Historic Homes for Sale in Lafayette, IN

One of Tippecanoe County's best-kept secrets, this historic Italianate residence-known as Bird Acres-offers a rare opportunity to own a property where architectural significance and modern livability exist in balance. Built in 1880 and once home to naturalist Eliza Dana Weigle, the home carries a legacy that is both meaningful and remarkably preserved. Extensively expanded and thoughtfully

Donald Meeks F.C. Tucker Company

Graceful and timeless, this 1937 Colonial is nestled in Lafayette’s beloved Highland Park neighborhood, where tree-lined streets and historic architecture define the setting. Offering over 2,000 square feet above grade, this four-bedroom, one and a half bath home features restored original hardwood floors and classic details that honor its era. The living room centers around a fireplace with

Hayley Wheeler Raeco Realty

Welcome to this meticulously maintained 1938 Cape Cod nestled in one of Lafayette’s most desirable historic neighborhoods. With over 2,000 square feet of beautifully preserved character and carefully curated updates, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of old-world charm and modern comfort. Original hardwood floors flow throughout the home, complemented by stunning built-ins

Kristen Griffin F.C. Tucker/Shook

Have you been thinking about moving to the vibrant downtown area but are unsure about the upkeep of an older home? Great news! Discover this incredible new build located in the perfect spot for enjoying the best of downtown living! Currently under construction, with a completion date in early 2026, this modern home beautifully blends with the charm of historic downtown architecture and the lovely

Tabitha Casto TruVant Realty

Looking for a home with character that is walkable to EVERYTHING downtown? This Victorian gal has over 3200 sq ft, with 4 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, and 3 floors that offer flexible space for everyone. The first two floors showcase historic elements like high tin ceilings, antique built-ins, and hardwood floors, while the third-floor loft could be a contemporary luxury in-law suite with 15-foot

Jessica Collaco Keller Williams Lafayette

Embrace this incredible chance to own a beautifully restored American Foor square just steps away from upper Main Street! Homes like this, in such proximity to the historic downtown, are truly a rarity, and this property stands out with its thoughtful updates. Enjoy the comfort of dual-zoned heating and cooling, a charming fenced backyard, and a walk-out basement that opens right onto N. 8th St –

Tabitha Casto TruVant Realty

Step into timeless charm with this beautiful 3 bedroom 2 full bath Tudor-style home that blends classic character with fresh, updated interiors. From the moment you enter, you’re welcomed by warm hardwood floors, graceful archways, and inviting living spaces filled with natural light, all enhanced by beautiful custom window coverings that add both style and sophistication. The cozy fireplace

Thomas Albregts Keller Williams Lafayette

Step into timeless charm with this beautifully preserved home, featuring gorgeous hardwood floors throughout. The spacious layout includes four amply sized bedrooms, offering comfort and flexibility for a variety of living needs. A third-story walk-up attic provides abundant storage or the potential to be transformed into additional living space. The kitchen is thoughtfully updated with granite

Lynn Beckham Keller Williams Lafayette

Here’s a fantastic opportunity for a single-family rental! This delightful home on N 6th Street is currently renting for $1,075 per month, with tenants covering all utilities. Its prime location is perfect for anyone wanting to be close to historic downtown or just a quick commute to West Lafayette and Purdue’s campus. You’ll find yourself just steps away from local restaurants, shops, and

Tabitha Casto TruVant Realty

This historic, 1950 sq ft two-story duplex, was built in 1901, and is located just outside downtown Lafayette on a 0.08-acre lot. It contains 4 total bedrooms and 2 bathrooms overall (configured as two units, each with 2 bedrooms and 1 bath), making it well-suited as an income-producing rental property. The home features traditional construction with aluminum siding, forced-air heating, central

Ryan Griswold Elite Property Mgmt and Realty

Excellent opportunity to own a 6-unit investment property featuring two separate buildings on a single parcel. The property includes a duplex built in 1900 and a fourplex built in 1880, offering a unique blend of historic character and functional rental space. 2 units currently rented. Tenants pay all utilities.

Eric Campos Indiana Integrity REALTORS

Welcome to this charming triplex, fully rented and situated in a fantastic part of town! This investment gem is just a stone's throw away from the historic downtown area. Tucked away off Kossith Street on S. 5th St., it features two roomy units on the main floor and a cozy unit upstairs. Utilities are conveniently included in the rent. Currently, it brings in $2,765 per month, with a planned

Tabitha Casto TruVant Realty

Welcome to one of Lafayette’s most extraordinary estates. This true one-of-a-kind masterpiece sits on over 25 private acres and boasts more than 2,000 feet of scenic Wildcat Creek frontage. Custom built in 2011 to capture the timeless charm of a 100+ year-old home, every inch of this property blends historic character with modern comfort. From the authentic push-button light switches and custom

Josh Shives Raeco Realty

Fully rented 5-plex in highly desirable Historic 9th Street Hill neighborhood. Close to downtown. Earns $5,400 gross monthly rent. Every unit has been renovated within the past 4 years.

Lynn Beckham Keller Williams Lafayette

Experience the joy of new construction in this stunning home, now complete and ready for you to make lasting memories! The open main level floorplan is perfect for entertaining, featuring a delightful kitchen with solid surface countertops, stainless steel appliances, a center island, and a spacious walk-in pantry. The expansive great room, dining area, and inviting entryway with a ventless

Tabitha Casto TruVant Realty