Recently Sold Cayuga, NY Homes

$215,000 Sold Sep 23, 2025

1059 State Route 326, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 4 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 1,617 Sq Ft
• Built 1930

Last Sold Summary

• 2% Below List Price
• $133/SF
• 47 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $221,752

Last Listing Agent Cheri Stebbins Listing by Baier Real Estate

1059 State Route 326, Cayuga, NY 13034

$265,000 Sold Jan 13, 2026

5849 State Route 90 N, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 2 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 1,498 Sq Ft
• Built 1960

Last Sold Summary

• 22% Below List Price
• $177/SF
• 114 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $260,804

Last Listing Agent Joseph Clare Listing by Clare Real Estate

5849 State Route 90 N, Cayuga, NY 13034

$484,000 Sold Jul 16, 2025

796 Clark Street Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 7 Beds
• 2.5 Baths
• 4,981 Sq Ft
• Built 1970

Last Sold Summary

• 8% Below List Price
• $97/SF
• 30 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $511,675

Last Listing Agent Midge Fricano Listing by Lake Country Real Estate

796 Clark Street Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

$410,000 Sold Jan 12, 2026

6198 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 4 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 2,201 Sq Ft
• Built 1840

Last Sold Summary

• 9% Below List Price
• $186/SF
• 85 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $405,000

Last Listing Agent Michelle Delzell Listing by Lake Homes Realty LLC

6198 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$370,000 Sold Oct 01, 2025

6198 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 4 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 2,201 Sq Ft
• Built 1840

Last Sold Summary

• 51% Below List Price
• $168/SF
• 4 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $405,000

Last Listing Agent Joshua Briner Listing by Keller Williams Realty Gateway

6198 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$55,000 Sold Apr 09, 2025

717 Clark Street Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 4 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 2,208 Sq Ft
• Built 1860

Last Sold Summary

• 39% Below List Price
• $25/SF
• 12 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $154,715

Last Listing Agent Laura Jensen Listing by The Spurling Group Real Estate LLC

717 Clark Street Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

$350,000 Sold Jun 13, 2025

5342 New York 90, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 3 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 1,314 Sq Ft
• Built 1875

Last Sold Summary

• 5% Below List Price
• $266/SF
• 43 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Midge Fricano Listing by Lake Country Real Estate

5342 New York 90, Cayuga, NY 13034

$275,000 Sold Dec 03, 2025

6166 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 3 Beds
• 3 Baths
• 2,258 Sq Ft
• Built 1900

Last Sold Summary

• 2% Above List Price
• $122/SF
• 36 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $277,963

Last Listing Agent John Parrott Listing by Coldwell Banker Finger Lakes

6166 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$850,000 Sold Aug 29, 2025

5185 Plaster Point, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 3 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 1,600 Sq Ft
• Built 1960

Last Sold Summary

• 8% Above List Price
• $531/SF
• 14 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $849,231

Last Listing Agent Michelle Miller RE/MAX In Motion

5185 Plaster Point, Cayuga, NY 13034

$255,000 Sold Jan 08, 2026

253 Wheat St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 3 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 1,564 Sq Ft
• Built 1956

Last Sold Summary

• 2% Below List Price
• $163/SF
• 101 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $246,936

Last Listing Agent Jane Ross Listing by Finger Lakes Sothebys Intl.

253 Wheat St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$450,000 Sold Jul 25, 2025

6511 New York 90, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 2 Beds
• 1.5 Baths
• 1,200 Sq Ft
• Built 1900

Last Sold Summary

• 10% Below List Price
• $375/SF
• 93 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $466,715

Last Listing Agent Richard Borza Listing by Ted Leader Real Estate

6511 New York 90, Cayuga, NY 13034

$400,000 Sold Oct 01, 2025

6170 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 5 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 2,297 Sq Ft
• Built 1900

Last Sold Summary

• 47% Below List Price
• $174/SF
• 4 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $484,286

Last Listing Agent Joshua Briner Listing by Keller Williams Realty Gateway

6170 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$145,000 Sold Mar 05, 2026

598 Turnpike Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 3 Beds
• 1.5 Baths
• 1,200 Sq Ft
• Built 1970

Last Sold Summary

• 3% Below List Price
• $121/SF
• 15 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $175,187

Last Listing Agent LINDA LEADER Listing by Ted Leader Real Estate

598 Turnpike Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

$315,000 Sold Aug 15, 2025

757 Clark Street Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 6 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 2,176 Sq Ft
• Built 1912

Last Sold Summary

• 10% Below List Price
• $145/SF
• 51 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $327,812

Last Listing Agent Karissa Thompson Listing by The Real Estate Agency

757 Clark Street Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034

$170,000 Sold Mar 19, 2026

6176 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 4 Beds
• 3.5 Baths
• 2,186 Sq Ft
• Built 1860

Last Sold Summary

• 26% Below List Price
• $78/SF
• 100 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $301,050

Last Listing Agent Mary St George Listing by Real Broker NY, LLC

6176 Lake St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$215,000 Sold Sep 16, 2025

6251 Willard St, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 2 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 1,392 Sq Ft
• Built 1960

Last Sold Summary

• 6% Below List Price
• $154/SF
• 21 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $231,896

Last Listing Agent Nathan Krause Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty

6251 Willard St, Cayuga, NY 13034

$305,000 Sold Sep 19, 2025

6487 State Route 90 N, Cayuga, NY 13034

• 2 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 648 Sq Ft
• Built 1990

Last Sold Summary

• 13% Below List Price
• $471/SF
• 26 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $310,565

Last Listing Agent Maggie Coleman Listing by RE/MAX Plus

6487 State Route 90 N, Cayuga, NY 13034