25

Lexington, NY Homes for Sale under $500,000

Section Image Section Image
  • /36

    $319,000

    $30K PRICE DROP
    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,420 Sq Ft

    23 Harter Rd, West Kill, NY 12492

    Charming, two-story home set on a picturesque half-acre lot, beautifully bordering West Kill Creek. This inviting property blends classic character with comfortable living.The first floor features an open-concept layout with a kitchen, dining area, and living room--perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A convenient primary bedroom and full bathroom are also located on this

    Agent Photo

    Yaroslava Tkachuk

    Hunter Mountain Realty

    23 Harter Rd, West Kill, NY 12492
  • /22

    $350,000

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,660 Sq Ft

    247 Truesdell Rd, Prattsville, NY 12468

    Peace and tranquility abound with this 3 bedroom home set on 10.90 acres, adjoining NYC lands, at the end of a scenic cul-de-sac. Remarkable vistas from every vantage point especially from the expansive deck. This 3 bed, 2 bath home was built in 1998 and offers 1660sf of living space. More photos and drone footage coming soon! Mature plantings including perennial gardens. Don't miss this

    Agent Photo

    Susan Miller

    WINDSTAR REALTY GROUP LLC

    247 Truesdell Rd, Prattsville, NY 12468
  • /34

    $295,000

    • 5 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,027 Sq Ft

    170 Spruceton Rd, West Kill, NY 12492

    WEST KILL -- THE SETTING SELLS IT! Tucked up and away from the road on 2.5 serene acres, this unique property enjoys beautiful mountain views and is surrounded by NYC Watershed land, creating a wonderful sense of privacy and a true Catskill Mountain setting. Originally built in 1865 and renovated in the 1970s, the home is currently configured as a side-by-side two-family residence offering a

    Agent Photo

    Carol Shaw

    Shaw Country Realty, Inc.

    170 Spruceton Rd, West Kill, NY 12492
  • /18

    $245,000

    • Land
    • 32.5 Acres
    • $7,538 per Acre

    0 Route 23a Unit 20263122, Lexington, NY 12452

    The newly approved percolation test permits the construction of a home with up to five bedrooms. This beautiful 32.5-acre parcel is located in the picturesque town of Lexington, ideally situated between Windham, Hunter, and Belleayre Mountains. Generous road frontage provides easy year-round access, while the property's gradual southern slope offers ideal southern exposure and abundant

    Agent Photo

    Yaroslava Tkachuk

    Hunter Mountain Realty

    0 Route 23a Unit 20263122, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /34

    $390,000

    $29K PRICE DROP
    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 845 Sq Ft

    31 Van Etten Rd, Lexington, NY 12468

    Escape to your own private slice of the Catskills. This charming 2-bedroom log cabin, built in 1988, offers the quintessential mountain lifestyle on over 10 sprawling acres of pristine Lexington landscape. Whether you are looking for a secluded primary residence, a seasonal ski chalet, or a high-potential short-term rental, this property delivers the perfect blend of rustic character and natural

    Agent Photo

    Susan Miller

    WINDSTAR REALTY GROUP LLC

    31 Van Etten Rd, Lexington, NY 12468
  • /36

    $499,000

    $51K PRICE DROP
    • 5 Beds
    • 3 Baths
    • 2,700 Sq Ft

    12266 New York 23a, Prattsville, NY 12468

    Two Family Mountain Escape awaits you! Nestled between Windham and Hunter Mountains. Just a short 10 min drive to the slopes and excitement of Hunter Mtn. This versitile 2 family house is an exceptional opportunity for investors and life-style buyers alike. One 3 bed/2 ba unit and one 2 bed/1 ba unit. From thrilling ski runs and pristine snowmobile trails, to amazing hiking, off roading and

    Brian Cohen RHR Realty Group

    12266 New York 23a, Prattsville, NY 12468
  • /15

    $425,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,128 Sq Ft

    116 Reme Rd, Prattsville, NY 12468

    Nestled among mature trees and surrounded by natural beauty, this turnkey Catskills retreat offers the kind of peace and privacy buyers are searching for. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 1 bath, split-unit heating and cooling throughout the home and basement, laundry, and generous parking, this well-maintained property is ready for its next chapter. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend

    Carlos Rodriguez Dugo Realty

    116 Reme Rd, Prattsville, NY 12468
  • /19

    $395,000

    • Land
    • 15.21 Acres
    • $25,970 per Acre

    L20.2 Overlook Dr, Lexington, NY 12452

    Welcome to Deer Pen Estates--where the hardest decision you may have to make is which breathtaking view you want to wake up to each morning. Nestled in Prattsville, NY (In the Town of Lexington) and surrounded by the spectacular Northern Catskills, this exceptional land opportunity offers 13+ distinctive building lots ranging from approximately 4 to 15 acres, with pricing starting at $135,000.

    Alex Cooley Compass Greater NY LLC

    L20.2 Overlook Dr, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /7

    $325,000

    • Land
    • 11.1 Acres
    • $29,279 per Acre

    00 Bruce Cross Dr, Lexington, NY 12452

    Sited along a scenic ridge of the Northern Catskill Mountains, this rare 11-acre parcel offers sweeping big-sky views across the southern mountain range, exceptional privacy, and a peaceful natural setting filled with mature hardwoods, exposed rock formations, and a sun-soaked native meadow with desirable southern exposure. With DEP-approved perk test, site approval for new home construction,

    Laurie Hanenberg Hunter Windham Real Estate

    00 Bruce Cross Dr, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /20

    $210,000

    • Land
    • 10.43 Acres
    • $20,134 per Acre

    L28.1 Deer Ln, Lexington, NY 12452

    Welcome to Deer Pen Estates--where the hardest decision you may have to make is which breathtaking view you want to wake up to each morning. Nestled in Prattsville, NY (In the Town of Lexington) and surrounded by the spectacular Northern Catskills, this exceptional land opportunity offers 13+ distinctive building lots ranging from approximately 4 to 15 acres, with pricing starting at $135,000.

    Alex Cooley Compass Greater NY LLC

    L28.1 Deer Ln, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /29

    $439,000

    $60K PRICE DROP
    • Land
    • 61.7 Acres
    • $7,115 per Acre

    Unlisted Address

    61.70 Acres of Wooded Privacy Bordering State Land!Discover the perfect blend of seclusion and opportunity on this expansive 61.70-acre parcel, largely wooded and rich with natural beauty. An established trails winds through the property, making it easy to explore on foot, ATV, or horseback while enjoying the peaceful forest setting.Bordering state land, this property offers enhanced

    Jeffrey Ashton Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

    Unlisted Address
  • /20

    $325,000

    $74K PRICE DROP
    • Land
    • 148.21 Acres
    • $2,193 per Acre

    L15.2 Mt Eden Estates Rd, Lexington, NY 12452

    Looking for Hunting Land? A Get away? Your Own Private Place for Receation? Hiking? Look no further! 148+ mountain top acres of raw wilderness at it's best! Perfect for that off the grid camp, hunting land, quads, side by sides, dirtbikes or just hiking in your own piece of mountain top paradise with springs, babbling brooks and wildlife galore! Surrounded by gorgeous views, but still close to

    Douglas Schenk Re Max Capital

    L15.2 Mt Eden Estates Rd, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /19

    $397,000

    • Land
    • 15.28 Acres
    • $25,982 per Acre

    L36 Overlook Dr, Lexington, NY 12452

    Welcome to Deer Pen Estates--where the hardest decision you may have to make is which breathtaking view you want to wake up to each morning. Nestled in Prattsville, NY (In the Town of Lexington) and surrounded by the spectacular Northern Catskills, this exceptional land opportunity offers 13+ distinctive building lots ranging from approximately 4 to 15 acres, with pricing starting at $135,000.

    Alex Cooley Compass Greater NY LLC

    L36 Overlook Dr, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /22

    $249,000

    • Land
    • 29.17 Acres
    • $8,536 per Acre

    0 Airport Rd Lot #4 Unit 20265242, Lexington, NY 12452

    Beautiful N. Lexington 29.17 acres on Airport rd., bordering 28 acres of State land. Stone wall borders for most of the property. Lush green open areas with lots of Pines, Hemlocks, American Beech and Oak trees. Lower level has area for pond. May have some views with clearing Close to Hunter and Windham Mountains. Wildlife abundant.

    Jacqueline Coyle Coldwell Banker Village GreenW

    0 Airport Rd Lot #4 Unit 20265242, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /36

    $299,888

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,021 Sq Ft

    125 Deer Ln, Middletown, NY 12468

    Owner financing considered for a qualified buyer.........Great ski house, seasonal getaway, or year-round home in the Catskills........ Welcome to 125 Deer Lane, Arkville — a fully renovated turnkey cottage on approximately 1.7 private acres at the end of a quiet dead-end lane....... Move-in ready.........Outside: new metal roof, wood siding, deck, and a maintained shed....... About 1.7 acres

    Joseph Lombardo Listing by Lombardo Homes & Estates

    125 Deer Ln, Middletown, NY 12468
  • /31

    $439,000

    $60K PRICE DROP
    • Land
    • 61.7 Acres
    • $7,115 per Acre

    30 Harter Rd, Westkill, NY 12492

    61.70 Acres of Wooded Privacy Bordering State Land!Discover the perfect blend of seclusion and opportunity on this expansive 61.70-acre parcel, largely wooded and rich with natural beauty. An established trails winds through the property, making it easy to explore on foot, ATV, or horseback while enjoying the peaceful forest setting.Bordering state land, this property offers enhanced

    Jeffrey Ashton Coldwell Banker Timberland Pro

    30 Harter Rd, Westkill, NY 12492
  • /20

    $320,000

    • Land
    • 12.5 Acres
    • $25,600 per Acre

    L40 Overlook Dr, Lexington, NY 12452

    Welcome to Deer Pen Estates--where the hardest decision you may have to make is which breathtaking view you want to wake up to each morning. Nestled in Prattsville, NY (In the Town of Lexington) and surrounded by the spectacular Northern Catskills, this exceptional land opportunity offers 13+ distinctive building lots ranging from approximately 4 to 15 acres, with pricing starting at $135,000.

    Alex Cooley Compass Greater NY LLC

    L40 Overlook Dr, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /27

    $398,500

    $27K PRICE DROP
    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,288 Sq Ft

    6194 Route 23c, Prattsville, NY 12468

    Private Mountain Retreat on 3+ AcresDiscover the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and outdoor adventure in this beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bath home situated on more than 3 secluded acres. Nestled in a peaceful setting with scenic views, this property offers the tranquility you've been looking for while remaining conveniently close to popular ski areas and year-round recreation.The home

    Chelsey Decker RVW Select Properties

    6194 Route 23c, Prattsville, NY 12468
  • /24

    $325,000

    $74K PRICE DROP
    • Land
    • 148.21 Acres
    • $2,193 per Acre

    Land On Mount Eden Estates Rd, Lexington, NY 12452

    REDUCED! Looking for Hunting Land? A Get away? Your Own Private Place for Recreation? Hiking? Look no further! 148+ mountain top acres of raw wilderness at it's best! Perfect for that off the grid camp, hunting land, quads, side by sides, dirtbikes or just hiking in your own piece of mountain top paradise with springs, babbling brooks and wildlife galore! Surrounded by gorgeous views, but still

    Douglas Schenk RE/MAX Capital

    Land On Mount Eden Estates Rd, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /40

    $350,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 1.5 Baths
    • 1,540 Sq Ft

    162 Terrace Dr, Prattsville, NY 12468

    Tucked away on nearly five private wooded acres, this enchanting log chalet is the authentic Catskill Mountain retreat -- a place to unplug, recharge, and reconnect with nature. With a finished basement level, living area is a generous 1540 square feet, though tax record reflects 770sqft.Set along one of the area's most scenic Catskill Mountain roads and backing directly to protected

    Lindsey Arnold BHHS Nutshell Realty

    162 Terrace Dr, Prattsville, NY 12468
  • /30

    $275,000

    • Land
    • 13.25 Acres
    • $20,755 per Acre

    L28.2 Deer Ln, Lexington, NY 12452

    Welcome to Deer Pen Estates--where the hardest decision you may have to make is which breathtaking view you want to wake up to each morning. Nestled in Prattsville, NY (In the Town of Lexington) and surrounded by the spectacular Northern Catskills, this exceptional land opportunity offers 13+ distinctive building lots ranging from approximately 4 to 15 acres, with pricing starting at $135,000.

    Alex Cooley Compass Greater NY LLC

    L28.2 Deer Ln, Lexington, NY 12452
  • /41

    $459,000

    $20K PRICE DROP
    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,080 Sq Ft

    668 Tumbleweed Ranch Rd, West Kill, NY 12492

    Welcome to Westkill, NY, where a stream winds through the valley and mountain trails invite you to enjoy nature at its finest. Follow Tumbleweed Ranch Road to the private entrance at #668 and discover this peaceful Catskills retreat.This charming Catskill Mountain cabin is a fully renovated, well-maintained log-sided with glowing hardwood floors and soaring vaulted ceilings. The brand-new

    Laurie Hanenberg Hunter Windham Real Estate

    668 Tumbleweed Ranch Rd, West Kill, NY 12492
  • /30

    $399,000

    $10K PRICE DROP
    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,302 Sq Ft

    8 Trailside Dr Unit B10, Hunter, NY 12442

    Welcome to Trailside Condominiums, where residents take pride in ownership and the well-maintained grounds. Natural landscaping and outdoor lighting complement the mountain scenery, while sidewalks and parking areas are kept clear of snow for easy access upon your arrival.Step into your private weekend retreat, kick off your boots, and unwind on the spacious sectional as the cozy propane

    Laurie Hanenberg Hunter Windham Real Estate

    8 Trailside Dr Unit B10, Hunter, NY 12442
  • /36

    $309,000

    $30K PRICE DROP
    • Land
    • 28 Acres
    • $11,036 per Acre

    380 Terrace Dr, Lexington, NY 12468

    Have you ever dreamed about owning property in the Catskills but just haven't found what you are looking for? Look no further -.this 28 acre property in the town of Lexington could turn your dream into a reality.Whether you are looking for a weekend getaway or want a full-time home, this property located on a quiet, dead-end road offers privacy and seclusion surrounded by a peaceful setting that

    Sharri Cunningham Bunce Realty

    380 Terrace Dr, Lexington, NY 12468
  • /31

    $369,000

    $29K PRICE DROP
    • 1 Bed
    • 1 Bath
    • 798 Sq Ft

    1425 Route 2, Prattsville, NY 12468

    You searched and you searched for your own one bedroom in the mountains--but they don't build quaint, little Catskills cabins like this anymore. You dreamed and you dreamed of waking to the morning song of wild birds, of throwing open your doors to the smell of fresh snow, or freshly cut grass, galloping raspberries and darting hummingbirds, of the sight of rolling acres of permanently enshrined

    Hillary Kolos Compass Greater NY, LLC

    1425 Route 2, Prattsville, NY 12468

Home Price Trends

Median Sale Price
$557,450
Median Single Family Sale Price
$435,000
Median 2 Bedroom Sale Price
$390,000
Median 1 Bedroom Sale Price
$634,900
Average Price Per Sq Ft
$309
Number of Homes for Sale
25
Last 12 months Home Sales
4
Months of Supply
3.00
Median List Price
$484,000
Median Change From 1st List Price
12%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change
89%
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home