Barnum Island, NY Houses for Sale

/29
$699,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,100 Sq Ft
123 Baker Ct, Island Park, NY 11558

Turnkey Perfection on Baker Court! This beautifully updated ranch is truly move-in ready and filled with modern amenities. Featuring 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, the home boasts hardwood floors throughout, vaulted ceilings, and a stylish barn door providing privacy between the main living area and backyard/basement.The fully finished basement adds valuable bonus space ideal

Richard Krug

Coldwell Banker American Homes

(516) 407-8474

123 Baker Ct, Island Park, NY 11558
Explore Barnum Island
/26
$750,000
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,002 Sq Ft
189 Pennsylvania Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

Welcome to 189 Pennsylvania Avenue, Island Park! Located just minutes from Long Beach and within walking distance to shops, parks, and transportation, this meticulously maintained and thoughtfully upgraded home sits on a desirable corner lot with exceptional space and charm. The first floor features a spacious and sunlit living room, a formal dining room perfect for hosting, and an eat-in kitchen

Michael Venuto Link NY Realty

189 Pennsylvania Ave, Island Park, NY 11558
/8
$575,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,250 Sq Ft
163 Vanderbilt Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

Great Opportunity To Make This Adorable 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom Home in the Lovely Barnum Isle Section of Island Park Yours Before It's Gone.

Michelle Rivera Island Advantage Realty LLC

163 Vanderbilt Ave, Island Park, NY 11558
/21
$659,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,365 Sq Ft
9 Hamilton Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

Charming 3-Bedroom Home with Expansive Yard in Island Park/Barnum Isle!Welcome to this warm and inviting 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home situated on a generous 8,000 sq ft lot in the desirable Island Park/Barnum Isle area. This well-maintained property offers a rare combination of indoor comfort and outdoor space, featuring a huge backyard and oversized side yard—perfect for entertaining,

Christina Carter Douglas Elliman Real Estate

9 Hamilton Ave, Island Park, NY 11558
/46
$1,499,000
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 3,335 Sq Ft
248 Delaware Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

STUNNING BAYFRONT!Nestled away on the east side of Barnum Isle is where you find this stunning and very spacious Colonial -Contemporary, which seamlessly blends a stately home with a waterfront lifestyle. This incredible four or five bedroom, three bathroom beauty is situated on an oversized 52' x 160' waterfront property. You are greeted by a charming covered lemonade porch w/ never

Michael Scully Century 21 Scully Realty

248 Delaware Ave, Island Park, NY 11558
/30
$809,000
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,021 Sq Ft
4081 Massachusetts Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

Exceptional Hi Ranch with space for Everyone. The cook will love the kitchen with the prep-Island, SS Appliances & skylight. The Large Living Room is open to the Dining room w/ Andersen Sliders leading to a large deck w/ stairs to your outdoor space. Ideal for hosting gatherings, the yard is fully enclosed and features a hot tub and a brick patioThe main Level has oak flooring, Modern bath with

Maria Cino Quality Home Shoppe Ltd

4081 Massachusetts Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

New York Nassau County Barnum Island

Why Live in Barnum Island

Barnum Island, NY, a South Shore hamlet, offers a quiet suburban lifestyle with a strong connection to fishing and boating in the Western Bays. Residents enjoy easy access to Shell Harbor and Shell Creek for boating and fishing, with facilities like Empire Point Boating Center and Empire Kayaks available for those without private docks. Shell Creek Park provides additional recreational opportunities with athletic courts, a playground, and a splash park. The community is just 2 miles from the Atlantic Ocean and Long Beach’s boardwalk. Housing options include classic single-family homes from the prewar era through the 1960s, featuring Cape Cods, colonials, ranch-style homes, and split-levels, as well as townhouses in The Yacht Club, a gated waterfront community. Barnum Island is part of the Island Park Little League, which hosts an annual Opening Day Parade ending at Shell Creek Park. The area’s commercial hub is Austin Boulevard, offering dining options like Jimmy Hays Steak House, Ananau Peruvian Cuisine, and Moo Burger, along with shopping at King Kullen and nearby stores in Oceanside. Highly rated schools include Francis X. Hegarty Elementary School, Lincoln Orens Middle School, and Long Beach High School, known for its award-winning choir. Commuting options include the Island Park LIRR Station with a 50-minute ride to Penn Station and a 30-mile drive to Manhattan. JFK Airport is 11 miles away, and Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital is 4 miles away. Residents should be aware of the flood zone risk, necessitating flood insurance and preventive measures.

Learn more about living in Barnum Island

Home Trends in Barnum Island, NY

On average, homes in Barnum Island, NY sell after 104 days on the market compared to the national average of 70 days. The median sale price for homes in Barnum Island, NY over the last 12 months is $487,500, down 24% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price

$487,500

Median Single Family Sale Price

$750,000

Median 2 Bedroom Sale Price

$752,499

Median 1 Bedroom Sale Price

$445,000

Average Price Per Sq Ft

$556

Number of Homes for Sale

Last 12 months Home Sales

Months of Supply

8.40

Median List Price

$614,999

Median Change From 1st List Price

Median Home Sale Price YoY Change

-24%

How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home

In Barnum Island, there are currently 6 houses for sale, offering an array of options for potential buyers. With houses priced between $575,000 to $1,499,000, there's a range to accomodate every budget. As of August, 2025 the median home price in Barnum Island is $614,999, while the average sale price is $595,999, offering insights into the local housing market. On average, houses spend 104 days listed before being sold. Whether you're searching for a single-family residence, exploring single-family detached houses for sale, or considering new construction houses for sale, there are options to cater to different lifestyles. Explore the listings and houses for sale in Barnum Island, NY and find the perfect place to call home.

Barnum Island Types of Homes for Sale

More About Living in Barnum Island

Homes in Nearby Neighborhoods

Homes in Nearby Cities

Homes in Nearby Counties

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage