Recently Sold Elm Heights Homes

This handsome home circa early 1800s is one of the oldest homes in Bloomington. This was the original home in this part of Bloomington now known as Elm Heights and Maxwell Manors and was owned by Dr Maxwell, Bloomington’s first physician, who was sometimes called the “father of Indiana University.” This beautiful Home on this fantastic corner lot near Bryan Park and the Indiana University campus

Jeffrey Franklin FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

Finally, a home that takes your breath away! Impressive stone taper columns & broad windows beckon you in. First impressions are everything and this Craftsman bungalow exudes historic charm & warmth from the first step over the threshold. With modern renovations that remedy the worries of owning a historic home, this one is ready for you. True to Arts & Crafts era, all the earmarks are intact.

Don Griffin Griffin Realty Holdings LLC

Excellent investment opportunity! 2 blocks to campus!!! 3 bedroom with 3 occupancy permit. Zero vacancy rental history. Invest in Bloomington today! Leases signed: Current Lease: $2,675/month - 08/14/2024 - 07/18/2025 Signed future lease: $2,800/month - Aug 2025 - July 2026

Chris Clark Century 21 Scheetz - Bloomington

This well-maintained and updated 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath limestone home is located just blocks from Indiana University in the desirable Elm Heights neighborhood of Bloomington, IN. The main level features a formal living room with hardwood floors and 9 foot ceilings, a fireplace, and access to both the sunroom and backyard. The remodeled kitchen boasts double ovens, a gas range, custom Nancy Hiller

Trish Sterling Sterling Real Estate

This 2 bedroom, 1 bath Lustron Home is just 1 block south of Atwater adjacent to the IU Campus. This little gem of a bungalow has been a great rental property but it's time to move on. Currently rented till 8/1/2025 for $1,400 per month and already rented for the 25/26 school year for $1,520. This property does have a 5 person HAND permit good thru 4/30/2029, something you don't see often.

Brian Thompson FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

This beautiful 1925 bungalow home in the desirable Elm Heights neighborhood has been completely restored and remodeled! In addition to the cosmetic updates including new flooring, paint, cabinetry, bathroom fixtures, light fixtures, appliances, etc, the home also has a new roof as of 2022, reconstructed foundation, new electrical, new windows, and more, all completed in 2022! This property is

Natalie Utnage Utnage Realty

This charming limestone ranch with a full walkout basement is perfectly positioned in the desirable Elm Heights neighborhood! With 3-bedrooms, 2-bathrooms, and a one-car garage it offers a thoughtfully-designed layout with abundant natural light, thanks to its south-facing orientation. In winter, the home is flooded with warmth, while in summer, it's bright without being overwhelming—enhancing

Sarah Perfetti Northwest Indiana Real Estate

LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! You're not going to find a better location than this! Walking distance to IU's stunning campus, less than a mile to the shopping and restaurants that the East side of town has to offer, and just 1 mile to Kirkwood Ave and downtown! This property truly is in the heart of all that Bloomington has to offer! In addition to the unbeatable location, this beautifully

Natalie Utnage Utnage Realty

This stunning Elm Heights brick home has a marvelous location near Indiana University and wonderful access to the 40 acre Bryan Park. This traditional center entry home has had a wonderful renovation with an additional wing that accommodates a large entertaining kitchen with hand crafted custom cabinetry. Busy gourmets will love two sinks-one for you and one for a sous chef. This delightful

Jeffrey Franklin FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

This amazing 4 bedroom, 2 bath, mid century atomic ranch was purchased from the original owners and refurbished by a local architect in 2009. As you enter you will note the warm, original cork floors that flow throughout this light-filled home. Located just 3 blocks from downtown and Indiana University, the home offers mid century style with an open floor plan, rare in the south campus area.

Becky Wann Becky Wann Real Estate Services

Wonderful opportunity to build your new home or an investment property near IU, downtown Bloomington, and Bryan Park. This is a corner double lot, half of which is in a conservancy. The property owner cannot build on the conservancy portion but can enjoy the use of the space for entertaining, outdoor activities, and gardens. This property is a teardown. The city has stated the home can be razed

Ron Plecher RE/MAX Realty Professionals

Nestled in the heart of the highly sought-after Elm Heights neighborhood, this classic Tudor-style home exudes timeless charm and character. With over 3,300 finished square feet on the main and second levels, the home offers generous living spaces that maintain a warm and inviting ambiance. The updated kitchen adds modern convenience, while the rest of the home provides a wonderful opportunity to

Dawn Evans Century 21 Scheetz - Bloomington

Live the Elm Heights lifestyle! This beautifully modified four square just south of the Indiana University campus has had stunning updates that make this classic home live in a modern way. The Craftsman style of this home was enhanced by an addition to the home that added a large great room and an updated kitchen that is historically complementary to the beautiful design of the original

Jeffrey Franklin FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

Welcome to this quintessential prestigious limestone four square in the heart of one of Bloomington's most desirable neighborhoods, Elm Heights. Immerse yourself as you enter the foyer stepping onto mosaic style terracotta tile leading to the living room with rich oak hardwood floors and spectacular limestone fireplace with an ornate hand carved facade. Move into the gracious dining room with

Jeff Warden RE/MAX Realty Professionals

This income-producing duplex is located near Indiana University and offers steady rental income. Due to it's great location, the property is fully leased through July 2026! Each of the two units features 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and off-street parking. The current monthly rent is $7,575. In August 2025, the monthly rent increases to $8,100. This investment opportunity presents a promising return

Jeff Brawley Brawley Real Estate

This beautifully updated ranch home over finished walkout basement has modern updates in one of Bloomington‘s most established neighborhoods near Indiana University. This home backs up to the Kinsey home (founder of the Kinsey Institute) and is just a couple of blocks from Bryan Park. Bryan Park is a 40 acre city park with recreation, outdoor pool, tennis, arts performance area and walking

Jeffrey Franklin FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

This historic craftsman style home is perfect for those who want a house with character but also the perks of modern finishes. From the original hardwood floors and exposed brick to the updated kitchen and bathrooms, this house has the best of both worlds. The best part? It is centrally located and within walking distance to IU Campus and Kirkwood. While it’s considered move in ready, there’s

Quinton Mayo FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

Mid-Century Modern fans take note of this lovely Bryan Park home with a green space view. Natural stone, pine, hardwoods and clean lines enhance the appeal of this desirable south of campus location near one of Bloomington’s favorite parks. This pristine home with updates has a cathedral ceiling in the great room and a circular plan with a stone gas fireplace, exposed beams, a remodeled kitchen

Jeffrey Franklin FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

SUPER LOCATION Just a few blocks to the Indiana University Campus and to Bryan Park. This charming four square, solid brick home in Elm Heights Subdivision has that wonderful classic front porch everyone loves. The house is sunny and cheerful from all the natural light flowing in through the many high quality, energy efficient, wood windows, which are in great condition. The four season sunroom

Mitzy Lewis Jason Millican Group

This charming limestone 1940’s home south of campus has a perfect location and beautiful high caliber finishes. Beautiful hardwood flooring, a fireplace in the living room and an updated kitchen with a circular floor plan adds to the appeal. The upper level and finished walkout lower level with separate access creates additional bedroom spaces and study opportunities. This home with maple

Jeffrey Franklin FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS

This inviting bungalow, nestled just three blocks south of IU Campus, is move-in ready and filled with classic charm. The home features all original woodwork, beautiful hardwood floors, and a wood-burning fireplace in the living room. A light-filled den off the living room provides a perfect space for a home office. The dining room includes a delightful window seat, while the kitchen is bright

Chris Smith RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

This beautifully updated and well-maintained home sits in the heart of the highly desired Elm Heights neighborhood, walking distance to all that downtown Bloomington and IU have to offer! It offers 5 bedrooms, a main living space, formal dining room, additional living space in the basement, large front porch and is the perfect investment property for your portfolio or a place to call home!

Natalie Utnage Utnage Realty

Dave Nakarado INDIANA Dave Real Estate