$158,842Average Value$132Average Price per Sq Ft8Homes For Sale
Dutch colonial-like main street community
Bentleyville, located about 25 miles directly south of Pittsburgh in Washington County, is an appealing rural western Pennsylvania suburb. Established homes featuring traditional architectural styles dot quiet neighborhood streets. Residents are served by a Main Street that bisects the community and provides a surprising level of convenience. The surrounding landscape is relatively untouched, featuring acreage homes scattered among the farmland. Those living in the community enjoy a laidback country lifestyle with the added benefits of access to top-rated schools and interstate travel for work and play.
Mansard roofs for miles
Prevalent in the community is a collection of established homes, from Colonial Revival farmhouses built at the turn of the 20th century to minimalist brick homes built after World War II. Many of the homes have been upgraded over the years, including remodeled Dutch Colonial Revival homes with Craftsman touches and modernized bungalows. Dutch Colonial Revival is the most common architectural style in Bentleyville. Homes are typically priced between the low $100,000s to the high $200,000s, although acreage homes can sell for hundreds of thousands more depending on how much land accompanies the purchase.
Colonial Dutch Revivals can be found in Bentleyville, PA.
This victorian home has been meticulously restored in Bentleyville, PA.
This bungalow in Bentleyville has been carefully restored and modernized.
Older homes stand on Washington Street, while the Bentley Towers stands in the background.
1/4
Lead the horse to water
Retail and dining options are conveniently concentrated along the Pennsylvania Route 917 corridor, which runs north and south through the community and is alternately designated as Wilson Road and Main Street. A Giant Eagle Supermarket anchors a retail center off Wilson Road on the northern edge of town, while dining is spread throughout the community. Popular independent eateries include Carlton Diner, a relatively new family restaurant that gets rave reviews for its homemade food, and Crazy Horse, an established neighborhood bar that serves up comfort food favorites.
The Crazy Horse Bar & Grill is a popular watering hole in Bentleyville, PA.
Scoops ice cream parlor is a great place to stop for a delicious treat in Bentleyville.
The Carlton Diner is a family favorite in Bentleyville, PA.
Grocery needs can be fulfilled at Giant Eagle in Bentleyville.
1/4
School experts for students with autism
Students have access to a trio of conveniently located public schools. Bentworth Elementary School is A-rated by Niche, while Bentworth Middle and Bentworth Senior High are B-rated schools. The teachers at all three schools were given As by Niche. Bentworth Elementary is adjacent to Bentworth Senior High, and Bentworth Middle is only a half-mile away. The Bentworth School District’s special needs program includes a partnership with the Kommittee for Autism Research and Education, a collaboration between educators and parents that helps newly diagnosed students and their parents navigate available services.
Bentworth Elementary School is a public K-4 school rated A- by Niche.
Bentworth Middle School is a public school for grades 5-8 and is rated a B by Niche.
Bentworth Senior High is a public school for grades 9-12 and is rated a B- by Niche.
The Bentleyville Library is focused on children with a terrific area for story time.
1/4
Close commuter routes
Interstate 70 borders the north side of the community and can be easily accessed for work commutes or travel around the greater Pittsburgh area. Route 917 actually leads directly to downtown Pittsburgh, but if interstate travel is more the speed, I-70 connects to I-79 about 15 miles west of Bentleyville. From there, Pittsburgh is about 25 miles away. Despite the difference in miles, the travel time for each is roughly an hour.
Community parks for community pastimes
Bentleyville Richardson Park is a community green space located in the heart of town along Pigeon Creek. It hosts youth soccer competitions and is the home of community events, including an annual Fourth of July celebration. A paved trail encircles the park, making it a popular spot for walkers, bike riders and skaters. The neighborhood’s youngest residents have access to a small playground there. Baseball and softball competitions take place nearby at Caramel Park. Ellsworth Community Park on the south side of the community offers basketball courts and a larger children’s playscape. Golfers in Bentleyville have access to the nearby Chippewa Golf Club, a popular public facility that features an 18-hole, par-70 layout that winds its way for 6,000 yards among the tree-filled, rural landscape of Washington County.
The Chippewa Golf Club offers multiple water hazards to challenge all levels of golfers.
A resident takes a walk on the paved trails of Richardson Park.
The baseball field at Roadman Park is active every spring in West Brownsville.
A bridge spans the creek in Bentleyville Richardson Park in order to reach a small playground.
1/4
Written By
Matt Pallister
Photography Contributed By
Jeffrey Muschar
Video By
Jacob Cooperman
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Judi Agostinelli,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Bentleyville, PA sell after 108 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Bentleyville, PA over the last 12 months is $170,000, down 3% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Brand new 2025 manufactured home designed with modern style and smart efficiency! This spacious layout offers an open-concept living area, a sleek kitchen with energy-efficient appliances, and generously sized bedrooms. Thoughtfully crafted for comfort and functionality, it also features a stylish exterior with great curb appeal, ample storage, and low utility costs. Perfect for buyers seeking
A statement house poised on 10 acres. 4 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath, oversize rooms, full basement, large attic, 3 car garage. Barn adjacent to two fenced pasture fields. Mature trees and landscaping. Updated counter tops and fixtures throughout. New roof on rear side, front side 6 years old. Hardwood floors just refinished, new patio French door with internal mini blinds. Stone wood burning fireplace in
0.7543 ACRE LOT IN BENTWORTH SCHOOLS (SURVEYED)!! This lot is easily accessible off Piersol Ave on the outskirts of Bentleyville. This site has a great usable flat to gently sloped area for your NEW HOME! You will appreciate the mature trees & the established neighborhood. This lot is close to all amenities in Bentleyville (Schools, Churches, Shopping, & more). It's under 2 miles from I-70 at the
Welcome 102 Johnston Road in Bentleyville Pa! This recently updated 3-bedroom, 1 full bath ranch-style home situated on a corner lot. Features include a new furnace, new hot water tank, new central A/C, freshly painted throughout and updated plumbing throughout. Conveniently located just minutes from shopping, dining, and major roadways for easy commuting.This charming home also offers a
Michael WickerBERKSHIRE HATHAWAY THE PREFERRED REALTY
114 Beallsville Road offers 3 generous sized bedrooms, with one and a half baths. The backyard is fenced it, with a working above ground pool and expansive deck space for all of your entertaining needs. A large kitchen with a new refrigerator, with ample cabinets and counter space, along with a nice size living room and dining room. Located in the Bentworth School District, this home is also
AUCTION-HOME CANNOT BE SHOWN - Colonial home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with approximately 2188 square feet of living space. No Buyer Premium on this property. The buyer has the right to select their own title/closing company. The buyer is responsible for all closing costs in this transaction. It is a criminal offense to trespass on this property. NO TRESPASSING.
400 Oliver Ave is so ready for you! 3 bedrooms! Bentworth Schools. Talk about curb appeal...white picket fence, stone front, gorgeous full length covered front porch, plenty of paved parking, & the landscape is on point! You will notice the metal roof (under 10 years). Just steps away from the house (nice concrete walkways & steps connecting) is the detached garage (note: storage under some of
Fully Updated in the last few years. Recent improvements include new roof, hot water tank, fresh paint and updated bathroom as well as flooring. Open concept with single floor living. This home has the configuration to be utilized as a 3 bedroom with the master bed on the main floor. Whether you are first time buyer or looking to downsize and have 1 floor living, this home is the perfect blend of
Welcome to 24 Hillman Street—an excellent opportunity for homeowners or investors alike! Nestled at the end of a quiet dead-end road in Bentleyville, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers privacy, space, and potential. Situated on a generously sized lot, the property provides plenty of room for outdoor enjoyment, gardening, or future improvements. The peaceful location with minimal traffic makes it
TWO LOTS FOR THE PRICE OF ONE!! Perfectly situated at the corner of Mary St & Piersol/Coal Center Road on the outskirts of Bentleyville. BRING YOUR BUILDERS - this 1/2 acre lot is calling for your newly built home! This location allows for country feels, the benefits of a mature neighborhood, & close to all amenities in Bentleyville (Schools, Churches, Shopping, & more). What's better? It's under
EXTERIOR COMPLETE – INTERIOR BLANK SLATE : INVESTOR SPECIAL IN BENTWORTH SCHOOLS. Unlock the potential of this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom bungalow located in the heart of Bentleyville, PA. Perfect for investors, house flippers, or DIY homeowners, this property offers the ultimate "head start" on a renovation. The heavy lifting on the exterior is already finished, featuring a brand-new roof and new
Malinda KoncarBERKSHIRE HATHAWAY THE PREFERRED REALTY
Have you been looking for land? This 163 +/- acre property in Bentworth school district is a must see! There are endless possibilities with recreational outdoor activities, build your dream home, or farming...the possibilities are endless! The barn is the only structure on the property. Clean and Green. **Sellers are reserving all Oil, Gas and Mineral Rights**
Elizabeth DamichHOWARD HANNA MID MON VALLEY OFFICE
@@Fabulous Rental Opportunity@@ This home has never been lived. So New and Amazing. No Carpet. 3 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths. Off Street Parking Here. Newly Graveled Area for Additional Parking. Only 3 Homes in the park. Close to Interstate 70 for convenience. Must See!
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
