5-Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cayuga County NY

This stunning 6-bedroom, 4-bath Italianate gem blends timeless 1860s craftsmanship with a top-to-bottom renovation for today’s lifestyle. Every detail has been thoughtfully restored or renewed, preserving its historic charm while adding modern comfort. Step inside to a bright, open layout where white oak floors and luxury vinyl flow throughout. The spacious first-floor primary suite offers a

Marian Anderson Listing by Acropolis Realty Group LLC

9.1 acre property situated in Fair Haven with frontage on two roads, featuring a 5 bedroom 2 full bathroom 1,868 sq ft home plus a large outbuilding with garage space and additional space that has potential to be finished into a variety of uses. Second level of outbuilding provides tremendous storage space. Home is beautifully landscaped and offers a spacious deck to be able to relax and enjoy

Patrick Haggerty Listing by Century 21 Leah's Signature

Welcome to your lakeside retreat! This beautifully landscaped 5-bedroom, 2 bath and 1 powder room home offers the perfect blend of relaxation and recreation. Enjoy exclusive access to two deeded lake rights-of-ways complete with docks, ideal for boating, swimming, or simply soaking in the serene water views.Take in breathtaking sunsets from the front porch or retreat to the private

Nicole McNeilly Listing by Acropolis Realty Group LLC

Welcome to 4700 W. Lake Rd. Located in the heart of the Fingerlakes!!!! This very unique property offers 6 bedrooms and 3 full baths.The waterfront area has a level beachfront and a private concrete boat launch and dock.The 2 car detatched garage is currently set up for entertaining which offers a 2 tier patio and 2 bonfire pits overlooking beautiful Owasco Lake.The owner has owned this rare

John Triska Listing by Crown Realty

Tucked away on private acreage, set among the grand, tree-lined mansions on South Street in the city’s cherished historic district of Auburn, New York, lies a home like no other. Irreplaceable at this price, and possessing a level of beauty and refinement that is rarely found. This residence combines timeless architecture with everyday comfort in one of the Finger Lakes' most peaceful settings.

Michael DeRosa Listing by Michael DeRosa Exchange

Square footage has changed do to finished laundry room and fifth bath in detached garage. Welcome to this incredible custom home located in the premier waterfront community of Buck Point, offering direct access to Owasco Lake and the convenience of public water and sewer services. This stunning property boasts 120 feet of shared accesson a spacious 1.10 acre corner lot, complete with a 4-car

Todd Post Listing by Century 21 Post Realty

A beautiful country spacious home in fine conditions with many huge improvements such as a New metal roof. This fine, mostly brick home has great curb appeal. The large sprawling interior can accommodate A great number of people. The large lot is nicely, secluded with 50% finally manicured the remaining 50% being wild vegetation. The owners claim the tax records for square footage is not correct.

Joseph Viscomi Listing by Realty Boom

Spacious 5-bedroom 2 full bath home with large, private fenced yard! Welcome to your new home! This lovely home offers the perfect blend of space, comfort and convenience. Featuring a two-car detached garage you'll have plenty of room for vehicles, storage or even a workshop! Step inside to find a large country kitchen with plenty of cupboards and inviting floor plan with a formal

Dale Karlik Listing by Riordan Realty

Amazing opportunity for the buyers with vision and or home improvement skills! Big Beautiful Colonial home with 5 bedrooms and 2 baths! Huge 3 bay garage with second story space perfect for your own hideaway! Major systems recently improved or replaced including metal roofs on both house and garage, hot water baseboard heat and new septic just 6 months old! Large corner lot just

Laurie Wood Listing by Land of Lakes Realty, Inc.

This stunning historical brick Federal Greek Revival home sits majestically on six eye-catching acres in Scipio Center, offering an extraordinary blend of period charm and modern convenience. The lovingly restored residence features soaring ten-foot ceilings, spacious rooms with original moldings, and has been thoughtfully updated while preserving its classical beauty. The property has the

Catherine Armijo Listing by Howard Hanna Real Estate

Prime Investment Opportunity – 13.67 cap rate - Cash Flow & Versatility! This multi-use commercial building is a money-maker from day one! This multi-use 9316 sq. ft. Building has frontage on both Genesee and Van Patten Street, a high-traffic high-visibility corner lot in Auburn, N.Y. close to shopping including Tops, Bass Pro and more. The main level features a fully operational restaurant/bar

Robert Harvey Listing by Hunt Real Estate ERA

Great Opportunity to own this Two-Family home in the desirable East End of Auburn. Each spacious unit offers three bedrooms, one full bathroom, and their own private entrance. The tenant-occupied apt. (#1) on the first floor is very ample and well-maintained since it was last remodeled in 2018. Apt #2 was just renovated (July 2025), featuring new flooring, kitchen cabinets, kitchen counter, light

Yolanny Pereira Listing by Keller Williams Syracuse

Spacious Family Home with Endless Potential! Discover this expansive 2,000+ square-foot, 5-bedroom, 2-bath doublewide, in a Park, offering incredible space for your family to grow. Step inside and be greeted by a large kitchen, complete with a center island and pantry— perfect for preparing family meals. The generous family room features a cozy wood-burning fireplace (which can be converted to

Theresa Arnold Listing by Coldwell Banker Prime Prop,Inc

Perfect opportunity for investment opportunity. Fully rented and ready to go! Don't miss out on the chance to make this property yours!

Paul McGrath Listing by The Real Estate Agency

Located on a quiet private street, this solidly built two-family side-by-side home offers a fantastic opportunity for owner-occupants or investors alike. Each spacious unit features 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom as well as providing comfortable living with thoughtful updates and enduring quality.Recent improvements include updated hall and bathroom flooring, a refreshed front porch, a

Nicole McNeilly Listing by Acropolis Realty Group LLC

ALLOW 24 TO 48 HOUR NOTICE TO SHOW.Great Investment Opportunity – Fully Rented Side-by-Side Duplex in AuburnWell-maintained side-by-side duplex located on a quiet street in the City of Auburn. Each unit features 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom, offering spacious layouts for tenants. Property is fully rented and generating $1,800/month in rental income. All utilities are separately

Todd Post Listing by Century 21 Post Realty

Welcome to this unique investment opportunity in the heart of downtown Auburn, NY! This charming commercial property features 7 one-bedroom units, perfect for renting out, living in or using for a business venture. This spacious property offers potential for multiple income streams or a versatile living arrangement. Two of the largest units are on the first floor, 3 units can be found on the 2nd

Nicole McNeilly Listing by Acropolis Realty Group LLC

This multifamily property features a side-by-side setup with three bedrooms and one bath on each side. All separate utilities and each apartment has its own access to basement and adding space. There are separate driveways on either side of the house with separate detached one car garage for each apartment. There's even a fence in the backyard to separate the shared space. Must see to appreciate!

Gregory Mott Listing by Howard Hanna Real Estate

Calling all investors, contractors and/or future home owners looking for a diamond in the rough! This 5 bed/ 1.5 bath property is begging to be restored to its original glory. The charm in this property is endless and boosts high ceilings, original gorgeous woodwork, stained glass windows and pocket doors. Currently the property is set up as a single family residence it can be easily converted

Felicia Rocker Listing by Clare Real Estate

Two family home, could be excellent owner occupy. Upper unit currently vacant and with some paint and a few touch ups could rent for $1200-1300/month. Long term tenant downstairs wants to stay and pays $1000 early every month. Vinyl siding, replacement windows, both units have been remodeled over the years, solid mechanics, positive cash flow, low maintenance lot. This home is priced to sell!

Simon Fricano Listing by Lake Country Real Estate

This fully occupied, income-producing property features two buildings on one parcel: a renovated single-family home at 206 Seymour and a well-maintained duplex at 208–210 Seymour. With all three units tenant-occupied and updated, this is a true turnkey opportunity for investors seeking reliable cash flow and long-term equity growth. Updates to 206 Seymour include newly installed central air,

Dillon Phillips Listing by The Young Agency

This is an amazing opportunity for the right investor ready to unlock this property's full potential. This duplex features two spacious 3-bedroom apartments, one of which is already tenant-occupied and updated, providing immediate income while the other offers a blank canvas for renovation and upside. Unit 1 is a tenant-occupied 3 bedroom with recent updates including new flooring throughout,

Dillon Phillips Listing by The Young Agency

This fully tenant-occupied quadplex offers a rare opportunity to acquire a high-performing asset with strong cash flow and recent capital improvements. Located adjacent to 17 Perrine Street and boasting 3,926 sq ft of living space, this property is ideal for investors seeking a stabilized, low-maintenance addition to their portfolio. Unit 1 is a 1 bedroom offering new flooring, updated kitchen

Dillon Phillips Listing by The Young Agency

This unique three-unit property is centrally located just minutes from downtown Auburn, offering easy access to restaurants, shops, and local amenities. Each unit features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, making it an ideal setup for long-term tenants. Apartment 2 is already updated with new flooring and refinished hardwoods, updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances, fresh paint throughout,

Dillon Phillips Listing by The Young Agency

Welcome to your peaceful sanctuary nestled within a quiet, pastoral setting near Owasco Lake, where evenings are graced with breathtaking sunsets. This charming home has been used as an AIRBNB, and is minutes from the vibrant community of Auburn, and a short drive to the quaint village of Skaneateles. With two bedrooms & full bathroom on the first level and three more bedrooms & 2nd full

Samantha Dougherty Listing by NextHome CNY Realty

Bring your vision to this generously sized 5-bedroom, 2-bath home offering over 2,500 sqft of living space not including the enormous basement that once functioned as a second kitchen. The main level features a huge kitchen that’s perfect for hosting or entertaining. With some TLC throughout, this home could truly shine. House also has a large garage space with a breezeway leading to large yard

Samuel Wilson Listing by United Country Palmer Real Estate

Investor opportunity: 6 units across 3 buildings totaling over 7,500 sq. ft. of rental space, all conveniently located near shopping, amenities, and public transit. Properties are being sold as-is and are currently undergoing light cosmetic updates due to tenant turnover—offering immediate upside potential. Conservative gross rent projection is $7,750/month, with high-performance planning up to

Simon Fricano Listing by Lake Country Real Estate

This stunning custom-built Colonial sits on just over 18 acres of land, surrounded by beautifully landscaped grounds that enhance its curb appeal. The home boasts 4-5 bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and one half bathroom. Inside, you'll find a welcoming foyer entrance, formal dining and living areas, and a recently updated kitchen with a convenient coffee station that opens up to the cozy family

Molly Elliott Listing by Howard Hanna Real Estate

Set amidst the serene beauty of Skaneateles Lake, West Lake Farm is a 17 acre compound of lush pastures adorned with wildflowers and boasting 82 feet of pristine waterfront. Enjoy unparalleled privacy and tranquility while still being within easy reach of the charming village of Skaneateles with its upscale shops and restaurants. This meticulously designed 5 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms estate offers

Albert Joerger Listing by Keller Williams Syracuse

Route 20 to Hoffman to Walnut to S. Fulton

Lynne Petrie Listing by Howard Hanna Real Estate

This unique property nested on 5.65 acres in the Skaneateles school district with municipal water offers a rare opportunity for investors or residential buyers to own a multi-family home (2-family plus in-law apartment) and an additional heated seasonal "artist's studio" on the grounds. This secluded listing has an Adirondack feel with acres of woods, multiple ponds, enclosed waterside pavilion,

Jane Ross Listing by Finger Lakes Sothebys Intl.

Are you an investor looking for a property below market price for its size, or a first time home buyer looking to off set your mortgage with a tenant? Look no further than this massive 2 unit that offers 2 identically laid out, 1,300 sq foot 3 bedroom apartments! Some big fixes have already been taken care of for the new owners including a new metal roof, 1 new furnace and 1 new hot water tank!

Adam Hurd Listing by Sun Harvest Realty Inc.

Nestled in the picturesque Village of Aurora, NY, Wavebank stands as a historic gem on the shores of Cayuga Lake. This distinguished four-unit apartment house offers a unique blend of charm and convenience. With an easy stroll to the Village center, the Inns of Aurora, and Wells College, residents enjoy a seamless blend of tranquility and accessibility. Immerse yourself in the beauty of lakeside

Dana Decker Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

Great investment opportunity that offers two 3 bedroom apartments with market rents, long term tenants, In-unit laundry hookups, separated utilities and 2 brand new hot water heaters! Take advantage of this "bang for your buck" 2 unit property!

Adam Hurd Listing by Sun Harvest Realty Inc.

Discover a tranquil retreat in this beautifully updated raised ranch, nestled on 1.63 acres of picturesque countryside. Enjoy peaceful pastoral views that stretch across the landscape. Imagine comfortable evenings in the transformed entertainment room, formerly a 2-car garage, now a welcoming space for relaxation and gatherings. A pellet stove provides warmth, while a built-in bar offers a

Nathan Krause Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty

Own an enormous farm house for the price of a small starter home! This sprawling estate has such a rich history, and a potential for an even richer future! Whether you're an investor, or simply in the market for your dream home, with some TLC this property has so much to offer; so call a licensed real estate professional and set up a showing TODAY!

Joshua Beardsley EXIT REALTY FRONT AND CENTER

Historic 3-story, 5-bay Federal style mansion circa 1827 home originally owned by Captain William Swain, a famous Nantucket Sea Captain reputed to have speared a whale himself on one of his last voyages before settling permanently to the completed four level mansion in 1827. Many improvements have been recently made to this property including foundation repair, gutters, rebuilt historical

Lucas Ferrin Listing by Howard Hanna Real Estate

Todd Post Listing by Century 21 Post Realty