City Island Houses for Sale

Just Renovated and Move-In Ready! Step inside the beautifully reimagined home at 98 Pell Place, where timeless charm meets modern comfort. Recently completed in 2025, this fully updated 3-bedroom (lives like a 4BR), 2.5-bath gem has been thoughtfully transformed with meticulous attention to detail — offering the perfect blend of style, space, and functionality. Nestled on a quiet, tree-lined

Eric Staub Keller Williams NY Realty

City Island Oasis: Your Turnkey Island EscapeDiscover the perfect blend of modern comfort and peaceful island living in this beautifully renovated City Island home. The property offers a serene retreat with its spacious, fenced-in backyard that borders a lush wooded lot, providing a private and tranquil setting.You'll find convenience at every turn, with off-street parking for up to

Brenda Prohaska Bee Home Realty

Charming City Island Retreat – 3-Bed, 2-Bath + Bonus Bungalow!Welcome to the heart of City Island, where every day feels like a getaway. Nestled on a lush, private lot, 97 Hawkins Street offers a rare opportunity to own a charming single-family home with unique bonus space and endless potential.This 3-bedroom, 2-bath home opens to a spacious living room full of natural light and

Ronald Echavarria RE/MAX In The City

Water Views - 25 Bay Street – 7,500 ft2 DOUBLE LOT & 3,750 ft2 FARThis serene, WATER VIEW property on a DOUBLE LOT of 75 x 100 square feet, and with an ADDITIONAL 2,550 square feet to expand this house if you so choose - gives this property an undeniable value as a very private, and potentially prominent piece of real estate - on PRIME City Island - with its unusually large total FAR of

Sandra Salander R New York

Live the City Island dream in this beautifully renovated classic Dutch Colonial home. The Certificate of Occupancy for this special property is a desirable 2-family. Currently used as an expansive one-family home with 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 1 half-bathroom with laundry. The first floor features a spacious primary suite with large walk in closet, new carpet and a tastefully

Teddy Island ERA Insite Realty Services

A truly exceptional home on prime City Island! The Certificate of Occupancy of this special property is a desirable 2-family. - Currently used as an expansive one-family home with 5 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 1 half-bathroom. (PRICED JUST REDUCED TO SELL PROMPTLY)An excellent layout over 3 spacious floors - plus a full basement with laundry, storage, egress etc. Direct

Sandra Salander R New York

Nestled just beyond the bridge, this charming ranch-style home presents a fantastic opportunity to create your dream living space. While it awaits your personal touch and updates, the layout offers a solid foundation with all the essentials. On the main floor, you'll find three comfortable bedrooms and a full bathroom. The eat-in kitchen flows seamlessly into the living room, complete with a cozy

Brenda Prohaska Bee Home Realty