$5,105,491Average Value$1,285Average Price per Sq Ft31Homes For Sale
A peninsula community in New Jersey
On the Barnegat Peninsula, tethered to New Jersey, sits the beach community of Mantoloking. With views of the sunrise and sunset across the water and many of its homes on the beachfront or bayfront, Mantoloking is just one of the area’s numerous beach communities. “There’s probably 15 or 16 communities in a 15-mile stretch there,” says Matthew Schlosser, vice president of Schlosser Real Estate. “If you want to be quiet and relaxed, you have that ability, and you can be at boardwalks and all sorts of recreation within a mile or two. It’s a good blend of everything.”
Islands, parks further inland and boardwalks
While no parks are within Mantaloking’s specific boundaries, venture out to Herring Island just off the bayside shore to the west. It can be accessed by small craft, such as paddleboards, and is one of many small islands in the vicinity. On the mainland, in Brick Township, Mantoloking Bridge County Park offers seafarers options for fishing and crabbing while remaining open year-round. Lit paths line the park, which also features a pier, picnic areas, a boardwalk and a panoramic view of the bay. Beachfront homeowners won’t have to worry about tourism, as there’s no public recreation on the beach, and limited parking means access is mostly for residents. “There’s many different little beach communities,” Schlosser says. “There’s islands in the middle of the bay that are state-owned property only accessible by boat. As far as the beach goes, it’s very quiet and not overpopulated. It’s just a quiet, relaxing beach town.”
Some homes have the Atlantic Ocean as their backyard in Mantoloking, NJ.
Here is an aerial of Herring Island located in the Barnegat Bay in Mantoloking, NJ.
Mantoloking is split between the Atlantic Ocean and Barnegat Bay in Mantoloking, NJ.
1/3
Vacation-based living
Homes in Mantoloking primarily serve as vacation getaways. “It has the largest lots of all the surrounding beach communities,” Schlosser says. “It’s a real narrow strip of land and it’s mostly second homes for buyers, but there is a little bit of year-round living.” Whether there for the summer or the whole year, homes on the oceanfront can sell for between $9 million and $12 million, while bayside non-waterfront residences can dip down as low as around $2 million. Styles in the area include Cape Cods, custom builds and other types of ocean retreats, some with stonework and many with pools. Other homes on the bayfront even have small docks on the water.
Custom built homes can range from 2 to 12 million dollars in Mantoloking, NJ.
Here is a row of custom built homes in Mantoloking, NJ.
Cape Cod style homes can be found in Mantoloking, NJ.
1/3
Shopping and dining southbound
For local fare, residents will have to head north or south for most of the area shops and restaurants. Point Pleasant is half a mile north, while other beach communities are within a mile or two to the south, and that’s where the local outlets can be found. “The biggest restaurant around is Charlie’s of Bay Head on the water there,” Schlosser says. The restaurant is perched along the bay and is bordered on two sides by water, and other local favorites include the Dune Grass Café and Theresa’s South. Check out the Shore Fresh Seafood Market and Restaurant for indoor and outdoor dining at what’s been rated the best seafood destination in Point Pleasant, as well. “You can have nightlife and restaurants if you want it,” Schlosser says, “or, if you just want to be low-key and relax with your family, it’s a great place as well.”
Charlie's of Bay Head is situated on the water in Mantoloking, NJ.
Shore Fresh Seafood Market offers the freshest seafood in Mantoloking, NJ.
1/2
A pair of highly-rated schools for education
Students can attend G. Harold Antrim Elementary School from pre-kindergarten all the way up through eighth grade, which ranks at an A-minus on Niche with a student-to-teacher ratio of nine to one, and that’s followed by grades nine through 12 at Point Pleasant Beach High School. The high school has a ratio of 10 to one and is ranked as the third-best high school in Ocean County on Niche, scoring an A-minus as well. Both are located north of Mantoloking off the peninsula and are part of the Point Pleasant Beach School District, which is named as the best school district in all of Ocean County by Niche, and the schools also feature 80% of the student population taking part in extracurriculars as well as Advanced Placement courses, dual-enrollment and more.
Route 35 is the main roadway artery in Mantoloking, NJ.
Specific access points in and out of Mantoloking
Three options exist to access Mantoloking, stemming from the north, south and west. “You can come down through Point Pleasant on Route 35, come across Mantoloking Bridge through Brick Township or come up through the south on Route 37,” Schlosser says. “If there’s one area that’s much heavier in traffic, you have other options to get there.” Route 35 is also known as Ocean Avenue, which runs through the center of Mantoloking and branches into much of northeastern New Jersey. With a daily dose of ocean breeze, Mantoloking offers seasonal or year-round living with views across the water and bay, all while staying within reach of the surrounding area.
Written By
Adam Cheek
Photography Contributed By
John Georgiadis
Video By
Tyler Newbold
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
MaryBeth Tomaro,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Mantoloking, NJ sell after 86 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Mantoloking, NJ over the last 12 months is $2,575,000, up 43% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Life on Easy Street! Welcome to easy coastal living at Sand Castle Condominiums in Mantoloking. This beautifully situated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers the perfect beach retreat, just steps from the association's private beach access. Enjoy a private outdoor patio space, ideal for relaxing and entertaining after a day by the ocean, along with the convenience of four dedicated parking
Nestled in the prestigious Autumn Estates subdivision of South Mantoloking, this exceptional coastal residence offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and seaside living. Located on the barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and Barnegat Bay, and part of the South Mantoloking Beach Association with private beach access. This home places you in one of the Jersey Shore's most sought-after
Discover the ultimate Jersey Shore getaway in this turnkey 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom condo nestled on the second floor in the prestigious gated community of The Ocean Club in Mantoloking. Known for its welcoming, neighborly atmosphere and pristine barrier island setting, this property offers an unbeatable coastal lifestyle with a private guarded beach and vast swimming pool. Enjoy a generous ocean
Peter ThomasKeller Williams Realty Premier Properties
Welcome to this stunning newly built 3 BR, 2.5 BA duplex located in the private beach community of Osborn Dunes in South Mantoloking. This new construction by Walter Homes represents a rare opportunity to own a thoughtfully crafted coastal retreat just steps from a private, lifeguarded beach. Elevated w/ parking & storage underneath this home offers it all: welcoming open dining & living areas w/
Under Construction Oceanfront | Summer 2027 Completion - Orchard Hills presents one of the finest homes being offered at the Jersey shore, located on a sprawling 105' wide lot. High end appointments throughout, quality workmanship, and attention to detail is the mark of Orchard Hills. This 7 bedroom, 7/2 bath Shingle style home offers old world charm and the amenities of today. A great home for
Oceanfront lot in Bayview Shores section of South Mantoloking. Rare opportunity to build your new beachfront home The currently undeveloped land is approximately 6,600 sf and measures 55 x 100. Enjoy this desirable ocean block neighborhood just a short walk to local restaurant and bar ''Used to Be's.'' Purchaser will need to do their own due diligence to determine what can be built on this legal
Mantoloking Oceanfront - Rare opportunity to own 100' of oceanfront in Mantoloking Borough. This exceptional oversized lot measures approximately 100' x 365' and sits at one of the higher elevations in town, offering both privacy and premier beachfront living. The existing dune is constructed to EL 22' with protective steel revetment installed per Borough requirements, allowing the first floor to
Privately positioned at the end of a long, landscaped approach, this distinctive Barnegat Bay residence offers an exceptional combination of space, privacy, and waterfront living. Set on an impressive 70-by-330-foot property, the home is surrounded by mature hedges and established gardens, creating a peaceful retreat just minutes from the Mantoloking Yacht Club and downtown Bay Head.A
Experience coastal luxury in this beautifully appointed two-bedroom oceanfront condo in prestigious Mantoloking. Perfectly positioned just steps from the sandy beach, this exceptional residence offers breathtaking, unobstructed ocean views and an effortless beachfront lifestyle. Large windows fill the home with natural light, while the private balcony provides the perfect setting to enjoy
Experience coastal luxury in this beautifully appointed two bedroom oceanfront condo in prestigious Mantoloking. Perfectly positioned just steps from the sandy beach, this exceptional residence offers breathtaking, unobstructed ocean views and an effortless beachfront lifestyle. Large windows fill the home with natural ligiht, while the private balcony provides the perfect setting to enjoy
Grazyna ZiarkoThe Agency One Rock - Franklin Lakes
Under Construction Oceanfront | Summer 2027 Completion - Orchard Hills presents one of the finest homes being offered at the Jersey shore, located on a sprawling 150' wide lot. High end appointments throughout, quality workmanship, and attention to detail is the mark of Orchard Hills. This 8 bedroom, 8/1 bath Shingle style home offers old world charm and the amenities of today. A great home for
This exceptional Mantoloking residence is situated on an expansive 100' x 150' property and offers over 5,500 sq. ft. of refined coastal living with sweeping ocean and bay views from all three levels. Designed for effortless entertaining, the open main level features a sunken living and dining area with fireplace, custom kitchen, wet bar, and two private guest suites. The luxurious primary suite
Newly aligned price, & ready for its new owner. This turnkey oceanfront residence creates an ideal opportunity for qualified buyers to premier living at The Ocean Club at Mantoloking. This custom rare 1st-floor 2BD/2BA unit comes fully furnished. Features top-tier Viking appliances, wine cooler, seamless hidden fridge & dishwasher, Miele W/D, and radiant heated floors throughout. Step onto your
MAGNIFICENT MANTOLOKING ESTATE. Private...Elegant...and having everything you need to escape & spend this summer at the Jersey Shore. Stay longer if desired & enjoy this 6 bedroom, 8 bath private HAVEN surrounded by water & tranquility. Home features a first floor suite with doors that open on to a deck with picturesque water views.A Chef's kitchen, huge island, two dishwashers, 2 sub zeros,
WINTER RENTAL -Downstairs house...South Mantoloking Jersey Shore Retreat. Enjoy the peaceful beauty of the Jersey Shore during the off-season in this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath winter rental in South Mantoloking. Offering a bright and comfortable open floor plan, this home is the perfect place to settle in and enjoy coastal living throughout the winter months.The spacious eat-in kitchen features
*WEEKLY RENTAL: $30,000 PER WEEK* Welcome to Knockout North! Waterfront living at its finest on the largest residential lot in the area, designed for those who appreciate luxury, privacy, and breathtaking natural beauty. Behind an impressive gated-entrance is an incredible compound that seamlessly blends modern luxury w/ historical charm. The main house boasts magnificent primary wing w/ stunning
Avail 9/5-9/12 @ $18,950, 9/19-10/3 @ $13,950 per week. Off Season 10/3 on @ $12,500 per week. CurrentlyBooking Summer 2027. Exquisite, High End, Custom built home w/ 6 bedrooms, 5.5 baths, IG pool & steps to the beach. This home is simply stunning w/attention to detail at every turn.1st floor hosts an open floor plan, 2 separate living areas, a billiard rm, DR w/ butlers pantry, 1.5 BAs, 2 sets
Please email jacquig@kw.com for any additional questions.Available dates left May 22 -June 19 $6000/weekAugust 15 - Sept 12. $6500/weekSeasonal rental opportunity to enjoy -- a stunning 4BR, 2.BA 2 1/2 BA coastal home in Mantoloking. This three story residence offers spacious living areas, three balconies, and a peak at the ocean and bay views. The rear balconies lead to a patio
Jacqueline GordonKeller Williams Realty Ocean Living
Finish out the summer in Style!! Beautiful Oceanfront 5 bedroom, 3 full bath Custom designed home with wide open floor plan and spectacular ocean views. Vaulted ceilings, huge open eat in kitchen, tons of windows and a sprawling beachfront deck are just a few of the many outstanding amenities this beach home has to offer. Plenty of parking and direct beach access. No groups, pets or
Michael MulroyWard Wight Sotheby's International Realty
Summer Rental. Last 3 weeks left. Avail 7/31-8/21 @ $8,900 per week. 2week minimum. Friday to Friday Rental. Updated 3 bedroom, 2 bath beach block home. First floor features beautiful HW floors in living, dining & kitchen area, living room w/ new wet bar & sliders that lead to a great deck, dining area that opens to an updated kit w/ breakfast bar & butlers area, 1st floor bedroom, office &
AVAILABLE FOR WINTER RENTAL!! CONTACT LA FOR DETAILS. Paradise on the water at Curtis Point!! Fully Furnished. Everything is included! Direct Access to Barnegat Bay. 5 Bedrooms featuring 2 king size beds, 2 queen size, 2 full size, and a blow up mattress. 2.5 Baths, fully equipped kitchen, all the comforts of home! Enjoy the outdoor oasis featuring a heated saltwater pool, outdoor shower, patio
WEEKLY SUMMER RENTAL FOR 2026! One of the Jersey Shores Premiere rentals. This Custom, 3 years young home is in the sought-after private beach enclave of Normandy Beach! This stunning residence boasts unparalleled architecture and high-end design elements throughout.This exceptional waterfront home offers the epitome of luxurious coastal living featuring 6 bedrooms and 4 full, 2 half baths.The
Brand new 16x32 gunite saltwater heated pool ready for enjoyment! Located just across the street from the beach, this stunning 3-story home offers breathtaking ocean views and the ultimate in coastal living. Featuring 6 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and an open-concept layout, this home is perfect for family gatherings and entertaining.Relax on the oversized back deck or unwind by the heated pool
Summer 2027 Weekly Rental. Owner would prefer a two week rental in August, but may be open to other dates. Please inquire. $12,000 per week.Come enjoy this home on the bay, that is also not too far from the beach! Watch the sun set from the dock or the deck, and bring your kayak, paddleboard or boat if you have one! Open floor plan, with multiple decks, and an enclosed porch, if you want
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
