$248,558Average Value$133Average Price per Sq Ft14Homes For Sale
Low cost of living in Indiana
If buying a home in a rural town of 1,200 people, noted for its historic Victorian homes and its starring role in a popular 1986 movie sounds intriguing, then Knightstown, Indiana might be worth a good look. Located 32 miles east of Indianapolis, the town sells itself as “A Good Place to Visit; A Better Place to Live.” Notable for its role as the setting for the award-winning film “Hoosiers”, Knightstown has plenty of historic homes, schools and museums. With its historic buildings designed with Italianate façades in the downtown shopping district to its local parks, Knightstown offers history, beauty and intriguing places to explore. Knightstown has also been ranked by Niche as one of the places with the lowest cost of living in Indiana. As Realtor Lisa Jines-Plessinger, with Christie’s of Indiana, and a real estate agent for more than 25 years explains, “Buyers who want historic homes will find them here, from Victorians to cottages and bungalows. There are opportunities here to put one’s own touches on older homes. At the same time, there are pockets of new homes that are getting attention as well.”
Knightstown, IN is East of Indianapolis from US 40 or I-70.
Italianate Facade buildings can be seen in downtown Knightstown, IN.
1/2
Victorian stunners and turn-of-the-century-cottages
Historic homes are common in Knightstown, and buyers will find both Victorian homes with decorative trim and carved porch posts, as well as renovated Colonial homes from the early 1900s. Victorian cottages with original trim work sell for $225,000 to $450,000 depending on the square footage and condition. Turn-of-the-20th century two-story homes with 2nd-floor porches have sold for around $210,000. Ranch-style homes with about 1,300 square feet have recently sold for around $155,000. Most homes in Knightstown are historic or midcentury, but there are some new homes, as well as buildable lots. A notable historic site, The Knightstown Academy was a Quaker school in the late 1800s and now offers apartment living for seniors.
Knightstown, IN is a rural community of 1200 people 32 miles East of Indianapolis.
Most homes in Knightstown, IN are older but there is some new construction available.
1/2
Pizza and primitive art
Locals dine in and also grab takeout from Redbones Pizza and Chicken. It offers buckets of roasted chicken, wings and pizza. They’re also known for their homemade desserts and welcoming setting. The Glass Cupboard Antique Mall offers plenty of vintage, antique, primitive and collectibles including art, pottery and furniture.
There are many options to shop in downtown Knightstown, IN. like antiques.
Pizza or ice cream is available at the Pizza King in downtown Knightstown, IN.
1/2
Athletes and scholars shine in Knightstown
Kids in Knightstown attend public schools in the C.A. Beard Memorial School Corporation, which has an overall Niche grade of B and is ranked the 31st best school district in the Indianapolis area. Knightstown Elementary offers pre-kindergarten through third grade and earns an overall Niche grade of B-minus. Knightstown Intermediate School earns a C-plus grade from Niche and has a student-teacher ratio of 16:1. Knightstown High has an overall Niche grade of B and is ranked one of the best high schools in Indiana for athletes. It also offers Advanced Placement classes and a program for gifted students.
Knightstown Intermediate School has an overall Niche Grade of C+.
Knightstown Elementary School serves students in the Knightstown community.
1/2
Football and state fairs
NFL fans can enjoy Indianapolis Colts games at Lucas Oil Stadium, which is about 20 miles west of Indianapolis. The Indiana State Fair is held each year for two weeks in July and August and is the sixth oldest state fair in the nation. The Indiana State Fairground also hosts the Christmas Nights of Lights from early November through New Year’s Eve each year.
Gardens, golf and a famous movie site
Residents enjoy living close to Royal Hylands Golf Club, one of only five links courses in Henry County. The Veterans Garden of Memories Park offers tribute to veterans and features an eternal flame. Sunset Park offers a splash pad in the summer months while baseball and softball players will enjoy the baseball diamond. Movie fans will enjoy visiting Hoosier Gym, the setting for the 1986 movie “Hoosiers”, which was based on the story of the 1954 Indiana state basketball champions, Milan High School.
Royal Hylands Golf Course in Knightstown, IN was voted in 2018 a Top 25 Best Value course.
Sunset Park in Knightstown, IN has a large shelter that can be rented for events.
1/2
Big cities beckon
Residents enjoy having quick access to Highway 40 and Interstate 70 which points east toward Indianapolis and west toward Dayton. Indianapolis International Airport sits west of downtown Indianapolis about 50 miles from Knightstown. Residents can reach Chicago in 4 hours, Fort Wayne and Cincinnati in about 2 hours and Louisville, Kentucky in about 2.5 hours. Hancock Regional Hospital is 15 miles east of Knightstown and the closest area hospital.
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Rhonda Krebs,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Knightstown, IN sell after 44 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Knightstown, IN over the last 12 months is $250,500, up 10% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Charm, character, and modern comfort come together in this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2 full-bath home offering approximately 2,000 square feet of inviting living space. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the beautifully landscaped yard that creates exceptional curb appeal and a warm first impression. Step inside to discover soaring vaulted ceilings that fill the home with
You can't build a 4 Bed, 3 Full Bath for this price point! Located in the heart of Knightstown, a city rich in history and Hoosier pride. This is where they filmed the movie! Primary on the Main with en suite Bath. Large 2nd Bed on the Main with another Full Bath next to it. All fully tiled showers. Beautiful! WIC and Ceiling Fans throughout. Kitchen is open to Living Room. Plenty of room for a
The Oasis floor plan boasts 2100 square feet of living space which includes 2 BR+flex room,2 full baths, open living concept with stainless steel appliances, solid surface countertops, large living space with 9' ceilings, screened porch/patio, 2 car attached garage. Upgrades on countertops, cabinets, flooring, and fixtures.Primary bedroom features a full bath walk in closet Quality built by local
Private country setting with views of Lake Haven and a walkout fully finished basement on almost 3/4 acres. This fully remodeled (2025&2026) 4 bedroom 2 bath and 2 kitchen home has the privacy and views comparable to luxurious private communities. The large covered front porch and main living room have peaceful unobstructed views of the private lake. The lower floor has 2 bed and 1 full bath,
Seven commercial acres! Approximately 1,400 feet of road frontage! Henry Community Health construction underway! Be on the front end of development taking place at this exit just east of Indianapolis! Ideal for HOSPITALITY, RESTAURANT, MEDICAL services/business plaza! So many possibilities! FULL visibility on interstate, adjacent to both Interstate 70 and new medical complex! Electricity,
The Cottage floor plan boasts 1700 square feet of living space which includes 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, open living concept with stainless steel appliances, solid surface countertops, large living space with 9' ceilings,, 2 car attached garage. Quality built by local builder/developer. Truly maintenance free living, each townhome is an HOA member, lawn care, snow removal, exterior maintenance are
The Tranquility floor plan boasts 1775 square feet of living space which includes 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, open living concept with stainless steel appliances, solid surface countertops, large living space with 9' ceilings, screened porch/patio, 2 car attached garage. Upgrades on countertops, cabinets, flooring, and fixtures. Primary bedroom features a full bath walk in closet. Quality built by
Welcome home to 336 North Madison Street in Knightstown, where quality craftsmanship meets comfortable, modern living. This beautifully designed ranch offers nearly 1,500 square feet of thoughtfully planned living space with a desirable split-bedroom floor plan featuring three spacious bedrooms and two full baths. The heart of the home is the impressive 20' x 17' great room with a soaring vaulted
Brand new condo with the Oasis floor plan of 2100 sq ft of living space, 2 BR & Flex room, 2 full baths, open concept living space, 9' ceilings, screened patio, 2 car attached garage, many upgrades including, back up generator and tornado shelter. Truly maintenance free, member of HOA, lawn care, snow removal, and outside maintenance included.
LandProz is pleased to present the DMP Farm property in Henry County, IN.68.15 +/- acres with 67.95 +/- tillable acres. This nearly all-tillable farm consists of two highly productive fields, separated by a small mini-farm owned by another landowner. Both fields are nearly square in shape, allowing for efficient farming operations. The north field borders Interstate 70, providing
81.5 acres with 79.5 acres cropland in Henry County Indiana just north of Hwy 109 and I-70. Knightstown Schools. Great location and investment in a growing area. Close to Greenfield and Indianapolis I-465.79.54+/- crop acres. Soybeans now1/2 mile North of I-701/2 mile frontage on Kennard Rd and 1/4 mile on Co Rd 550 STaxes $33.49/acre or $2730/yrCounty
Schrader IncSchrader Real Estate and Auction Company, Inc
LandProz is pleased to present the DMP Farm property in Henry County, IN.47.26 +/- acres with 47.13 +/- tillable acres. This highly productive farm carries a strong 156.5 Weighted Average Productivity Index (WAPI). The property offers approximately 940 feet of road frontage along County Road 850 South and 1,600 feet of frontage on County Road 1075 West, providing excellent access and
Charming Bedford Stone Home with Garage & Workshop! Take a look at this well-maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath Bedford stone home that offers comfort, functionality, and plenty of space both inside and out! Step inside to find a spacious living room perfect for relaxing or entertaining guests, along with a welcoming eat-in kitchen that provides plenty of room for family meals and gatherings. The home
Stylish and spacious living with all the modern amenities nestled in the small and quaint historic community of Knightstown. Make our Knightstown Villas your new home and head out on foot. Located just 2 blocks off Main Street makes hitting a local shop or restaurant a breeze. Conveniently situated minutes from I-70 and less than a half-mile from U.S. 40, “the National Road that built America.”
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
