$2,610,666Average Value$1,310Average Price per Sq Ft19Homes For Sale
The magnificent Casa Marina resort that is the heart of this neighborhood.
From Flagler’s vision to a residential oasis
Once a destination for the island’s finest visitors, Casa Marina has become one of Key West’s most coveted neighborhoods. The community takes its name from the Casa Marina hotel, originally designed by Henry Flagler in the 1920s as a centerpiece at the end of the Overseas Railroad. Now, the historic Spanish Renaissance-style resort is surrounded by spacious, palm tree-filled lots showcasing some of the island's largest and most extravagant homes. But despite its high price tag, the neighborhood retains much of the casual coastal vibe for which Key West is known. “There’s a lot of money down here, and you would never know it,” says Key West resident Mike Caron, a Realtor with Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty. “I can give you five of my friends and line them all up against the wall, and you won’t know which one sold his company for $100 million and which one is a handyman that sells popcorn at sunset.”
Although a few vacation properties are within this quiet, oceanside community, the neighborhood often attracts established island residents looking for more space. “They want a larger house. They want more outside areas for their pets. So they go from Old Town and come to Casa Marina,” says Brenda Donnelly, broker and owner of Brenda Donnelly Real Estate and a 40-year resident of Key West. But the neighborhood is still within minutes of local churches, the island’s only synagogue and Duval Street's buzzing nightlife, making it ideal for those hoping to pair convenience and calm. “We get a lot of people that have really worked hard all their lives, and this is their dream,” says Key West resident Lisa Lennon, a Realtor with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Knight & Gardner Realty. “This is the reward.”
One of the best park that you can go to is the Higgs Beach Park in Casa Marina.
Snorkeling at Higgs Beach
Clarence S. Higgs Memorial Beach Park sits at the edge of the neighborhood. It covers more than 16 acres of shoreline and has a sandy beach, volleyball courts and multiple playgrounds. The clear turquoise sea supports swimming, snorkeling and water sports. Scuba divers explore the deeper areas that stretch just beyond the tip of the White Street Pier. Donnelly says the pickleball and tennis courts across Atlantic Boulevard are usually packed on the weekend, and active locals take full advantage of the newly paved fitness trail. Dense tropical foliage peeks above the Key West Garden Club fence, and visitors can get free tours of the landscaped garden and Civil War-era tower. Multiple championship Bocce ball courts border the wildlife-rich grounds of nearby Indigenous Park, a nature preserve home to shady trails, picnic areas and a Wildlife Rescue Center.
Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park sits at the island’s tip and is home to one of the country’s largest collections of pre-Civil War weapons. The 54-acre park has another beloved beach, pine-shaded picnic tables and nature trails. There is a small entrance fee, but many residents have annual passes. The Key West Amphitheater, a new addition to the area, hosts concerts throughout the year. Truman Waterfront Park, with a massive playground and splash pad, is beloved for its quiet sunset views and Thursday afternoon farmers market. At the island's center, Bayview Park is a destination for youth sports.
You can also find multi million dollar estate style homes in Casa Marina.
Contemporary architecture in a historic setting
Homes in Casa Marina are typically larger than those in Old Town, with wide leafy lots offering shade and privacy. Architectural styles are diverse, ranging from midcentury moderns to Southern Craftsman cottages to contemporary estates. While some historic, wood-framed homes remain, many of the neighborhood’s original properties have been replaced or extensively renovated in the past few decades. Most homes cost between $1.5 million and $4 million, while the largest and most extravagant mansions can sell for $5 million to $6 million. A handful of one-bedroom condo units and studio townhouses are also available, usually costing between $500,000 and $700,000. As an oceanfront community, Casa Marina is at a high risk of flooding during tropical storms and hurricanes. Flood insurance and hurricane preparedness features such as roof straps and impact-resistant windows are highly recommended.
Salutes is a perfect beach side restaurant with terrace seatings in Casa Marina.
Oceanside sips at Louie’s Backyard
Waterfront restaurants on the island’s oceanside are rare but also some of the most popular. Louie’s Backyard, established in 1971, offers a one-of-a-kind experience with an afterdeck that hovers over the sea. In a nationally registered historic building, the restaurant highlights locally caught seafood while also serving as a cozy, tropical hangout for year-round residents. “Louie’s Backyard has always been that great place where all the locals go to have a cocktail,” Lennon says, explaining that the deck also has a great view of the neighboring dog beach. “Louie’s is actually a really nice place to go for sunset, too,” Donnelly says. Half a mile up the coast, Salute! On The Beach also serves a locally sourced menu near Higgs Beach. Its sister restaurant, Blue Heaven, sits about a mile away and is famous for its homemade Key lime pie with a mountainous meringue topping. Other Old Town favorites include El Siboney, a traditional Cuban restaurant, and The Lobster Shack, one of the few spots on the island to offer Maine lobster in addition to Key West’s uniquely spiny breeds. The gourmet market Fausto’s Food Palace, a family-owned staple since the 1920s, sells a selection of freshly caught seafood. Additional grocery options, including Publix and Winn-Dixie, are about 3 miles north in New Town, where shoppers will also find T.J. Maxx, The Home Depot and a Regal movie theater.
The art district of Key West is part of the Casa Marina lifestyle.
Local art on display during Walk on White
Key West has a full calendar of events, from music festivals in January to holiday boat parades in December. White Street’s galleries come to life during Walk on White, a Mid Town art stroll held on the third Thursday of each month since 1999. Casa Marina residents have a front-row seat to the fireworks display during the annual Patriotic Party, a Fourth of July celebration held at Indigenous Park. July also brings the annual Key Lime Festival, Lobsterfest and the nationally recognized Hemingway Days, a week-long celebration of the late author and former island resident Ernest Hemingway.
Key West High School is the largest school complex in the Keys.
Dual enrollment at Key West High School
Horace O’Bryant School, rated B on Niche, serves kindergarten through eighth grade students. B-plus-rated Key West High School offers dual enrollment classes with The College of the Florida Keys. Biotechnology and marine science courses are available to students who enroll in the college’s STEM-focused Academy Public Charter High School, a new program rated A by the Florida Department of Education. Private options include the Montessori School of Key West and The Basilica School of Saint Mary Star of the Sea, Monroe County’s only Catholic high school program.
Families love to take a bike ride around town in Casa Marina.
Workforce transportation via Key West Transit
Casa Marina’s wide roads are bike-friendly, and many locals cycle or walk to Duval Street. Key West Transit provides bus service across the island, including a dedicated workforce route for Old Town employees. The Lower Keys Shuttle leads 50 miles north to Marathon via U.S. Highway 1, also known as the Overseas Highway, which connects the Keys to mainland Florida. Key West International Airport is about 3 miles away.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Casa Marina neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Casa Marina
US
Homicide
1
4
Sexual Assault
4
4
Assault with Weapon
3
4
Robbery
4
4
Burglary
4
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
5
4
Larceny
4
4
Crime Score
4
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Casa Marina Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Casa Marina, Key West sell after 126 days on the market compared to the national average of 54 days. The median sale price for homes in Casa Marina, Key West over the last 12 months is $2,150,000, down 23% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Charming conch cottage on a generous size lot with refreshing pool and plenty of off street parking! This home is uniquely situated on a corner lot with many possibilities to expand on the footprint or add an additional pool side cottage. An open floor plan welcomes you through French doors to this delightful cottage. Enjoy high ceilings, wood floors with 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. The
Nestled in the prestigious Casa Marina neighborhood, 1120 Seminary Street offers the quintessential Key West lifestyle with a perfect blend of charm, luxury, and tropical serenity. Located in an X Flood Zone. This enchanting bungalow boasts 2 bedrooms and 2.5 baths within the main home, where an open floor plan invites effortless entertaining and everyday living. Rich Dade County Pine accents on
NEW PRICE: This exceptional turnkey three-bedroom, three bath and one half-bath residence is located in the prestigious Casa Marina neighborhood, one of Key West's most sought-after enclaves. Showcasing timeless Spanish Colonial architecture, the home offers a bright, open floor plan enriched with elegant architectural details and enchanting stained glass accents throughout.The main level is warm
Historic Casa Marina Gem - Fully Restored & Furnished! Experience timeless Key West charm blended with modern luxury in this stunning, fully restored historic home in the highly sought-after Casa Marina neighborhood. Perfectly located five blocks from Higgs Beach and six blocks from Duval Street, this residence offers the ideal balance of privacy and proximity to all that Key West has to
Experience the best of Key West living at 809 Washington Street #102, located in the exclusive Casa Marina neighborhood. This exquisite 3-story townhome offers a 3-bedroom, 3.5-bath residence (sleeps 8-10) showcasing nearly 1,800 sq ft of sophisticated island style, featuring high-end finishes, bright open living spaces, a gourmet kitchen with stainless steel Viking appliances, seamless
1420 Whalton Street is a masterfully engineered luxury residence where elevated construction, refined design, and resort-style amenities converge in one of Key West's most desirable residential neighborhoods.Built by Shaw Construction in 2023 with Insulated Concrete Form (ICF) construction and reinforced rebar, the home offers exceptional structural integrity, energy efficiency, and prepped for
Refined Key West living in the coveted Casa Marina neighborhood, located in the Old Town Historic District. Built in 2004 and thoughtfully updated in 2021, this elegant residence blends timeless design with modern comfort--anchored by a showstopping Wedgewood Blue kitchen featuring Viking appliances and a wine cooler. Designed for both entertaining and everyday ease, the home offers a spacious
INVESTORS, DEVELOPERS, CONDO CONVERSION--1005 FLAGLER AVE AND 1009 FLAGLER AVE--Two fourplexes in the highly desirable Casa Marina neighborhood on 18,371 sq ft of land, with 7,193 sq ft of Floor Living Area, for a total of 10 bedrooms and 9 baths. 1005 Flagler is 4 units, 3 of which are 1/1, ground floor unit #1 is a 3/2 with a courtyard. There's an on site coin laundry, as well as a garage and
Luxury Estate -- A Masterpiece of Light, Space & DesignA new benchmark for modern island living is rising in the coveted Casa Marina district, with completion set for March 2026. Crafted by renowned builder Denis Savoie, this brand-new mid-century modern estate blends architectural sophistication with next-generation sustainability. Designed for minimal maintenance and maximum efficiency, the
This Casa Marina Pied-a-Terre offers the perfect opportunity to experience indoor/outdoor Key West living. Enjoy a private, gated courtyard and expansive lot of over 1,700 square feet with potential for renovating, rebuilding, and/or expanding. This highly sought after location is within walking distance to many Old Town landmarks - Louie's Backyard, Duval shopping/dining/bars, and stunning sandy
Welcome to 1720 United Street -- a rare opportunity to own a spacious, build-ready lot in one of Key West's most desirable residential neighborhoods. Surrounded by mature palms and tropical greenery, this cleared parcel offers the perfect blank canvas to design your island dream home. Enjoy the quiet charm of a well-established neighborhood while being just minutes from beaches, restaurants,
Jaime CaballeroKey West Vacation Properties & Realty, LLC (KW)
This unit in the Casa Marina Estates townhomes is unique. As an end unit, it is the only home with a westward exterior wall receiving natural light from all 3 sides. Its location in the quiet, desirable Casa Marina neighborhood is blocks from Higgs Beach and within a short walk to restaurants and nightlife. This comfortable home features an open floor plan with 3 bedrooms, 3 1/2 baths, private
Experience the charm of this bright and airy 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom Southpark Condominium located in the prestigious Casa Marina neighborhood. Known for its tranquil atmosphere and prime location, this condominium is just a short stroll from Higgs Beach, the beloved Salute! on the Beach, and the iconic Louie's Backyard, where you can enjoy breathtaking ocean views and savor fine dining. Enjoy two
Experience the grandeur of this exceptional six bedroom, five and a half bath estate located on one of the most exclusive streets in Key West. A stunning wall of bougainvillea and the stately front porch welcome you to this 3,751 square foot property on an expansive 10,750 square foot lot that embodies historic Key West architecture. The main residence features four bedrooms, three and half baths
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
