$265,293Average Value$138Average Price per Sq Ft24Homes For Sale
A small town in Ohio with strong community spirit
Over the eastern shores of Mosquito Creek Lake is Cortland, a small town in Trumbull County just over 10 miles from the Pennsylvania state line. "Cortland has that small-town, Americana feel to it," says Realtor Tyler Obradovich, team leader of the Wolf Pack Sales Team at Keller Williams Chervenic Realty. Obradovich was born and raised in the neighboring town of Warren and has sold homes across the area for over eight years. "It's a strong community where everyone knows everyone. There are a lot of community events where everyone gets together. One of the most popular is the Cortland Community Street Fair."
The downtown has a charming, small-town feel in Cortland.
Residents pay homage to their veterans in Cortland.
1/2
Established homes from the 1970s
Cortland's housing stock was fully fleshed out in the 1970s, with most build dates dating back to the late '60s and early '70s. Homeowners mostly live in roomy, traditional colonials and split levels with an average of 2,000 square feet and four bedrooms. Ample ranch-styles are in the mix, often with 1,200 square feet and at least three bedrooms. Several homes have two-car garages, small front porches and manicured front lawns. Houses mainly cost between $150,000 and $300,000. "For Trumbull County, Cortland has some of the higher price points, but they're still lower than many areas across America," Obradovich says. Cortland is a woodsy community, so mature deciduous trees line most streets and scatter most quarter-acre yards. There are few sidewalks, but locals still enjoy an evening stroll, and many roads have small light posts.
Residents enjoy properly caring for their homes in Cortland.
Residents take pride in well-maintained lawns in Cortland.
1/2
Students attend a string of highly-rated schools
Kids growing up in Cortland attend Lakeview Local School District schools, earning an overall B-plus from Niche. Children first attend the highly rated Lakeview Elementary School, where they score above the state average on their tests, according to GreatSchools. The elementary school earned an overall A-minus on Niche. Students progress to Lakeview Middle School, which Niche ranked the number one middle school in Trumbull County and gave an overall A-minus. High schoolers head to Lakeview High School to earn their degrees. Students have several options for extracurriculars and sports, including pep band, drama club, basketball and golf. The high school earned an overall B-plus on Niche.
Lakeview High School provides education in the neighborhood of
Outlying Trumbull County.
Lakeview Elementary School provides education in the neighborhood of
Outlying Trumbull County.
1/2
Splash pads, sledding and fun on Mosquito Creek Lake
The City of Cortland owns and maintains five parks, including Willow Park. Local athletes rally at Willow Park's pickleball and tennis courts, sand volleyball court and baseball fields. Other park amenities include woodsy nature trails, a picnic area and a playground for the kids. Pearl Park is another local favorite for outdoor recreation. During the summer, locals bring their kids to enjoy the splash pad. Plus, park-goers enjoy Pearl Park's athletic fields, playgrounds and basketball courts. While Pearl Park is a summer hit, locals head to the sled hill at Eastlake Metropark during the winter. And with Mosquito Lake bordering Cortland, locals are often on the water boating, fishing or hiking the waterfront trails. Kids especially enjoy the dynamic Imagination Station playground at Bazetta Township Park.
Pickleball is a great way to exercise in Cortland.
Imagination Station Park has a very unique playground kids flock to in Cortland.
1/2
Locally-owned restaurants
There are a few locally cherished restaurants in Cortland's town center, like Brother's Pizza and Restaurant. The restaurant hit the local news in 2023 for its decorative, hand-painted mural. Inside, residents rave over hand-tossed pizzas and heaping plates of pasta. Families also grab a table at El Torero Mexican Restaurant for dinner. Locals enjoy traditional Mexican favorites like fajitas, burritos and enchiladas, and adults enjoy sipping a margarita. Another popular spot for a meal is Vasilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria. The restaurant features savory Italian favorites, including homemade meatloaf and pasta primavera. Residents mostly do their grocery shopping at the Sparkle Market off Route 5, but Dollar General and Dollar Tree offer additional options.
Vasilio's Family Restaurant serves up classic Italian food in Cortland.
Residents get their groceries at Sparkle in Cortland.
1/2
The Cortland Street Fair
Locals flock to Cortland's town center annually for the Cortland Community Street Fair. The fair features a parade with various entertainment, rides, live music and many food and drink vendors.
Commuting in Cortland
Cortland is a car-dependent community, and Highways 5 and 46 pass directly through town. Drivers also often use Interstate 80 and Route 11 to reach areas like Youngstown, just over 20 miles south of Cortland. In case of an emergency, the Trumbull Regional Medical Center is 9 miles away. And the Youngstown-Warren Regional Airport is just over 8 miles away.
Written By
Brennen Martin
Video By
Francisco de la Vera
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Troy Polis,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Cortland, OH sell after 35 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Cortland, OH over the last 12 months is $220,000, up 1% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Wonderful 4 BR 2.5 bath home in beautiful Timber Creek Estates. Features include a new air conditioner, furnace, hot water tank, sump pump, spacious eat-in kitchen with newer appliances, granite countertops, luxury vinyl flooring, formal dining room, cozy family room with fireplace. A formal living room being used as an office. First floor laundry. Vaulted master suite with master bath and
Welcome to your new home! Discover the perfect blend of comfort, space and versatility in this beautifully maintained 3 plus bedroom home. Set on a generous fully fenced in lot, this property offers multiple outbuildings ideal for hobbyists, small business owners, or anyone seeking extra storage or workspace. Step inside to find a spacious floor plan featuring a massive addition that expands the
Imagine having scenic, personal getaway views every day from the comfort of your kitchen, family room or as you dine? This remarkable Corland residence places you high above sloping hillsides that overlook a winding waterway; a view that is best experienced in person for the amount of depth and natural beauty. Continue to expect the unexpected while you explore the tastefully updated ranch,
Beautiful 4-bedroom brick ranch situated on a serene wooded lot with a park-like setting. This home features stunning hickory hardwood flooring throughout the bedrooms, hallways, living room, and dining room. The kitchen, bedroom closets, and four-seasons room offer a stylish porcelain tile flooring. Enjoy natural light pouring into the spacious family room through a striking round skylight. The
Thinking of building? Then look no further and check out this beautiful half acre lot! Located in a great location and on a quiet cul-de- sac in a developed ideal neighborhood. City utilities including public water, electric, gas and sewer are there and available for hook up. Manufactured homes with foundations are permitted as well. If wanting to build don't miss out on this one!
The Ridge in Fowler Township, this farmhouse overlooks the countryside while remaining just minutes from Route 11 and everyday amenities. Set on 4.001 acres. This updated homestead offers the perfect blend of peaceful rural living with convenient access to town, shopping, and highways.The move-in-ready farmhouse is surrounded by colorful landscaping and features inviting outdoor living
Historic Charm & Endless Potential on Over an Acre!Welcome to 2432 Cadwallader Sonk Rd, a classic conventional-style home situated on a spacious 1.05-acre lot in the desirable Lakeview School District. 1 Built in 1900, this property offers a unique opportunity for investors or DIY enthusiasts looking to restore a piece of history or create their dream country retreat. selling the property
Welcome to this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath condo located in a highly sought-after Cortland development, offering 1,244 square feet of comfortable living space. This well-cared-for home provides a great balance of functionality and low-maintenance living, with spacious living areas that make everyday living easy and enjoyable. This condo features a bright and inviting interior, while
Welcome to this charming two-story townhouse! Inside, you'll find a spacious living room that offers tons of natural light and a high vaulted ceiling. The dining room features a corner fireplace that creates a warm atmosphere, perfect for nights at home or entertaining. The eat-in kitchen flows seamlessly from the dining room and highlights a cozy breakfast nook area with stainless steel
It’s finally here, the one you’ve been waiting for! Welcome home to this all-new Cortland construction set withina highly desirable, up-and-coming local development. This custom-built home is set to stun with its breathtaking visualsand high-quality materials that are found throughout the sprawling, three-bedroom design. Both brick and stone accentleads you inside a deep-set foyer
Build your custom home in the desirable Walnut Run Estates subdivision in Cortland. This 0.33-acre residential lot offers public water and sewer, making it a convenient option for new construction. Located in Mathews Local School District, this property provides an opportunity to bring your own builder and design a home that fits your needs. Deed restrictions apply. Established neighborhood
Bring your dream home to life on this 1.20-acre flat, buildable lot located in a highly desirable Cortland area along Route 46. Offering an ideal blend of space, privacy, and convenience, the property provides easy access to local amenities while maintaining a peaceful setting. This blank canvas is ready for your custom vision—start planning today. Buyer to verify all utilities, zoning, and
Looking for the perfect country retreat with endless possibilities? LOOK NO FURTHER than this Stunning 41.6 acre piece of PARADISE! Want to unwind in peace after a long day? Weekend spot for prime hunting? NEW Development? The choice is yours! There are 2 Gas wells on the property! Cauv credit in place! Make an appt today before it's gone! This is a ONE OF A KIND property!
The Seasons is redefining the Art of Living! The Seasons Residences, located in Howland, Ohio offers Luxurious two-bedroom patio homes. Our stylish Residences offer modern and spacious interiors with private patios and attached 2-car garage. Our ranch style patio homes also feature an open kitchen layout with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, wood cabinetry, hard surface flooring,
Property Id: 25018142 miles north of Cortland (East Mecca Township)Three bedroomOne bathLivingroomKitchen FridgeElectric stoveWasher and dryer hook upWhole house water filter systemElectric, gas and trash pick up are renters responsibilityYou can install a window unit air conditionThe landlord does all the lawn maintenanceBeautiful quiet
470 Fowler2 Bedroom 2nd Floor Unit with Patio, $775/Month Plus Electric. Appliances; Laundry Facilities in Building.1 Year Lease. Deposit & Credit Approval Required. Registered Service Pets/Assistance Animals Only.
Welcome to 174 Market Street in Cortland, OH! This charming 4 bedroom, 1 bathroom home boasts plenty of counter space in the kitchen, along with all necessary appliances. Enjoy the spacious backyard and relax on the back porch with an awning for shade. Conveniently located in Cortland, this property also features a 2 car detached garage and a double lot for extra outdoor space. Your furry friend
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
