loading

14 Parcels of Land For Sale in Shelter Island, NY

Sort by:
New
$1,350,000Est. Payment
9 Acres
32 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Beautiful Estate Setting On The Historic Isle Of Shelter Island. Asserting A Total Of 9.74 Acres, The Property Faces South Directly On Coecles Harbor, Encompassing An Unmatched 1/3 Mile Of Water Frontage, & 360 Degree Water Views Inclusive Of Gardiners Bay. Truly An Exceptional Property For Those Looking For Ultimate Privacy, & Relaxation!

$2,495,000
$16,235,000Est. Payment
13.45 Acres
1 3a/3b 4 5 Pandion Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Pandion is a once in a lifetime opportunity to own a cherished piece of Shelter Island. Lot #1 is a waterfront parcel at 3.62 acres that could have a 10,000 sq. ft. house. Lot 3A & 3B are a combined duo of waterfront lots totaling 6 acres and will allow up to a 18,000 square feet house. Lot #4 is a 3.83 acre lot with water views of Coecles Harbor that could accommodate up to a 10,000 sq. ft. house. Lot #5 perched atop Pandion is 3.77 acres and can accommodate up to a 10,000 sq. ft. house. All four parcels would need special town permits for their size of each house over 6000 s.f. There is also the potential for a private dock on lots 1 and 3a/b and lots 3 a/b could also have its own tennis court and a paddock. Pandion is a residential neighborhood of remarkable natural beauty comprised of 24.8 acres. With its sweeping views of Coecles Harbor, Ram Island, the protected lands of Mashomack Preserve and Gardiners Bay in the distance, Pandion is unique on Shelter Island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve the environmental and visual integrity of the land and seascape. Common parcels have been set aside to preserve open space corridors and accommodate shared amenities so as to reduce the number of structures near the water and lessen the environmental impact on pristine Coecles Harbor. There are five residential parcels and two Home Owners' Association parcels with a waterfront boathouse, a 6 slip deep water dock, a boat barn and 1-2 tennis courts. Build your dream houses. Come and experience this amazing place.

$700,000Est. Payment
1.96 Acres
18 Country Club Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Incredible opportunity to own 1.96 Acres abbuting Gardiners Bay Country Club in the Hay Beach section of Shelter Island. Build your dream home on this large, private lot, with many mature oak trees for added character. Ample of room for a large custom home with tennis court, pool, etc. Once in a lifetime opportunity for a lot of this size in an extremely desireable location.

$1,150,000Est. Payment
4 Acres
29 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Lovely flat 4 acre property. Level and partially cleared. Partially wooded at one time in cultivation with nursery stock. Mature nursery stock still exists on Southern half of property. Conservation easement on 2 of the 4 total acres. The Northerly 50% of property can be developed residentially with 2 building lots. Bounded on the West side by 24 acre preserve. Property has been removed of buildings, cesspools and fuel tanks

$1,950,000Est. Payment
1.56 Acres
47 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Incredible bay-front panoramas from this elevated bluff above Shelter Island's Crescent Beach. A truly amazing location for your island dream home. Private, spacious & elegant, this setting is incomparable & very rarely available.

$595,000Est. Payment
1.2 Acres
8 Wheeler Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Beautiful, level, wooded1.2 Acre lot in the Silver Beach Area waiting for your design and building ideas.Very close to boat ramp and Shell Beach. For viewing call Don Dunning @ 516-369-5380 or Debra Binder @ 631-872-2889

$649,000Est. Payment
1.9 Acres
12 Sleepy Hollow Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

1.9 acres of flat land located at the end of Sleepy Hollow Rd. on the cul de sac. A short drive from beaches and the town center with surrounding trees for privacy. Taxes:$2,789.50 ...

$305,000
$1,995,000Est. Payment
3.83 Acres
4 Pandion Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

As you enter Pandion on the southern border sits this gracious 3.83 acre parcel which would allow up to a 11,000 sq. ft. house (subject to town approval), pool and garage. Pandion is a residential neighborhood of remarkable natural beauty comprised of 24.8 acres. With its sweeping views of Coecles Harbor, Ram Island, the protected lands of Mashomack Preserve and Gardiners Bay in the distance, Pandion is unique on Shelter Island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve the environmental and visual integrity of the land and seascape. Common parcels have been set aside to preserve open space corridors and accommodate shared amenities so as to reduce the number of structures near the water and lessen the environmental impact on pristine Coecles Harbor. There are five residential parcels and two Home Owners Association parcels with a waterfront boathouse, a 6 slip deep water dock, a boat barn and 1-2 tennis courts. Exclusively listed at $1,995,000. This is a great opportunity for a savvy client to buy into a fabulous community with all the amenities listed above, with amazing water views at a terrific price.

$205,000
$3,495,000Est. Payment
3.62 Acres
1 Pandion, Shelter Island, NY 11965
Lots Land For Sale

This gorgeous cleared and flat 3.62 acre waterfront parcel in the Pandion residential community on Coecles Harbor would allow up to a 10,000 sq. ft. house (subject to town approval) with pool and garage. There is also the potential for a private dock. Pandion is a residential neighborhood of remarkable natural beauty comprised of 24.8 acres. With its sweeping views of Coecles Harbor, Ram Island, the protected lands of Mashomack Preserve and Gardiners Bay in the distance, Pandion is unique on Shelter Island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve the environmental and visual integrity of the land and seascape. Common parcels have been set aside to preserve open space corridors and accommodate shared amenities so as to reduce the number of structures near the water and lessen the environmental impact on pristine Coecles Harbor. There are five residential parcels and two Home Owners Association parcels with a waterfront boathouse, a 6 slip deep water dock, a boat barn and 1-2 tennis courts. Build your dream home. Come and experience this amazing place.

$30,000
$950,000Est. Payment
1.6 Acres
5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Exceptional & rare opportunity to build in a coveted & desirable setting on Tuthill Drive on Big Ram Island. A 1.6 acre partially cleared parcel awaits your custom built home with year round water-views of Coecles Harbor. A short distance to Reel Point, bay beaches & The Ram's Head Inn is just up the street.

$2,650,000Est. Payment
5.8 Acres
40 South Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Located on south Menantic Peninsula on West Neck Harbor, this virgin acreage comprised of 5.8 +/- level acreage has recently been sub-divided. With 441 +/- feet of shoreline, the views are breathtaking, and include a scenic easement with sunsets. Throughout the property are carefully carved walking trails with guideposts to explore the countless possibilities. A wide flag-lot entry offers estate quality curb appeal to an inspiring setting within. Established growth with a high canopy include groves of copper beech trees. A meditation area has been created to appreciate the natural visual and aural beauty that surrounds you. At any given moment, songbirds, long legged waders, and scampering baby foxes can be seen and heard. A scenic easement on the western side and a 10 acre reserve on the north side offer a lifetime of preserved views, within which a gazebo, boardwalk or other non-permanent structure may be sited. The expansive shoreline supports a dock for your kayak or small vessel. It is easy to envision a once in a lifetime dream home that captures this incredible Shelter Island setting. Health Department Permits are in place, all that is needed is you and your imagination. See listing 728106 - www.8ASimpsonAvenue.com for adjacent 5.04 acres to expand your estate compound to nearly 11 acres! https://vimeo.com/355564358

$8,250,000Est. Payment
6 Acres
3 Pandion Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

Lot 3b, (3.62 acres) -- 0700-016.00-01.00-005.006 is being sold with Lot 3a (2.380 acres) -- 0700-016.00-01.00-005-005 for a total of 6 acres comprised of two single and separate lots. This combination will allow for an aggregate total of 18,000 sq. ft. either as one house or two (subject to town approval). Both lots could have pool and garage, and there is room for tennis and even a paddock. Let your imagination run wild! These two parcels, being sold together, are flanked by Coecles Harbor and protected wetlands, making it private and cradled in a gorgeous natural setting. Pandion is a residential neighborhood of remarkable beauty comprised of 24.8 acres. With its sweeping views of Coecles Harbor, Ram Island, the protected lands of Mashomack Preserve and Gardiners Bay in the distance, Pandion is unique on Shelter Island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve the environmental and visual integrity of the land and seascape. Common parcels have been set aside to preserve open space corridors and accommodate shared amenities so as to reduce the number of structures near the water and lessen the environmental impact on pristine Coecles Harbor. There are five residential parcels and two Home Owners Association parcels with a waterfront boathouse, a 6 slip deep water dock, a boat barn and 1-2 tennis courts. Exclusively listed at $8,250,000

$50,000
$625,000Est. Payment
3.1 Acres
7 Dering Woods Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

In the historic Village of Dering Harbor, this 3.1 acre property is down a scenic, wooded lane. This acreage awaits your new home. Assured of privacy, one side of the property abuts a 17 acre preserve & another backs up to the 6th tee box at Gardiner's Bay Country Club Golf Course. Ride your golf cart to the club for dinner!

$2,850,000Est. Payment
5.04 Acres
8a Simpson Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Lots Land For Sale

In one family for generations, this pristine acreage on south Menantic Peninsula on West Neck Harbor was recently subdivided with thought and sensitivity, offering privacy and room for an expansive estate compound on 5.04 +/- of level acreage. Its shoreline encompasses nearly 472 feet with stunning direct sunset views, which also offer prevailing southwest breezes during the summertime. Paths that meander through the acreage allow your creativity and mind to explore countless possibilities. Established trees with high canopy include groves of copper beech trees with distinctive speckled bark. At any given time, one can hear birdsong resonating throughout the forest. Along the shoreline, long-legged wading birds fish within close proximity of those fishing from boats. The waterway is abundant in marine life, including weakfish, and offers easy access to open water, with the possibility of a dock. Located in an area where estate quality homes have recently been built, this property affords added privacy with a flag-lot entry. A scenic easement on the western side and a 10 acre reserve on the north side offer a lifetime of preserved views, within which a gazebo, boardwalk or other non-permanent structure may be sited. Health Department Permits are in place. Presented with guided trails for clarity to its metes and bounds, this harborfront acreage needs to be visited to be fully appreciated for its unique and beautiful qualities. See listing 728105 - www.40SouthMenanticRoad.com for adjacent 5.8 acres to expand your estate property to nearly 11 acres! https://vimeo.com/355564358

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >