12

Carey, OH Homes for Sale

Section Image
  • /2

    $45,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,100 Sq Ft

    147 W Brown Ave, Carey, OH 43316

    This 1,100 sq. ft. home has been mostly gutted down to the studs, offering a blank canvas for investors, flippers, or buyers looking to customize every detail to their vision. With the demo already complete, you can jump straight into rebuilding without the hassle and cost of tear out. The property features a functional layout ready to be reimagined. Situated on a quiet street with convenient

    Holly Crislip Key Realty

    147 W Brown Ave, Carey, OH 43316
  • /5

    $42,000

    $10K PRICE INCREASE
    • Land
    • 0 Sq Ft

    57 Autumn Ave, Carey, OH 43316

    Lot #57 - 120' x 160' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Autumn Avenue. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. Buyers to pay for title insurance.

    Kenneth Lucius Key Realty

    57 Autumn Ave, Carey, OH 43316
  • /10

    $102,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,008 Sq Ft

    608 Crabapple Dr, Carey, OH 43316

    Three bedroom ranch in Carey's Snyder Park Development. Large eat-in kitchen and attached garage.

    Bill Hanna RE/MAX Unlimited Results Rlty

    608 Crabapple Dr, Carey, OH 43316
  • /11

    $225,000

    $3K PRICE DROP
    • 2,659 Sq Ft

    517 E Findlay St, Carey, OH 43316

    Great investment opportunity. 5 units all rented. Great rental history. Back lot parking and street parking available. Barn for storage or could also be rented out. Tenant rights apply.

    Kristie Fox BHHS Koehler Realty

    517 E Findlay St, Carey, OH 43316
  • /3

    $42,000

    $2K PRICE INCREASE
    • Land
    • 21,562 Sq Ft
    • $84,848 per Acre

    18 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316

    Lot 18 Phase 11 150'x143.82'Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.

    Kenneth Lucius Key Realty

    18 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316
  • /2

    $199,000

    • Land
    • 7.45 Acres
    • $26,711 per Acre

    0 West St, Carey, OH 43316

    7.45 +or- Acres in Carey Near Fast food restaurants, Caseys Gas Station , Ford Dealership, Day Care Facility .Bring your Ideas to develop this parcel . Will need a lot split and possible Zoning Change .All utilities are very near if not on the parcel .

    Kenneth Lucius Key Realty

    0 West St, Carey, OH 43316
  • /3

    $42,000

    $2K PRICE INCREASE
    • Land
    • 21,605 Sq Ft
    • $84,677 per Acre

    19 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316

    Lot 19 Phase 11 137.70'x160.65'Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568.. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.

    Kenneth Lucius Key Realty

    19 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316
  • /3

    $42,000

    $4K PRICE INCREASE
    • Land
    • 16,291 Sq Ft
    • $112,299 per Acre

    16 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316

    Lot 16 Phase 11 100'x162.90' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in a Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay For Title Insurance.

    Kenneth Lucius Key Realty

    16 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316
  • /2

    $468,000

    $71K PRICE INCREASE
    • Land
    • 18.72 Acres
    • $25,000 per Acre

    0 Sr 23 103 Unit 6104429, Carey, OH 43316

    18.72 Acres Available w/smaller divisions available. Located on the edge of Carey, Ohio with easy access to US23 / OH 15 next to retail and food chain businesses. Agent Owned

    Paul Wagner WMS Marketing Services

    0 Sr 23 103 Unit 6104429, Carey, OH 43316
  • /20

    $110,000

    $30K PRICE DROP
    • 4 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,318 Sq Ft

    444 Frederick St, Carey, OH 43316

    Spacious 4 bedroom 1 bath home located on a cul-de-sac. Offers a newer roof and partially remodeled with a blank canvas ready for your own personal style or just add to your real estate investments. MORE photos to be shared soon ! PREAPPROVED buyers for conventional loan or cash ONLY. Seller is motivated. Schedule your appointment today.

    Monica Bess Bess Blvd Real Estate Co

    444 Frederick St, Carey, OH 43316
  • /3

    $42,000

    $4K PRICE INCREASE
    • Land
    • 16,639 Sq Ft
    • $109,948 per Acre

    15 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316

    Lot #15 (Phase 9)- 100'x157.53' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Summer Drive. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. Buyers to pay for title insurance.

    Kenneth Lucius Key Realty

    15 Summer Dr, Carey, OH 43316
  • /42

    $149,000

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,996 Sq Ft

    449 Frederick St, Carey, OH 43316

    Beautiful 4-bedroom, 2-bath home featuring gorgeous wood floors, a stunning foyer staircase leading to a private upstairs bedroom, and a cozy gas stove. Enjoy an oversized 2-car garage with workshop, large backyard with deck and above-ground pool, plus major updates including a 2025 furnace and newer water heater. Perfect blend of charm, space, and functionality!

    Charity Ritzler Key Realty

    449 Frederick St, Carey, OH 43316

Why Live in Carey

Carey, Ohio is a small, close-knit community of approximately 3,500 residents, surrounded by expansive farmland and ranchland. The village is known for its annual Carey Fest, which features live music, food vendors, and a parade that draws locals together. Carey’s tree-lined streets are home to vintage properties, including American Foursquares, Colonial Revivals, and classic farmhouses, typically situated on compact lots under an acre. Memorial Park offers amenities such as a pool, splashpad, and a new inclusive playground, while Carey Bark Park and Shrine Park provide additional recreational spaces. The nearby Springville Marsh State Nature Preserve, located 5 miles away, features a boardwalk through cattail meadows, and Wyandot Wildlife Area, just 2 miles away, is popular for hunting. Shopping options along U.S. Route 23 include Dollar General and IGA, with local dining spots like pizza parlors and The Coffee Shop offering smoothies, lattes, and ice cream. Carey Exempted Village Schools are highly rated, and students can participate in dual enrollment at Owens Community College starting in seventh grade. U.S. Route 23 connects Carey to Columbus, 84 miles south, and Toledo, less than 70 miles north, with Interstate 75 providing an alternative route 20 miles west in Findlay. Emergency care is available 11 miles away at Wyandot Memorial Hospital.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Carey, OH?
Homes for sale in Carey, OH have an average home price of $174,589.
Are home prices dropping in Carey?
Yes, home prices in Carey are down 8% in the last 12 months.
How many homes have sold over the last 12 months in Carey, OH?
23 homes have sold in Carey, OH over the last 12 months.
What are the most popular zip codes in Carey, OH?
The most popular zip codes in Carey, OH include 43316, 43351, 44830, 45867 and 45840.
How much do you need to make to afford a house in Carey?
The median home price in Carey is $174,900. If you put a 20% down payment of $35,000 and had a 30-year fixed mortgage with an interest rate of 6.36%, your estimated principal and interest payment would be $870 a month plus property taxes, HOA fees, home insurance, PMI, and utilities. Using the 28% rule, you would need to make at least $37K a year to afford the median home price in Carey. Learn how much home you can afford with our Home Affordability Calculator.
How are the schools in Carey, OH?
Carey, OH has highly rated public and private schools. Some of the best schools in Carey based on Niche Grades are Carey Elementary School, Carey High School and Our Lady of Consolation School. Browse all the schools in Carey, OH to learn more.

Home Trends in Carey, OH

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price
$172,000
Median Single Family Sale Price
$153,500
Average Price Per Sq Ft
$103
Number of Homes for Sale
5
Last 12 months Home Sales
23
Months of Supply
2.60
Median List Price
$174,900
Median Change From 1st List Price
7%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change
10%
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home