Wautoma, WI Homes for Sale under $400,000

Huge Price Reduction as sellers are motivated to sell!!!! This charming home on 19.5 acres is ready for new owners. Inside this turn key home are 2 bedrooms, main floor laundry, master bedroom, bathroom and a spacious open concept main level. Newer electrical panel, annually serviced HVAC equipment, metal roof all make this a buyers dream house. Outside there is a 2.5 car detached garage, another

Dan Dahlke

Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group

Step in local lore, **Le Shack II** is more than a cabin—it's part of Wisconsin's fly-fishing heritage. This beautifully restored former one-room schoolhouse sits on 4.3 wooded acres along the renowned White River, one of Wisconsin's premier trout streams, and borders hundreds of acres of DNR land. Completely rebuilt in 2022 with exceptional craftsmanship, this 2BR/1BA retreat blends historic

Michelle Fenske

First Weber, Inc.

This 3-bedroom, 1-bath home is ready for someone with vision to bring it back to life. Featuring a newer 2-car detached garage and an extra-deep lot, you'll enjoy a spacious backyard with added privacy and room to relax or play. With some repairs and updating, this property offers excellent potential for homeowners or investors alike. Conveniently located close to shopping, schools, parks, and

John Eagan

First Weber, Inc.

If you love nature this is a place for you. Here is a home snug in the woods. Has a wooded lot on each side of the home for your privacy. Sellers have done many updates to this home over the years.Kitchen was updated with new cabinets and counter tops. Large Master bedroom suite, large walk in tile shower. Wood stove in the living room. Hot water heater new in 2016. AC new in 2021 Per Seller.

Karen Tschurwald

First Weber, Inc.

Enjoy the lake lifestyle without the lakefront price tag! This charming 2-bed, 1-bath home offers deeded access to Upper White River Mill Pond, just a short walk down the road. Inside you'll find many updates, including newer flooring. Step outside to a large backyard with a spacious deck perfect for grilling and relaxing, plus a beautiful rock fire pit for summer evenings. Upper Mill Pond offers

Bobbi Ruffalo

First Weber, Inc.

Well-maintained, income-producing upper/lower duplex with both units currently rented, offering immediate cash flow and investment potential! Each unit features 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath. The lower unit (936 sq. ft.) offers two private entrances and its own washer/dryer hookups, while the upper unit (900 sq. ft.) provides a bright, functional layout with comfortable living space. Tenants pay

Michelle Fenske

First Weber, Inc.

This 4-bedroom (1bd considered nonconforming, have to walk thru bd room to get to it) 1.5-bath home sits on 2 scenic acres in Waushara County just minutes from downtown Wautoma. The 1.5-story layout includes a 1-car attached garage and a new roof and well in 2023. While the home needs new windows/siding, kitchen floor is sloping, it offers endless possibilities for renovation and personalization.

Michelle Fenske

First Weber, Inc.

Beuatifully Remodeled Ranch home on 4.58 Acres near Porters Lake. Experience the perfect combination of privacy, comfort ,and outdoor recreation with this beautifully reodeled 2 bedroom 1 bath ranch home nestled on 4.58 senic acres. Move in ready and thoughtfully updated throughout this charming property. Home features brand new luxury vinyl plank flooring, a cozy fireplace, updated finishes, and

Karen Tschurwald

First Weber, Inc.

This home has had a lot of updates. Spiral staircase was taken out and steps to the upstairs and the basement were installed. New flooring and paint throughout the home. Upper cabinets in kitchen were removed to give a better view, and allow more sunlight in. New septic was installed in 2025. 2 mini splits were also installed. You are surrounded by nature.

Karen Tschurwald

First Weber, Inc.