wetland permit will be needed for expansion to the cottage or a new house and pool. From this magical spot one can fish, clam, kayak, canoe, motor boat, watch July 4th fireworks and enjoy the ever unique nightly sunsets in total privacy or with large gatherings of family and friends. The adjacent property is for sale separately.

$1,295,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,664 Sqft
1257 Sagg Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Just outside the village of the Sag Harbor, this new construction traditional offers three bedrooms, three and a half bathrooms in 2,664+/- sq. ft. of luxury living space set in a private and beautiful setting surrounded by verdant pine and oak trees. Inside, you'll enjoy a brand new canvas to paint your dream home portrait, with entirely new fixtures and appliances throughout. On the finished lower level, the additional living space can be used as an entertainment area, private gym or both. Outside, you can listen to the birds sing as you enjoy your heated gunite pool on .69 of an acre amid detailed specimen landscaping that includes a masonry wall for additional privacy and Hamptons living. In the mornings, relax on your private balcony overlooking the pool while enjoying your coffee before you head out for the day at the beach, the village or local boating and sailing. Do not miss out on this Sag Harbor gem, which offers a luxury living and investment opportunity.

$17,900,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,220 Sqft
2 Bluff Point Lane, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

The year was 1952 and the Pulitzer Prize-winning novelist, John Steinbeck, had just completed the highly acclaimed "East of Eden". A few years later, John and Elaine came to Sag Harbor and fell in love with a sundrenched cottage, tucked away in the trees on a bluff. His newly found "Eden" was his latest in a line of treasured habitats that inspired him to say: "I look forward to Sag Harbor - after seeing you, of course. And do you know, journalism, even my version of it, gives me the crazy desire to go out to my little house on the point, to sharpen fifty pencils, and put out a yellow pad. Early in the morning to hear what the birds are saying and to pass the time of day with Angel and then hitch up my chair to my writing board and to set down the words - "Once upon a time...." By John Steinbeck This inspiring light-filled property, studded with old growth trees is located at the end of a long lane on 1.8+/- acres of a waterfront. Its rare 586+/- sf of waterfront gently slopes down to the water's edge on two sides, overlooking Morris Cove and Upper Sag Harbor Cove and offers unparalleled western facing sunsets. The Main House is a cozy 2 bed, 2 bath cottage-- the perfect place to live your next chapter. The living room is wainscoted and beamed with a cathedral ceiling. Bookcases line one wall opposite french doors which lead to the patio outside. A large fieldstone fireplace graces the head of the room where a painting of "Charlie" hangs prominently. The kitchen opens to a sitting area with a wall of windows overlooking the waterfront and dock. The Steinbeck's created "The Library Loft" - a place for the kids to get away and play, has bookcases on three sides and overlooks the living area - a great place to read or just wile away the time. Out on the point sits John's "Writing House," a gazebo-like structure with windows on all sides. It's a perfect place to watch the waterfront life. The "Cozy Cabin", quest cottage has room enough to sleep two with bathroom and outdoor shower, views over the water and sometimes a sandy beach. The pool, or "Cement Pond" as John called it, rests amidst the spacious trees. From the 60' dock, launch a boat or kayak and head over to the village for lunch, or fish from the end of the pier. This opportunity has unparalleled significance: private, protected by topography of land, waterfront on two sides, upside opportunity for building, 60' dock, and minutes away from the coveted village of Sag Harbor Village. And now the house with a history is waiting for its next stewards .. "CHAPTER ONE BEGINS HERE...."

$1,495,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,588 Sqft
230 Northside Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Incredible Value - off bucolic Deerfield Road, in the blue ribbon Sag Harbor School District, lies the prestigious North Side Hills community. Surrounded by well-appointed homes, 230 Northside Drive sited on an acre, offers 4 bedrooms, 4 full baths, more than 2500 square feet of light-filled living space and great bones! First floor features include a parlor, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen, living room with vaulted ceiling, wood-burning fireplace and glass doors to a poolside dining area overlooking the heated 20x40 pool, plus a Master Bedroom Suite that opens out to the large deck and pool area. There are three welcoming guest bedrooms on the second level, one with an en-suite bathroom and a balcony view of the grounds. Hardwood floors & Andersen windows throughout this wood-clad Postmodern retreat. Central air, central vac. A 2200+ sq. ft. full basement completes the package, which can be finished for additional living space. Recent upgrades include: new roof, skylights, pool heater, furnace, hot water heater, gutters. Priced To Sell! Won't Last! Convenient to Village of Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton, and Southampton.

$8,200,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 6 Baths | 4,218 Sqft
15 Mashomuck Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

This is a stunning property. Floor to ceiling glass doors and windows on two levels of this recently constructed waterfront contemporary located in peaceful North Haven section of Sag Harbor. This modern masterpiece presents a glorious panorama of water and sky with views across the bay to Shelter Island Sound and East Hampton. Light-filled open living areas have glass on two sides and flow easily among indoor and outdoor spaces for entertaining or relaxation. The great room has a built-in banquette and plenty of room for multiple seating areas. The sleek, high end kitchen with island seating and an adjacent dining area present water views in two directions. A state of the art powder room is in a hidden alcove on the main floor. On the second level, the serene water-view master suite, done in gray and white, has a frameless glass-enclosed shower and soaking tub. There are two additional en-suite bedrooms on this level, also with drop dead views, and an area suitable for an office. On the finished lower level is a fourth en-suite bedroom, a living room and another full bath. Outdoors enjoy the heated pool or relax on the deck or on your own stretch of beach. Permit for dock pending. You may never want to leave this little piece of paradise, but if you do, the restaurants, shops and cultural destinations of charming Sag Harbor Village are just minutes away, or take the nearby ferry to Shelter Island.

$5,999,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 4 Baths | 4,312 Sqft
117 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Unique opportunity to own one of Sag Harbor Village's most iconic buildings. The ground floor features 1,150 sf of prime retail space that has been leased to numerous high-end brands over the decades. The three-level, 3,162 sf Traditional is located on coveted Main Street, in the center of world-class restaurants, shops, theaters and marinas. The residential portion of the home can be accessed on Main Street or through the plush grounds on Church Street. The interior of the residence offers stunning details throughout, with exposed wood beams, seven custom brick fireplaces, and hardwood flooring. The first floor features a spacious living room, formal dining room, gourmet kitchen, butler's pantry, laundry, and a full bath. The eat-in kitchen contains state-of-the-art appliances, double ovens, and center island. French doors lead out to a spacious brick patio, heated gunite pool, and lush manicured backyard. Stairs lead to the second floor which offers three bedrooms, an office and a full bath. The habitable third floor features two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and ample storage. Multiple permitted uses, with expansion possibilities.

$9,250,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 8 Baths | 8,000 Sqft
81 Day Lily Lane, Bridgehampton, NY 11963
House For Sale

Photos don't do justice to this exquisite property minutes from Bridgehampton Village. Well-hidden at the end of a long winding driveway, this unique compound has been included in the prestigious East Hampton Garden Club House and Garden Tour and featured in the recently released book: "Behind The Privets: Classic Hamptons Homes." by Barons and Rumbough. Encompassing nearly seven acres of manicured lawns, rolling meadows, pool and tennis court, this is a property rarely found. Conceived as a private country retreat merging spectacular living spaces with two authentic artist studios, this 8,000+/- sq. ft. barn-style home features a majestic great room with 25' ft ceilings and walls, a large fireplace and beams and floors constructed entirely from solid pine. The great room and adjacent dining room and open kitchen form the heart of the home and flow naturally out French doors to a south facing blue-stone patio with exceptional views of open sky and beautiful landscaping. Five distinct barns are connected by a striking 120' ft breezeway which looks out upon a beautiful English style garden. The space is artfully divided into separate zones dedicated to gathering, cooking, entertaining, sleeping and studio space. The Eastern wing accommodates a master suite with dual dressing rooms and an impressive library also constructed entirely of solid pine. A western wing features two guest rooms plus an entire guest annex with three additional bedrooms and a central charming den. Both the stunning heated gunite pool and clay tennis court are away from the house and partially hidden by mature privet hedge, making the year round views extraordinary. Additionally there is a two-car garage and a large finished basement. Designed to fit the spirit of its magical location, the elegant simplicity of this barn complex is the perfect setting for modern living.

$4,250,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 5 Baths | 3,300 Sqft
22 Maple Ln, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Waterfront 2.4 acres with Dock If you, like so many others, are considering the best options for yourself, and loved ones, in our covid-facing world, this gorgeous, extremely private Sag Harbor home - just on the market - is your answer. Nestled into 2.4 acres of secluded waterfront property, this home assures some of the most exclusive space in the Hamptons. A rolling yard of pastoral acreage, hot tub, salt water pool and a private boat dock will make it hard not to have fun. The water offers a host of activities, from jumping into your motor-, ski- or sailboat and exploring the waters and towns of Sag Harbor, Shelter Island and Greenport, or hopping on a kayak or paddle board to explore the sensational local nature. The newly renovated home offers a light, bright common area including a stunning stainless steel kitchen, which opens to both interior and exterior dining and living areas, for plenty of comfortable entertaining space. The house offers 4 bedrooms, each with their own working space, including a fully independent home office. An expansive Master deck makes you feel like you are on top of the world - and is the perfect place for morning coffee, or a sunset cocktail. The house has 5 full bathrooms - including an exquisite master bath with free standing glass shower - not to be missed! Perfectly situated, it's possible to get to Southampton, Bridgehampton, Sag Harbor and Easthampton without ever getting on a major road - which lets you skip the Summer traffic! The lovely surrounding towns offer a lovely community for all different lifestyles - which is what makes living in the Hamptons year round so great! And if by any chance you do have children to think about, this jewel of a home falls flatly in the middle of the Pierson High School district. This small, seemingly private, highly accredited High School offers the prestigious International Baccalaureate (IB) degree, which is considered by many to be the best college preparatory program in the world, and

$12,995,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,812 Sqft
314 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Multi Family For Sale

Whaling Captain Pierson's House situated prominently on the largest waterfront lot on Captain's Row in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, is an idyllic 2-building historic compound commanding breathtaking panoramic views over Upper Sag Harbor Cove making it a very rare and coveted property in the Hamptons market. The original house, rich in history was built in 1790 and expanded in 1820 during the Whaling era and features 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths and original windows, fireplace mantels, doors, staircase with whale tail moldings and shipboard floorboards throughout. The sun-drenched living-room parlor leads to a renovated chef's kitchen and an inviting sun porch. The 2nd floor includes the primary bedroom's, large sitting room, a guest bedroom and an additional bonus room with a deck overlooking the water. The charming attic has three bedrooms and was added onto in 1890. Tucked behind the main house in a wonderland of mature natural landscaping, the renovated waterfront artist studio, built in 2007 has a delightful living room warmed by a fireplace, and a full bathroom, a claw-foot tub/shower, central AC, and a dining area which opens to a path down to a private beach giving you water access to Sag Harbor Cove that leads out to the bay. There are plans, permits, and approvals in place for a beautiful renovation and expansion which includes adding a pool, garage, and terraces. Explore the natural beauty of the cove and open bay waters by boat, kayak or paddle board. Enjoy glorious sun all day, extraordinary sunsets in the evening, dinner in ultra-charming Sag Harbor Village, the marinas, the quaint shops and some of the best restaurants in the Hamptons without getting into a car. A world class Hamptons lifestyle, just minutes to polo, golf, tennis and some of the best beaches in the world. A rare opportunity to own a part of Sag Harbor's treasured history in such a picturesque and outstanding location will not last.

$1,900,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,800 Sqft
3752 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Beautiful Cape Cod House Totally Updated With 3 Bedroom and 3 Full Baths on Three Levels. Main Floor Features an Open Living Room with Stacked Stone Fireplace, Recently renovated Eat in Kitchen, Full Bath and Three Season Porch, all with French Doors Leading to The Patio and Pool Area. The Second Floor Has Two Bedrooms and a Full Bath With Jacuzzi and a Deck Off the Master Bedroom. The Lower Level Features a Den/media Room, Bedroom, Full Bath and Laundry Room. Outside is a Large landscaped Backyard with Heated Salt Water Pool and Waterfall. Close to Sag Harbor Village Shops, Restaurants and 5 Minutes Walk From Long Beach. Wont Last. Great Summer Rental History. More pictures coming soon.

$3,600,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 5 Baths | 4,500 Sqft
1584 Noyac Path, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

This modern 5 bedroom/4.5 bath home with architectural lines is like its own private resort...You never need to leave this gated estate. The lush, private 2.2 acre property features a 50' Infinity Pool, 8-person Hot Tub, Sunken Tennis, and Spa with Sauna. Manicured grounds and expansive flat lawn are perfect for entertaining. Inside, 10-16' ceilings and walls of windows allow for fantastic light. The top level features a full-floor entertainment area with treetop views and a dramatic loft feel. It includes an oversized living room, dining room, modern rift oak kitchen, breakfast room and deck with dining for 16. There are fantastic tree-top views on all sides. One flight up, a full floor roof deck offers water views with stunning sunsets--perfect for cocktail hour. The middle level has an enormous walk-out master suite, with covered porch and a master bath with spa jet tub and Dornbracht faucets. There are 3 additional bedrooms on the middle floor, with 2 full baths. The ground level features a 5th bedroom, the junior master, with its own sitting area, kitchenette and spa with sauna. It sits just off the pool and hot tub, so it can also function as a pool house if desired. The home is centrally located, where Bridgehampton, Water Mill and Sag Harbor intersect. The area is quiet and private, just few minutes to Long Beach and local marinas, and 10 minutes to Southampton, Bridgehampton or Sag Harbor Village. Sag Harbor school district. Fully renovated with new interiors, siding and all new mechanicals, this property is tunkey and ready for move-in.

$1,295,000Est. Payment
2 Acres
182 Wildwood Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Lots Land For Sale

At the end of a private 1/4 mile drive sits one of the most special remaining Sag Harbor parcels. This is an incredibly unique find--a fully prepped lot, ready for building, surrounded by reserve on 3 sides for total privacy...offering views, tennis and community bay access...and under $1.3MM! The property is perched at the highest part of Noyac Golf Course, with gorgeous first-floor views down the length of a 138 acre manicured golf course. Second floor and roofdeck views are even better, over the entire course and out to Noyac Bay. This 2.1 acre lot, with favorable R-80 Zoning, offers an estate presence that couldn't be replicated, as it is surrounded by 135 acres of preserve on 3 sides. There are miles of hiking trails to explore from your own back yard. And you'll never hear or see a car, as the front yard overlooks manicured grounds 12 months a year, as far as you can see. The property was just prepped for building--with a 500' long driveway consructed, property cleared, and house/pool/tennis plotted and staked. Architect plans and health department permits may be facilitated at buyer's request. This parcel allows generous 35% clearing and a tremendous building envelope. It sits in Sag Harbor's exceptional school district, a minute to bay beaches and boat moorings. It is equidistant to Southampton, Watermill, Bridgehampton and Sag Harbor Village.

$5,999,000Est. Payment
10 Beds | 11 Baths | 5,942 Sqft
375 Brick Kiln Road, Bridgehampton, NY 11963
House For Sale

Enjoy peace and privacy on this gated 5.23+/- acre estate in Bridgehampton with two homes and two pools. The two homes between them have ten bedrooms, nine full and two half baths. A new construction two-story residence built by Farrell has seven bedrooms, six full and one half baths, plus an additional half bath off the patio. Enter to light-filled open living areas flowing among a living room with fireplace and glass doors to a spacious stone patio, built in bbq and pool area, dining area also with glass doors to the patio, and eat-in kitchen with waterfall island with seating and stainless steel appliances by Wolf, Sub-Zero and Bosch. A first floor junior master suite includes a bath with double vanity and frameless glass-enclosed shower. A den/TV room is also on this level, along with a powder room and attached two-car garage. Four upstairs en-suite bedrooms include the luxurious master suite which features radiant-heated flooring, glass doors to a private terrace, and bath with marble-topped double vanity, soaking tub and frameless glass-enclosed steam shower. In the finished lower level are two bedrooms, a full bath, media lounge, wet bar, mirrored gym with ballet barre, infrared sauna and full wall of extra storage closets. Outdoors enjoy the 1,600+/- sq. ft. of bluestone patio, 20' x 40' heated gunite pool and spa, tennis with sport court finish and basketball. Additional amenities include 5" white oak flooring throughout, child fencing and electric gates. The second house was built in 1963 by Andrew Geller, who designed a series of quirky, playful weekend homes. For this one, the Betty Reese House, he adapted an A-frame design, flattening the roof, modifying the slant of the walls and adding triangular windows. In 2012 this noteworthy home was thoughtfully gut renovated and redesigned by local designer John Bjornen, who updated all of the electrical and plumbing systems, painted the interiors white, including the original stone fireplace, to bring in more l

$2,095,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,322 Sqft
140 Ferry Road/Rt 114, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Meticulously renovated, this classic shingle house has a fresh contemporary interior and a Savant/Lutron smart home system that allows for full remote management and state of the art home entertainment. Designer decorated with top of the line finishes and appliances. The living area includes a cozy window seat, a gas fireplace and formal dining room, and separate sitting area with ample space. The kitchen includes a Wolf gas range / oven and separate convection oven / microwave, a Sub-Zero refrigerator and wine refrigerator, and a Miele dishwasher. The powder room, laundry room and dog washing station, are conveniently located off the kitchen. Upstairs there are three bedrooms and two bathrooms which have been designed with comfort in mind. There is an oversized master bedroom suite, complete with a separate seating area and an en-suite bathroom with steam shower and whirlpool tub. The backyard offers complete privacy and beautiful gardens, mature trees and privet, new fencing, and a large saltwater gunite pool. The house is a stone's throw from Sag Harbor Village, and from bay beaches. Listing ID:874602

$575,000Est. Payment
1 Bed | 1 Bath | -- Sqft
23 Maple Lane, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Nestled on a quiet waterfront cul-de-sac is a rare development opportunity with approvals in place to build a new modern two-story home with a water views from the second story and a wraparound deck to take in all the surrounding beauty. Alternatively there is a income producing cottage with low taxes that comes with mooring rights and is only 350 ft. to a launch for boats, kayaks and paddle boards. The property is adjacent to the vast 187-acre Elizabeth A. Morton Wildlife Refuge for complete privacy and serenity. Enjoy the sandy beaches with views of the surrounding nature preserve and amazing sunsets or take off by boat to visit Greenport or Shelter Island, the options are endless with this easy water access. Its equidistant from Southampton, Bridgehampton and Sag Harbor for exploring all that the Hamptons has to offer.

$3,150,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,950 Sqft
49 Rysam Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

On a very desirable street in the heart of Sag Harbor Village this historic Greek Revival home built in 1834 has been brilliantly renovated in an inspired synthesis of old and new. The renovation retained and restored all of the home's original architectural details while adding comprehensive 21st century amenities. Situated on .24+/- acre - a large lot for the village - the property feels even bigger and includes a legal cottage and a grandfathered shed. The 1,950+/- sq. ft. home has two bedrooms and two full baths. On the first floor the living room includes a wood-burning fireplace and built-in recessed shelving. The dining room is in the center of this floor, and the kitchen with Bertazzoni range is to one side. In the rear of the home is a spacious family room with exposed original beams and ceiling, a wood-burning stove and large windows on two sides. Upstairs is the master bedroom with fireplace, beamed ceiling, window banquette and built-in storage original to the house. A full bath and second bedroom complete this level. Outdoors is a brick patio and pea gravel "backyard" with a flowering cherry tree, a fire pit and heated gunite pool with benches, jets and an automatic cover. A secret path leads to an outdoor living room and dining area, and the legal pre-existing, nonconforming cottage which contains a stunning living room, kitchenette and bath. A separate sitting area with fountain also leads to the cottage. Conveniently located a block to the marina and a few blocks in the other direction to restaurants and shops.

$4,495,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 8 Baths | 7,261 Sqft
28 Barclay Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
House For Sale

Divinely appointed, this beautiful, custom traditional home is located in the coveted waterfront community of West Banks, North Haven. A designer's own home, this property has elegant style and sophistication with a serene setting reflective of a shining gem. A desirable open floor plan offering 7,000 sq ft + of living space and custom craftsmanship with vaulted ceilings and wide glass doors and windows allowing in the coastal bright light, sea air and sunshine. This property envelope also has the potential to increase the square footage by an additional 3000 sq ft. Offering a spacious eat-in chef's kitchen, a living room with custom built-in bookcases and fireplace hearth, a formal dining room and custom mahogany bar all over looking outdoor patios for al fresco dining. A separate wing completely dedicated to a large VIP master suite for privacy is also included on your first level. The second floor offers 3 delightful ensuite bedrooms, including a very large master suite, spa-like marble bath and a beautiful dressing room. A generous bonus room and laundry room are also great features on this floor. Your fully-finished, entertainment lower level offers extra space that only enhances this already perfect home. Outdoors, a heated gunite pool with expansive sun-filled patios , a gazebo and poolside bar all with mature, lush landscaping completes this gorgeous property. Community tennis, a deep water dock and just steps to your private sandy beachfront with westerly sunset makes this truly unsurpassed tranquility.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >