The first settlers in the village of Fayetteville planted roots in the late 1700s and later named the area to honor one of the heroes of the American Revolution, Marquis de Lafayette. An area rooted in trade and waterpower due to its location along Limestone Creek, Fayetteville grew to become a hub for commuters. “It’s an extremely convenient area and is a prime spot for people who don’t want to be too far from the action,” says Nancy Quigg, associate broker with MyTownRealty, who has 15 years of experience selling in the area. “You can quickly get to shopping centers from the homes here, and all you have to do is hop on Interstate 690 to get to Syracuse in less than 20 minutes.”
Everything from historic homes to ranch-style and new builds
Most of Fayetteville’s residential pockets are tucked away from the busiest main roads and the streetscapes vary as much as the architecture in the area. In some parts of the village, historic and midcentury homes on well-maintained quarter-to-half-acre lawns are surrounded by dense thickets of mature trees, while new construction neatly lines streets flanked by sidewalks. Regardless of the type of home, the majority feature some off-street parking, whether a small driveway or a two-car garage. A renovated farmhouse, colonial or Victorian home built in the 1800s is typically priced around $290,000. Buyers with a budget of $390,000 to $425,000 will find ranch homes, split-levels and new construction on the market. While they tend to be outliers, there are custom builds and Millennium mansions on 5-acre lots in Fayetteville priced above $1 million.
Colonial Revival style homes are popular in Fayetteville, NY.
Fayetteville, NY has multiple Greek, Italianate, and Federal style homes from the 1800s.
1/2
Retail and restaurant scene clustered along Highway 5
The village’s shopping and dining scene is clustered along Highway 5. The Towne Center at Fayetteville can serve as a one-stop shop, housing several banks, salons, a YMCA, grocery stores like Target and TOPS and national retailers including Kohl’s, TJ Maxx and Ann Taylor. Chain eateries like Bonefish Grill and Carrabba’s are dotted around the shopping complex. Limestone Plaza showcases the area’s history through a string of local shops and restaurants, where residents frequently mingle over a coal-fired pizza at Avicolli’s or sipping on margaritas and mules at Bull and Bear Roadhouse.
Clothing is a popular item for sale at Encore Thrift Shop in Fayetteville.
Patrons enjoy their drinks with a lively mood at Gino's Cheesesteak & Onion in Fayetteville.
1/2
Ample clubs and activities at highly rated Fayetteville-Manlius schools
Highly rated schools are another perk for newcomers to Fayetteville, according to Quigg. Students are part of the Fayetteville-Manlius Central School District and will attend either Fayetteville Elementary School or Mott Road Elementary School, each earning an A rating from Niche. They’ll later filter into A-rated Wellwood Middle School, which underwent a massive renovation in 2017 with a new cafeteria, music and art rooms and additional classrooms. “The two elementary schools and the middle school also sit in a concentrated area, which makes it easy for parents to commute between them,” says Quigg. At Fayetteville-Manlius High School, which Niche rates an A, students will have more than 50 clubs and activities to choose from. The Model UN club hosts a yearly conference, often inviting more than 1,000 delegates from around New York. The school also has an award-winning arts program with a symphony orchestra, concert band and ukulele ensemble.
The Wellwood Middle School serves grades 5-8.
Just over 420 students attend the Mott Road Elementary School.
1/2
Waterfront parks and recreation scene
Green Lakes State Park is planted at Fayetteville’s eastern edge and spans nearly 2,000 acres. Much of the activity centers around the park’s two glacial lakes, Green Lake and Round Lake, where people can go fishing or kayaking. During the summer months, locals lay out on the sandy beach of Green Lake before jumping in for a swim. Visitors who stop by during the frigid, snowy winter can snowshoe or go cross-country skiing along the 15 miles of trails winding through the park. There are also two courses for golf and disc golf, grounds for hunting and several playgrounds. Several community pocket parks are dotted throughout the village, including Canal Landing Park. It’s one of the newest in the area, situated alongside Limestone Creek. It took more than 30 years to finish the final product in 2011, complete with a playground, outdoor fitness stations and trails. The shaded pathways lead to a pedestrian bridge that crosses Limestone Creek and links to the Erie Canalway Trail, the most expansive trail system in the state, stretching 360 miles from Buffalo to Albany.
There are many benches you can sit and relax on at Green Lakes State Park in Fayetteville.
The Beard Park in Fayetteville is 5.8 acres and features a large pond.
1/2
Less than 8 miles to Syracuse University and other major employers
The Centro transit system runs buses throughout Fayetteville, with stops along East Genesee and South Manlius streets, which can connect locals to neighboring areas, including Dewitt, Manlius and Syracuse. Fayetteville is primarily car-dependent, with residents relying on Route 5 and Interstates 481 and 690 to navigate the area. Just off Highway 5 on North Burdick Street, locals will find a hub for medical centers and doctors' offices. Still, they can also make the 7.5-mile trip west along I-690 to SUNY Upstate Medical University or Crouse Hospital in Syracuse. The city is packed with museums, restaurants and shops all centered around Syracuse University. Travelers going on a trip outside the city can catch a flight at Syracuse Hancock International Airport, which is less than 16 miles northeast of Fayetteville.
Syracuse University is only 8 miles from Fayetteville, NY.
It only takes 15 minutes to get to Downtown Syracuse from Fayetteville, NY.
1/2
Written By
Sara Ferguson
Photography Contributed By
Ryan Gwilliam
Video By
Barry Ridgeway
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Ryan Millard,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Fayetteville, NY sell after 41 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Fayetteville, NY over the last 12 months is $417,307, up 7% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
**A wonderful Mid-Century Ranch on a private lot in Dewitt**Award Winning Jamesville Dewitt School District**Conveniently located near Highways, Schools, Shopping, and Wegmans**This home has been immaculately cared for over the years and has a very comfortable feel from the moment you step in**There is a spacious hearthwarmed Living Room with plenty of natural light, Formal dining Room with
Welcome to 217 Redfield Avenue, a charming 4-bedroom, 1.1-bath Cape located in the heart of Fayetteville. Situated on a large, fully fenced corner lot, this home offers the perfect combination of charm, functionality, and outdoor space within the highly sought-after Fayetteville-Manlius School District. Conveniently located just minutes from shopping, restaurants, supermarkets, parks, and
Premier buildable 0.86 acres lot in Waterford Woods. Surround yourself with all the exquisite one of the kind homes. Easy accessible to Wegman's Dewitt, Fayetteville, Highway 690 & 481.
An unparalleled commercial development opportunity in the highly desirable Fayetteville/Manlius area. Spanning approximately 1.5 choice acres, this premium parcel represents a rare find in an affluent, well-established business corridor. Shovel-ready and positioned for immediate market impact, this land is the ideal setting for an ambitious company looking to establish a signature corporate
Cherished by the same owner for many years, this warm and inviting 2-bedroom, 1-bath manufactured home is now ready to welcome someone new. Tucked inside a sought-after park in the JD School District, this well-maintained home has been lovingly cared for and shows it.Step out onto the enclosed porch and take in peaceful views of the golf course and lush landscaping — the perfect spot for your
Also listed as Condo/Townhouse MLS#S1680924 Enjoy maintenance-free living in this well-maintained 2-bedroom condo located in a desirable HOA community within the Fayetteville-Manlius Central School District. The open-concept main living area offers a functional layout with great flow between the kitchen, dining, and living spaces. A convenient half bathroom is located on the first floor, while
Perfect for a professional office; A Prime location; The 12 Room house Zoned R/3 on 1/2+ acre lot in Fayetteville NY represents a unique investment opportunity; The Italianate is short distance to everything in town. 4 exit doors make division doable. 8 years of professional design and $500K worth of renovations includes 3 new roofs; 2 new furnaces, renovated walls/ floors; all new appliances,
Welcome to 7322 Dartmoor Crossing. This well-maintained home offers comfortable living spaces, thoughtful updates, expansive storage, and beautifully improved outdoor surroundings. Situated on a corner lot with a private backyard and generous side yard, the property provides exceptional outdoor space and flexibility for entertaining, recreation, or simply enjoying the setting. Entering the home,
Set on a half-acre lot in a desirable neighborhood near Lyndon Corners, this classic center hall Colonial combines timeless character with four levels of living space and a spacious, inviting layout. Hardwood floors, natural woodwork and custom details bring warmth and charm throughout the home, complemented by architectural accents that enhance its appeal. Recent updates including a new furnace
Set on 1.34 acres, this well-maintained, custom-built Bill Kelly contemporary is surrounded by mature trees and manicured grounds. Nestled on a cul-de-sac for added privacy, this home showcases clean architectural lines complemented by a natural wood exterior and stone accents. A new slate walkway leads to the covered front entry, opening to a welcoming foyer with tile flooring and a graceful,
Luxury meets convenience in this exceptional maintenance-free Fayetteville condominium in the Jamesville-DeWitt School District. Ideally located just minutes from downtown Syracuse, major hospitals, Towne Center, Wegmans, and Onondaga Golf & Country Club, this impressive home offers over 5,000 square feet of flexible living space with six bedrooms and seven baths—it is perfect for one floor
Nestled on a beautiful park-like setting, this prestigious Cape Cod offers far more space than meets the eye with 5 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms in an ideal Fayetteville location close to everything! Filled with charm and character, the home features formal living and dining rooms with abundant natural light, built-ins, and timeless appeal. The updated kitchen offers exceptional storage, newer gas
Fayetteville Pines is a wooded apartment community located in historic Fayetteville, NY, within walking distance of Towne Center and a short drive to downtown Syracuse, Syracuse University, and area hospitals.We offer 1-bedroom apartments and 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath townhomes in the Fayetteville-Manlius School District. Features include sunken living rooms, walk-in closets, private entrances,
Crystal Tree Apartments is a 46 unit apartment complex nestled in a beautiful wooded area. Our complex is owned and managed by a local family with 45 plus years of property management experience. Our experienced staff works to meet the needs of each tenant, and this enables us to offer an apartment that is the next best thing to living in your own home. If you have ever been dissatisfied with
Second floor apartment in charming home in the heart of Fayetteville. Close to shopping, restaurants and park. Perfect residence for a single mature adult. Apartment includes one off street parking space, secure entry, water, trash and snow removal of stairs and walkway. No pets. No smoking. Tenant pays for heating, cooling and internet. Communal laundry in basement. There is no
A truly unique find rental in the FM school districtLovely family home with four toFiveGenerous sized bedrooms including the primary bedroom suiteSituated on an acre sized park like setting with new large deck The home has a light airy feel with much natural sun light Coffered ceiling. Wood burning fireplace and lovely hardwoods are just a few of this home’s featuresEasy to
Welcome to unit #5 at 219 Highbridge Street in Fayetteville!Located in the lower village of Fayetteville in the Highbridge Landing Condominium Complex. Completely renovated, 2 bedroom, 1.5 bath, 1560 sp.ft. Two car garage, laundry, patio.One year lease, Tenant pays utilities. Sorry No Pets and must be a non smoker
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
