$408,744Average Value$212Average Price per Sq Ft10Homes For Sale
The lakeside community of Lake Lorelei continues to grow 60 years after its founding
Centered around a manmade lake, Lake Lorelei offers a resort-style atmosphere and sporty lifestyles just an hour outside Cincinnati. “We have band ‘raft-ups’ on most weekends,” says Jennifer Fehr, a Realtor with Bastion Realtors who has lived in Lake Lorelei since 2018. “Bands visit people’s docks, and we all have fun together on a cove in the water. In our pavilion, we usually have a DJ and parties.” This community, developed in 1968, is all about outdoor activity. A lake of nearly 200 acres hosts fishing, pleasure boating and fireworks shows, while local clubs put together yearly social events and athletic competitions. "We have a lot of fishing, including fishing tournaments," Fehr says. "Even if you’re off the water - and there are plenty of people who live there - they can launch their boats in the lake." As new homes continue to be built, and a clubhouse is slated to open by 2026, Lake Lorelei’s tide continues to rise.
Lake Lorelei is a private, secured, gated community founded in 1968.
Lake Lorelei is all about outdoor activity with its 200 acre lake.
1/2
Boating and beach recreation along the lake
This community derives its name from its central lake, which was created in 1968 as the merger of three separate bodies of water. Its name derives from a prominent rock along Germany's River Rhine, and its streets, like Cologne, Dusseldorf and Dortmund Drives, recall the central role that German culture plays in southwestern Ohio. “Our streets are named after German places; we just had our first Oktoberfest this year,” Fehr says. Decades after its creation, this 197-acre lake is surrounded by 10 access points, dozens of cabanas and a pavilion open for lakefront parties. West Beach offers a stretch of lakeside recreational opportunities and will soon host the Lake Lorelei Club House, projected to open in the mid-2020s. Residents often launch their boats from their backyards or from the community’s marina and embark on waterborne adventures. A Fishing Committee and Activities Committee are just two of the many clubs that set up seasonal community events, including a summer kickoff party marked by pickleball, cornhole and tug-of-war competitions. In addition to these pre-arranged events, neighbors can set up impromptu volleyball, disc golf, mini-golf and basketball games at the community’s sports facilities.
Properties from the 1960s mix with 2010s builds
Founded in 1968, Lake Lorelei offers a mixture of homes built in the mid-20th century and properties finished as recently as the mid-2010s. Ranch-style homes built since 2000 tend to sell for between $350,000 and $450,000, while smaller houses built from the 1960s to 2000 have sold for between $185,000 and $350,000. Older properties with home sizes exceeding 2,200 square feet have attained sale prices between $600,000 and $725,000. Homes may sit along the waterfront and include backyard boat launches, or they may be located along heavily foliated residential lanes further inland. Quiet Lake Lorelei's CAP Index score of 1 indicates a negligible risk of crime.
Retail and restaurants are accessible within 20 minutes
Lake Lorelei’s isolated location both adds to its charm and puts the nearest grocery conveniences around a 10-minute journey away. This community’s Marina Store stocks residents with snacks, spirits, fishing equipment and propane tanks, but Fayetteville is where residents commute for shopping and dining. In addition to a Dollar General, Kiley’s Market serves as Fayetteville’s other grocery venue, offering essentials like cereal and bread within its small retail floor. Dining options include the vintage-themed Pike Street Bar & Grill, an outpost of the Skyline Chili diner chain and SheBrews Coffee, a small business offering breakfast blends and Amish-baked pastries. 20 minutes south of Lake Lorelei, Mount Orab is home to the nearest Kroger and a few more restaurants.
SheBrews Coffee near Lake Lorelei offers a variety of coffee drinks, smoothies and breakfast items.
For groceries, Lake Lorelei shoppers can head to the Kroger in nearby Mt. Orab.
1/2
Students attend Fayetteville's school system
Students attend the Fayetteville-Perry Local School District, starting out at Fayetteville-Perry Elementary School, which Niche gives a C-plus rating. Fayetteville-Perry Middle School receives a B and Fayetteville-Perry High School a B-minus. The high school forges a strong student community through smaller than average class sizes, extracurriculars like student council and FFA and an extensive offering of “Rockets” sports programs.
Fayetteville-Perry Middle School received an overall grade of B from Niche
Students of Lake Lorelei attend the Fayetteville-Perry Local School District, starting out at Fayetteville-Perry Elementary
1/2
Healthcare and daily conveniences are just around the corner
Lake Lorelei’s location in rural Brown County puts residents nearly an hour’s drive away from Cincinnati, but most conveniences are local. Shopping is just 10-20 minutes way in either Fayetteville or Mount Orab, while Mount Orab puts the Mercy Health medical center less than 25 minutes around the corner from home.
Mercy Health medical center is less than 25 minutes from Lake Lorelei.
Lake Lorelei residents are just a few minutes from nearby Fayettesville.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Lake Lorelei neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Lake Lorelei Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Lake Lorelei, Fayetteville sell after 34 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Lake Lorelei, Fayetteville over the last 12 months is $340,000, up 18% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath brick ranch in Lake Lorelei offering peaceful lake views and easy single level living. This home features a spacious great room with vaulted ceilings, a skylight, and a striking stone fireplace. The open floorplan provides excellent flow between the living, dining, and kitchen areas. Enjoy generous bedroom sizes, several options for laundry areas, and a layout designed
Your lake house less than an hour from Cincinnati! *Waterfront* Escape to the lake in this charming A-frame cottage nestled on a private drive within the sought-after Lake Lorelei private community! Wooded & lake views- offering 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, & a versatile study, this home provides the perfect blend of cozy retreat & everyday living. Enjoy beautiful views overlooking the lake & take
Build your dream home on these 3 lots being sold together at Lake Lorelei totally over an acre of land. Lot numbers are 160, 161, 162. This is a gated HOA lake community.
Gated community offers 3 Lakes, 2 Beaches, newer Clubhouse, Pavilion, picnic areas, putt putt golf, and many more outdoor activities. Hunting, fishing, boating, and swimming. Build your dream home on this wooded lot with a peaceful and serene setting. Close to Boat Ramp, Clubhouse, Pavilion, and beach. Lot is marked due to recent survey. Water and sewer available
Terrific lot with a few trees on a quiet street in the Gated golf cart Community of Lake Lorelei . Perfect time to get out on the water boating, skiing, swimming and more. The lake is open and the fishing is great. grinder pump sewer hook up is at the road.
Looking for a wooded lot in a beautiful, gated Lake Community?? Lake Lorelei has 3 Lakes, 2 beaches, clubhouse, pavilion, and offers swimming, boating, fishing, kayaking, tubing, and skiing. Lot is marked as a recent survey was completed. Close to front gate entrance
You know you've found somewhere special when it feels like you've left Ohio, only to realize you're still here. Set on 2 tree-lined waterfront lots in gated Lake Lorelei, this home offers a peaceful lifestyle people spend vacations searching for. Water instantly quiets the mind. Here you're surrounded by it, with 2 lakes in your backyard! Well arranged, the layout offers more space than it
Rare .80 acre double lot directly across the street from the lake. Build your dream lake home or add another property to keep your loved ones close. Gated lake community includes yearly events, clubhouse and much much more. Home will not sell FHA as it needs some work.
2 wooded lots that abuts additional Private Community Recreation area in the Gated Community of Lake Lorelei. Come rest in your hammock, take a walk, bike ride, kayaking, swimming, boating, skiing and more it's all right here in the Golf cart Community of Lake Lorelei. Sellers will pay buyers initiation fee of $2,108.22 at closing.
Beautiful open floor plan brick ranch close to the entrance and within walking distance to the store and lake! Covered front porch and rear patio that backs up to farm land. Large detached shed with electric. 3 lots included that totals 1 acre with curved driveway for easy access. Priced to SELL! Make your offer!
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
