Hayward, WI Homes for Sale under $400,000

Whether you’re hoping to find a quiet northwoods retreat, full time residence, seasonal retirement home or a short term rental investment property, this year round cabin home in Hayward fits the bill. The 3 bedroom, 1 bath home is situated on a picturesque 7 acre lot and offers a Hayward location close to endless high quality year-round outdoor adventures- fishing, snowmobiling, ATV trails,

Christian Klempp Compass

Set in the country in the Hayward area, where the Northwoods lifestyle actually delivers on its promise, this 4-bedroom, 2-bath, 2,273 finished square foot home offers space, privacy, and recent updates on 12.7 wooded acres. Three of the four bedrooms are conveniently located on the main level with two full bathrooms, one of which has been recently updated. The heart of the home features a newly

Jeremy Mavis Woodland Developments & Realty

Here is your opportunity to own this charming four-season home on Nelson Lake in beautiful Bog Bay- the perfect blend of peaceful lakefront living and close-to-town convenience. This half acre lot provides some privacy while enjoying the peaceful bay. A warm and inviting 2-bedroom home features a walkout basement and is ready for your personal touches to build equity and make it truly your own.

Angelyn Tinucci Route 63 Realty LLC

Just in time for summer! Take a look at this beautiful chalet style home just minutes south of one of Wisconsin's most popular towns, Hayward. This home features an open concept, hardwood floors, a large deck for enjoying the morning coffee or evening entertainment, a newer roof, fenced yard, and a 30X24 garage for storing the toys. Located on the ATV trail and just minutes from several lakes,

Andrew Pelke Prime Realty LLC

Hayward - Custom built ranch style home in family-friendly neighborhood! Welcome to your Northwoods retreat in the heart of Hayward! This like-new, quality-built home offers the perfect blend of comfort, charm and convenience just minutes from town. Built in 2004 and set on a spacious .57 acre lot, this beautifully updated 3 BRM, 2 BA home features 1,440 finished sq ft with stunning cherry, ash

Bonnie Burns Coldwell Banker Real Estate Consultants

Welcome to this delightful 4 bed, 3 bath, cedar-sided single-family home, that is situated on 1.32 acres on a dead-end road in the town of Hayward and is close to walking trails, area lakes, shopping, downtown, and medical services. The well-maintained residence spans 2688 square feet, offering an abundance of room for comfortable living in a park-like setting. The main level features mostly

Jeremy Mavis Woodland Developments & Realty

Convenient location just 1.5 miles north of City of Hayward on 3 acres; at the end of a cul-de-sac. A spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home on two levels with many updates including LP SmartSide, windows & new roof in 2020. Updated kitchen, main level & lower level bathrooms. Newer LVP & LVT flooring & new carpets in bedrooms. Main level has 3 bedrooms, full bath, kitchen, pantry & spacious dining

Gary Nathan Woodland Developments & Realty

Brand new home, being built spring/summer 2026, close to Hayward, just 3 miles from town on a beautiful 2 acre lot w/mature trees. 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms including a master bedroom with walk-in closet and private bathroom with walk-in shower. The floor plan features an open concept kitchen, dining, living area. The home is extremely well insulated and very efficient with forced air heating

Sam Werner C21 Woods to Water

FIRST TIME OFFERED! Nestled on 5.39 beautifully wooded acres just east of Hayward off Twin Lake Rd and near Round Lake, this inviting 1.5-story home offers privacy, comfort, and Northwoods charm only 10 minutes from town. The property features a finished 36x24 detached garage complete with an overhead heater, perfect for vehicles, storage, or a workshop. Inside, the main level welcomes you with

Gary Nathan Woodland Developments & Realty

Beautifully maintained Lake Hayward townhome offering sweeping water views and sandy shoreline access. Set on a level, low-maintenance lot, enjoy true Northwoods lake living with association-managed grounds, dock maintenance, and snow removal—ideal for year-round use or a worry-free getaway. The main level features an open-concept layout with kitchen, dining area, laundry, half bath, and a

Matt Albrecht Woodland Developments & Realty

Tucked back at the end of a private drive just outside of Hayward, this well-kept 2BR/2BA home delivers the Northwoods setting buyers are looking for without giving up easy access to town and recreation. Built in 2009, the home features an open and efficient layout with kitchen, dining, living area, laundry, bedroom, bathroom, and mechanicals all on the main level, while the upper loft is

Brooke Damaske Pine Point Real Estate LLC

Historyland Condominium on Lake Hayward, this standalone 3 bedroom, 2 bath condo lives more like a private home than a traditional condo. It has a thoughtfully designed layout that offers one level living with comfort and space, paired with the ease of condo life. Beautifully maintained inside and out! Whether you're enjoying a quiet morning coffee on the shared dock or hosting friends and

Annie Lawrence Northwest Wisconsin Realty Team

3 bedroom, 2 bath brick facade home located in the City of Hayward directly across the street from Smith Creek. The welcoming covered front porch is perfect for relaxing summer afternoons, while the 12x10 back deck with pergola and fenced backyard creates a great space for outdoor entertaining or quiet evenings at home. Step inside to a tiled entryway featuring a built in bench and coat nook that

Jeremy Mavis Woodland Developments & Realty

Nelson Lake Cabin Retreat – Prime Hayward Location Enjoy the perfect Northwoods escape with this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath cabin on sought-after Nelson Lake, located less than 10 minutes from downtown Hayward. This inviting three-season retreat offers stunning lake views, excellent lake access, ATV/UTV trail at the end of the driveway, and a turnkey opportunity to start enjoying lake

Nick Cernohous Keller Williams Realty Diversified

Charming, fully updated two bedroom, one bath cabin on the Tiger Cat Flowage in Hayward. This cozy Northwoods retreat blends rustic charm with modern upgrades and beautiful water views. The warm, inviting interior features tongue and groove ceilings, new windows and trim, fresh paint, and a newer gas electric fireplace with blower. The updated kitchen flows into a coffee bar and dining area,

Ty Wiley Area North Realty Inc

Seller is Negotiable and Motivated. Like-New Open Concept Home - Spacious, Stylish, and Exceptionally Maintained! This beautiful, like-new home offers exceptional design, comfort and craftsmanship with 2500 sq. ft all on one level. The open concept layout features generous sized bedrooms with large walk-in closets, well-appointed bathrooms, and abundant storage throughout. Distinctive Wyoming

Angelyn Tinucci Route 63 Realty LLC

New construction home being built in the city of Hayward, estimated completion is June 1, 2026. Located in a great subdivision with newer homes. 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms including a master bedroom with walk-in closet and private bathroom with walk-in shower. The floor plan features an open concept kitchen, dining, living area. The home is extremely well insulated and very efficient with

Sam Werner C21 Woods to Water

Just ten minutes north of Hayward, this well-maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bath condo offers just under 900 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Featuring attractive wood siding and a warm, inviting feel, the home blends cozy comfort with timeless appeal. Enjoy the added bonus of shared frontage on Nelson Lake—perfect for relaxing weekends, fishing, or taking in the peaceful waterfront

Michael Furtak Coldwell Banker Realty - Iron River

Spacious and well-maintained 6-bedroom home on 1.04 acres just minutes from Hayward schools, shopping, and everything this classic Northwoods town is known for, from lakes and trails to year-round events. With over 2,600 sqft, this home offers a functional layout with room for everyone. The updated kitchen, dining area, and living room all feature vaulted ceilings, creating an open, airy feel

Jeremy Mavis Woodland Developments & Realty