As one of the five villages making up the hamlet of Port Washington, Baxter Estates enjoys a close relationship with its neighboring communities on Long Island’s Cow Neck Peninsula while maintaining a distinct neighborhood identity. That identity largely revolves around residents who rarely want to move away from the serenity of its sloping and winding streets on the shores of Manhasset Bay. “Neighbors know one another. It’s not a place where neighbors don’t speak to each other,” says Baxter Estates mayor Nora Haagenson. “I can’t tell you why that’s the case, but it’s always been that way. Even those who might be reluctant at first, they’re sort of drawn in and talk to each other.”
Baxter Estates offers waterfront tranquility while being a short ride away from Manhattan.
Many of the homes in Baxter Estates feature large plots of property.
1/2
A century of styles with a low rate of turnover
Baxter Estates houses were constructed in multiple waves between 1913-2020, providing a diversity in styles. Cape Cods and Colonial Revivals are common, but Tudors and cotemporary designs can also be found. Some newer homes also harken to the neighborhood’s older styles even if constructed from different materials. However, turnover is so rare that even the mayor often knows whether there are any homes on the market. “Residents, for the most part, are long-term residents,” says Haagenson, who has lived here since 1975. “It’s a very stable community.” Homes in Baxter Estates have recently sold between $650,000-$2.1 million.
Contemporary colonial style homes are popular among residents in Baxter Estates.
Colonial Style homes are common throughout Baxter Estates, with large plots of land.
1/2
Port Washington schools highly regarded
Students in Baxter Estates attend Port Washington schools, all of which receive an A-grade on Niche. John Philip Sousa Elementary – named for the famed marching band composer who lived on Cow Neck – serves grade schoolers. Students attend Carrie Palmer Weber Middle School before advancing to Paul D. Schrieber High School. Schreiber, which is simply known as Port Washington in athletic competition, was rated the 66th-best high school in New York State by U.S. News and World Report. In 2022, 75% of students took at least one Advanced Placement exam, far exceeding the state average of 16%.
Welcome to John J Daly Elementary School in Port Washington.
Carrie Palmer Weber Middle School in Port Washington is home to 1,208 students.
1/2
Baxter's Pond, beautiful sunsets, and a beloved library
Barbara Johnson Park & Preserve, more commonly known as Baxter’s Pond Park, is a greenspace owned by Nassau County but maintained by neighborhood residents around its namesake pond. The city maintains a small, non-swimming beach along Shore Road that is a popular spot to view sunsets – as is the much larger Sunset Park, which is located just over the border in Port Washington. The Port Washington Library, located in Baxter Estates, is another popular community gathering place thanks to events like weekend concerts and programs for children and seniors. “People come from other communities just to take advantage of the materials and programs we have here,” Haagenson says. “The library is very much part of the community.”
Find inner peace on the trails at Baxter Pond Park in Baxter Estates.
Get lost in a book at The Port Washington Library in nearby Port Washington.
1/2
A small neighborhood with a big appetite
For a village of around 1,000 residents, Baxter Estates has a rich array of shopping and dining options. Ayhan’s Mediterranean Marketplace and the neighboring Shish Kebab Restaurant are credited with introducing eastern Mediterranean cuisine to Long Island in the early 1980s. Tominaga Shouten is a Japanese grocery that features takeout sushi, bento boxes and miso soup. Irish pub Finn MacCools is the Real McCoy, featuring live Irish music and dancers for the entire week leading to St. Patrick’s Day. Grocery and chain shopping options are a short trip into Port Washington North.
Order up at Mediterranean Marketplace in nearby Port Washington.
Finn MacCools in Baxter Estates.is More than your Local Irish Pub.
1/2
LIRR puts NYC in close reach
The relative tranquility of Baxter Estates can feel a world away from New York City, but it’s only a short train ride. It’s about a 10-minute walk to the Long Island Railroad’s Port Washington station, from which a trip to Penn Station is 48 minutes and a Mets game at Citi Field is 28 minutes. The NICE (Nassau Inter-County Express) Route 23 bus serves the neighborhood along Shore Road and Main Street. Baxter Estates is also about 15 miles from LaGuardia Airport and 18 miles from John F. Kennedy Airport.
The LIRR station in nearby Port Washington serves Baxter Estates to all points west.
The N23 bus route on the Nassau Inter-County Express runs up to Baxter Estates.
1/2
Port Washington HarborFest a major draw
Baxter Estates residents and businesses participate in Port Washington HarborFest, which has been held annually each summer since 1990 at the nearby Port Washington Town Dock. The festival features local vendors, games for kids, and boat rides to help fund efforts to protect and preserve Manhasset Bay. Nearly 8,000 visitors attended the 2023 HarborFest.
Baxter Estates fighting against eroding beach
Baxter Estates has avoided severe storm damage since 1985’s Hurricane Gloria, but smaller weather events leave an impact. Due to severe erosion along Baxter Beach, Shore Rd. is prone to flooding during high tides and heavy rains – an issue for which the village has requested state funding to help mitigate. The village also shuts down its steepest street, Tianderah Rd., in winter. Haagenson says there are engineering plans in place to counter any potential sea rise related to climate change, though the construction also requires state approval.
Walk along Manhasset Bay at Sunset Park in Baxter Estates.
The Village of Baxter Estates has opted to close some roads due to seasonal flooding.
1/2
Photography Contributed By
Jeff Rainone
Video By
Andrew Sutton
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Lily Costa,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Stunning 2-bedroom corner unit in desirable Madison Park Gardens, offers the convenience of a washer/dryer in the unit as well as an updated kitchen and bath. The kitchen features white cabinets, quartz countertops, stainless appliances as well as a large pantry. Other features of the home include wood floors, recessed lighting and a generous dining area. This home is ideally situated near the
Prestigious location! Welcome home-the only thing you will need to do is move in.This charming 3-bedroom Colonial has been updated throughout, freshly painted, sprawling outdoor spaces surrounded by trees and flowers, well-positioned on a tree-line street. The perfect aspect allows natural light to drench the interior. Open floor concept encompasses living room and dining area flow into each
Fully renovated home nestled on a charming, quiet street in the heart of Port Washington. Ideally situated between Manhasset Bay and Mill Pond, this turnkey property offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and convenience - just moments from everything the town has to offer. The home features a fully fenced yard with a patio and spacious lawn, perfect for relaxing or entertaining, as well as
This inviting Craftsman architecture-inspired home in Port Washington blends casual comfort, warm tones and organic materials for timeless style, and effortless everyday living. Beautifully renovated, this 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath Colonial is filled with natural light and thoughtfully designed spaces that create an easy flow for both relaxed living and entertaining. The main level welcomes you with a
Beautifully updated Dutch Colonial blends timeless character with modern comfort. Fully renovated in 2026, every detail has been thoughtfully curated, including brand new kitchen with gas cooking, updated bathrooms, new flooring and completely upgraded plumbing and electrical systems offering the feel of new construction within a classic home. The home features 3 spacious bedrooms with
Heart of town - this home is centrally located to everything Port Washington has to offer: LIRR train station, restaurants, shopping, worship, schools, movie theater, library! This is a great opportunity to bring your home vision to life and redo this home to your liking! Featuring 4 bedrooms plus a full size walkup attic, full basement with a separate entrance, 2 full baths (1 new), young roof,
Stunning 2-bedroom corner unit in desirable Madison Park Gardens, offers the convenience of a washer/dryer in the unit as well as an updated kitchen and bath. The kitchen features white cabinets, quartz countertops, stainless appliances as well as a large pantry. Other features of the home include wood floors, recessed lighting and a generous dining area. This home is ideally situated near the
Enjoy modern comfort in this newly refurbished, South-facing 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment. The open floorplan offers seamless living, complemented by gleaming wood floors that add warmth and style. Dishwasher and Microwave included. Tucked away for privacy, this hidden gem is bright, airy, and conveniently located near essential amenities. Most pets are welcome.
Welcome home to a Commuter’s Dream! Welcome to this conveniently located 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath Dutch Colonial in the heart of Port Washington. Just a short distance to the Port Washington LIRR line, this bright and inviting home offers an open-concept layout ideal for modern living. The first floor features a sun-filled open living space with multiple entrances, creating excellent flow and
Two Bedroom Apartment on Main Street directly across the street from the LIRR. Spacious open layout with large living room, dining room and kitchen area. New windows throughout. Laundry in common basement area. Elevator building. Pet rent additional $150/mo. Utilities not included. Hallways to be remodeled.
Spacious one bedroom, maximum 2 people, 2nd floor apartment with bonus double loft. Apartment features hardwood floors, large living room, formal dining room, eat-in-kitchen with dishwasher, refrigerator and gas range. There is a charming full bath and one bedroom. Upstairs to private loft space, great for recreation room, office or your flexible use. Less than one block to the LIRR
Welcome to this sunny and inviting 3-bedroom apartment on the first floor of a classic Colonial home. Offering the comfort and feel of a private house, this residence features a generous living room and formal dining room—ideal for everyday living and entertaining alike. The oversized eat-in kitchen is perfect for cooking and gathering, and has been updated with a brand-new stove, microwave, and
Welcome home to 32 Herbert Avenue in Port Washington — a charming and well-maintained home offering 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. This inviting residence features beautiful hardwood floors throughout, a full basement providing ample storage and a private driveway with convenient parking.Enjoy relaxing on the wraparound porch or retreat to the oversized primary bedroom for added
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
