$1,086,128Average Value$443Average Price per Sq Ft14Homes For Sale
Suburban South Shore living with ocean views
After the Verrazzano Bridge opened in 1964, Staten Island went through a three-decade residential construction boom. While that momentum faded as all the usable land plots had houses built on them, construction continued in Prince’s Bay for a little longer than other South Shore neighborhoods. “We get more knockdowns and builds because there’s not much land for sale anymore,” says Kevin Bryant, a local real estate agent with six years of experience. “But I do see a house being torn down and rebuilt over there like every other day.” As recently as 2021, a string of new single-family homes was built at the southern end of the neighborhood, and farther south, a potential development of 108 homes may bring more suburban living options. “When you picture your house with the white picket fence, that’s the type of neighborhood you find here,” Bryant says.
A string of new single-family homes are being built at the southern end of Prince's Bay.
A development of 108 homes brings more suburban living options to Prince's Bay.
1/2
Waterfront townhouses, luxury new construction and million-dollar mansions
Typical of South Shore neighborhoods, Prince’s Bay has a broad mix of housing styles. “You could have townhouses across the street from a $2 million-dollar home,” Bryant says. Here, plenty of new-traditional luxury listings make average home prices high. “It’s more of your step-up living,” Bryant says. “People are usually selling their first home to purchase their next home here.” Modest attached townhouses on the south side start around $550,000 and go up to $750,000 in Captain’s Quarters, a private development with a swimming pool. Nearby, St. Edwards Pointe is another development with stucco-and-stone single-family homes priced around $1.2 million. Heading north, ranches start around $700,000, and colonials start at $850,000. Prices go up to $1.4 million for increasingly larger properties, and from there to $1.7 million are sprawling estates and Mediterranean-inspired waterfront villas. Multifamily home prices can go beyond $2 million for massive buildings, but most start around $800,000.
Typical of South Shore neighborhoods, Prince's Bay's has a broad mix of housing styles.
From 1.7 million there are sprawling estates and Mediterranean-inspired waterfront villas.
1/2
Over 200 acres of green space, plus a cozy beach
Approximately half of Prince’s Bay is taken up by Wolfe’s Pond Park, Arbutus Woods Park and the Lemon Creek Wetlands, giving residents lots of wooded areas for hiking and spotting wildlife. Closer to the Atlantic Ocean, Wolfe’s Pond also has a beach, dog run, playground and tennis courts.
Lemon Creek Wetlands gives the residents of Prince's Bay lots of wooded areas and wildlife.
Closer to the Atlantic Ocean, Wolfe's Pond Park has a beach, dog run and tennis courts.
1/2
Grade-A schools in a grade-A district
According to Niche, School District 31, which serves all of Staten Island, is the third most diverse district in New York state and has an overall A grade. Local students in kindergarten through fifth grade can attend P.S. 5, which has an A grade and was a Blue Ribbon School in 2015. They can then attend I.S. 7 middle school, which has an A grade, before going to Tottenville High School, which has a B-plus.
Local students in kindergarten through fifth grade can attend P.S. 5 in Prince's Bay.
I.S. 07 middle school has an A grade and was a Blue Ribbon School in Prince's Bay.
1/2
Centrally located pizza, sushi and bagels
At the center of Prince’s Bay, two strip malls host the neighborhood’s restaurants — including one of the South Shore’s only Starbucks — and most of the locally owned businesses. Casual Italian eateries serve pizza, pasta and sandwiches, and Japanese and Chinese restaurants offer some variety. For groceries, residents need to drive a little over 3 miles either north to the Key Foods in Arden Heights or east to the Stop & Shop in Eltingville.
In Prince’s Bay, two strip malls host the neighborhood’s local and chain businesses.
For groceries, residents need to drive a little over 3 miles to Stop & Shop in Eltingville.
1/2
Community gatherings in Pleasant Plains
Although residents in Prince’s Bay don’t put on many public events, in Pleasant Plains to the west, the Catholic Charities of Staten Island hosts food truck festivals, Italian street fairs, pumpkin picking parties and more community gatherings throughout the year. Many events take place in North Mount Loretto State Forest, which is within walking distance from Prince’s Bay.
Parkway access and commutes by bus and train
The Korean War Veterans Parkway, running along the north end of Prince’s Bay, lets residents easily reach New Jersey to the west or go north to connect to the Staten Island Expressway and the Verrazzano Bridge. Express buses can reach lower Manhattan in 1 hour and 20 minutes, and riding the Staten Island Railway to transfer to the Staten Island Ferry takes just as long.
The Korean War Veterans Pkwy, at the north end of Prince’s Bay, lets residents easily reach NJ.
Residents ride the Staten Island Railway and transfer to the ferry to reach lower Manhattan.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
I moved here 4 years ago from Palm Springs California. It is a beautiful neighborhood where you get to know your neighbors, there are many local stores I am to walk to and the train and bus is within walking distance. I have really enjoyed living here. Beautiful suburban feel with the city within reach.
Are you familiar with the Prince's Bay neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Prince's Bay Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Prince's Bay, Staten Island sell after 60 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Prince's Bay, Staten Island over the last 12 months is $930,000, up 13% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Welcome to 71 Excelsior Avenue! This gorgeous multi-level, 3-bedroom, 2-bath, single-family detached home is set on a sprawling 10,000 sq. ft. lot, offering a true park-like backyard retreat. The house is in excellent move-in condition, and showcases thoughtful updates throughout. Featuring a custom kitchen completed in 2021, modern upgraded flooring, luxuriously renovated bathroom, young roof
Welcome to 5434 Amboy Road - a fully renovated legal 2-family home offering 5,700 sq ft of luxurious living on a rare 60 × 175 lot. It features a private driveway fitting 6+ cars and a 2-car garage.First FloorStep into an open-concept living and dining area with a gas fireplace, radiant-heated tile floors, and recessed lighting. The chef's kitchen boasts granite countertops, a
Exquisite 4-Bedroom Retreat in Huguenot - Modern Luxury Meets Timeless SerenityDiscover your dream home in this stunning, fully renovated 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom masterpiece, nestled on a generous lot surrounded by protected, unbuildable greenbelt land. Built in 2000 and updated in 2025, this open concept offers a sophisticated living space, perfect for families, entertainers, and those seeking
With a Little TLC, Opportunity Knocks! Located in the desirable Princess Bay area, this 2-family semi-attached home offers a private driveway and a spacious rear yard. The home features a primary suite, plus two additional bedrooms on the second floor and a full bath that services those bedrooms. The first floor offers a large open living room/dining room combo, half bath, spacious eat-in
Welcome to this beautifully renovated bright and airy Hi-Ranch home in the quiet and desirable neighborhood of Huguenot on Staten Island's South Shore. Boasting great curb appeal, this spacious 2,600 sq. ft. residence sits on a 4,000 sq. ft. lot and offers 4 spacious bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms.Step inside to find a bright eat-in kitchen with a nice sized island, comfortable living and
New to market - Prime investment opportunity This 3-bedroom 1 bath high ranch residence offers a traditional layout consisting of a kitchen, living room, dining room, hardwood floors and a full basement. The home opens up to a beautiful sun porch for relaxing or entertaining and also has a garage. Located in the sort after neighborhood of Princes Bay, this traditional high ranch
Property Id: 1212214Prince's Bay Fully detached, 3 bedrooms 3.5 Baths EIK with access to Yard/ deck, Family room W/ fireplace Hardwood floors throughout the house. Second floor laundry room for a stackable unit. En suite master bath to additional generous size bedrooms,. Separate side entrance to Full, finished basement with 3/4 bath and yard access. Driveway for 3 cars, 3 zone
Beautifully maintained basement apartment in desirable Princes Bay. This spacious unit offers comfort and convenience, with all utilities included in the rent. Prime location near transportation, shopping, and parks.
Shawn TatynskiyHomes R Us Realty of NY, Inc.
$1,900 per month
1 Bed
1 Bath
725 Sq Ft
IMMEDIATE MOVE IN
Jeanette RasmussenKeller Williams Realty Staten Island
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
