$175,880Average Value$120Average Price per Sq Ft8Homes For Sale
Carey offers rural views, friendly faces and annual celebrations
The village of Carey is a close-knit community of about 3,500 surrounded by miles of farmland and ranchland. “It’s a great little town,” says local Realtor Kristie Fox with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Koehler Realty. “They have a bit of everything, just on a smaller scale.” Every year, this community’s small-town charm is put on full display with Carey Fest, an event that features live music, food vendors and an iconic parade. “We go back for the parade once in a while, and you can’t walk 5 feet without seeing someone you know,” Fox says. “It’s a great parade… there’s everything, there are clowns on motorcycles.”
The downtown Carey pavilion often hosts festivals, markets, and concerts.
Historic downtown Carey blends small‑shop retail with local dining in preserved buildings.
1/2
Tree-lined streets with vintage homes on compact lots
Carey offers a variety of vintage properties, from grand American Foursquares and Colonial Revivals to classic farmhouses. Most homes sit on densely set lots, under an acre, along sidewalks and oak tree-lined streets. Prices range from less than $100,000 to around $420,000. Tornado Alley’s eastern shift into Ohio has left Wyandot County vulnerable to tornadoes. Prospective homebuyers should confirm their insurance covers wind and tornado damage.
Colorful vintage facades add curb appeal along Carey’s residential blocks.
Carey offers American Foursquare, Colonial Revival, and farmhouse options on sidewalk-lined streets.
Victorian homes with period trims lends character to Carey’s oak‑lined streets.
Neat landscaping frames tidy residential yards across Carey.
Many Carey homes offer roomy layouts suited to growing families.
1/5
Students can dual enroll at Owens College starting in Grade 7
Carey Exempted Village Schools earns a B on Niche, and so do its two schools: Casey Elementary and Carey Middle/High. As early as seventh grade, students at the middle/high school participate in the statewide College Credit Plus program, offering dual enrollment at participating colleges, including Owens Community College’s Findlay-area Campus, about 18 miles away.
Carey Exempted Village Schools earns a B on Niche and serves the Carey community.
As early as grade seven, Carey schools offer College Credit Plus with Owens, 18 miles away.
1/2
Nature and history meet in parks, preserves and scenic landmarks
Memorial Park opened a new inclusive playground in June of 2025, and other amenities include a pool and a splashpad for kids. Carey Bark Park is a favorite among local dog owners. Shrine Park is popular for its manicured greenery. It’s home to a minor basilica of the Roman Catholic Church and a historic shrine to the Virgin Mary from 1875. Springville Marsh State Nature Preserve is only 5 miles up the road. The preserve has a short boardwalk that juts through marshy cattail meadows. Wyandot Wildlife Area, popular for rabbit and pheasant hunting, is only 2 miles away.
Carey Bark Park is a local favorite for off‑leash play and neighbor meetups.
Springville Marsh State Nature Preserve lies 5 miles from Carey with a long boardwalk.
Memorial Park in Carey added an inclusive playground in June 2025, plus a pool and splashpad.
Wyandot Wildlife Area, 2 miles from Carey, is popular for rabbit and pheasant hunting.
1/4
Dollar General and IGA anchor shopping along Route 23
Main road U.S. Route 23 has a few fast-food chains and shopping options, including IGA and Dollar General. Some locally owned pizza parlors are clustered around its intersection with Findlay Street, just down the street from The Coffee Shop, which sells pick-me-ups like smoothies, lattes and ice cream.
Frederick’s IGA anchors everyday shopping along U.S. Route 23 in Carey.
McDonald’s and other quick‑service chains line U.S. Route 23 through Carey.
Dollar General on U.S. Route 23 in Carey covers everyday staples and basics.
The Coffee Shop in Carey serves lattes, smoothies, and ice cream near downtown.
1/4
U.S. Route 23 and I-75 offer regional access from Carey
The main road, U.S. Route 23, is a direct path to Columbus, about 84 miles south. It can also take drivers most of the way to Toledo, less than 70 miles north, though Interstate 75, accessible 20 miles west in Findlay, offers a zippier alternative route. All-hours emergency care is available about 11 miles away at Wyandot Memorial Hospital.
Wyandot Memorial Hospital provides 24‑hour care about 11 miles from Carey.
U.S. Route 23 offers a direct path from Carey to Columbus, about 84 miles south.
1/2
Written By
Micaela Willoughby
Photography Contributed By
Grace Kim
Video By
EB Fox
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Bob Meyerhoffer,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Carey, OH sell after 87 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Carey, OH over the last 12 months is $153,500, down 2% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Stop searching and start building equity! Located right on the edge of the village of Carey, this massive property blends in-town convenience with a private, country-style backyard. The outdoor space features mature trees, multiple storage sheds, and a practical woodshed overhang. The home offers a mix of updated areas and equity-building projects. Following a previous second-floor expansion, one
Welcome home to this stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home nestled in a desirable newer neighborhood! The open-concept floor plan features a spacious living room with a soaring cathedral ceiling and abundant natural light, flowing seamlessly into the dine-in kitchen complete with a breakfast bar—perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The owner's suite offers a private bath for added comfort. A
Lot #57 - 120' x 160' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Autumn Avenue. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. Buyers to pay for title insurance.
Ready to put your personal stamp on a classic two-story single-family home? This charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath home is packed with character and recent updates that make it move-in ready while leaving room for your vision. Step onto the covered front porch for peaceful mornings, or head straight out the sliding glass doors to the brand-new two-tier deck, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor flow
Spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offering over 2,200 square feet of flexible living space with the character and craftsmanship that only a historic home can provide. The oversized kitchen offers abundant cabinet and counter space, while the formal dining and living rooms can be opened for entertaining or separated with original doors for added privacy.A beautifully remodeled and generously-sized
Great rental history. All five units rented. Back lot parking. Each unit has kitchen, bedroom and bathroom, each unit varies in size. Current Rents Unit 1-595 Unit 2-600 Unit 3-625 Unit 4-570 Unit 5-600 Total-$2990 In past barn had been rented for $200. Please allow 24 hour notice for showing requests.
Lot 18 Phase 11 150'x143.82'Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
7.45 +or- Acres in Carey Near Fast food restaurants, Caseys Gas Station , Ford Dealership, Day Care Facility .Bring your Ideas to develop this parcel . Will need a lot split and possible Zoning Change .All utilities are very near if not on the parcel .
Welcome home to this wonderful ranch nestled in the heart of Carey! Recent updates make this home move-in ready, including new flooring throughout, fresh paint, new trim, replacement interior doors, and updated electrical outlets. The attached garage adds everyday convenience, while the spacious backyard offers plenty of room to relax, entertain, or play. Whether you're looking for your first
New home located in Carey. This 1579 sq/ft home features an open floor plan that connects the living, dining, and kitchen featuring spacious vaulted ceilings with 9ft ceilings throughout. The Primary suite includes a walk-in closet and bathroom large enough for two, featuring porcelain tile floor, marble vanity and a 5ft shower. Stylish full bath at the opposite end of home for bedrooms 2 and 3
18.72 Acres Available w/smaller divisions available. Located on the edge of Carey, Ohio with easy access to US23 / OH 15 next to retail and food chain businesses. Agent Owned
Beautiful 4-bedroom, 2-bath home featuring gorgeous wood floors, a stunning foyer staircase leading to a private upstairs bedroom, and a cozy gas stove. Enjoy an oversized 2-car garage with workshop, large backyard with deck and above-ground pool, plus major updates including a 2025 furnace and newer water heater. Perfect blend of charm, space, and functionality!
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
