$207,758Average Value$121Average Price per Sq Ft9Homes For Sale
Garrett is a city in DeKalb County with a small-town atmosphere
Garrett, a historic railroad community, was named after former B&O president John W. Garrett. The city was a hub for steam locomotives, which is celebrated with a large train mural in the community’s downtown. Since then, the main industry has transitioned to manufacturing, which helps support the population of approximately 6,700. “It’s a small town that is community-oriented. I grew up and graduated there,” says RE/MAX Results associate broker Tina Stuckey, who has about five years of expertise in the area. Downtown Garrett is the heart of the city, featuring buildings that date to the 1880s. Residents gather at the retail district for local businesses and festive events.
Downtown Garrett has a small town charm and extra wide streets.
Garrett is a small town suburb with rows and rows of two-story homes.
1/2
Historic downtown Garrett's local retail includes hardware and books
Randolph Street, the city’s walkable downtown, has historic Italianate storefronts that house an assortment of locally owned businesses, including Garrett Do It Best Hardware. Slow Burn Books, an independent bookstore specializing in romance novels, is about a mile away. Some of the area’s most popular restaurants include the elegant dinner spot Shorty’s Steakhouse and Chef Peng Chinese Restaurant, which serves authentic dishes in a casual setting. “There’s some nightlife happening there. C J's Canteena is like an old ‘Cheers’ bar; everyone knows your name,” Stuckey says. The area also has entertainment like the bowling alley, Garrett Bowl. For groceries, Miller’s Market offers a deli and more.
Shorty's Steakhouse in Garrett serves specialty steaks and has a back patio.
Chef Peng Chinese Restaurant in Garrett is known for its orange chicken.
1/2
Bungalows, ranch-style homes and new construction in Garrett
Surrounded by farmland, the community is composed of grid-style blocks lined with maple trees and single-family homes. The lawns usually have sparse landscaping, like a few boxwood bushes or a magnolia tree in the front yard. Much of Garrett has historic architecture from the early 1900s, including Craftsman bungalows and Victorians. The edges of the city have small subdivisions of midcentury ranch-style homes and contemporary houses, including new construction. “I have brand new homes getting ready to go, about 40 homes,” Stuckey says. The historic and midcentury houses range from $120,000 to $250,000. Contemporary homes built in the mid-2020s range in price from $270,000 to $380,000.
Ranch-style homes in Garrett sit on long lots with plenty of flora.
Colonial homes are common in Garrett, and many of them date back to the early 1900's.
1/2
Schools from J.E. Ober Elementary to Garrett High
Niche rates E. Ober Elementary School a C-plus. Garrett Middle School scores a B-minus while Garrett High School has a B rating. The high school’s course catalog has classes like Automotive Technology, Commercial Photography and Sustainable Energy Alternatives.
J.E. Ober Elementary has a 14:1 student-to-teacher ratio in Garrett.
Garrett Middle School teaches Garrett students from grades 6-8.
Garrett High School has a 94% graduation rate.
1/3
Events, including trick or treating and the Fourth of July
Garrett hosts well-attended events like trick-or-treating on Halloween. “It's kind of like the environment how it used to be — like in my childhood. There are more houses available for trick or treating instead of being limited to subdivisions. Businesses in the downtown area contribute to the community during that time,” Stuckey says. Garrett Heritage Day, celebrated on the Fourth of July, has live music, a parade and fireworks.
Recreation options from Feick Park to Garrett Country Club
Feick Park, the city’s largest recreation space, features a swimming pool with a waterslide on the south side of Garrett. It also has baseball diamonds and basketball courts. “There is also a private JAM center, a YMCA that’s locally owned and operated,” Stuckey says. It has an indoor pool and a gym on the east side of the community. In the northeast part of the city, Garrett Country Club offers a public 18-hole course.
The JAM Center in Garrett is a community center with a pool and basketball court.
The Garrett Country Club has been open for over 100 years and has a full-sized course.
1/2
Attractions like Auburn Garrett Drive-In and the Garrett Museum of Art
On the north side of the community, Auburn Garrett Drive-In is one of the most popular places to visit in the summertime, with double features and a concession stand. “It got redone, so they just reopened it. There was a big storm that took it out. It took three years to revamp it,” Stuckey says. The Garrett Museum of Art, located in a former bank downtown, has a permanent collection and traveling exhibits.
A 25-mile commute to Fort Wayne and more transportation
Garrett’s major employers include manufacturers like Mossberg Industries Inc. and ZF Active Safety US Inc. The community is only 5 miles from Auburn. Via Interstate 69, Butler is about 25 miles from downtown Fort Wayne. The closest major airport, Fort Wayne International Airport, is about 35 miles away from Garrett.
Written By
Anna Anderson
Photography Contributed By
Chris Freeman
Video By
Mike Dunleavy
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Becky McArdle,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Garrett, IN sell after 32 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Garrett, IN over the last 12 months is $202,500, up 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
**Now Offering $5,000 in buyer financing incentives**Welcome to Saddle Ridge, Kiracofe Homes' newest neighborhood, conveniently located just north of downtown Garrett! The "Blackthorne" is thoughtfully designed 1,622 Sq Ft, 3 bed-2 bath-2 car garage home offers a perfect blend of modern style, comfort and efficiency. The main living area has a lovely vaulted ceiling and provides an open-concept
*Now Offering $5,000 financing Incentives!* Welcome to Saddle Ridge, Garrett Indiana's newest neighborhood, bought to you by Kiracofe Homes! The Atlanta floor plan, at 2244 Sq Ft, is a lofted two story, 2.5 bath home that offers open concept living and well-appointed finishes. The main floor includes a kitchen with eat-in peninsula, dining area and a spacious living room. A den, powder room and
OPEN HOUSE IS CANCELLED AS OFFER HAS BEEN ACCEPTED Welcome home to this charming ranch nestled in a quiet neighborhood within an award-winning school district! Offering a desirable split-bedroom floor plan, this home provides the perfect balance of comfort and privacy. The spacious primary suite serves as a relaxing retreat with a large walk-in closet and private en-suite featuring dual vanities,
R1 Residential Vacant Lot in Garrett! .06 Acre Lot. Approx Lot Dimensions: 31x90. Approx Lot Sq Ft: 2614. Level Lot. Located in Heart of Garrett. Great Investment Potential. Schedule your showing today!
Beautiful craftsmanship, original woodwork, and excellent corner-lot frontage give this four-bedroom, two-bath home a presence that is hard to miss. A covered entry welcomes you into a warm and inviting interior filled with timeless character and thoughtful updates. The main level offers the potential for a primary bedroom, along with a fully updated bathroom for added convenience. Relax in the
**Now Offering $5,000 in buyer financing incentives**Welcome to Saddle Ridge, Kiracofe Homes' newest neighborhood, conveniently located just north of downtown Garrett! The "Blackthorne" is thoughtfully designed 1,622 Sq Ft, 3 bed-2 bath-2 car garage home offers a perfect blend of modern style, comfort and efficiency. The main living area has a lovely vaulted ceiling and provides an open-concept
*Now Offering $5,000 financing Incentives!* Welcome to Saddle Ridge, Garrett Indiana's newest neighborhood, bought to you by Kiracofe Homes! The Atlanta floor plan, at 2244 Sq Ft, is a lofted two story, 2.5 bath home that offers open concept living and well-appointed finishes. The main floor includes a kitchen with eat-in peninsula, dining area and a spacious living room. A den, powder room and
Escape the hustle and bustle of city life and embrace the tranquility of rural living with our rural lots. Nestled among mature trees and accessible via a charming gravel road, these secluded properties offer the perfect blend of privacy and serenity. Imagine waking up each morning to the sounds of nature, surrounded by the beauty of towering trees and the fresh, crisp air. Our lots provide the
Welcome home to this beautifully maintained newer-construction ranch in Garrett, Indiana! Offering 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this move-in-ready home combines modern comfort with thoughtful updates throughout. Step inside to discover brand-new luxury vinyl plank flooring flowing seamlessly throughout the home, creating a fresh and cohesive feel. The open-concept layout provides
This inviting 4-bedroom home offers the perfect blend of small-town convenience and a peaceful, country-like setting. The main level features an open-concept living, dining, and kitchen area—ideal for everyday living and entertaining. A versatile front room provides flexible space that can be used as a den, home office, or additional dining area to suit your needs. Step outside to enjoy the
OPEN HOUSE this Sunday, Aug 2 @ 12pm - 2pm. Remarkably well-maintained 2 Bedroom, 2 1/2 Bath Ranch conveniently located in Maple Glen subdivision. Features include new hardwood floors in 2026, fresh paint throughout house including bathroom cabinets, and updated roof and mechanicals. Roof and water heater replaced within last 6 years, furnace and A/C replaced within the last year. Primary Bedroom
Welcome to our 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment located in Garrett, IN. This cozy unit features gas forced heat, a shared front porch, and a shared yard for outdoor enjoyment. With no animals allowed, residents can enjoy a clean and peaceful environment. The apartment also includes convenient amenities such as, keyless entry, LVP and carpet throughout. Residents are responsible for providing their
Welcome to our 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment located in Garrett, IN. This cozy unit features gas forced heat, a shared front porch, and a shared yard for outdoor enjoyment. With no animals allowed, residents can enjoy a clean and peaceful environment. The apartment also includes convenient amenities such as, keyless entry, LVP and carpet throughout. Residents are responsible for providing their
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
