Newest Homes for Rent in Amagansett, NY

Discover the charm of Amagansett at this stunning Bluff Road Beach House, available for summer and fall 2025. Located in one of the area’s most sought-after spots, this historic 5+ bedroom home offers spectacular views of the dunes and ocean, with a perfect mix of vintage character and modern comfort. Built in 1911 and recently renovated, the home features a sun-soaked interior, full of

Best at the Beach. Charming Scheffer traditional on a sandy dunes lane, that leads straight down the street to the ocean beach. This warm, inviting beach house offers 4 spacious bedrooms, beamed ceiling living area with a wall of French doors opening to grand deck and private backyard. Dine al fresco or create an intimate meal in the dining room set apart from the main house. One of the treats of

Discover this modern gem of a beach house on 3 private acres with 355 feet of water frontage on Gardiner's Bay. The private path over a dune leads to an oasis of wide sandy beach perfectly situated for sensational direct evening sunsets. The open interior has walls of glass for continuous water views and to invite in warm coastal breezes throughout. There are 5 bedrooms, 6 baths, den and separate

This barn style house has it all with its open and airy living area. It features wooded floors throughout and two fireplaces. It also hosts a European Style kitchen in addition to the open dining, living room and pool table playing area. There is a den leading out to an enclosed screened-in porch, and outdoor decking featuring a swimming pool and outdoor shower. This terrific house is a great

Step into this beautifully restored 1930's cottage, where timeless charm meets modern comfort. With cozy, easy living vibes, this home is the perfect backdrop for your next summer vacation. Featuring a first-floor primary ensuite bedroom, plus a second ensuite and two guest rooms upstairs, it's ideal for families or friends. Set on over an acre of private land, the expansive backyard invites you

Jeremiah Baker built this house in the 1850s from proceeds gained during the California Gold Rush. He later became an entrepreneur operating the first daily stage coach mail from Sag Harbor to East Hampton. Today the house has been renovated to its original splendor, rightfully reclaiming its position as one of the first and most prominent houses in the history-rich hamlet of Amagansett.

Set deep within a private, wooded enclave of Amagansett, 41 Deep Wood Lane offers a rare opportunity to experience one of the East End's most cherished natural settings with remarkable tranquility. Approached by a long, secluded drive and enveloped by mature trees and lush plantings, the property feels deeply peaceful, yet remains moments from Amagansett's beloved farm stands and its world-class

Renovated both inside and out, this beautiful Amagansett Dunes cottage has it all! Located just around 400 feet to ocean beach walkway, this charming house has just been completely landscaped including a brand new lawn, blue stone patio in back with all new outdoor furniture including dining table and chairs, gas BBQ, and entertaining area with sofa and chairs. The new blue stone walkway leads