Homes for Sale near Cayuga Mennonite School

Exceptional Cayuga Lake compound set on 1.2 acres with 100 feet of prime east side lake frontage. Offering 6 total bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms across two private residences, alongside a rare blend of turnkey living, privacy, and income potential. Whether you’re seeking a fulltime lake home, weekend escape, or investment with short-term rental upside, this property delivers versatility that is

Evan Schaefer Listing by NORCHAR, LLC

54ft WATERFRONT ON SENECA RIVER EASY ACCESS TO CAYUGA AND CROSS LAKE. Beautifully renovated three-bedroom, 2 bath home offering 54 feet of Seneca River frontage. This move-in-ready property features gleaming hardwood floors, a stylish full bath with sliding barn door, and a bright, updated interior throughout. Enjoy the added bonus of a detached two-car garage with loft space—perfect for storage

Todd Post Listing by Post Realty

Looks like you’ve found your GET AWAY right here in Seneca County NY! Close to the CASINO- WINERIES- SHOPPING and so much more! You’ll love vacationing (or LIVING YEAR ROUND) in this updated 3 BEDROOM, 1 FULL BATH, RANCH STYLE home with a METAL ROOL- NEW VINYL SIDING- NEW MINI SPLIT for HEAT and AC! The FRESH remodel includes GRANITE COUNTERS-TILE BACKSPLASH - UPDATED APPLIANCES- LUXURY VINY

Darlene Maimone Listing by Howard Hanna

Beautiful Riverfront Home with Airbnb Income PotentialThis stunning 2023 manufactured home sits on 50 feet of river frontage, just steps from the lock that opens into Cayuga Lake. Over $200,000 in site work has already been completed, offering peace of mind and lasting value. Currently operating as a successful Airbnb, this property generates more than $45,000 annually in rental

Todd Post Listing by Post Realty

This 20+- acres is part of a larger parcel with tax ID, taxes and assessment TBD. Parcel has open field, wooded areas, a large yard, and on approx 600' of Black Brook Creek. House sq ft are approx. Country location within minutes to NYS thruway and many Finger Lakes activities & sites. First floor bedroom, kitchen w/cooking island, eating counter and living area with views of Black Brook Creek.

Mike Virts Listing by DeAngelis Real Estate LLC