23 Houses For Sale in Sagaponack, NY

Sort by:
$2,950,000Est. Payment
7 Beds | 5 Baths | 4,368 Sqft
877 Sagg Road, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

A complete renovation and expansion in 2019 has transformed a one-story home into a spacious and artfully crafted contemporary residence. The renovation has expanded the home to a total of 4368 square feet, with 2607 square feet on the two levels above ground and 1761 square feet on the beautifully finished lower level. Thoughtfully considered down to the last detail, the seven bedroom, five bath home on 1.28 acres is ideal for entertaining or enjoying peaceful Sagaponack living. Enter to light-filled open interiors with white walls and ceilings and beautiful wood floors, stairs and handrails. A living room with wood-burning fireplace flows to a sitting area with skylight and French doors opening to outdoor entertaining areas. The eat-in kitchen and dining area is flooded with light from skylights and a wall of large windows, and features Caesarstone countertops, Ann Sacks ceramic tile backsplash, Viking Professional range and Sub-Zero refrigerator. Off the sitting area is a hallway with pantry closet, linen closet and hidden laundry. A full bath has Caesarstone vanity, glass shower with subway tile walls and penny dot tile floors, and a guest bedroom across the hall. Also on this level is an en-suite bedroom with bath with double Caesarstone vanity, tub-shower with subway tile walls and penny dot tile floors. A second floor added in 2019 provides two additional bedrooms with private balconies, sharing a bath with double Caesarstone vanity, frameless glass enclosed tub/shower with marble subway tile walls and porcelain tile flooring. In the finished lower level with porcelain plank floors find a wet bar, large recreation area and two bedrooms, one with sitting area, sharing a full bath. Outdoor spaces are wonderful for entertaining or simply enjoying life. A large, open deck with barbecue off the first floor leads to a brick patio by the heated saltwater pool, with an outdoor dining area, lounge with fire pit and outdoor heater - all beautifully lit at night. A seco

$16,995,000Est. Payment
6 Beds | 7 Baths | 7,000 Sqft
138 Seascape Lane, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Facing west over the prestigious Sagg Pond with expansive views of farm, pond, and ocean, this stunning modern retreat designed by Stelle Lomont Rouhani Architects, features a multiple structured gated modern piece of art. Methodically constructed over several years, the owners spared no expense in site design, infrastructure development, and finishes. With over 7,000 sq. ft. and 6 bedrooms throughout, the main residence includes a 2,433 sq. ft first floor with luxurious open kitchen, dining room, living room, media room, separate attached guest house with 2 guest bedrooms and 2 ensuite bathrooms, first floor finished office, and additional 1,200 sq. ft. finished walkout lower level with a high-grade movie theater, laundry room, mudroom with built-in cabinetry, and 2 car garage. The second level spans 1,684 sq. ft. and includes 2 additional guest bedrooms with a 900 sq. ft. walkout deck overlooking Sagg Pond, the ocean, and adjacent farmland. The second floor is highlighted by a master bedroom suite enhanced by floor-to-ceiling windows enhancing the light and full western sunset views of farmland and Sagg Pond. Additional features include 5,581 sq. ft. of exterior decking, upgraded construction elements such as an enhanced insulation package, a steel bulkhead, marine wood, smart-home technology, custom lighting, and several other states of the art features and amenities. The luxurious pool area features an elevated infinity-edge pool and spa that enhances the sunset pond, farm, and oceanview experience, a1,658 sq. ft. pool house adjoins the pool and includes a kitchen, gym, or entertainment area, full bath and shower, and lower level bonus room.

Let's get you that Dream Home!

See A Home You Love? Call Monica Reiner Today!

(631) 259-7125
$9,950,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 5 Baths | 3,376 Sqft
98 Daniels Lane, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Surrounded by farm fields on Daniel's Lane in Sagaponack South, this exceptional 1.1 acre compound sheltered by mature trees features a stylishly renovated circa 1896 farmhouse, guest cottage with 2 car garage, heated gunite pool and spa, pool house gym, and infrastructure for hobby farming. Past the three shuttered dormers and columned, covered porch that compose the charming front facade, enter the 4-bedroom main house with interiors clad in the meticulously restored, original wainscoting and molding. A sympathetic but supremely stylish renovation preserved many original details, from the doors to the antique push button light switches, while adding contemporary indoor and outdoor lighting, and luxury, modern conveniences like Sonos Home Audio and Nest Thermostats. The front door opens to the foyer with powder bath and living room with original fireplace and a wall of paned windows with banquette beneath. The gourmet kitchen features a long, 2-inch marble-topped island, commercial stainless steel prep tables, custom teak plywood shelving and cabinetry, and top of the line appliances from Subzero, Wolf, and Bosch. Off the kitchen, the dramatic sitting and dining room with beamed, cathedral ceiling, hanging fireplace and large picture windows leads to the rear covered porch and brick dining patio. The upstairs has 4 bedrooms and 3 baths with marble showers and vanities and contemporary fixtures. The master suite has a dressing room, desk nook, and a lavish bath with oversized steam shower, free-standing tub, and dual vanities. The former barn crowned with a jaunty cupola was converted into an airy, loft-like guest house with ample fenestration. Landscaped for privacy, the heated gunite pool and spa with bluestone patio is complemented by a pool house gym with steam shower, and a pair of sliding glass disappearing doors. The enclosed garden with architecturally significant chicken coop has produced organic fruits, vegetables, herbs, flowers, and honey for an unbeatably local farm to table existence. The farm shed has an outdoor potting sink covered by a sleek breezeway. The epitome of farm chic located on prime Sagaponack soil.

$12,500,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 5 Baths | 8,000 Sqft
19 Sagg Pond Court, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Stunning panoramic ocean and pond views that span a 23 acre reserve instantly captivate from this unique Sagaponack estate setting. Located on a quiet cul-de-sac, simply a direct 1/2 mile to Sagg Main beach, enjoy spontaneous access to the ocean. The Interior has four bedrooms with expansion approval for eight, five baths, office, two dens, three fireplaces and a finished lower level. Soaring ceilings of 21 feet with glass doors and windows invite in the flow of abundant natural light with Southwest exposure for fabulous sunsets, ocean, pond and reserve views. The waterside 50 foot swimming pool holds ocean views over the expansive field and is surrounded by multiple stone patios, second floor balconies and lush green lawns. Specimen trees with lavish gardens infuse color and ensure intimate privacy. The sunken all weather tennis court enclosed with stacked stone and landscaped for privacy with various viewings areas complete this inspired lifestyle by the sea in an incomparable setting.

$3,500,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,285 Sqft
788 Sagg Road, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

This expansive 2.72+/- acre property currently hosts a 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath cottage with 2,285+/- sq. ft. of living space. The existing home has hardwood flooring, living room, dining room and open kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Additional amenities include a fireplace and central air. Exceptional craftsmanship and detail throughout makes this property highly unique and desirable. There is room for a new pool and tennis to be built.

$4,495,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 6 Baths | 5,742 Sqft
9 Forest Crossing, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

This 1.43 acre property in Sagponack is the site of a new construction home with a 20' x 40' heated saltwater gunite pool. Offering 5,742+/- sq. ft. of living space with 5 bedrooms and 5.5 baths, this masterfully constructed home is beautifully finished and appointed. Enter from the portico to a double height foyer leading to an oversized great room with wood-burning fireplace, which flows to the eat-in kitchen with island seating and high end stainless steel appliances. Multiple glass doors open to a rear terrace overlooking the pool and grounds. The kitchen flows to a formal dining room at the front of the home, and also has access to an attached two-car garage. On the other side of the foyer find an en-suite bedroom with full bath; a half bath is also on this level. Upstairs is the spacious master suite featuring a large bedroom with tray ceiling, three large walk-in closets and a huge master bath with soaking tub, frameless glass-enclosed shower, double vanity and private water closet. Three additional bedrooms, one en suite and two sharing a bath with double vanity, are also on this level, along with a laundry room. The finished lower level has a full bath, two large rooms to finish as desired, and generous storage space. Located in the Sag Harbor School District, the home is convenient to Sag Harbor Village, Bridgehampton and ocean beaches

$6,400,000Est. Payment
8 Beds | 10 Baths | 9,607 Sqft
363 Wainscott Harbor Road, Sagaponack, NY 11968
House For Sale

This just-shy 2 acre parcel on Wainscott Harbor Road in Sagaponack can accommodate a large home with pool, spa, cabana and tennis. Located in the Sag Harbor School District, in easy reach of Sag Harbor Village, Bridgehampton and ocean beaches. Build your dream home here!

$5,400,000Est. Payment
8 Beds | 9 Baths | 9,101 Sqft
482 Wainscott Harbor Road, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Build your dream home on this 1.3+ acre parcel in Sagaponack, with a 50' wide conservation easement in front of the property and a 100' easement in back. This property can accommodate a 7,000+/- sq. ft. home with 50' pool, spa and cabana. Located in the Sag Harbor School District, with easy access to Sag Harbor Village, Bridgehampton and ocean beaches.

$11,995,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 7 Baths | 5,900 Sqft
543 Hedges Lane, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Few properties compare to this south of the highway farmhouse masterpiece, adjacent to 100+ acres of protected serene and pastoral farmland on idyllic Hedges Lane. Nestled on 1.75 acres and mere minutes from the Atlantic Ocean waves and white sandy beaches, this impressive 5,900+/- SF modern barn-style residence boasts sweeping western views with mesmerizing sunsets pierced with striking stripes of deep blue, purple, pink and orange. Among the highlights within the farmhouse are original barn timber, gorgeous handpicked reclaimed Pennsylvania pine floors and millwork throughout, as well as metal doors from a Brooklyn firehouse affixed with hardware from a Pennsylvania train station. All of the unique reclaimed wood, fixtures, hardware and finish details were thoughtfully curated by the homeowners and master local builder and restorer Bob Tortora. The home is complete with 4 large bedrooms, 6.5 bathrooms and exquisite custom touches throughout, including a private oversized master suite with two full baths and office/lounge area on the upper level. The main floor is bathed in natural light boasting a giant glassed-in living area surrounded by an open modern kitchen plan and a cozy den with full laundry and linen room and the three ensuite guest bedrooms. The expansive lower level with high ceilings is the perfect place to create substantial additional living and entertaining space, if required, to suit anyone's needs. Here, with the sound of the ocean in the background, an effortless Sagaponack lifestyle unfolds with old growth trees around the property and in the back, a chicken coop modern structure which is home to a rare sunken indoor 55ft lap pool with electric cover and Desert Aire System, sauna and full bath. From the indoor pool, enjoy views to the outdoor relaxation gunite pool and lounging area overlooking endless farmland. The front and back of the property are bracketed by fields of wildflowers and privet to the East giving the home complete privacy. Back

$14,950,000Est. Payment
8 Beds | 12 Baths | 9,592 Sqft
46 Hildreth Lane, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

State of the art - unparalleled top of the line constructed 9,600 +/- sq. ft. 3 story modern, perfectly sited on 1 +/- acre, 8 ensuite bedrooms and 12 baths with views overlooking Poxabogue Pond. Floor to ceiling windows allow for true indoor/outdoor living. The first floor offers a grand chefs kitchen with top of the line appliances, library, full bar, office and 2 ensuite bedrooms. The second floor features a luxurious master suite with electric shades and terrace, 3 additional ensuite bedrooms and access to the second story deck with views over the manicured grounds and pond. The lower level is not to be missed - a spectacular dining/wine room made for entertaining leads to a 5,000 bottle wine cellar. A theater, game room, sauna plus 2 ensuite bedrooms complete the lower level. Plenty of space for outdoor entertaining around the salt water infinity edge pool and complete privacy framed by mature trees. This rock solid top of the line luxuriously appointed residence has been enjoyed by many celebrities, eg: Beyonce and Jay-Z and others. First time offering. Exclusive. Beate V. Moore

$4,250,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 5 Baths | 3,930 Sqft
44 Greenleaf Lane, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Sited on 2.8 acres, on a quiet cul-de-sac, in prestigious Sagaponack Village, this property features a builders' own custom-built farmhouse with an attached 3-car garage, an additional detached barn, and room for tennis. The heart of the home is the great room, with its 20 ft. vaulted ceilings, beautiful barn-like beams, stone fireplace, and large sliding doors that lead to the pool area. The kitchen is well designed and well equipped, with island seating, plentiful counter space and storage, and an additional walk-in pantry. There is a first floor powder room that also serves as the pool bath, and there is a sizable first floor laundry room. The first floor also features a welcoming foyer that leads to the formal living room, formal dining room, and a large office, and separate service/mudroom entrance. On the other end of the spacious first floor, we find three bedrooms including an en-suite bedroom that overlooks the pool, and two additional bedrooms with built-in desks and storage that share a hall bath. Upstairs we find the master, with wraparound windows and high ceilings that make for a bright and sunny space. The lower level has 10 ft. ceilings, is partially finished with an exercise/recreation room, a half bath, and an additional 1,830+/- sq. ft. of unfinished convertible space. There is a whole house generator in place. The attached 3-car garage with attic storage presents plenty of additional unfinished space that could be re-imagined. Outside we are greeted by large swaths of green grass, established specimen trees, a freeform pool, an outdoor shower, and a dreamy detached barn with a full basement, a half loft, and room for an additional 4 cars. For those interested in expanding or redeveloping, the lot supports a home of up to 8,410 sq. ft. above ground of finished space, a total of 9,672 finished and unfinished sq. ft. above ground, lot coverage of 37,999, and room for tennis

$4,595,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,546 Sqft
493 Sagaponack Road, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

On Sagg Pond! This luxurious & sophisticated home is just minutes away from Sagg Main Ocean Beach as well as the 100-acre Sagg Preserve. It also lies within close proximity to both Bridgehampton and Sag Harbor Village, offering an abundance of Shops, Restaurants, Entertainment and the Waterfront. This 3/4 Bedroom, 3 1/2 Bath residence was custom built with a keen sense of design, purpose & superior craftsmanship! The home offers plentiful opportunities to unwind and relax as you take in the stunning Sagg Pond views from almost everywhere in the residence! This modern, spectacular beauty boasts 3500+ square feet, replete with high-end materials and finishes throughout! Situated on 1.15 Acres, this one-of-a-kind residence also features a posh, gunite plunge pool & separate hot-tub, perfectly sited to overlook Sagg Pond, as well as a private dock leading out to Sagg Pond and Sagg Ocean Beach. This is a must-see, private enclave with opportunities to expand!

$28,800,000Est. Payment
14 Beds | 20 Baths | 16,000 Sqft
414 & 414a Hedges Lane, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

2 Homes with 2 adjacent single and separate lots , totaling over 3.2 acres overlooking protected farmland. All brand new and awaiting your arrival. The pictures tell the story or call for details.

$1,320,000Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,257 Sqft
429 Sagg Road, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Bright and airy with an open floor plan, this 2 bedroom (potentially 3+) and 2 bathroom home is perfectly located--5 minutes from Sag Harbor, 5 minutes from the beach, 5 minutes to Bridgehampton, 10 minutes from East Hampton. A fifty-foot setback from the road and a wooded half-acre afford privacy. The oversized great room with high ceilings has 3 skylights and exposed beams. Separate living room contains a wood-burning fireplace and the formal dining area is fully windowed for abundant summer light. The second floor contains a large master bedroom, bathroom with tub and shower, and separate toilet area. The attached garage will keep you dry in the rain, with a laundry room and mudroom just inside. Also, a priceless amenity; there is a standby generator with automatic transfer and 1000 gallon propane tank that will will power the entire house for 2 weeks.

$2,750,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 4 Baths | 3,115 Sqft
86 Northwest Path, Sagaponack, NY 11963
House For Sale

If privacy and seclusion are required for your weekend recharge, this is the vacation retreat you are looking for. Set back far from the street by a long winding driveway through the woods, on 2.9 acres, your shingled cottage emerges. Expertly executed by a top East End builder with an open floor plan and windows placed to bring the outside in, the home offers 3,115+/- sq. ft. of living space on the first two levels. The first level consists of a generous two-story living room with a large field stone fireplace for those cozy fall/winter nights. Any cook will love the gourmet kitchen with stainless steel appliances and plenty of workspace on the granite countertops to create feasts for family and friends. A dining room overlooks the rear yard. Two bedrooms along with full bathroom are perfect for guests. The upper level consists of a larger master bedroom where you can unwind, plus two more generous bedrooms and another full bath. The finished lower level adds another 1,680 sq. ft. and has a billiard room, two rooms for work space etc, bath and gym. Outside is a full-sized pool and generous deck with a spa. The only item missing is you, relaxing in a deck lounge listening to the oak leaves rustle, reading a book. Yoga on the deck? Long relaxing strolls? Or simply doing nothing. Wonderfully located within a short distance to vineyards and multiple village centers, where your toughest decision will be deciding in which one of our fabulous restaurants to dine. All this is waiting for you at a very reasonable price. Updated Survey with room for Tennis Court plotted (or more clearing) Owner obtaining permit for tennis court.

$4,250,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 5 Baths | 5,500 Sqft
21 Forest Crossing, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

This 2+ acre property in Sagaponack is the site of a new construction home with pool, pool house and tennis. Enter to a foyer, off which is a study with vaulted ceiling and fireplace; a dining room is on the opposite side of the floor. A central hallway with powder room leads to a spacious two-story great room with a wall of windows, gas fireplace and glass doors to a patio. The eat-in kitchen includes an island with seating, prep area, gas range, wet bar, pantry and butler's pantry. Glass doors open to a rear terrace overlooking the grounds and pool area. On the other side of the floor, past the study, is the master suite which includes a large bedroom, luxe bath with double vanity and frameless glass-enclosed shower, and an oversized walk-in closet with access to attic storage. On the second floor are four additional bedrooms - two en suite and two sharing a bath. All have walk-in closets. The lower level with 9' ceilings is ready to finish as desired. Located in the Sag Harbor School District, the home has easy access to Sag Harbor Village, Bridgehampton and ocean beaches.

$11,995,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,426 Sqft
331 Sagaponack Main Street, Sagaponack, NY 11962
House For Sale

Outstanding opportunity to renovate the existing home, or build a custom compound, on this rectangular 3.10+/- acre lot located amidst some of the most sought-after property in the Hamptons. The parcel's rolling lawns are set across from a 15+/- acre agricultural reserve, near to local farm stands, and are a short distance directly down the street to magnificent Sagg Main Beach's sunny southern exposure on the Atlantic Ocean. The existing traditional 2400+/- square foot home features 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths with an open kitchen/dining floorplan. A living room, and separate family room, both with exposed beams, large swimming pool, and detached garage with capacity for 4 automobiles are also included, or build your own 8700 +/- SF House, Pool, Pool House and Sunken Tennis Court.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >