Central Fire Island Homes for Sale

• 

  

  

  /46

  $5,200,000

  $1M PRICE DROP

  • 5 Beds
  • 5.5 Baths
  • 3,600 Sq Ft

  0 Charach & 1 West Walk, Water Island, NY 11772

  Water Island Awaits. Two Iconic Buildings. One Majestic View.Location-Tucked between Fire Island Pines and Davis Park lies Water Island. With only 48homes adjacent to the protected Fire Island National Seashore; Water Island createsa unique sense of remoteness and natural beauty — a true retreat for those seekingto unwind in quiet luxury. This secluded estate offers 200 feet

  

  Nathaniel Larson

  Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  0 Charach & 1 West Walk, Water Island, NY 11772
• Explore Central Fire Island

• 

  

  

  /41

  $4,495,000

  New Construction $500K PRICE DROP

  • 5 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • 3,600 Sq Ft

  36 Cayuga St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Stunning Ocean View 5 BR New Construction With Pool & Gym Situated on an ocean view double lot, one house back from the beach, this ground up new construction home is truly spectacular. With nearly 3,600 interior square feet and 2,680 square feet of mahogany decking, a 30’ swimming pool, panoramic ocean views, and multiple entertaining areas, this home does not disappoint. Enter through the

  Abigail Mago Fire Island Sales And Rentals

  36 Cayuga St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  

  /36

  $1,750,000

  • 6 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2,136 Sq Ft

  27 Dune Walk, Patchogue, NY 11772

  Big, Bold and Beautiful on the Ocean. Open Kitchen, Living and Dining room. 6 Bedrooms, hang out room, 2 Full baths and 2 half baths. A separate screened porch and private walkway to the ocean beach.

  Nancy Bush H & G Realty New York

  27 Dune Walk, Patchogue, NY 11772
• 

  

  

  /48

  $3,600,000

  $190K PRICE DROP

  • 5 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2,785 Sq Ft

  18 Ocean Bay Blvd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Experience the best of Fire Island living in this newly constructed Ocean Bay Park home offering ocean views, bay views, and resort-style outdoor space. Designed for effortless summer living, this 5-bedroom, 4-bath retreat features bright open interiors, modern finishes, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow. Enjoy sunrise over the ocean, sunset over the bay, and long afternoons around your oversized

  Megan Wallace Wallace Rlty Sales & Vacation

  18 Ocean Bay Blvd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  

  /11

  $1,275,000

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 900 Sq Ft

  445 Sail Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Perched high and dry on the secondary dune with sensational ocean views this 2 bedroom 2 bathroom mid-century cottage presents an ideal opportunity for first time home buyers. The many amenities include 30'x14' solar heated pool, hot tub, outdoor shower, out door grill & primary bedroom with ensuite bath.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  445 Sail Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /26

  $1,599,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,531 Sq Ft

  77 Bay Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782

  Welcome to 77 Bay Walk, a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home in the heart of Fire Island Pines. Designed for effortless indoor-outdoor living, this inviting retreat features an open floor plan, abundant natural light, and two wood-burning fireplaces that add warmth and character. Step outside to your own private oasis with a saltwater swimming pool, hot tub, expansive sun decks, and

  John Forte D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD

  77 Bay Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782
• 

  

  /18

  $2,475,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,080 Sq Ft

  146 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, NY 11782

  Direct ocean views provide a beautiful backdrop to the open and airy living spaces throughout this exceptional oceanfront property. A 17-foot wall of glass in offering expansive water views opens out to a generously proportioned beachfront deck featuring saltwater pool and hot tub, creating a luxurious backdrop for outdoor living and entertaining. Designed for year-round living, the home is fully

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  146 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, NY 11782
• 

  

  /19

  $1,799,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,644 Sq Ft

  27 Ontario St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Classic Fire Island charm meets endless potential in this spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath beach cottage in the heart of Ocean Bay Park. Set on an oversized 100x100 lot and just moments from the ocean, this home offers the kind of easy coastal living that makes summers here so special — with plenty of room for a pool. Designed with a unique and functional layout, the home features two bedrooms and a

  Joan Woletsky The Agency Northshore NY

  27 Ontario St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /11

  $1,000,000

  $250K PRICE DROP

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 1,200 Sq Ft

  313 Fire Island Blvd, Sayville, NY 11782

  Excellent investment opportunity. 4 bedroom 3 bath bungalow with long rent history. Large private deck with hot tub. Open living / dining area and equal sized bedrooms. Roof deck ideal for sunset cocktailing.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  313 Fire Island Blvd, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /18

  $2,500,000

  • 6 Beds
  • 6.5 Baths
  • 3,000 Sq Ft

  362 Ocean Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Perched high on the secondary dune on a corner lot we are pleased to offer Pines Bluff Overlook Guest House for sale. Comprised of 6 private guest suites all with ensuite baths. The many amenities include ,Apple TV, Central Air Conditioning, Fireplace, Heat, Hot Tub, Ocean Views, Outdoor Shower, Pool, Roof Deck, Wet Bar & Wifi.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  362 Ocean Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /4

  $349,000

  Pre-Foreclosure

  • Land
  • 3,920 Sq Ft
  • $3,877,778 per Acre

  185 Holly Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  This vacant land sits right in the heart of Cherry Grove on lovely, Holly Walk. Close to all the Grove has to offer and of course, steps to the most beautiful beach on the Atlantic Coast.

  William Ottignon Summer Place Realty

  185 Holly Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /50

  $2,500,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,256 Sq Ft

  1 Steels Walk, Patchogue, NY 11772

  Featured in Architectural Digest, this extraordinary oceanfront residence on Steels Walk in Water Island, designed by acclaimed architect and designer Carl D’Aquino, is one of the most distinctive and architecturally significant properties on all of Fire Island. As co-founder of the internationally celebrated design firm D’Aquino Monaco, D’Aquino is renowned for creating homes that blend

  Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  1 Steels Walk, Patchogue, NY 11772
• 

  

  /19

  $1,500,000

  $200K PRICE DROP

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 1,500 Sq Ft

  118 Bayview Walk, Croton On Hudson, NY 10520

  Experience coastal living at its finest in this exceptional 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom home featuring stunning bay views from multiple levels and some of the most breathtaking panoramas in Cherry Grove. Relax on the spacious rear deck as you watch ferries glide across the bay and enjoy the ever-changing waterfront scenery. The primary suite opens to a charming Juliette balcony, offering a private

  Roberta Terzo Summer Place Realty

  118 Bayview Walk, Croton On Hudson, NY 10520
• 

  

  /30

  $4,200,000

  $300K PRICE DROP

  • 5 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 3,700 Sq Ft

  37 Traffic Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Introducing a rare oceanfront masterpiece in the coveted enclave of Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island, ideally positioned along the border of Point O’ Woods. This custom-built home offers an exceptional level of privacy, complete with semi-private beach access via a dedicated walkway.Designed to capture the essence of coastal living, the home showcases unobstructed, panoramic views of the

  Rachel Tosini Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  37 Traffic Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /8

  $2,999,000

  Open Sat 12PM - 2PM

  • 4 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • 1,500 Sq Ft

  17 Superior St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Be among the first to experience this stunning new construction in Ocean Bay Park. Designed with an upside-down layout that maximizes natural light, views, and effortless coastal living, this 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers a thoughtful blend of style, comfort, and functionality.The home features two private primary-style suites—one on each level—providing flexibility and privacy for

  Joan Woletsky The Agency Northshore NY

  17 Superior St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /14

  $795,000

  $55K PRICE DROP

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,276 Sq Ft

  71 Bayview Walk, Fire Island, NY 11782

  Charming original cottage situated directly on the Great South Bay, featuring two bedrooms and two full bathrooms, plus an outdoor shower and ample space for a large pool. The open-concept living and dining area boasts vaulted ceilings and a cozy fireplace, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere. The primary bedroom features sliding glass doors that open directly onto the bayside deck,

  William Ottignon Summer Place Realty

  71 Bayview Walk, Fire Island, NY 11782
• 

  

  /28

  $1,749,999

  • 5 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2,228 Sq Ft

  337 Shell Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  This one-of-a-kind, exceptionally spacious 5-bedroom, 4-bath residence has been fully renovated to the highest standards, offering the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and privacy. Beautifully designed with contemporary finishes throughout, the home features an expansive open-concept gourmet kitchen and dining area that seamlessly flows onto a large outdoor entertaining deck complete with a

  John Forte D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD

  337 Shell Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /15

  $1,500,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 1,780 Sq Ft

  293 Bay Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782

  Classic mid-century beach house with large saltwater pool is the last word in casual beach living.. Open floorplan and beautifully landscaped outdoor space. 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths close to the harbor & a short walk to the beach.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  293 Bay Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782
• 

  /2

  $349,000

  $10K PRICE DROP

  • 1 Bath
  • 200 Sq Ft

  176 Ocean Walk Unit 15, Sayville, NY 11782

  Top Floor studio co-op at the Cherry Grove Inn. Enjoy views of the Atlantic Ocean from this lovely, corner apartment. Outoor seating area, coin-op laundry, shared outdoor shower and the most amazing common roof deck with 360 views of Fire Island, ocean & bay!! Subletting permitted. Pets permitted. Occupancy is approximately six months. Maintenance is 12 months.

  Roberta Terzo Summer Place Realty

  176 Ocean Walk Unit 15, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /18

  $2,100,000

  $250K PRICE DROP

  • 4 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • 1,800 Sq Ft

  172 Pine Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Representing a seamless combination of mid-century and contemporary influences, 172 Pine Walk represents Pines living at its refined. The double height & sunblasted open living / dining / kitchen / area provides for casual beach living at its most comfortable. The primary suite with ensuite bath offers views to the ocean and leads to a breathtaking roof terrace with superb 360 degree views ideal

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  172 Pine Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /14

  $1,799,000

  $100K PRICE DROP

  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2,000 Sq Ft

  605 Shore Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Unparalleled privacy in this triple mint 4 bedroom, 4 bath home with a meticulous attention to detail. the large living/dining area opens onto a sun drenched pool deck featuring a  hot tub and a separate cabana which can easily double as an additional guest bedroom. Exceptional appointments and furnishings throughout including energy efficient & cost saving solar panels with an additional

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  605 Shore Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /9

  $299,000

  $40K PRICE DROP

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 200 Sq Ft

  78 E Bayview Ave Unit 14, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Rarely available studio condo available at the Seashore Condo Hotel. Situated in the heart of Ocean Bay Park, and just a 4-minute walk to Fire Island's pristine white sand beach, this unit provides an affordable entry point to secure your home away from home at the beach. Make the most of your leisure time enjoying the Summer fun, not worrying about landscaping, property maintenance, and the

  Abigail Mago Fire Island Sales And Rentals

  78 E Bayview Ave Unit 14, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /12

  $649,990

  $19K PRICE DROP

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 300 Sq Ft

  78 E Bayview Ave Unit 2122, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Experience Fire Island with Hotel Amenities! This junior suite at the Seashore Condo Hotel is the only property of its kind. These two adjoining units are just steps from the beach, dining and shopping. Situated just one block from the ferry terminal - with full-time, on-site management - everything is provided for a perfect stress-free beach vacation, from bicycles to beach chairs to barbecue

  Kevin Hill The Agency Northshore NY

  78 E Bayview Ave Unit 2122, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  /2

  $925,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,548 Sq Ft

  176 Fire Island Ave, Babylon, NY 11702

  The perfect Pines starter house. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, large open living space featuring screened porch. Ample room to add a pool and additional decking.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  176 Fire Island Ave, Babylon, NY 11702
• 

  

  /17

  $799,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 900 Sq Ft

  236 Sea Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Tucked away in the west end of Cherry Grove, 236. Sea Walk offers the perfect blend of privacy, charm and natural beauty. Situated on one of Cherry Grove‘s, most peaceful and picturesque walks this queen cottage is surrounded by lush, landscaping and serene outdoor spaces that capture the essence of Cherry Grove living. Inside the home features four bedrooms, one full bathroom and an open floor

  Matthew Hughes D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD

  236 Sea Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /15

  $1,350,000

  $50K PRICE DROP

  • 7 Beds
  • 6.5 Baths
  • 3,000 Sq Ft

  154 Doctors Walk, Fire Island, NY 11901

  Welcome to an exceptional opportunity in the heart of Cherry Grove, where spacious accommodations, outstanding outdoor living, and breathtaking Great South Bay views come together in one remarkable three-story property. Featuring 7 bedrooms and 6½ baths, this generously proportioned home offers an ideal combination of privacy, comfort, and entertaining space. Whether envisioned as a private

  William Ottignon Summer Place Realty

  154 Doctors Walk, Fire Island, NY 11901
• 

  

  /11

  $1,825,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 1,565 Sq Ft

  617 Shore Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Designed in 1964 by Horace Gifford, this sophisticated, private & totally renovated mid-century represents the very best that the Pines has to offer. Set amid lush gardens and smartly furnished. 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, 2 half baths. Large solar heated pool & wrap around decking.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  617 Shore Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /10

  $225,000

  • 1 Bath
  • 200 Sq Ft

  176 Ocean Walk Unit 9, Sayville, NY 11782

  Beautiful, main floor studio co-op apartment at the Cherry Grove Inn. Nicely renovated with new floors, updated kitchen and bath. Wi-Fi, thru-the-wall A/C, shared outdoor shower & coin-op laundry. Enjoy the best views of Fire Island from the roof deck... ocean, bay and fabulous sunsets! Seasonal occupancy, approximately six months each year with options to sublet both short term and seasonally.

  Roberta Terzo Summer Place Realty

  176 Ocean Walk Unit 9, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /17

  $1,900,000

  $200K PRICE DROP

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 1,260 Sq Ft

  529 Sail Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  One-of-a-kind Horace Gifford “tree house”. This 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom, dramatically set at the eastern edge of the Pines, is truly a one-of-a-kind residence. A spiral staircase leads you above the trees into the breathtaking, glass enclosed Great Room. Over 200o sq ft of multi level decking allows for both large scale entertaining or more intimate gatherings. While respecting Gifford’s original

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  529 Sail Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /11

  $1,095,000

  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 672 Sq Ft

  284 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY 11706

  Floated over from the mainland in the mid 1950s 284 Bay Walk defines mid-century chic & simplicity. Smartly appointed with many original details still intact. 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom plus dressing room there is plenty of room for expansion.

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  284 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY 11706
• 

  

  /37

  $3,300,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2,100 Sq Ft

  443 Sail Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  One of Fire Island Pines’ most recognizable residences, the Pyramid House is an extraordinary expression of the experimental modernism that came to define the Pines.Designed circa 1960 by Buenos Aires–born architect Julio Kaufman, the house was later thoughtfully reimagined while preserving Kaufman’s iconic silhouette. A monumental steel-and-glass wall opens the soaring upper-level great

  Esteban Gomez Compass Greater NY LLC

  443 Sail Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /38

  $1,200,000

  $75K PRICE DROP

  • 4 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,500 Sq Ft

  146 Doctors Walk, Fire Island, NY 11782

  "Valhalla" on lovely Doctor's Walk in Cherry Grove. This charming four bedroom encompasses all the amenities of a fine summer home. Large living room with wood-burning fireplace, two large master bedrooms with vaulted ceilings, large galley kitchen and wonderful solarium with views of the "English" garden and pond which has a collection of various types of lilies, seedum and ivy. Roof deck for

  William Ottignon Summer Place Realty

  146 Doctors Walk, Fire Island, NY 11782
• 

  

  /20

  $1,325,000

  $175K PRICE DROP

  • 4 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 1,870 Sq Ft

  20 Seneca Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Come see this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath beach home with loft, outdoor shower and hot tub! Perfectly situated on a sunny corner lot just one block from both the ocean and town, this home is the ultimate year-round getaway. Features include vaulted ceilings, a cozy wood-burning fireplace, a brand-new (2025) wraparound deck, hot tub, and a spacious loft for extra living or sleeping

  Rachel Tosini Douglas Elliman Real Estate

  20 Seneca Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /56

  $3,990,000

  New Construction

  • 4 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 2,905 Sq Ft

  18 Michigan St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770

  Discover the future of coastal living at this breathtaking new build in West Ocean Bay Park. Spanning 2,904 square feet and designed by the acclaimed Coughlin Scheel Architects, this 4-bedroom, 3-full bath, 2-half bath home combines sleek contemporary sophistication with the timeless beauty of Fire Island. Set on a 75' x 100' lot once home to an Andrew Geller original, the design pays homage to

  Luke Belford FIRE ISLAND LIVING INC

  18 Michigan St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770
• 

  

  /12

  $1,695,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 1,616 Sq Ft

  279 Bay Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Impeccably maintained, secluded Bay Walk property located eight minutes from the Waterfront. Renovated in 2025 including kitchen appliances; cabinetry; refinished hardwood floors; heated XL saltwater pool; hot tub; gas water heater; roof and fully serviced Andersen windows & doors. New furnishings throughout. Extensive mahogany decking. Wood burning fireplace and propane fire pit. Fully air

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  279 Bay Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /15

  $1,195,000

  $100K PRICE DROP

  • 2 Beds
  • 1.5 Baths
  • 792 Sq Ft

  92 Teal Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Classic shingled beach cottage available for the first time in 25 years. This “tiny but mighty” summer retreat offers superb amenity from the light filled solarium overlooking the large & inviting pool deck to the classic screened in porch ideal for kicking back with friends on long summer evenings. 2 bedrooms 1.5 baths, outdoor shower. Further amenities include central air / heat, hot tub,

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  92 Teal Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /26

  $3,490,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,260 Sq Ft

  59 Laurel Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Oceanfront on Laurel Street in Seaview (Brookhaven) — Fire Island's Most Coveted block Welcome to 59 Laurel Avenue, a rare oceanfront offering just steps from the sand on the Brookhaven side of Seaview. This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom midcentury ranch sits on a standard 60' x 100' lot, tucked behind a pre-Sandy, mature, vegetated dune that delivers natural beauty, privacy, and real protection from the

  Abigail Mago Fire Island Sales And Rentals

  59 Laurel Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /39

  $4,490,000

  New Construction

  • 5 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • 3,600 Sq Ft

  2 Ocean Bay Blvd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

  Incredible New Construction Ocean & Bay View Home with Pool! Welcome to your dream coastal retreat in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island! This stunning brand new construction bay view home for sale boasts 5 spacious bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and 2 half bathrooms across two floors, offering over 3,600 square feet of luxurious living space. Properties of this size and scale are extremely hard to come by

  Alan Medvin Fire Island Sales And Rentals

  2 Ocean Bay Blvd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
• 

  

  /13

  $1,825,000

  $16M PRICE DROP

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • 1,557 Sq Ft

  39 Lone Hill Walk, Sayville, NY 11782

  Summer as imagined by Bromley Caldari Architects. This thoughtful & sophisticated contemporary represents the very best of Pines modernism. New 2016 construction with clean minimalist lines, this meticulously maintained triple mint property is both secluded within natural landscaping, yet steps from the harbor. A central unifying feature is the dramatic clerestory custom skylight providing soft

  Vincent Petrarca Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

  39 Lone Hill Walk, Sayville, NY 11782
• 

  

  /13

  $824,900

  $50K PRICE DROP

  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 648 Sq Ft

  169 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782

  This beautifully maintained Cherry Grove home offers the perfect combination of comfort and style.Step inside to discover beautiful wood flooring throughout, soaring vaulted ceilings, and an abundance of natural light from the skylight and thermal double-pane windows. The inviting living room features a wood-burning fireplace, creating the perfect atmosphere for cozy evenings in every

  Doreen Katen D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD

  169 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782

Showing Results 1 - 40, Page 1 of 2

Why Live in Central Fire Island

Central Fire Island is a coastal neighborhood characterized by its pristine beaches, forests nestled between dunes, and small coastal towns. Known for its long history as an LGBTQ+ friendly area, Cherry Grove, or "The Grove," is one of the oldest communities and a popular summer destination for New York’s theater and arts groups since the 1930s. The island is car-free, with residents and visitors relying on walking, bicycles, or golf carts. The National Park Service reports that 2.2 million visitors come to Fire Island from May through October. Attractions include the Sunken Forest, a rare maritime holly forest, and Sailors Haven beach and marina. Architectural styles vary from beach cottages with cedar shake siding to contemporary and modern homes. The neighborhood has a lower crime risk compared to the national average. Events like The Invasion of the Pines on the Fourth of July and The Pines Party highlight the vibrant local culture. Nightlife is lively, with venues such as Cherry’s on the Bay, the Pavilion, and Sip-n-Twirl offering music, dancing, and drag shows. The Cherry Grove Community House and Theater hosts various events, including fitness classes and nighttime shows. Children attend the highly rated Bay Shore Middle School and Bay Shore High School on Long Island. The island's seasonality means most businesses close by the end of October, requiring residents to be well-prepared for the winter months. Access to the island is primarily by ferry, with reduced service in the off-season.

Learn more about living in Central Fire Island

Central Fire Island, Fire Island, NY Home Prices vs. Nearby Neighborhoods

	Central Fire Island	Western Fire Island	Fort Salonga	Dix Hills
Median Home Price	$1,549,500	$1,699,000	$1,200,000	$1,399,000
Median Sale Price	$911,500 -27% YoY	$1,405,000 +41% YoY	$1,192,500 +19% YoY	$1,312,500 +14% YoY
Median Single Family Price	$1,599,500	$1,725,000	$1,200,000	$1,390,000
Total Active Listings	44 listings	23 listings	28 listings	64 listings
Market Conditions	26 Months of Supply Buyer's Market	11 Months of Supply Buyer's Market	3 Months of Supply Seller's Market	3 Months of Supply Seller's Market

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Central Fire Island a good place to live?

Central Fire Island is a good place to live. Central Fire Island is considered very car-dependent and very bikeable. Central Fire Island is a suburban neighborhood. Central Fire Island has 6 parks for recreational activities.It is sparse in population with 1.0 people per acre and a median age of 59. The average household income is $118,368 which is above the national average. College graduates make up 16.1% of residents. A majority of residents in Central Fire Island are home owners, with 19% of residents renting and 81% of residents owning their home. A local real estate agent serving Central Fire Island can help you decide if this neighborhood is the right one for you. Learn more on our Central Fire Island neighborhood guide.

How much do you need to make to afford a house in Central Fire Island?

The median home price in Central Fire Island is $1,549,500. If you put a 20% down payment of $309,900 and had a 30-year fixed mortgage with an interest rate of 6.71%, your estimated principal and interest payment would be $8,010 a month plus property taxes, HOA fees, home insurance, PMI, and utilities. Using the 28% rule, you would need to make at least $343K a year to afford the median home price in Central Fire Island. Learn how much home you can afford with our Home Affordability Calculator. The average household income in Central Fire Island is $118K.

What are the best public schools in Central Fire Island?

The best public schools that serve Central Fire Island are:

• Bay Shore Senior High School has an A Niche grade, a student teacher ratio of 11:1 and an average review score of 4.3.
• Bay Shore Middle School has a B+ Niche grade and a student teacher ratio of 11:1.

What are the most popular zip codes in Central Fire Island, Fire Island, NY?

The most popular zip codes in Central Fire Island, Fire Island, NY include 11770, 11730, 11782, 11702 and 11706.

What are the most popular neighborhoods near Central Fire Island, Fire Island, NY?

The most popular neighborhoods near Central Fire Island, Fire Island, NY are Western Fire Island and Downtown Bay Shore.

Are home prices dropping in Central Fire Island?

Yes, home prices in Central Fire Island are down 30% in the last 12 months.