Middle Island, NY Homes for Sale

• 

  

  

  /22

  $599,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 1,002 Sq Ft

  17 Arnold Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Turn the key and start living — this updated ranch delivers space, style, and a backyard built for making memories. Featuring 3 bedrooms and 3 full baths, this move-in ready home offers the layout with modern upgrades already done. The renovated eat-in kitchen showcases quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and gas cooking — perfect for busy mornings and weekend gatherings alike.

  

  Hector Rodriguez

  HomeSmart Premier Living Rlty

  (631) 646-1954

  17 Arnold Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• Explore Middle Island

• 

  

  

  /43

  $749,999

  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,260 Sq Ft

  37 Lakeview Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to 37 Lakeview Drive! This brand-new 2025 Colonial has been crafted with modern luxury and timeless design. The door opens to a grand foyer with an open-concept and a ton of natural sun light. The built-in electric fireplace, recessed lighting, and seamless flow set the tone for both intimate evenings and vibrant gatherings. At the heart of the home, the chef’s kitchen shines with an

  Kevin Iglesias Signature Premier Properties

  37 Lakeview Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  

  /27

  $699,999

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,204 Sq Ft

  5 Fox Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953

  This beautifully updated home features a thoughtfully designed main level with a luxurious eat-in kitchen, complete with white shaker cabinets, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, vaulted ceiling, and designer light fixtures. Enjoy elegant meals in the formal dining room and unwind in the expansive family room with a wood-burning fireplace. A bright and functional laundry room

  Elaine Kelly Signature Premier Properties

  5 Fox Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  

  /5

  $848,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,551 Sq Ft

  4 Bunker Ln, Middle Island, NY 11953

  To Be Built. Rendering/Photos Shown Conveys Craftsmanship of Homes Previously Built. Amenities included are hardwood floors on the first floor with carpet in the bedrooms, granite kitchen countertops, 3 choices of cabinets with dove-tail draws and soft touch close, central air conditioning, colonial base moldings & choice of tile for bathrooms. Some optional features include venting out for

  Lynn Anne Daly Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  4 Bunker Ln, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  

  /5

  $848,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,551 Sq Ft

  2 Bunker Ln, Middle Island, NY 11953

  To Be Built. Rendering/Photos Shown Conveys Craftsmanship of Homes Previously Built. Amenities included are hardwood floors on the first floor with carpet in the bedrooms, granite kitchen countertops, 3 choices of cabinets with dove-tail draws and soft touch close, central air conditioning, colonial base moldings & choice of tile for bathrooms. Some optional features include venting out for

  Lynn Anne Daly Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  2 Bunker Ln, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /30

  $849,990

  • 3 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 1,365 Sq Ft

  58 Coram Swezeytown Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953

  This is a True Must See!; More Than Meets The Eye!; 1 Property, Just Shy 2 Acres, 2 Houses, 2 Barns, Endless Potential! Possible AirBNB, Compound, Possible Sub-Division, Room for Mom with Proper Permits. Room For Horses! Original House Dates Back From 1880 and is Drenched in Charm, 2 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, Historical Walk-Up Attic, Covered Porch. Much of The Home Is Original and in Pristine

  Robert Privitera Coldwell Banker Reliable R E

  58 Coram Swezeytown Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /48

  $849,999

  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,600 Sq Ft

  4 Cardinal Ct, Ridge, NY 11961

  New Construction Colonial – To Be Built. 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms Incredible opportunity to build your dream home with an interest rate as low as 4.99%! This Lot has the option to add a full walk out basement for ground level access from the oversized yard! Choose from three thoughtfully designed models: The Mattituck, The Jamesport, and The Jamesport Plus. Each model offers a spacious and

  Bryan Karp Coldwell Banker American Homes

  4 Cardinal Ct, Ridge, NY 11961
• 

  

  /31

  $779,999

  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,260 Sq Ft

  3 Cardinal Ct, Ridge, NY 11961

  New Construction Colonial – To Be Built. 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms Incredible opportunity to build your dream home with an interest rate as low as 4.99%! Choose from three thoughtfully designed models: The Mattituck, The Jamesport, and The Jamesport Plus. Each model offers a spacious and functional layout with high-quality finishes throughout. This beautiful Colonial will feature four generously

  Bryan Karp Coldwell Banker American Homes

  3 Cardinal Ct, Ridge, NY 11961
• 

  

  /21

  $525,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 888 Sq Ft

  1 Pine Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953

  This newly three-bedroom Ranch fully renovated on a corner lot property fully fenced. Driveway re-done all cement. All wood flooring throughout the house, Waser/Dryer hook up. New electrical system. Great starter home or looking to downsize. Low taxes close to all shopping and hospitals nearby. Don't let this opportunity pass you by.

  Eman Prestyly H & G Realty New York

  1 Pine Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /15

  $259,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  289 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  This beautifully updated 1 bedroom ground level condo offers efficient kitchen, a comfortable living room, and a cozy dining area perfect for everyday use. The community features a community pool, a dog park, a basketball court, a tennis court and a playground. Enjoy everything a club house has to offer featuring a gym, a pool table and ping pong. there is plenty of parking space available

  Sham Lal Blackstone Realty

  289 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /12

  $329,900

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 947 Sq Ft

  305 Fairview Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Updated 2 Bedroom 2 Bath Ground Level Condo In Desirable Artist Lake. All New Kitchen, Baths, Floors, Doors, Trim, Paint & More. Gas Heat, Central Air, Covered Patio. The Community Features a Pool, Clubhouse & Gym. Private End Unit Priced To Sell!

  Rick Hovanec Coldwell Banker Easton Prop

  305 Fairview Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /35

  $217,500

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  64 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to 64 Artist Lake! Freshly painted, 1st floor condo with in unit laundry hookup. Comfortably designed with gas cooking and central air conditioning, dining area and large living room. The community features a community pool, a dog park, a basketball court, a tennis court and a playground! Enjoy everything the clubhouse has to offer; featuring a gym, a pool table and ping pong! There are

  Gerald Wood New Door Properties LLC

  64 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /4

  $675,000

  • Land
  • 1.77 Acres
  • $381,356 per Acre

  217 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Vacant Commercial Land with all permits and drawings, approvals, and ready to go. Medical or any type of commercial use.

  Kalliope Gemelas Coldwell Banker American Homes

  217 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /46

  $299,900

  • 2 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 904 Sq Ft

  204 Fairview Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953

  A charming condominium, this home offers two bedrooms and two bathrooms in a peaceful, park-like setting. Residents enjoy access to community amenities such as a clubhouse and pool. Conveniently located near shopping, transportation, and major roadways, this property offers comfortable living with easy access to everyday essentials.

  Jose Feliciano New Door Properties LLC

  204 Fairview Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /7

  $299,990

  • Land
  • 1.46 Acres
  • $205,473 per Acre

  0 Middle Country Rd Unit KEYL3539072, Middle Island, NY 11953

  1.46 Acres, with Suffolk County Board Health & Town of Brookhaven Planning Board approval.!!, Additional information: from corner: 461Ft. east of the intersection Wadding River Hollow Rd. and Middle Country Rd. property is located on the south Side

  Christopher Armstrong Century 21 Princeton Prop

  0 Middle Country Rd Unit KEYL3539072, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /21

  $299,000

  • 2 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 900 Sq Ft

  617 Lake Ct Unit 617, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Step into this sunlit two-bedroom, one and a half-bathroom co-op, where comfort and style come together effortlessly. The thoughtfully designed layout features two well-proportioned bedrooms, a bright and airy living space, and a dedicated dining area that’s ideal for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. With ample storage throughout, this home offers the perfect balance of functionality

  Sean Gray Compass Greater NY LLC

  617 Lake Ct Unit 617, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /17

  $250,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  280 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Condo with 1 Bedroom and Bath, Heat and Hot Water Included in HOA, Tenant Lease Expires Dec 2026

  Robert Scarito Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  280 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /28

  $564,900

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,716 Sq Ft

  10 Tracie Ln Unit 313, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Enjoy Country Club Living! Perfectly Maintained2 Bedroom 2 Bath Springfield Model With Updates That Include: New Vinyl Flooring, New LG Stainless Wi-Fi Appliances, Gas Fireplace, Newer LG Washer Dryer and HI Hat Lighting! Amenities Include: Private 9 Hole Golf,2Clubhouses,4 Pools Tennis, Pickleball, Racquetball,2 Gyms, and Many Social Activities All In A 24 Hr Gated Community!

  Thomas Annunziato Howard Hanna Coach

  10 Tracie Ln Unit 313, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /9

  $669,900

  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,000 Sq Ft

  13 N Swezeytown Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953

  NEW CONSTRUCTION- HOUSE IS BUILT, STILL TIME TO CUSTOMIZE!!! 4 BEDROOMS, 2 1/2 BATHS, FULL UNFINISHED BASEMENT W/8FT CEILINGS AND SEPARATE OUTSIDE ENTRANCE. BEAUTIFUL EAT IN KITCHEN GREAT FOR ENTERTAINING. FABULOUS OPEN FLOOR PLAN, FORMAL DINING ROOM AND A LARGE LIVING ROOM. OAK FLOORING FIRST FLOOR & UPSTAIRS LANDING, OAK TREDS & RAILING ON STAIRCASE / HIGH HATS ON 1ST FLOOR / APPLIANCES CREDIT

  Angela Mandarino Listing Pro Realty Services

  13 N Swezeytown Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /29

  $439,000

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,218 Sq Ft

  757 Spring Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath townhouse-style condominium located in the desirable Birchwood at Spring Lake Driver community. This spacious Galaxy Model offers approximately 1,218 sq ft of comfortable, single-level living with an open and functional floor plan. Enjoy peaceful golf course views from the rear of the home, providing a scenic and serene backdrop year-round.

  Paul Musso Realty Connect USA L I Inc

  757 Spring Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /34

  $484,900

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 1,870 Sq Ft

  728 Birchwood Park Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Enjoy Country Club Living! Golf Views! Perfectly Maintained 3 Bedroom 2.5 Bath Malibu Model With Updates That Include: Tile Flooring , New Quartz Kitchen With Shaker Cabinets , New Stainless Appliances, Newer Washer Dryer, New Primary Bath, Updated Second Bath, Fresh Paint ,New Windows And Newer Heat And Cac, Extended Rear Patio Amenities Include: Private 9 Hole Golf,2Clubhouses,4 Pools Tennis,

  Thomas Annunziato Howard Hanna Coach

  728 Birchwood Park Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /5

  $170,000

  • Land
  • 0.5 Acre
  • $340,000 per Acre

  VL Daniel Ln, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Calling ALL builders. Great opportunity to build on a dead end lot! Half (.5) acre land with dimensions of 138 by 178. This is one of the remainin glots on this street. The ONE (1) acre lot across is also available. NOW is the time to obtain this gem.

  Charbel Cerda-Hidalgo Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life

  VL Daniel Ln, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /10

  $320,000 Coming Soon

  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 900 Sq Ft

  92 Gauguin Ct Unit 92, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Beautiful 2-Bedroom Co-op featuring a new bathroom, new heating system, and new central air conditioning for year-round comfort. Bright and inviting living space, plenty of storage, with an enclosed back patio perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Set in a warm, green setting offering a peaceful atmosphere. A wonderful opportunity for comfortable, low-maintenance living.

  Linda Catalano Island Advantage Realty LLC

  92 Gauguin Ct Unit 92, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /19

  $219,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 800 Sq Ft

  42 Monet Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to this 1 bedroom upper unit. This spacious co-op features a generously sized bedroom, a large open living room with dedicated dining space, and the convenience of an in-unit washer and dryer! Private balcony for outdoor enjoyment. This unit has great potential to customize and make it your own, this home offers a wonderful opportunity in a well-maintained, carefree community. Enjoy newer

  Samantha Cacciatore Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  42 Monet Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /4

  $235,000

  • Land
  • 100 Acres
  • $2,350 per Acre

  0 Daniel Ln Unit KEY944644, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Amazing 1 acre lot on a dead end road. Calling ALL builders and investors looking to build at an exclusive location. The lot across is also for sale.

  Charbel Cerda-Hidalgo Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life

  0 Daniel Ln Unit KEY944644, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /40

  $249,999

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  96 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Experience luxury and convenience in this stunningly renovated 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom garden style apartment located in the desirable Artist Lake community of Middle Island. This first floor unit features a designer kitchen; a true centerpiece with custom white shaker cabinets, elegant quart countertops and a chic tiled backsplash. Fully equipped with premium stainless steel appliances and a gas

  Gerald Wood New Door Properties LLC

  96 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /26

  $430,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 1,431 Sq Ft

  97 Drexelgate Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath condominium located in the desirable Coventry Manor community of Middle Island. This sun-filled home features an inviting eat-in kitchen complete with quartz countertops, modern cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a built-in wine fridge — perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. Vaulted ceilings create an open and airy

  Paul Perrone Realty Connect USA LI Inc

  97 Drexelgate Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  /2

  $249,900

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,510 Sq Ft

  174 Garden Gate Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Cash offers. Contract Vendee. No gate access, no interior access. Sold occupied, as-is. 2 bed, 2 bath with 1 car garage in sought after Coventry Manor. Perfect for investor, flipper or end user.

  Justin Pollio New Door Properties LLC

  174 Garden Gate Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /16

  $225,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  250 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  This charming updated 1- Bedroom 1- Bathroom 2nd floor unit offers an efficient kitchen with granite countertops, a cozy living room and a dining area perfect for everyday use. Additional highlights include new refinished oak hardwood flooring throughout. Gas, water, sewer and outside maintenance are included in HOA. Amenities featuring clubhouse, community pool, dog park, basketball court,

  Maria Michaelson Signature Premier Properties

  250 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /11

  $249,999

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  199 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Beautifully remodeled 2nd Floor unit offering 1 bedroom, Full Bathroom, Brand new Kitchen with stainless steel appliances, Livingroom with sliding doors that lead to the balcony, dinning area. Great community with lots of amenities featuring a community pool, dog park, basketball court, tennis court and playground. Gas, water, sewer, and outside maintenance are included in the maintenance. Move

  Arkadiy Munarov Classic Realty Partners Inc

  199 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /20

  $669,999 Open Sat 2PM - 4PM

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,684 Sq Ft

  4 Rainbow Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to this charming and beautifully renovated Contemporary home, offering a perfect blend of comfort and style. This mint condition home features 3 bedrooms, possibly 4, and 2 full baths, thoughtfully designed with bright, light-filled spaces that create a warm and inviting atmosphere. Originally built in 1996 and beautifully renovated in 2026, the home blends modern updates with timeless

  David Jaramillo Realty Connect USA L I Inc

  4 Rainbow Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /47

  $999,999

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • 2,500 Sq Ft

  7 Sander Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Spectacular home renovated with high end modern luxury finishes. The kitchen is a show-stopping modern masterpiece with custom cabinetry and porcelain center island. The porcelain countertops with full height backsplash creates a sleek, cohesive, ultra luxury look. The kitchen is equipped with professional grade stainless steel ZLINE appliances including a built in refrigerator, wall oven with

  Gina Galante Realty Connect USA L I Inc

  7 Sander Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  /2

  $170,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 792 Sq Ft

  63 Bailey Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to 63 Bailey Court, Middle Island! 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom Upper Unit Co-op. Utilities are off and it is in need of renovation.

  Amanda Rose OverSouth LLC

  63 Bailey Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /35

  $479,990

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 1,870 Sq Ft

  654 Birchwood Park Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Enjoy Country Club Living At It's Best! Resort Style Living In This Spacious And Updated MALIBU MODEL Townhouse! With Golf Views Just Steps Away From The 9th Hole! The Paved And Extended Patio Is Perfect For Entertaining Or Just For Relaxing! This Beautiful Model Home Is Perfectly Maintained With Updated Kitchen With extra Kitchen Cabinets And Counter Space, Stainless Appliances, Granite Counter

  Lilly Kaklamanis Realty Connect USA LI Inc

  654 Birchwood Park Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /31

  $215,900 Open Sat 1PM - 3PM

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 836 Sq Ft

  57 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to Artist Lake Condominiums — Situated on the First Floor, with Private Patio, Gas cooking, Central Air conditioning & more- this condo can be the perfect downsizer, snow bird, investment or first-time home! Enjoy resort-style living with access to fantastic community amenities, including a swimming pool, fitness center, tennis and basketball courts, dog park, and a playground— perfect

  Lisa Palermo Signature Premier Properties

  57 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /3

  $235,000

  • Land
  • 1 Acre
  • $235,000 per Acre

  0 W Bartlett Rd Unit KEY957053, Middle Island, NY 11953

  * Discover a prime 1-acre vacant lot in Middle Island NY 11953. Perfect for building your custom home or investment project. Quite residential setting with easy access to parks, 7 minutes from Strathmore commons shopping mall, and major roadways. Endless possibilities, strong area growth and ample space for your vision. * Lot is located in the middle of nature preserve which offers privacy.*

  Usman Naeem OverSouth LLC

  0 W Bartlett Rd Unit KEY957053, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /30

  $595,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,444 Sq Ft

  48 Kate Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to Effortless Luxury & Resort-Style Living! This stunning Hampton model offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and lifestyle in a sought-after 24/7 gated community designed for effortless living. From the moment you enter, you’ll be greeted by a welcoming foyer with a convenient half bath just off the front door. The thoughtfully designed floor plan features a spacious first-floor

  Gina Orlando Executive Group Realty

  48 Kate Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /23

  $199,999

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 800 Sq Ft

  83 Gauguin Ct Unit 83, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Move right into this beautifully updated 1st-floor one bedroom, one bathroom unit in the desirable Picasso Way Community! This spacious home features stainless steel appliances, gas cooking, abundant cabinet and counter space, plank tile flooring, and a stylish tile backsplash. A dedicated laundry room conveniently located right off of the kitchen adds everyday ease. The open-concept living and

  Nicole Chimento Coldwell Banker American Homes

  83 Gauguin Ct Unit 83, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  /2

  $329,000

  • 2 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 947 Sq Ft

  370 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to this beautifully renovated lower-level Arden Model condo offering 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Washer and dryer are conveniently located in the unit. The open living and dining area flows into an efficiency kitchen. The spacious primary bedroom features two closets and a private half bath. The community includes a clubhouse, outdoor pool, gym, playground, and more. Common charges cover

  Rachel Tabibov Voro LLC

  370 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
• 

  

  /23

  $274,900

  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 1,000 Sq Ft

  266 Lake Pointe Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953

  Welcome to your beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath co-op in the desirable Shores community of Middle Island! This upper level home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and value, all within a tranquil setting just minutes from shopping, dining, parks, and scenic hiking trails. Step inside to find a spacious living area and updated kitchen with modern finishes, perfect for everyday

  Jeanette Cinelli Signature Premier Properties

  266 Lake Pointe Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953

Showing Results 1 - 40, Page 1 of 2

Why Live in Middle Island

Middle Island, NY, situated centrally on Long Island, offers a blend of convenience and charm. The hamlet is known for its quiet, tree-lined streets and a variety of home styles, including colonials, Cape Cods, ranch-style, and hi-ranch homes, many of which are set back from the road with large front yards. The Longwood Central School District serves the area, with Longwood Middle School, Longwood Junior High School, and Longwood High School all receiving high ratings. Middle Island provides numerous things to do, such as hiking in the unique Prosser Pines Nature Preserve, which boasts the oldest concentration of white pines on the East Coast, and the adjacent Cathedral Pines County Park, popular for hiking, mountain biking, and camping. The Middle Island Dog Park and local golf courses like Spring Lake Golf Club and Middle Island Country Club offer additional recreational options. Dining options include local favorites like Bagels 101 and Lombardi’s for Italian cuisine. Middle Country Road (State Route 25) runs through the hamlet, providing easy access to Interstate 495 and nearby Long Island Rail Road stations in Yaphank, Medford, and Ronkonkoma, making commutes to Midtown Manhattan feasible in under 90 minutes during peak times. Middle Island also hosts an annual Fireman’s Carnival & Parade each July, featuring rides, games, and fireworks, adding to the community’s appeal.

Learn more about living in Middle Island

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Middle Island, NY?

Homes for sale in Middle Island, NY have an average home price of $443,714.

How many homes have sold over the last 12 months in Middle Island, NY?

207 homes have sold in Middle Island, NY over the last 12 months.

What are the most popular zip codes in Middle Island, NY?

The most popular zip codes in Middle Island, NY include 11953, 11961, 11727, 11980 and 11763.

How much do you need to make to afford a house in Middle Island?

The median home price in Middle Island is $434,500. If you put a 20% down payment of $86,900 and had a 30-year fixed mortgage with an interest rate of 6.11%, your estimated principal and interest payment would be $2,110 a month plus property taxes, HOA fees, home insurance, PMI, and utilities. Using the 28% rule, you would need to make at least $90K a year to afford the median home price in Middle Island. Learn how much home you can afford with our Home Affordability Calculator.

How are the schools in Middle Island, NY?

Middle Island, NY has highly rated public and private schools. Some of the best schools in Middle Island based on Niche Grades are Mount Sinai High School, Mount Sinai Elementary School and Mount Sinai Middle School. Browse all the schools in Middle Island, NY to learn more.

Home Trends in Middle Island, NY

On average, homes in Middle Island, NY sell after 53 days on the market compared to the national average of 54 days. The median sale price for homes in Middle Island, NY over the last 12 months is $430,000, down 7% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price

$430,000

Median Single Family Sale Price

$495,000

Median Townhouse Sale Price

$234,250

Median 2 Bedroom Sale Price

$330,000

Median 1 Bedroom Sale Price

$215,900

Average Price Per Sq Ft

$317

Number of Homes for Sale

34

Last 12 months Home Sales

207

Months of Supply

2.00

Median List Price

$434,500

Median Change From 1st List Price

0%

Median Home Sale Price YoY Change

-7%