Fire Island, NY Homes for Rent under $2,400

Explore Similar Homes Within 2 Miles of Fire Island, NY

/77

$2,350 - $3,100 per month

Renaissance Bay

1 - 2 Beds

200 La Bonne Vie Dr, Patchogue, NY 11772

none

200 La Bonne Vie Dr, Patchogue, NY 11772
/14
$2,000 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 500 Sq Ft
- House for Rent
Unlisted Address

Freshly painted adorable 1 bedroom, 1 bath bungalow with finished loft area offering extra space for home office or playroom-recently upgraded kitchen cabinets, flooring, and new stone driveway. Convenient prime location in Patchogue Village, close to shopping, beaches, dining, and entertainment.. Owner requesting full credit report with at least 650 credit scores, proof of resources to pay rent,

Amy Schuler Your Team D&G Realty Ltd

Unlisted Address
/35

$2,095 - $3,950 per month

Fairfield Townhomes at Islip

Studio - 2 Beds

75 Circle Dr, Central Islip, NY 11722

Welcome to Fairfield Townhomes At Islip, a new centrally located community where bright and airy layouts are accompanied with high-touch service and warm inviting amenities. Our studio to two-bedroom with den apartment homes are comfortable, convenient, modern and one of a kind. Amenities like our yoga studio, coffee lounge, and state-of-the-art clubhouse, make everyday life at Fairfield

75 Circle Dr, Central Islip, NY 11722
/6
$2,300 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 800 Sq Ft
- Property for Rent
19 Pinebrook Place Unit 19, Bay Shore, NY 11706

2nd Floor 1 Bedroom Apartment, Tenant Responsibility: Electric, Cable & Internet. Washer & Dryer In Development.

Jack Ramsay Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC

19 Pinebrook Place Unit 19, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/63

$2,026 - $5,040 per month

The Belmont at Eastview

Studio - 3 Beds

300 Carleton Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722

The Belmont at Eastview is set on over 62 acres of park like setting. We offer Studio, 1- & 2-bedroom apartments along with endless amenities including bark parks & pet spas, tennis and pickleball courts, picnic areas with BBQ's, sports courts, community gardens, walking trails and children's playgrounds throughout, just to name a few. The Belmont will also be home to an 18,000 square foot

300 Carleton Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722
/4
$2,150 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 800 Sq Ft
- Property for Rent
86 Pinebrook Place Unit 86, Bay Shore, NY 11706

2nd Floor 1 Bedroom Apartment, Tenant Responsibility: Electric, Cable & Internet. Washer & Dryer In Development.

Jack Ramsay Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC

86 Pinebrook Place Unit 86, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/25

$2,050 - $2,650 per month

Bay Shore Manor

1 - 2 Beds

2 Garfield St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Lease by 5/31/26 & receive 2nd month free + $99 security deposit (qualified credit). Enjoy a cozy, peaceful, beautifully maintained community in the heart of Bay Shore—just minutes from Southside Hospital, Northwell Health, Westfield South Shore, Bay Shore Commons, Sunrise Highway, the Southern State Parkway, the LIRR. Close to vibrant Main Street dining, shopping, Fire Island Ferry. Spacious,

2 Garfield St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/19
$1,900 per month
- 1 Bath
- 400 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
94 4th Ave Unit 208, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Welcome to "The Lofts" Studio Apartments. Conveniently located in the heart of Downtown Bay Shore. This Unit is on the second floor and has a spiral staircase that leads up to the Loft space. Private Parking on site included-1 parking space. AC in Unit. Laundry Room in Building. No Smoking-No Pets. Tenant pays Electric/Cable/WIFI. Appearance is excellent. Interior features separate thermostat,

Maria Flyntz Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

94 4th Ave Unit 208, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/42

$2,300 - $3,210 per month

Hawthorne Living

1 - 2 Beds

211 Hawthorne Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722

Our luxury apartment complex in Long Island is ready to welcome you home! Pet-friendly apartments in Suffolk County, NY, we offer studio, one bedroom, two bedroom, and three bedroom floor plans that feature elegant details that enhance every lifestyle. Our community is also packed with amazing amenities for residents to enjoy. Find your new home at Hawthorne Living today! Step into any floor plan

211 Hawthorne Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722
/8
$2,380 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 825 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
235 Lakeland Ave Unit 2-4B, Sayville, NY 11782

Ask About Our Outstanding Specials*: Located near downtown Sayville Village. Great location for Shopping, Dining, Parks and Activities. Tuscany Style Kitchen, Granite counters, SS Appls,Vinyl Plank floors and/or Gray Carpet. Some Styles have Terraces. Prices/Policies Subject To Change without Notice.*Restrictions Apply*.

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

235 Lakeland Ave Unit 2-4B, Sayville, NY 11782
/8

$1,850 - $2,995 per month

Mid Island Apartments

Studio - 2 Beds

35 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes

35 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/12
$2,375 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 708 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
303 Robinson Ave Unit 303-1, Patchogue, NY 11772

*Ask About Our Rent Specials*. $99 Sec.Dep Special*. Restrictions Apply** New Ledgestone Exterior and Landscaped Courtyards,paver paths. Granite Kit/Foyer Flr/Countertop! Stainless Steel Appls, Tuscany Cabs, Hi-Hats, Ceiling Fans, Stonington Gray Paint w/white Crown/Base, Gray Premium Carpet. Granite/Marble Bath/Vanitytop, Frameless Shower Doors. On Site Laundry Ctr. Nr Patchogue Village!.

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

303 Robinson Ave Unit 303-1, Patchogue, NY 11772
/21

$2,275 - $2,650 per month

1991 Union Plaza

1 Bed

1991 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Dear Future Tenant!We’re thrilled to introduce 1991 Union Plaza, a stunning new 3-story residential building in the heart of Bay Shore, NY, offering modern luxury and unbeatable convenience. Located steps from Northwell's South Shore University Hospital and minutes from Downtown Bay Shore’s vibrant shops, restaurants and entertainment venues. These brand-new apartments are designed for

1991 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/10
$2,200 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 457 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
40 Amity St, Patchogue, NY 11772

Welcome to 40 Amity Street. 1 Bedroom apartment with a spacious living room and an eat-in kitchen layout. With natural lighting throughout and hardwood floors. Less than 1/16th of a mile to the LIRR and less than 1.5 miles to sunrise highway and close proximity to Fire Island ferries. This apartment is perfect for professionals, commuters and those that want to enjoy the beautiful lively streets

Dominick Rosselli Rugen Realty Corp

40 Amity St, Patchogue, NY 11772
/39

$2,375 - $3,425 per month

Gracewood Estates

1 - 2 Beds

1 Gracewood Ct, Islip, NY 11751

1 Gracewood Ct, Islip, NY 11751
/5
$1,900 per month
- 1 Bath
- 400 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
94 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Welcome to "The Lofts" Studio Apartments. Conveniently located in the heart of Downtown Bay Shore. This Unit is on the first floor and has an accessible bathroom. Private Parking on site included. AC in Unit. Laundry Room in Building. No Smoking-No Pets. Tenant pays Electric/Cable/WIFI. Appearance is excellent. Interior features separate thermostat, hot water tank and electric panel.

Colleen Colasacco Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

94 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/19

$2,397 - $3,343 per month

Heatherwood House at Oakdale

Studio - 2 Beds

168 Oakdale-Bohemia Rd, Bohemia, NY 11716

Welcome to Heatherwood House at Oakdale – The place to be for those looking to experience the suburbs' tranquility and the perks of the city all wrapped in one. Our apartments in Bohemia, NY, allow offer you luxury studio, one, and two-bedroom floor plans for a carefree lifestyle with easy access to Sunrise Highway.Personalize your space as you see fit, as all our layouts are a blank

168 Oakdale-Bohemia Rd, Bohemia, NY 11716
/9
$2,365 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 650 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
64 S Clinton Ave Unit 2B, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Ask About Our Amazing Specials!: Beautiful Community with private entry apartments, spacious rooms, heat and hot water included, vinyl plank flooring, high-hat lights, air-conditioner, ceiling fans, gray paint, faux wood white window treatments, raised panel cabinetry, stainless steel appliance. Ceramic tile bath with granite vanity top, frameless shower doors. On-site laundry center. Prices,

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

64 S Clinton Ave Unit 2B, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/18

$2,350 - $3,550 per month

Courtyards on Fifth

1 - 3 Beds

45 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Experience life in the thriving area of downtown Bay Shore, NY. A short distance to the train station for commuting residents, and a close commute for South Shore University Hospital employees. Walking distance to main street's many restaurants and bars, as well as, additional attractions such as the Fire Island Ferry Terminal and the Bay Shore Marina. With several different floors plans of 1, 2

45 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/6
$2,400 per month
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 900 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
17 Chimney Ln, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Beautiful 2 bedroom apartment, newly renovated. Large bedroom, large living room efficiency kitchen, use of side yard.Immediate occupancy.

Winston Anderson Sir Winston Realty Inc

17 Chimney Ln, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/35

$2,130 - $3,020 per month

Fairfield On The Bay

Studio - 2 Beds

33 Midship Ln, Patchogue, NY 11772

Receive $1200 Off One-Time When You Lease A Selected Non-Waterfront Unit With Move-In By 3/15/26* And 15-, 16-, or 24- Month Lease With No Increase* $99 Security* *Restrictions Apply. Gorgeous waterfront property! Outstanding newly renovated Tuscany, Ceramic and Granite kitchen and bath-waterfront residences! Central air conditioning and terrace. Some with amazing views of Great South Bay.

33 Midship Ln, Patchogue, NY 11772
/4
$2,130 per month
- 1 Bath
- 456 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
82 Mainsail Dr Unit 8-82, Patchogue, NY 11772

*Ask About Our Amazing Specials*: *Restrictions apply.Private Entry Apartments.Kitchens W/ Raised Panel Cabinetry & Appliances Inc. Dishwasher & Microwave.Heat & Hot Water Incl! Window Treatments. Laundry Center.Close To Beaches,Marina And Village Shopping & Dining.Pet Friendly! Prices/policies subject to change without notice.

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

82 Mainsail Dr Unit 8-82, Patchogue, NY 11772
/35

$2,265 - $3,025 per month

Fairfield On The Lake

Studio - 2 Beds

3-15 Willowbrook Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

$99 Security Deposit* *Restrictions Apply.Outstanding location in top-rated Islip School District. Studio, One and Two bedrooms. Enjoy the charming views of Lake Orowoc. Located close to Islip Village main street and Bay Shore main street. Spacious, air-conditioned apartments with heat and hot water included in the rent. Features include tuscany wood cabinets, stainless steel appliances, bath

3-15 Willowbrook Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/6
$2,400 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 800 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
239 Curtin Ave, West Islip, NY 11795

Welcome to 239 Curtin Avenue, West Islip, NY — a cozy and well-maintained 1-bedroom apartment offering comfortable living in a desirable neighborhood. This unit features a bright layout with ample natural light and a functional living space perfect for everyday living. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, and transportation, providing easy access to everything you need. A great opportunity

George Ortiz ARVY Realty

239 Curtin Ave, West Islip, NY 11795
/35

$1,995 - $2,925 per month

Fairfield Hedges at Bay Shore

Studio - 2 Beds

405 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

In the heart of Bay Shore downtown and close to all. White shaker-style cabinets, quartz tops and backsplash, Whirlpool gold-series stainless steel appliances, kitchen and dining room plank tile flooring. Spacious apartments.

405 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/3
$2,095 per month
- 1 Bath
- 475 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
75 Circle Dr Unit 75-110, Central Islip, NY 11722

Ask about our Outstanding Move-In Specials! Bright Airy layouts w/high-tech service and inviting amenities, comfortable,convenient,modern,one of a kind.White shaker cabs 39" high, Quartz tops & backsplash, Whirpool Gold Appls, Porc kitchen & dining floors.Yoga studio, coffee lounge, and beautiful Clubhouse make life enjoyable & effortless.*Prices/policies subject to change without notice.

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

75 Circle Dr Unit 75-110, Central Islip, NY 11722
/18

$2,150 - $2,545 per month

Fairfield Lakeside At Moriches

1 - 2 Beds

1775 Montauk Hwy, Moriches, NY 11955

55 And Over Rental Community$99 Security Deposit* *Restrictions apply. Beautiful ledgestone exterior. Fairfield Lakeside At Moriches offers luxury, private entry, one bedroom with one bath plus den and two bedroom with 1.5 baths plus basement. Large terrace. Convenient location, near shops, public transportation, local beaches and community activities.

1775 Montauk Hwy, Moriches, NY 11955
/9
$2,100 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 500 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
119 Lake Shore Dr, Patchogue, NY 11772

Bright, Sunny , cozy and freshly painted second floor apartment overlooking Patchogue Lake. Separate entrance, sky lit kitchen, living room, large storage closet, full bath and large bedroom with additional closet. Close to St. Joseph's University, NYU Langone Hospital and all Patchogue Village Amenities, Sunrise Highway, Shopping. Includes all utilities and provides Internet. NTN Tenant

Joanne Schloen Howard Hanna Coach

119 Lake Shore Dr, Patchogue, NY 11772
/23

$2,277 - $4,393 per month

Heatherwood House at Patchogue

1 - 2 Beds

99 Waverly Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772

Experience a higher level of comfort and convenience in a centrally located community next to Great Patchogue Lake and Main Street’s vibrant entertainment district. You will be within walking distance to local shopping and dining, as well as a famous Long Island brewery. With easy access to both Montauk Highway and Sunrise Highway, traveling to other parts of Suffolk County and beyond is easy and

99 Waverly Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772
/9
$2,340 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 805 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
234 River Ave Unit 26, Patchogue, NY 11772

*Ask About Our Rent Specials*. Restrictions Apply* Waterfront Community. Units with granite countertop & kitchen floor, Stls Stl Appl w/dw & micro. window trmts, crpt,hi-hats,ac,fans. On site laundry. Boat dock available end of River/Cresent, ask us! At heart of Patchogue village. Near LIRR. Pet Friendly! Prices/ policies subject to change without notice., Additional information:

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

234 River Ave Unit 26, Patchogue, NY 11772
/25

$2,310 - $3,300 per month

Fairfield Park At Babylon Village

1 - 2 Beds

100 Friendly Ct, Babylon, NY 11702

Located in historic, seaside Babylon Village. Great shops and restaurants and quaint village to explore. Nearby world-class beaches. Great location within walking distance to the Long Island Railroad-Babylon Station train. 50-minute commute to NYC. Resident clubhouse with fitness center, billards and party room. One and two bedroom modern apartments with heat, hot water and cooking gas

100 Friendly Ct, Babylon, NY 11702
/8
$2,390 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 700 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
325 Brook Ave Unit 325-1B, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Ask About Our Amazing Specials*: Tuscan Kitchen, SS Appl. Heat, Hot Water And Cooking Gas Included. Courtyard Setting. On-Site Laundry Center. Minutes To Sunrise Highway, Lirr & Westfield South Shore Mall. *Restrictions apply-Prices/policies subject to change without notice.

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

325 Brook Ave Unit 325-1B, Bay Shore, NY 11706
/35

$2,345 - $2,865 per month

Fairfield North At Patchogue

1 - 2 Beds

72-76 Mount Vernon Ave, East Patchogue, NY 11772

2-BEDROOMS FREE RENT MARCH-2026 With Move-In By 3/15/26 AND 12-, 15-, 16- Or 24-Month Lease With No Increase* Ask About 1BR Special* $99 Security* *Restrictions Apply. Conveniently located near St. Joseph's College, Route 112, Sunrise Highway, the Long Island Rail Road. The beautifully landscaped grounds feature on-site laundry room, playground, basketball court.Our spacious One And Two

72-76 Mount Vernon Ave, East Patchogue, NY 11772
/2
$2,105 per month
- 1 Bath
- 552 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
819 Long Island Ave Unit 15B, Deer Park, NY 11729

*Ask About Our Rent Specials*. $99 Sec.Dep Special*. Restrictions Apply* Charming Studio Apartments. New Kitchens And Baths. Hot Water Included. Luxurious Vinyl Planl flooring . Convenient To Long Island Expressway (Exit 51) And The Lirr. Close Walk To Shops. Prices/policies subject to change without notice.

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

819 Long Island Ave Unit 15B, Deer Park, NY 11729
/24

$2,360 - $4,030 per month

Hillcrest Village

Studio - 2 Beds

865 Broadway Ave, Holbrook, NY 11741

With a new home comes a brand-new lifestyle, and that is what you’ll experience at Hillcrest Village Apartments. Luxury amenities, attentive services, attractive upgrades, and well-designed layouts are all part of the deal as soon as you become a resident of our apartments in Holbrook. Bring your furry friends with you—we welcome pets!Life is enjoyable and stress-free in any of our

865 Broadway Ave, Holbrook, NY 11741
/10
$2,050 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 1,788 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
50 Sunburst Dr, Deer Park, NY 11729

Welcome to 50 Sunburst Dr Deer Park! This cozy 1 BR apartment is a ground level unit, with a private separate entrance, and a large fenced off dedicated yard space and patio. Driveway Parking, and all utilities are included EXCEPT for WIFI and/ or Cable. Large LR/Kitchen Combo, 1 Bedroom with Closet, and a secondary large walk in closet. Very clean and well maintained. Located very close to

Christopher Silliman Real Broker NY LLC

50 Sunburst Dr, Deer Park, NY 11729
/30

$1,732 - $2,598 per month

Pinehurst Apartments 55+

1 - 2 Beds

3000 Brookwood Cir, East Patchogue, NY 11772

WE ARE NOW LEASING 1 BEDROOMS FROM $1732- $2598/MO* - APPLY TODAY!Pinehurst offers senior 55 and over luxury rental community! This state-of-the-art facility offers comfortable, yet modern accommodations, bursting with amenities. Residents enjoy innovative additions such as wireless medical alert transmitters, high-speed internet, and discounted premium television packages. Other superior

3000 Brookwood Cir, East Patchogue, NY 11772
/8
$2,000 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 800 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
892 Pine Ave, West Islip, NY 11795

Very nice Ground floor Apartment, Eat in kitchen, Large Bedroom with a big closet, Full Bath (tub) Good size Living room and a bonus Storage room. Sorry No Pets -- No Smoking -- Street Parking Only

Anthony Rubino Leading Edge R E Services

892 Pine Ave, West Islip, NY 11795
/35

$1,968 - $4,175 per month

Colony Park

Studio - 2 Beds

500 Peconic St, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

A country club lifestyle in a tranquil park-like setting filled with things you love. Colony Park Luxury Apartments offers beautifully appointed Ronkonkoma apartments at affordable prices in one of Long Island's most accessible and desirable locations. Starting with the inviting outdoor leisure spots and continuing with the professional services, our homes brighten your day, every day. Pets

500 Peconic St, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
/8
$2,220 per month
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 410 Sq Ft
- Apartment for Rent
105 Lincoln Ave Unit M, Sayville, NY 11782

White shaker kitchen cabinets, quartz counters, stainless steel appl, DW, micro. Full size washer and dryer. Customizable closets, vinyl plank floors, high-hats, ceiling fans, crown molding AC. Subway tile bath, handheld rain showerhead, frameless shower doors. Sayville Village and Main Street nearby

Michelle Holmes Fairfield Properties

105 Lincoln Ave Unit M, Sayville, NY 11782

New York Suffolk County Fire Island

How to Rent a Home

Rentals in Fire Island

Fire Island Houses for Rent

Rentals by Number of Bedrooms in Fire Island

More About Living in Fire Island

Homes by Amenity in Fire Island

Homes for Rent in Nearby Neighborhoods

Homes for Rent in Nearby Cities

Homes for Rent in Nearby Counties

Suffolk County Homes for Rent

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage