Beaver Island, MI Homes for Sale under $500,000

Perfectly situated on the corner of White Cedar Trail and Hemlock Trail, this spacious six-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers comfort, functionality, and the peaceful beauty of Northern Michigan living. Set on four lots (702, 703, 704, and 705), the property spans an impressive 298’ x 180’ and the house provides 2,626 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space as well as a large one car garage.

Sheri Richards Five Star Real Estate

This 1902 island gem, known as the McCann House, is a well preserved example of island architecture of the past. You will love many original features such as the stamped metal ceiling in the living and dining rooms, fine woodwork, original wood floors and door hardware, large windows, and views of the harbor from many rooms in the house. Enjoy watching sunrises from the kitchen table, or out on

Heather Robinson-Sleutel Bay North - Beaver Island

There is something timeless about waking to the first light over Lake Michigan. Nestled on one acre of peaceful woodlands along the sandy shoreline of Wicklow Beach, this inviting four-bedroom, two-bath ranch home offers 100 feet of private sandy Lake Michigan frontage and a place where mornings begin with coffee on the deck, afternoons drift by with the sound of gentle waves, and evenings end

Sheri Richards Five Star Real Estate - Beaver Island

Charming 3 bed, 2 bath home on nearly 10 private, wooded acres just minutes from Fox Lake and the Big Birch! You will enjoy the beauty of the surrounding woodlands and a convenient and functional layout. The home features a bright, open kitchen with a walk-in pantry and laundry area. Outdoor living shines with a full-length back deck and a versatile gazebo. The living room has a cozy soapstone

Heather Robinson-Sleutel Bay North - Beaver Island

207 feet of Lake Michigan waterfront on Cable’s Bay located at the south end of Beaver Island! Stairs lead down to the private beach which is a great place to paddle your kayak, or take a stroll. Pat's Road runs along the east side of the property, leading to Lake Geneserath, the island’s largest inland lake and a great fishing spot. Cable’s Bay is unique for its pristine beauty, and rich history

Heather Robinson-Sleutel Bay North - Beaver Island

Looking for a place to truly get away from it all? This cozy 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath cabin sits on over 14 acres of beautiful woodlands and borders state land, offering privacy, room to roam, and endless opportunities to enjoy the outdoors. A long driveway leads from the road all the way to the state land, creating a peaceful setting that feels miles away from the hustle and bustle. A large clearing

Sheri Richards Five Star Real Estate - Beaver Island

Experience breathtaking Lake Michigan sunsets from this beautifully situated year-round home or vacation getaway in the dunes of Donegal Bay. The open-concept floor plan is bright and welcoming with an office conveniently located off the living area, featuring ample built-in book storage. Upstairs there are two bedrooms with large windows overlooking the bay, and two full baths. You will love the

Heather Robinson-Sleutel Bay North - Beaver Island

Charming and cozy, this cedar shake sided chalet is tucked into the dunes on a beautifully scenic road close to Donegal Bay Beach. Enjoy woodland views out of the large windows throughout the home providing abundant natural light. The well-designed main floor features an open floor plan, and a private primary en suite. The laundry area is conveniently located on the main floor as well. Head up

Heather Robinson-Sleutel Bay North - Beaver Island

New construction home in Port Saint James. Finished in 2025 this home offers a virtually unlived-in home with true hardwood floors, open concept, main-level living, attached garage, and new everything. Located less than five minutes from downtown St. James, and walking distance to the Font Lake public access, which holds world-class bass fishing opportunities. Priced well-below new construction

Ryan Wojan smith realty GROUP