Eastern Fire Island Homes for Sale

Eastern Fire Island in Brookhaven is a unique Atlantic barrier island known for its sandy shores, ancient forests, and eclectic beach towns. From May to October, the area is bustling with beachgoers arriving via ferries and water taxis, as vehicles are not allowed on the island. Residents and visitors typically get around by foot or bicycle, with golf carts permitted for those with medical needs and businesses. The island's history is rich with tales of shipwrecks and pirates, and it has been a popular bohemian destination since the 1950s, especially within the LGBTQ+ community. Home styles range from bungalows and cottages to large waterfront houses, with newer homes being winterized for year-round living. Children attend East Moriches Elementary School and Center Moriches Middle School, both of which have high ratings. Outdoor activities are a major draw, with pristine beaches, the Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness area for hiking, and boating at Watch Hill Marina. Smith Point County Park is popular for swimming, surfing, and fishing. Summer events include the Fire Island Invasion and the Maggie Fischer Great South Bay Cross Memorial Swim. Essential supplies can be found at The Harbor Store, The General Store by BASE, and the year-round Mermaid Market grocery store. Dining options include Cherry’s on the Bay and CJ’s Restaurant & Bar, both offering lively atmospheres and ocean views. After summer, the island quiets down, with about 340 full-time residents enjoying the return of waterfowl and the presence of white-tailed deer. Commuters can reach Manhattan in just over an hour via train from Bay Shore.