$296,173Average Value$161Average Price per Sq Ft3Homes For Sale
Farming roots and family pride shape life in Coldwater
Surrounded by fields of corn, soybeans and wheat, Coldwater is home to roughly 5,000 people in the heart of Mercer County. Faith and family are closely held values for many residents. The cross-tipped Holy Trinity Catholic Church has served the area since 1899 and continues to symbolize the village’s strong German heritage. “I talk about pride in Coldwater a lot because everybody has a sense of pride for how they represent themselves, their homes and their families,” says Mayor Doug Bertke, a Coldwater native. “Farming has always been a part of life here. It’s never ended and it never will, and that’s where we get our work ethic.” Many homebuyers choose Coldwater for its stellar school system and deep family connections. “Even if young people move away for jobs or new experiences, it's very common for them to move back to be closer to family or look after elderly family,” says Sarah Klosterman, a local Realtor with Howard Hanna Realtors.
New Coldwater homes blend brick and siding near cornfields in a growing suburban area.
Bicyclists enjoy a quiet street in Coldwater, Ohio lined with lawns and two-story homes.
1/2
Coldwater schools are the best in Mercer County
Coldwater Exempted Village Schools receive an overall A grade from Niche while being ranked the best school district in Mercer County. “We’re big with the athletics and have many, many state championships. We just had three during the 2024-2025 school year,” Mayor Bertke says. “But every year with the students, it isn’t just ‘Hey, I’m an athlete and that’s what I’m focusing on.’ They focus on their academics as well.” Coldwater Elementary, Middle and High schools all share one building. High schoolers can earn college credit and take career and technical education courses at Tri Star Career Compact in Celina.
Coldwater Elementary’s glass entrance features the Cavaliers logo and shield emblem.
Brick columns and mascot branding mark Coldwater Middle School’s entrance in Coldwater, Ohio.
Coldwater High School entrance with stone portico, fluted columns, and Cavaliers branding.
1/3
Competitive housing market due to low turnover, limited development
Coldwater’s German roots are evident in its abundance of red brick buildings, but the village also has a variety of architectural styles. Most of the early 20th-century homes sit on compact lots with sidewalk-lined streets. “The market is fairly competitive here,” Klosterman says. “The town is landlocked by farmland, so there's not a lot of room for new development, and if there is, it tends to be costly.” Still, there are some new developments in town and around the outskirts near Burkettsville-St. Henry Road. Homebuyers may have to put in extra effort to find homes for sale, as many sellers don’t advertise or work with a Realtor right away. “It’s a lot of word of mouth,” Mayor Bertke says. Coldwater has a median sale price of about $200,000, roughly on par with the Celina median. However, prices can vary from the mid-$100,000s to nearly $1 million for sprawling farm estates.
Coldwater, Ohio street with new homes, sidewalks, and open fields in the background.
Residential street in Coldwater, Ohio shows brick and siding homes with well-kept yards.
1/2
Parks, trails and clubs bring neighbors together
Memorial Park spans 40 acres and features paved trails, playgrounds, sports courts, ball fields and a swimming pool. The 4.5-mile Celina-Coldwater Bike Path runs through town and is a popular avenue for biking, jogging and rollerblading. Just outside town, Baker Woods Nature Preserve has a hiking trail through one of the region’s best old-growth forests. Swimmers can hit the water on Grand Lake St. Marys, a few miles away. Residents stay involved in the community through fraternal organizations and community clubs like the American Legion, Knights of Columbus and the Kiwanis Club.
Cyclists ride the Celina CW Bikeway on a sunny day in Coldwater.
A game of pickleball unfolds at CW Memorial Park’s modern sports facility in Coldwater.
1/2
Local eats and drinks in town
Mornings might start with a doughnut from Home Bakery, a Coldwater institution, or coffee from Rooster Joe’s. Mariachis began serving Mexican fare in 2019 and moved to a bigger building in 2023 to accommodate the demand for margaritas and sizzling fajitas. Downtown Coldwater has local businesses like Penny Jane, an art gallery and studio, and boutiques like Golden on Main and The Turquoise Door. Live music and cold beer flow at McSober’s Saloon on the weekends. For a more laid-back vibe, The Vineyard at Evergreen Farm offers more than 20 wine varieties made with fruit grown on-site or sourced from regional producers. Chief’s has groceries in town, but Celina has more options and retail shopping about 10 minutes away.
Inside McSober, locals enjoy food and drinks under sports-themed decor in Coldwater.
In Coldwater, Evergreen Farm has an Outdoor patio with tables, chairs, and cornfield views.
1/2
Coldwater natives come home for the community picnic
The Coldwater Community Picnic is the town’s signature event and a homecoming for many Coldwater natives. “It’s a great event we have, and any proceeds coming from that go directly to capital improvements at Memorial Park and the library,” Mayor Bertke says. “The picnic draws a lot of people, including people that moved away who are like ‘This is that one time a year to go back and see my friends and family.’ We have fireworks on Friday night, live music and a huge parade on Sunday. It’s a family-fun weekend.”
About 2 hours to Columbus and Cincinnati
Coldwater is home to Mercer County Community Hospital, the only hospital in the county. U.S. Route 127 is a major thoroughfare for the region and the mainline to Dayton, about an hour away. Columbus and Cincinnati are both about 2 hours away. Coldwater runs on agriculture, so drivers can expect to share the road with tractors during the spring and fall. Relatedly, most farmers in the area use manure to fertilize their fields. Locals are accustomed to the seasonal scent, which they half-jokingly call “the smell of money.”
Written By
Leslie Klosterman
Photography Contributed By
Francisco de la Vera
Video By
Stewart Taveras
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Kelly Westgerdes,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Coldwater, OH sell after 64 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Coldwater, OH over the last 12 months is $254,000, up 33% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Welcome to 4978 Buschor Road, Coldwater--a rare opportunity to own a one-owner, custom-built home situated on a beautiful 3-acre corner lot in the Coldwater School District. Built in 1997, this spacious property features 6 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and an open-concept design highlighted by quality oak finishes and custom cabinetry throughout. Designed for comfort and versatility, the home offers
Welcome to this 3 bedroom, 1 Bath home situated on a spacious .40 acre lot, conveniently located close to town. Inside you will find an inviting layout, with large windows throughout. The spacious living room shows original hardwood flooring and opens to a large kitchen area.As you explore the bedroom, one on the main floor, you will love the generous closets in each room, plus an extra large
Christina SiefringHomes at Ohio's Edge Realty, LLC
Welcome to 511 W. Main Street in the heart of Coldwater! This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2 bathroom home offers the perfect blend of character, comfort, and functionality in the highly sought after Coldwater School District.Step inside to discover numerous updates throughout, including a spacious main floor primary suite and beautifully refreshed kitchen, dining, and living areas designed for
Welcome home to this well-maintained1,645 sq. ft. brick ranch offering the perfect combination of peaceful country living with the convenience of being just minutes from town. Situated on .91 acres, this property backs to a creek and borders the Rosenbeck Nature Preserve, providing beautiful wetland views and the rare benefit of no future neighbors to the south.Inside, you'll find 3 bedrooms, 2
Christina SiefringHomes at Ohio's Edge Realty, LLC
Welcome to 207 W South St. When you enter you will find a nice large open living room. There are 3 bedrooms on the main floor with the option for more on the second floor. The windows were replaced in 2020 and 2022. The laundry room is on the main floor. There is a nice front porch to enjoy your morning beverage on. Call your favorite realtor today!
There's so much to love about this beautifully remodeled home! With 2,336 sqft of living space, 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this home has a huge amount of space. Everyone who loves to cook or loves to eat will enjoy the large kitchen with tons of cabinetry, soft close doors and drawers, subway tile backsplash laid in a herringbone pattern, and real granite countertops! There are plenty of extras in
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
