Colonial Homes for Sale in Middletown, NJ

Get In Before The Netflix Rush: A commuters dream come true and less than 5 minutes from the NYC / Belford Ferry and a short drive to the GSP. Once inside you'll see why this is one of the smartest buys on the Bayshore right now. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home was rebuilt and elevated, giving you modern peace of mind in a location that's about to become one of the hottest

Kaycee Cavicchia RE/MAX Revolution

Christine Panzica RE/MAX Revolution

Welcome to 31 Hosford Avenue, a beautifully renovated Colonial offering nearly 2,500 square feet of refined, light-filled living space. Hardwood floors flow throughout the open interior, featuring an updated kitchen with custom cabinetry, granite countertops, an expansive center island and stainless steel appliances. Spacious dining and sitting areas open to a large deck and fully fenced

Tammy O'Brien O'Brien Realty, LLC

Welcome to 9 Emory Drive, ideally situated on a quiet, tree-lined street in the heart of Lincroft. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers approximately 2,298 square feet of inviting living space, hardwood floors, two fireplaces, an updated kitchen and a finished basement. Set on nearly half an acre, the private backyard features mature woods, an in-ground gunite pool and a

Angela Cora Sackman Realty

*** New Lower Price!** This character filled Colonial, dating back to the 1880s, is rich with history and timeless appeal. Featuring original hardwood floors, trestled ceilings, and classic architectural details., the home offers 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, along with the warmth and ambiance of two wood burning stoves. Set on approximately 0.46 acres, the property provides ample outdoor space and

Lisa Alaimo VRI Homes

Set along the Navesink River, this circa 1900 farmhouse was completely rebuilt & reimagined in 2015, offering exceptional waterfront living with a substantial Ipe dock & beautiful sunrises and sunsets over the water. The 4,149 sf home spans 3 levels while preserving original millwork, beamed ceilings, built-ins & doors. The oversized foyer with wainscoting & floating stair opens to gracious

Kelly Zaccaro Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

Welcome to this beautifully renovated farmhouse, a wonderful blend of historic charm and modern living. Over 250 years old, this home has been thoughtfully updated while preserving the character and details that make an older home so special. Inside, you'll find three spacious bedrooms and 2.5 baths, including a lovely primary bedroom with its own private bathroom. The heart of the home is the

Joann Wiener C21 Thomson & Co.

Tucked away on a quiet street in Middletown, this expansive 5-bedroom, 4-full-bath home offers 4,469 sq ft of living space, generously sized rooms and a versatile floor plan. The bright, open first floor features an eat-in kitchen with granite countertops, center island and stainless steel appliances, plus spacious family room, living room/game room and dining room. A flexible first-floor room

Graziella Caruso EXP Realty

Set high above the Navesink River on a bluff with a rare gentle slope to the river, this exceptional 1894 Queen Anne Victorian combines remarkable architectural character with the amenities of a thoroughly updated waterfront home. Sweeping 180° river views unfold from nearly every level. A private dock with illuminated boardwalk, boat lift & 2 jet-ski lifts extends to the water, complemented by a

Kelly Zaccaro Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

4 BR, 2.5-bath Colonial in the heart of desirable Lincroft. Filled with natural light, the open-concept floor plan features an oversized gourmet kitchen with two oversized center islands, granite countertops, Viking range, S/S appliances, and seamless flow into the great room, living room, and dining room. Vaulted ceilings, Anderson French doors & cottage windows open to the patio & backyard,

Christopher Casucci Robert DeFalco Realty Inc.

THE ULTIMATE PRIVATE RESORT. Handsome Colonial estate set on 2.73 acres along prestigious Navesink River Road, gracefully positioned nearly 250' from the street amidst lush, manicured grounds. The property is a true retreat, featuring a stunning pool and a private sport court--pickleball, anyone? Modern construction showcases high ceilings and an open, flowing floor plan enhanced by oversized

Mario Venancio Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach - Rumson

Just Listed! Welcome to 11 Sir Paul Court, a spacious 4 bedroom Colonial tucked away on a quiet four home cul de sac in Middletown. Offering approximately 3,676 square feet of living space, this home checks all the boxes with 2 full and 2 half baths, a beautifully renovated kitchen, generous living and dining spaces, a family room with fireplace, finished walk out basement and an impressive 2nd

Kristina Mager Coldwell Banker Realty

Coming Soon! Showings begin Saturday 9/26. Welcome to 41 Hillyer, a truly exceptional 6 bedroom, 3.5 bath Colonial in the highly sought after Oak Hill section. Beautifully appointed throughout, this stunning residence features exquisite hardwood flooring, sophisticated finishes and beautifully updated bathrooms. The gourmet chef's kitchen is a showpiece with granite countertops, stainless steel

Kristina Mager Coldwell Banker Realty

Experience refined living in the highly desirable Oak Hill section of Middletown. This impressive cedar-shake Colonial blends timeless elegance with a beautiful, nature-inspired setting. Expansive, light-filled rooms, oversized windows, and two fireplaces create a warm yet sophisticated atmosphere. The newer gourmet kitchen features a Viking stove, granite countertops, and custom cabinetry. The

Christele Terranova-beam Coldwell Banker Realty

Welcome to this beautifully renovated (2025) brick-front Colonial on a quiet double cul-de-sac in desirable Middletown Township. This exceptional home offers 5 spacious bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and 1 half bath, combining timeless elegance with modern upgrades throughout. A grand double front doorway welcomes you into a thoughtfully updated interior with abundant natural light and quality

Matthew Sirchio EXP Realty

Welcome to 25 Brittany Court, an exceptional residence in the highly sought-after Cottage Gate community of Atlantic Highlands.** Originally showcased as the community's model home, this distinguished property offers timeless design, spacious interiors, and the low-maintenance lifestyle today's discerning buyers desire. A dramatic two-story foyer with soaring vaulted ceilings welcomes guests into

Stefanie Prettyman Compass New Jersey, LLC - Fair Haven

Welcome to this spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Center Hall Colonial, ideally located in a desirable Middletown neighborhood. The inviting first floor features an updated kitchen, formal living and dining rooms, and a comfortable family room with a wood-burning fireplace. A versatile bonus room provides the perfect space for a home office, playroom, or flex space, while a first-floor powder room and

Shara Moran RE/MAX First Class

This is a Coming Soon and cannot be shown until Sunday, September 27! Just in time to be home for the holidays! Loved by the same owners for nearly 40 years, this 4-BD, 1.5-BA Colonial is ready for its next chapter. Tucked on a cul-de-sac with a comfortably sized property, it features an expansive front porch, heated 1-car garage, newer roof, replacement windows in progress & refreshed curb

Angela White NextHome Peninsula Realty Group

"Welcome Home" to this beautifully maintained double door Colonial Split, located in highly desirable Lincroft. You will be delighted to enter the impressive foyer with ceramic tiled floor, that leads to the spacious interior. Some features are the generous size living room with recently refinished gleaming hardwood floor as well as 4 amazing bedrooms also with refinished hardwood floors, formal

Carol O'hare Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

Sophisticated luxury meets exceptional indoor-outdoor living in this impressive 6-bedroom, 5.5-bath Chapel Hill residence. A gracious wraparound porch introduces beautifully appointed interiors featuring extensive crown molding, tray ceilings, custom built-ins and refined finishes throughout. The chef-inspired kitchen showcases granite and quartz surfaces, a 6-burner Monogram range, Monogram

Irene Zitzner NextHome Peninsula Realty Group

Welcome to this stunning, completely rebuilt home in the heart of Atlantic Highlands, ideally situated in the highly desirable Middletown Township School District! Offering approximately 2,775 square feet of beautifully designed living space on an expansive 150x125 lot, this exceptional home seamlessly blends modern luxury, thoughtful design, and incredible outdoor living. The thoughtfully

Alyson Mueller C21 Thomson & Co.

Rare opportunity on beautiful Shadow Lake in the desirable River Plaza section! Enjoy lake views, direct lake access, and a peaceful setting on a quiet dead-end street, all within walking distance to vibrant downtown Red Bank. Relax or entertain on two spacious decks while taking in the scenery, and enjoy the added charm of a tree house tucked among the trees.Located in the highly

MARISSA BASSO Daunno Realty Services

This is a Middletown home with a Red Bank zip code 07701. A most desired home is hitting the market!!! This 5 BR 3.5 baths with a full 2nd kitchen, bath and bedroom with a separate entrance sits back off the road with a gated entrance There is a generac system ,there is an arbor in the yard, a Sunsetter awning over deck, skylites, a full wall, wood FP, solar panels, inground saltwater pool and a

Carole Kubis EXP Realty

Set on 1.16 acres with sweeping, unobstructed views of Beacon Hill Golf & Country Club and the Manhattan skyline, this custom-built 2019 estate offers a rare blend of privacy, scenery, & convenience, just minutes to the NYC ferry for a quick commute. With 5 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, 10' ceilings, and an open layout, the home is designed for both everyday living & entertaining. The chef's kitchen

Michele Kiely-Richards Weichert Realtors-Rumson

Private Oasis in Lincroft!! This turnkey SMART home offers exceptional living inside and out. Open-concept kitchen featuring a large granite island, abundant cabinetry, and storage. Kitchen is equipped with KITCHEN AID refrigerator, double wall ovens, cooktop, under-counter microwave, and wine cooler. The inviting living room features a cozy gas fireplace. Private backyard oasis, featuring a

Janine Mazzaro Coldwell Banker Realty

Welcome to this gracious and meticulously cared for 4 bedroom,2.5 bath Classic Center Hall Colonial. Situated in a lovely established 1/2 mile circle neighborhood, ideally situated on a beautiful 3/4 acre private, level backyard perfect for creating your own family oasis. Built in 1968 this charming home offers tremendous living space, from the moment you enter you will feel the warmth and love

Carol O'hare Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

Welcome to this architecturally distinctive 2 bedroom, 2 bath home, offering modern upgrades, low maintenance and condo style living without the hoa or being attached. If you are looking for hassle free property upkeep this property is for you. No yards to mow or take care of. Stylish paver patio and deck to relax outside and maintenance free rock landscaping surround the property. This fully

David Scalese EXP Realty

Luxury at the Jersey Shore! Breathtaking views of Sandy Hook from the large balcony on the 4th floor. Only minutes from the SeaStreak Ferry to NYC and tucked high in the hills of Highlands away from the flood zone. This modern and contemporary custom home with approx 3,100+ sqft of living space was re-built from the studs in 2023. The builder used all high-end building materials and finishes

Brian McNamara Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

Calling all Builders! Large corner lot in Atlantic HIghlands with 2 rental properties on it! Great possibilities to renovate, expand or build new! Close to downtown shops, restaurants, movies & Harbor! Atlantic Highlands is an Amazing home town close to area beaches, trails, A great Art & Film culture and a Wonderful place to call home! Perfect for commuters with easy access to NYC via driving,

Erin Hughes Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

Welcome to 64 Locust Ave, an extraordinary custom new construction residence just completed by Lenape Builders, ideally positioned on a spectacular .60-acre property backing to the Navesink River in one of Monmouth County's most prestigious locations. Offering approximately 6,100 sq ft of beautifully finished living space across four levels, this exceptional home delivers unobstructed water

Aleksandr Pritsker EXP Realty

New construction in Holmdel sitting on a 1.35 acres. 5 beds, 4 full baths, 3-car garage -- this house is built with real attention to detail and thoughtfully designed. The primary suite has a custom walk-in closet, primary bath with shower and soak in tub. A fully finished with walk-out access completes the home so all you need to do is move in and unpack., The backyard is peaceful and scenic.

Bleranda Spahiu Keller Williams Village Square Realty

The one that could get away!! A charming 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath coastal retreat nestled in the scenic Highlands. Perched High With Views of NYC, The Atlantic Ocean, Navesink River & Sea Bright Beaches! Filled with character and natural light, this inviting home features a beautifully appointed kitchen with quartz countertops, farmhouse sink, stainless steel appliances and subway tile. Spacious

Amanda Cruz Signature Realty NJ

Welcome to 241 Shore Drive, a beautifully maintained 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home in one of Jersey Shore's most desirable coastal towns. Warm hardwood floors, freshly painted areas and thoughtfully maintained living spaces create a welcoming, move-in-ready home. The lower level offers flexible bonus space ideal for a home office, guest room or gym, plus access to the attached garage and additional

Emily Ross Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty