35 S Penataquit Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
Downtown Bay Shore NeighborhoodEstimated payment $12,793/month
Highlights
- 1.4 Acre Lot
- Deck
- High Ceiling
- Brook Avenue Elementary School Rated A
- 4 Fireplaces
- Wine Refrigerator
About This Home
Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer.
This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.
Listing Agent
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty Brokerage Phone: 631-647-7013 License #10301220901 Listed on: 04/10/2026
Home Details
Home Type
- Single Family
Est. Annual Taxes
- $25,396
Year Built
- Built in 1890
Lot Details
- 1.4 Acre Lot
Parking
- 3 Car Garage
Home Design
- Frame Construction
- Cedar
Interior Spaces
- 5,646 Sq Ft Home
- 3-Story Property
- High Ceiling
- 4 Fireplaces
- Entrance Foyer
- Formal Dining Room
- Storage
- Partially Finished Basement
- Basement Fills Entire Space Under The House
Kitchen
- Eat-In Kitchen
- Gas Oven
- Gas Cooktop
- Dishwasher
- Wine Refrigerator
- Stainless Steel Appliances
- Trash Compactor
- Disposal
Bedrooms and Bathrooms
- 9 Bedrooms
- En-Suite Primary Bedroom
Laundry
- Dryer
- Washer
Outdoor Features
- Deck
- Porch
Schools
- Brook Avenue Elementary School
- Bay Shore Middle School
- Bay Shore Senior High School
Utilities
- Ductless Heating Or Cooling System
- Cooling System Mounted To A Wall/Window
- Heating System Uses Natural Gas
- Natural Gas Connected
- Gas Water Heater
Listing and Financial Details
- Exclusions: Kitchen and Dining Room Chandeliers
- Legal Lot and Block 27 / 2
- Assessor Parcel Number 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000
Map
Home Values in the Area
Average Home Value in this Area
Tax History
| Year | Tax Paid | Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. | Land | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | -- | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2023 | -- | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2022 | $20,385 | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2021 | $20,385 | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2020 | $21,068 | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2019 | $20,385 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| 2018 | -- | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2017 | $20,279 | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2016 | $20,275 | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2015 | -- | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
| 2014 | -- | $77,900 | $17,900 | $60,000 |
Property History
| Date | Event | Price | List to Sale | Price per Sq Ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 04/10/2026 04/10/26 | For Sale | $1,999,999 | 0.0% | $354 / Sq Ft |
| 09/25/2024 09/25/24 | Price Changed | $1,810 | -2.9% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/21/2024 09/21/24 | Price Changed | $1,865 | +0.8% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/20/2024 09/20/24 | Price Changed | $1,850 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/18/2024 09/18/24 | Price Changed | $1,845 | +0.8% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/14/2024 09/14/24 | Price Changed | $1,830 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/13/2024 09/13/24 | Price Changed | $1,835 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/11/2024 09/11/24 | Price Changed | $1,840 | +0.5% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/09/2024 09/09/24 | Price Changed | $1,830 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/07/2024 09/07/24 | Price Changed | $1,825 | +0.8% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/06/2024 09/06/24 | Price Changed | $1,810 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/04/2024 09/04/24 | Price Changed | $1,815 | -0.5% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 09/02/2024 09/02/24 | Price Changed | $1,825 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/31/2024 08/31/24 | Price Changed | $1,820 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/31/2024 08/31/24 | Price Changed | $1,815 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/27/2024 08/27/24 | Price Changed | $1,820 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/26/2024 08/26/24 | Price Changed | $1,825 | +1.4% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/24/2024 08/24/24 | Price Changed | $1,800 | -1.4% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/23/2024 08/23/24 | Price Changed | $1,825 | +4.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 08/22/2024 08/22/24 | Price Changed | $1,750 | +0.6% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/21/2024 08/21/24 | Price Changed | $1,740 | +3.0% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/21/2024 08/21/24 | Price Changed | $1,690 | -1.7% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/20/2024 08/20/24 | Price Changed | $1,720 | +0.6% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/18/2024 08/18/24 | Price Changed | $1,710 | +0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/17/2024 08/17/24 | Price Changed | $1,705 | -0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/15/2024 08/15/24 | Price Changed | $1,710 | +1.2% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/14/2024 08/14/24 | Price Changed | $1,690 | -3.2% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/13/2024 08/13/24 | Price Changed | $1,745 | +1.2% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/07/2024 08/07/24 | Price Changed | $1,725 | +5.8% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/07/2024 08/07/24 | Price Changed | $1,630 | -3.0% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/05/2024 08/05/24 | Price Changed | $1,680 | -1.5% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/03/2024 08/03/24 | Price Changed | $1,705 | -2.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 08/07/2023 08/07/23 | For Rent | -- | -- | -- |
| 07/30/2023 07/30/23 | Price Changed | $1,745 | 0.0% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 07/12/2023 07/12/23 | Price Changed | $1,745 | +1.7% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 07/12/2023 07/12/23 | Price Changed | $1,715 | -1.7% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 07/11/2023 07/11/23 | Price Changed | $1,745 | -1.4% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 07/03/2023 07/03/23 | Price Changed | $1,770 | -1.7% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 07/01/2023 07/01/23 | Price Changed | $1,800 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 06/30/2023 06/30/23 | Price Changed | $1,795 | +1.1% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 06/29/2023 06/29/23 | Price Changed | $1,775 | +11.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 06/28/2023 06/28/23 | Price Changed | $1,595 | -19.0% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 06/21/2023 06/21/23 | For Rent | -- | -- | -- |
| 04/11/2023 04/11/23 | Price Changed | $1,970 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 04/07/2023 04/07/23 | Price Changed | $1,965 | +4.0% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 04/03/2023 04/03/23 | Price Changed | $1,890 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 04/02/2023 04/02/23 | Price Changed | $1,895 | -1.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 03/31/2023 03/31/23 | Price Changed | $1,920 | +0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 03/29/2023 03/29/23 | Price Changed | $1,915 | +1.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 03/28/2023 03/28/23 | Price Changed | $1,890 | +1.6% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 03/27/2023 03/27/23 | Price Changed | $1,860 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 03/18/2023 03/18/23 | Price Changed | $1,865 | -0.3% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 03/18/2023 03/18/23 | Price Changed | $1,870 | +14.7% | $5 / Sq Ft |
| 02/28/2023 02/28/23 | Price Changed | $1,630 | -0.9% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/28/2023 02/28/23 | Price Changed | $1,645 | -0.6% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/25/2023 02/25/23 | Price Changed | $1,655 | -0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/23/2023 02/23/23 | Price Changed | $1,660 | +3.1% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/23/2023 02/23/23 | Price Changed | $1,610 | -0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/22/2023 02/22/23 | Price Changed | $1,615 | -0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/20/2023 02/20/23 | Price Changed | $1,620 | +0.6% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/18/2023 02/18/23 | Price Changed | $1,610 | -0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/17/2023 02/17/23 | Price Changed | $1,615 | -0.3% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/16/2023 02/16/23 | Price Changed | $1,620 | -0.9% | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 02/15/2023 02/15/23 | Price Changed | $1,635 | -- | $4 / Sq Ft |
| 06/07/2022 06/07/22 | For Rent | -- | -- | -- |
| 05/19/2022 05/19/22 | For Rent | -- | -- | -- |
Purchase History
| Date | Type | Sale Price | Title Company |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deed | $1,150,000 | Sutton Land Title | |
| Deed | $1,150,000 | Sutton Land Title | |
| Deed | -- | -- | |
| Deed | -- | -- | |
| Interfamily Deed Transfer | -- | Fidelity National Title Ins | |
| Interfamily Deed Transfer | -- | Fidelity National Title Ins |
Mortgage History
| Date | Status | Loan Amount | Loan Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open | $550,000 | New Conventional | |
| Closed | $550,000 | New Conventional |
Source: OneKey® MLS
MLS Number: 944725
APN: 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
The data relating to real estate for sale or lease on this web site comes in part from OneKey® MLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Ten-X are marked with the OneKey® MLS logo or an abbreviated logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Copyright 2026 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID
- 28 S Montgomery Ave
- 100A Awixa Ave
- 100 Awixa Ave
- 7 Montgomery Ln
- 108 Awixa Ave
- 25 Shore Ln
- 1 Joyces Way
- 4 Colonial Ct
- 2 Bay Place
- 11 Allen Point Rd
- 88 Penataquit Ave
- 57 2nd Ave
- 9 Joseph St
- 12 Edwin St
- 91 Ocean Ave
- 150 Main St Unit 57
- 150 Main St Unit 32
- 150 Main St Unit 1A
- 19 Westside Ave
- 2 Burnett Ave
- 407 E Main St Unit 1B
- 405 E Main St
- 413 E Main St
- 39 Chapman Place Unit 1
- 1991 Union Blvd
- 11 1st Ave
- 11 S Saxon Ave Unit 3E
- 11 Maple Ave
- 11 S Saxon Ave
- 29 C Bay Shore Ave
- 52 1st Ave
- 1 E Main St
- 9 Willowbrook Ave Unit 7C
- 9 Willowbrook Ave Unit 9B
- 11 Willowbrook Ave Unit 8D
- 1-3, 2-4 Main St & 4th Ave
- 54 2nd Ave
- 16 Saxon Ave Unit 29
- 16 Saxon Ave Unit 23
- 16 N Saxon Ave
Ask me questions while you tour the home.