Henderson, NY Homes for Sale with Garage

A rare opportunity to own a true Historical Gem built of native limestone located just outside the Harbor situated on 1.5 acres! 5/6 bedrooms, 4 baths, over 3500SF, 2 woodstoves, 1 car garage and 30X50 pole barn! Formerly a B&B, this charmer has lots of original features and lots of character to include hardwood floors and old cast iron tub! Located just a few miles from downtown Henderson

Amanda Miller Listing by Lake Ontario Realty, LLC

Step into the charm and character of this inviting farmhouse, perfectly situated on more than an acre in the picturesque Village of Henderson. Blending timeless appeal with thoughtful updates, this spacious home offers room to gather, entertain, and create lasting memories. The generous living room provides a welcoming setting for family and friends, while the cozy sunroom—warmed by an efficient

Sherry LaFlamme Listing by LaFlamme Realty

A rare opportunity has arrived to own a premier Lake Ontario compound on Henderson Bay. This unique package offers the best of both worlds: a state-of-the-art architectural masterpiece at 10411 Bayshore Drive and a charming, successful rental cottage immediately next door--all situated on 115' of prime waterfront. Featuring a total of 5 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and almost 4400' square feet of

William Leepy Listing by NNY Homes Inc

A Rustic Diamond is for sale in Henderson. Originally a log cabin, this farmhouse has been completely updated while retaining its historic integrity. Two bedrooms on the first floor, the master bedroom has a modern bathroom and a deck to watch the abundant wildlife. The second bedroom was the original log cabin that has been updated with electric outlets and walls/ceiling completely insulated. A

Charlene Keck Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty Watn

Spectacular views of Lake Ontario are yours to enjoy year round from this 2308 square foot three bedroom, one bath log home on the shore. The open floor plan includes rooms that overlook the lakeshore, with each room sporting a great view. Amenities include a generous sized garage, new seawall, waterside screened pergola, whole house generator, a 21 unit solar array, 40000 BTU gas fireplace,

Gail Miller Listing by Ontario Bays Realty LLC

Experience 118 feet of level Lake Ontario waterfront with a protected shoreline, ideally located near Henderson Harbor and the Stony Creek Boat Launch. This property remains accessible throughout the winter via a seasonal road maintained by year-round neighbors. The charming cottage features an eat-in kitchen with included appliances, a first-floor full bath with a no-step shower, an enclosed

Catherine Wyble Listing by Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester

WELCOME TO YOUR OWN PRIVATE UPSTATE NEW YORK RETREAT. Set on 17.5 breathtaking acres just minutes from Lake Ontario, this beautifully maintained 1850 farmhouse offers timeless character, functional space, and lifestyle flexibility. Surrounded by peaceful countryside views and endless opportunity, this property is more than a home — it’s a destination. Offering over 2,300 square feet, the home

Renee Senn Listing by GRG Gloria Realty Group

Opportunity awaits at this Henderson property offering country living and endless potential. The home features a spacious interior, rustic stone accents, and a wood stove for supplemental heat. Situated on a generous lot with room to enjoy the outdoors, this property is ready for your vision and updates. Conveniently located near Lake Ontario, public boat launches, and local attractions. Being

Lara Wines Listing by North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Some homes are built; 10411 Bayshore Drive was thoughtfully crafted. Designed by architect Michael Aubertine, this custom modern masterpiece was completed in August 2022 with quality finishes and impressive upgrades throughout. Imagine waking every day to the glimmer of Lake Ontario just outside your window—that dream is real here. From the moment you arrive, the curb appeal is off the charts. A

William Leepy Listing by NNY Homes Inc