High visibility location in center of town. Business zoned for many different uses, .75 acres, architectural plans avail...
$550,000
View Est. Payment
110 Houses For Sale in Shelter Island, NY
Sort by:
Closest Match
West Neck Bay waterfront building lot with use of community dock.
$1,000,000
View Est. Payment
This 4 bedroom 5 bath colonial is the ideal island getaway. Start your day with coffee on the charming wraparound porch....
$975,000
View Est. Payment
$280,000
Heroic water views, blazing sunsets and a private dock are just part of the prologue to the story that introduces Four S...
$9,495,000
View Est. Payment
This Classic Island Farmhouse recently listed and offered for the first time in decades has been upgraded through the ye...
$850,000
View Est. Payment
$15,000
Surrounded by greenery, privacy abounds at this totally renovated in 2019 structure, four bedrooms, three bathrooms, sle...
$1,285,000
View Est. Payment
This lovely mid-century modern has it all. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, exquisite 42' x 21' heated gunite swimming pool with mar...
$1,250,000
View Est. Payment
$59,001
BEST VALUE ON SHELTER ISLAND!!! Complete Top to Bottom Renovation. MUST SEE!! 5 BEDROOMS!!!2 Baths, Gourmet Kitchen Just...
$759,999
View Est. Payment
A bucolic slice of nature with beautiful Westerly water views of Fresh Pond. This waterfront cottage features a watersid...
$1,300,000
View Est. Payment
Located a stone's throw from Wades Beach, this charming 1954 traditional offers three levels of finished living space wi...
$1,290,000
View Est. Payment
Located in the estate section of Ram Island on Shelter Island, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to build your ho...
$2,750,000
View Est. Payment
$100,000
TWO HEARTHS: Constructed in1848, this classic Greek Revival, a notable gem of Shelter Island, has been perfectly restore...
$1,350,000
View Est. Payment
Part of Original Westmoreland Subdivision nestled among 70 yr old pine trees, cedar shingled Ranch is on 1/2 acre park l...
$799,000
View Est. Payment
Bucolic English Country inspired 2-acre estate on secluded parcel. Classic interior, gracious common rooms, fireplace, c...
$2,988,000
View Est. Payment
New Listing - Ready for Sale THE STYLE: New Victorian THE LOCATION: Hay Beach close to golf, and sandy beaches ATTRIBUTE...
$870,000
View Est. Payment
Upon entering this charming farmhouse with original details, one feels like they have stepped back in time with its larg...
$1,250,000
View Est. Payment
Adjacent to - acres of preserved land this well sited home is turnkey and ready for new owners. Upon entering the foyer ...
$1,475,000
View Est. Payment
1 to 17 of 110 Results
Location data not available